|
51
on: November 12, 2026, 05:18:55 PM
|
|
Started by ChrisS - Last post by ChrisS
|
|
Very nice Hohner Lilliput D/G for sale. All buttons play. Bellows and casing in very good condition. With solid foam-lined case. Bought reconditioned about 10 years ago from melodeon specialists. In Birmingham, so could deliver within reasonable distance, or plus P+P. Can e-mail playing video/photos. £525.
|
|
52
on: November 12, 2026, 04:31:46 PM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by GBbox
|
But even considering that one as accented on the first beat, one swallow does not make a summer.
Which was my whole point: it can be accented on the 2nd beat, but not always (and also a general comment about traditional music interpretation that peremptory rules like "mazurka = 2nd beat accent" often miss a lot of the picture). You trying to make me say otherwise strikes me as oddly directed (moreover the mention - and its one-sided presentation - of this debate we had is also pretty gratuitous with regards to the current discussion). Enough off-topic for my part.
Dick started the discussion stating that the mazurka strong beat is the third, and not the first like in the waltz. I acutally mentioned the English Wikipedia page, that states it can be either the second or the third, but I also noted that the italian Wikipedia page just mentions the second. Then, remembering our discussion, I simply noted you clearly stated that even for the mazurka the strong beat can be the first. Which is something I disagree with, even if I have seen the mazurkas danced to tunes that were unmistakably waltzes.. Considering the generally assumed difference between the waltz and the mazurka is that the first beat is the strong inr the former, but not in the latter, and that was exactly what we have debated, I would say such a difference, rather then being off-topic, is actually the topic.
|
|
53
on: November 12, 2026, 01:46:25 PM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by -Y-
|
But even considering that one as accented on the first beat, one swallow does not make a summer.
Which was my whole point: it can be accented on the 2nd beat, but not always (and also a general comment about traditional music interpretation that peremptory rules like "mazurka = 2nd beat accent" often miss a lot of the picture). You trying to make me say otherwise strikes me as oddly directed (moreover the mention - and its one-sided presentation - of this debate we had is also pretty gratuitous with regards to the current discussion). Enough off-topic for my part (edit: what's off-topic is comments on your manners).
|
|
54
on: November 12, 2026, 01:39:45 PM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by Theo
|
|
My simple minded take on this. Speaking as a dancer I’ve noticed that the music for mazurkas is vary varied but my feet know a mazurka when I hear one. That’s not much help if you are trying to play a mazurkas, but does hint that the best way to get the feel of the music is to learn the dance!
|
|
55
on: November 12, 2026, 12:58:23 PM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by GBbox
|
Indeed, and I also remember providing recordings of traditional players that proved my point ...
And in turn I remember that in one of my posts I listed all the links you had posted, about eight if I am not wrong, and I clearly said that all them sounded to my ear accented on the second or/and on the third beat, with on eexception that sounded almost without any strong accent at all. But even considering that one as accented on the first beat, one swallow does not make a summer. But i suppose this is the same problem we have with the oral transmisson in the tradition: you can't never totally trust what was committed to memory, and what was is forgotten is lost.... Anyway, if you remember which was the thread, please post a link, so anybody who at the time didn't read it will be able to make his own mind.
|
|
56
on: November 12, 2026, 11:47:03 AM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by Chris Ryall
|
|
i'm also very flexible about anacrusis (= stressing notes). It's very important in British Morris dancing, but for bal folk … I haven't played for that recently because I can't feel my fingers (a drug side effect from over 18 months ago, slowly improving 🙂).
But … when I used to play informally in French festivals I would try "accompany" one of the better dance couples on the floor. That way you can "inform the feet", while still keeping things subtle?
|
|
57
on: November 12, 2026, 08:58:24 AM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by -Y-
|
Anyway, the accent is not on the first beat, although I remember that we have already made this discussion, and our friend -Y- firmly disagreed with that commonly accepted notion.  Indeed, and I also remember providing recordings of traditional players that proved my point, that is that you could very well have an accent on the first beat, or on the 2nd or on each beat (which is not equivalent to saying that it's not on the 2nd beat, as you try to put it). Plus it also depends on whether or not you consider the beginning of the melody to be an anacrusis or not. In which case you could have the sensation that it's on the 2nd beat but it'd be on the first, technically speaking. But as often with traditional music, what makes or not a type of melody cannot be reduced to a matter of accents and strong/weak beat.
|
|
58
on: November 12, 2026, 08:29:41 AM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by GBbox
|
The English page of Wikipedia Wikipedia states either on the second or on the third beat. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MazurkaYet is worth noting that the Italian page of Wikipedia clearly states that the strong beat is the second only. https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/MazurcaAnyway, the accent is not on the first beat, although I remember that we have already made this discussion, and our friend -Y- firmly disagreed with that commonly accepted notion. 
|
|
59
on: November 12, 2026, 01:55:03 AM
|
|
Started by Little Eggy - Last post by Derik Palmer
|
|
A waltz is a simple 3/4 time melody with the accent on the first beat - ONE two three, ONE two three. A mazurka is also in 3/4 time but with the accent on (usually) the third beat - one two THREE, one two THREE; although I have heard a couple of tunes described as mazurkas where the accent was on the second beat, which I found confusing enough to have to go and lie down in a darkened room...
|
|
60
on: November 11, 2026, 06:55:40 PM
|
|
Started by Dave Praties - Last post by Fionn
|
I learned to play by ear (like many of my generation) and have never learned the names of most of the buttons, especially in the upper octave.
Same here. Not a Scooby. It's because the information's not very useful. I don't memorise a new tune by the note names or looking at buttons, I go on what it sounds like. Also it's not a series of notes, it's a pattern of pitch intervals – which I think is why small children can transpose a well known song on the fly, depending on the key an adult leads it in. They learn the gaps. To be fair I have now located the mid A now, but only because it's what the flute player always asks for.
|
|
Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
|
|