Hmmm. No i hadn't really thought about that. A true 'fifth' chord is in essence between the second and third harmonics of any resonant system. In D - that's D and A (with a low D fundamental 'implied'). So far it's logic. It is the purest of harmony (apart from 'octave'), indeed Pignol and Milleret don't consider perfect 5
th a harmony at all as 'it brings no colour to the chord'! I think we're safe with what will always be close to the ideal 2:3 resonance in practice
I see now why right keyboard is different. Note A functions as a perfect 5
th - the colourless note -in the key of D - safe enough? Whereas in the key of G it is a 2
nd/9
th interval - a very 'coloured' interval indeeed, so liable to tuner 'justification'
Thanks for that insight. I use right hand chording a lot and it's explained why the same set of notes chorded on push don't sound quite the same on pull.

Does this mean that such off harmony issues are peculiar to right end. Maybe. I think it might explain the nuances of overall sound when the 3
rds go. I gues one's ear is the best arbiter.