Hi
I've never used hide glue for valves, but my instinctive feeling is that it would set too hard/brittle which might be a problem with vinyl valves.
give it a try ,i've used hide glue for over thirty years but never used it on plastic but seems to stick perfectly,i think because its quick tack and effectively dehydrates to stick it has many more uses than i thought
I have to hard felt some new cornet valves i,m going to try the bottom layer with hide as an alternative to pva ,its so cheap and easy to use and readily available, and also so easy to remove and " i like the smell" lol