This thread makes interesting reading - and I don't expect to have anything further to add of any consequence. Learning is a very individual process and can involve many a false start before one finds the way forward. For myself, having had obligatory piano lessons as a child and played (badly) guitar, banjo, mandoline purely for fun I had enough theory to understand all the processes suggested so far, yet I found the instinctive nature of the melodeon carried me along without thinking the process through. Indeed the bisonoric nature of the beast meant that I preferred to learn a tune by ear rather than struggle with any reference to written notation. I guess in many ways I was lucky to succeed in this way, but I had two mentors from our NW morris band whose playing I could observe and ask the odd question (and they were odd!) plus learning the repertoire of our local Border side. The melodies were not difficult and the true essence of these Border tunes lay in the chord progression and rhythm, which fitted well with my experience with fretted instruments.
Since reaching some level of maturity in my playing, I find that new starters react very differently when they ask how to best play a particular phrase. Often the intended help is ignored as being "too hard" because it conflicts with the general principles by which they have so far learnt. The ones who have responded positively have a similar intuitive approach to their playing. Somehow it is not just showing which buttons to press and whether to push or pull, but explaining how it feels to play it - how the phrasing works and why a particular choice of fingering facilitates that.
Many, many years ago I was sat by a lake taking a breather from my sailboard. A family turned up and most of them sailed off across the lake, but one lad just couldn't get going. He'd read all the books and his dad had answered all his questions about sailing, but every time he brought the sail across the board to make a start he was catapulted into the water. We sat and chatted about how it felt to balance the force of the wind, body position and steering. On the third attempt he was off, sailing much better than I ever could and visibly learning the nuances of fine control.
I believe there are some who define thought processes as typically male or female and I believe I am often more female than male in this respect - probably explains my spitefulness, too. But I believe it is this need to experience or understand what feels right that makes playing in the company of others so invaluable. This does not mean that the use of notation, ABC or tabs is not a useful tool for solitary practice and learning, though it may point to why each method will have varying suitability to the individual. At a stretch I can still make something from notation, but I can't stretch to learning to read ABC, which lacks the visual clues of notation. Tab I haven't even looked at, probably too late for me, but I did start to annotate manuscripts of tunes as a teaching aid, simply adding bass and chords above the stave which mostly dictates or at least limits the choice of fingering. Of course, Sod's Law kicked in and the old computer with all the necessary programs on it won't start up now. Maybe when we're allowed to go out again I can rescue the work in progress from the hard drive!
Rob