Someone, I think on this forum, had a semitone concertina that I tried. I think it was a C#/C? It doesn't really matter but it was a semitone system.
But it does matter, very much - not only the key, but also which way around the two rows were, and how the button allocations on the two rows were offset...
That's why I'm talking about designing it for box players, to play across the rows, and not for straight-row concertina players - which it seems may have been the problem with previous attempts at such an instrument!
Here is the original post from the one that I tried.
So it was a C# (outside row) - C (inside row) concertina. The key to me doesn't matter because I was playing by ear in whatever key they came out as. I tried playing some tunes in C on the inside row, and then tried playing some in F (tunes I'd normally play on my box in the key of G) and when I started cross-rowing I started running into problems. Whether the outside row was a semitone sharp (this case) or flat (like I'm used to on the box) doesn't matter because if you're playing up and down scales in various keys, at some point you're going to have to play two different buttons with the same finger. I found this awkward because when playing the concertina I'm used to using finger per column of buttons and reaching out with the little finger for any notes in the last columns.