As some of you will know, I've recently been fine-tuning the 1-row 4-stop melodeon which I built at Stowmarket a year ago. Thanks to Theo's and Rees's expert tuition at both Stowmarket and Mendlesham last March, I've assembled or made all the tools required and slowly, gently, made a start and gaining confidence as I progressed, went on to complete the tuning of the entire instrument. I have to say it is now sounding pretty good (and I am quite critical when it comes to tuning), and I just can't stop playing it! There is one minor problem which is annoying me and if anyone has advice I'd be grateful.
The melodeon is a 4-voice in D, tuned M+, M, L, H, with the M+ reeds being no more than 2 - 4 cents sharp across the range, so there is just the hint of tremolo. The M L H voices are exact unison octaves. The reeds are Binci hand-made type, on aluminium plates screwed on to the reed chambers.
The problematical reed is the M+ push D in the middle of the range (2nd line down on the treble stave). At low to medium bellows pressure, the pitch is OK, but on medium to strong pressure the reed plays sharp by as much as 15 to 25 cents. This means that when playing with all four voices on a good punchy tune with staccato attack, there is a noticeable rough tremolo which lasts a fraction of a second before the pressure moderates and the pitch settles down.
The sound quality of the reed is slightly different from the others too; difficult to describe but it has a rather twangy, hollow metallic sound, compared with the purer sound of its fellows. There is no dust or similar in the reed plate/reed tongue edge, and as far as I can tell the leather valve is OK.
I suspect the problem is due to the 'set' (gap) of the reed tongue above the reed plate. However, the gap looks similar to its neighbours and the reed speaks easily and is not 'breathy'. I've tried adjusting the gap slightly up and down, but it doesn't seem to make much difference to the variability in pitch.
I would be grateful for any ideas and advice.
Edited to add: I've just noticed that it is exactly a year since my melodeon started its life as a pile of cherry wood strips in a room in the Abbott's Hall in Stowmarket. Also this post has been my 500th and I appear to have been elevated to the status of 'hero member'. So if someone can help me solve my reed problem, that will be cause enough for a triple celebration, I think.