Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: History Unfolds: 100 Years of Hohner Accordions in pictures -- mixed thoughts  (Read 7563 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

finnhorse

  • Guest

If anyone was curious about the book but put off by the sticker price ($75), I just finished reading it and examining the photographic record.  The English translation is concise, but flat.  I have mixed feelings about the work as a whole, because I feel that it leaves big gaps in the Hohner story.  Did anyone else get the same impression?  Hohner provides instruments which for decades have driven and influenced folk music around the globe, and yet the history gives folk music little more than a passing recognition.  Arguably, it was neglecting this very market that almost ruined the company.  Now they've got a growing basket of small European makers to compete with, and little to show for it in terms of innovation.  It was kind of scary to learn that a 70% interest in the company was purchased by Taiwan, a move that precipitated the move to China.

I had intended to use the photos and history to establish a better timeline, which the book doesn't really provide.  The photos are interesting, but chromatics and PA's dominate the spread -- not a single Pokerwork, Erica, Corso, Double Ray, Trichord or Gaelic, and only one Corona (1998).  The cutlines are very meager and don't adequately enlighten the details of the instruments they are meant to describe.  Also, very little (if anything at all) was relayed about the many (many) changes in construction and cosmetic detail from 1900 to present.  They've changed the specs of their accordions so many times that almost no two are really alike, I guess that might be one of the reasons for why a comprehensive history hasn't been written.  I thought this would have been helpful in dating vintage instruments.  Obviously, the authors did not set out to provide a comprehensive guide to vintage instruments!  The book serves as a nice coffee table romp through accordiana, but fails to deliver as anything but that.  From what I can gather, it seems that either the people at Hohner aren't informed of the history, or otherwise no records are retained from which such a history could be compiled.  On the other hand, I couldn't resist taking a stroll around eBay after looking at the three or four clubs and Precosias included in the photo section... There is a cornucopia of old Hohner adverts as well, most notably an amusing print of a postcard from the First World War, showing a group of German soldiers playing Hohner accordions in their trench while two kilted soldiers of a highland regiment can't help but start dancing in no man's land. 

I think they closest thing we've got to a "Hohner guide" this is the hodge-podge of websites from devoted enthusiasts like Peter Unbehauen.  His "virtual tour" of the Trossingen factory is actually more informative than the section of the book devoted to the same purpose.  They should have consulted him to help write the book!  This book is indicative, I think, of Hohner's relationship with our market although I believe they're taking steps to get closer to select folk markets.

Theo: in an ancient post on the old board, you were wondering if anyone had ever offered a bass melodeon.  I've always wondered the same thing, because to me it seems like a pretty natural extension of the whole accordion concept.  If you haven't seen it yet, there's a photo of a Hohner bass model made during the heyday of the accordion orchestra movement.  It has the baritone notes on the treble side, and nothing but a handstrap on the other.  Didn't catch on, I guess.

It's an interesting item, if you've got the button box bug.  I received my copy as an ILL from the university library, I might recommend doing the same if you had similar expectations.  $75 is a bit much for what it offers.


Logged

finnhorse

  • Guest

ack.. I meant to post this in the 'general information' section, and put it here by mistake. 
Logged

CajunBoxPlayer

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5

I haven't read it, but it sounds interesting.  I wouldn't be surprised if there is lots of gaps in the book.  Lord knows there's a huge HOLE in Hohner's current servicing of parts.  Also a huge gap in workmanship in Chinese sweat shops
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal