Larger version.
Larger version.
Larger version.
The Serenellini 273 (27 treble buttons, 3 treble voices) is the slightly bigger brother of the 233 (the 233 is often referred to as "The Cloud" because of its similarity with the Saltarelle Nuage, a model that was originally made for Saltarelle by Serenellini and which, according to some, made Saltarelle's reputation). Whereas the 233 has 8 basses, the 273 has 12. On Serenellini's website the 273 is shown in a 10-9-8 treble configuration, but other permutations are possible including the 12-11-4 model that I have.
I had heard good reports about the quality of Serenellini boxes and chose this model because I wanted 12 basses (very hard to find a two-row box with 12 basses) and I thought the extra half-row might provide some useful reversals and r-h chord possibilities (all the accidentals being covered already with my C# row). After a couple of frustrating exchanges with dealers in Ireland and England who couldn't be bothered to contact Serenellini on my behalf, I ordered directly from the factory in Italy, getting extremely quick delivery (about. 6 weeks) and a very good price: 1700 euros in late 2005, which included a 100 euro upgrade to tipo a mano reeds and extras such as a hard case, flat keyboard and engraved logo (rather than on a plate).
I ordered it with 3 medium voices and the model they had in production was walnut (I would have chosen matt black at the time, but I have grown to like the dark finish of the walnut). It weighs in at 4.4 kg, which is about as heavy a box as I would ever want. After nearly two years of regular playing, either it has got nice and supple or my muscles have toned up - either way it's not a huge strain to play. There are three registers, one for each treble voice, and two for the bass side (one to remove thirds, and one to remove the low bass, which can be useful since the full basses are very powerful).
My general verdict: an excellent instrument, particularly the musical and mechanical aspects (I'd rate it a little less highly in the cabinet-making and finish department). It is thoughtfully designed and well engineered - my tuner and repairman was very impressed with the box in general and with the quality of the reeds and the treble mechanism in particular: this features a Paolo-Soprani-style "reverse lever" mechanism to ensure that the inner row of pallets open more or less equally with the outer row. The action is fast and very quiet (at least on the treble side: the bass buttons clonk away like dray horses on a cobbled street). A number of very good players have tried the box out, including Dave Munnelly and Sabin Jacques, and all have commented on it very favourably. One other in particular always asks to play it and then won't give it back to me for an hour or so...
Larger version.
Larger version.
As far as appearance is concerned, well it's no Castagnari, but nice enough. There were some annoying defects to the finish when the box arrived - a couple of scratches, the wooden veneer on the keyboard lifting in places, a bass button that kept coming unscrewed and falling off, but that's the extent of the problems I've had. To placate me the very nice people at Serenellini made me a present of a useful soft case. I'm not crazy about the design of the grille, and putting the bellows pins in a band of marquetry seems daft to me (one problem I forgot: a tiny piece of marquetry flaked off around one of the pin holes as I was carefully removing a pin).
A nice feature is a thick felt pad attached to the back of the instrument with snap fasteners behind the keyboard and treble cabinet. I'm not sure if this is intended to protect the finish or help prevent the box from sliding around. I would have liked to have snap fasteners to clip the long bellows-closing straps out of the way, and I wish the default position of the stop to remove thirds from the bases was off (thirds out) rather than on.
I've met a couple of other Serenellini players, both very pleased with their 233 or "Cloud" models. One of them summed up the manufacturer's products nicely: "under-rated, and under the radar".
Edited 2011-06-06 to correct errors caused by new forum software's interpretation of special characters.