Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Down

Author Topic: Soundboards again  (Read 9059 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #40 on: October 05, 2011, 02:11:48 PM »

The study is very interesting, thank you Ian and jb.

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #41 on: October 05, 2011, 02:30:23 PM »

Are you suggesting that all scientific research should be closed down to prevent the nasty consequences, ignoring the good ones?

No, what makes you think that? 

Quote
I suppose you'll quote the atomic bomb as an example of science gone mad. Well, in the past 66 years nuclear science killed about 200,000 people at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and all the peacetime nuclear accidents including Chernobyl are estimated to have killed less than five thousand people -- all of which are tragedies. On the other hand replacing coal power stations with nuclear ones has saved the lives of tens of thousands of miners, and peaceful uses of radiation (CT scanners, radiotherapy, smoke detectors) have saved the lives of millions. However few of the positive factors make headlines in the same ways as the negative ones -- but you can't concentrate only on the negative consequences of something without also looking at the positive ones.

200,000 people dead from nuclear weapons. So far, Ian, so far. The potential for millions to be exterminated by them is still with us.

Actually nuclear power provides a pretty good example of scientists foolishly assuming that they can solve any problem. When power stations started to produce nuclear waste, we were reassured that science would soon find an answer to the problem of neutralizing the stuff, or at least disposing of safely and cheaply. Last time I looked, and this is what, 50 years on, no such answer has been found, and increasing amounts of nuclear waste are being shuffled round the world on trains travelling through heavily populated areas, and on ships.

The thing that nobody seems to talk about with regard to nuclear power stations - the elephant in the room - is that by building them you are condemning future generations to deal with them. Which assumes that the technical, financial and human resources to do so will always be there. A very big, and stupid, assumption, in my view.

Anyway... I think we are getting a long way away from soundboards in accordions.


Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #42 on: October 05, 2011, 03:03:51 PM »

On the other hand replacing coal power stations with nuclear ones has saved the lives of tens of thousands of miners, and peaceful uses of radiation (CT scanners, radiotherapy, smoke detectors) have saved the lives of millions.

It's never that simple. We radiologists do a lot more good than harm with our linear accelerators and scanners - odd ratios are well, well toward 'benefit'. But a scan is still radiation and someone, somewhere gets a nasty as a result. eg the two scans I had in 2003 were equivalent to 'granite' dose from living in Cornwall for about a year. Interestingly, my motor bike would have been on Dartmore that very weekend 'had it not had its accident'  ::)

Radiation is funny stuff  >:E
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #43 on: October 05, 2011, 03:46:33 PM »

On the other hand replacing coal power stations with nuclear ones has saved the lives of tens of thousands of miners, and peaceful uses of radiation (CT scanners, radiotherapy, smoke detectors) have saved the lives of millions.

It's never that simple. We radiologists do a lot more good than harm with our linear accelerators and scanners - odd ratios are well, well toward 'benefit'. But a scan is still radiation and someone, somewhere gets a nasty as a result. eg the two scans I had in 2003 were equivalent to 'granite' dose from living in Cornwall for about a year. Interestingly, my motor bike would have been on Dartmore that very weekend 'had it not had its accident'  ::)

Radiation is funny stuff  >:E

I wasn't trying to say that nuclear technology was unequivocally a good thing (or that hydroelecticity is a bad one), simply that you have to look at all the pros and cons before making your mind up -- as David MacKay (author of "Sustainable Energy -- without the hot air") said, I'm in favour of numbers that add up :-)

What is clear is that the risks from radiation -- including Chernobyl -- are minute compared to the risks from many other everyday things which we accept without thinking. Falling while getting out of bed is the cause of death for about 100 people a year in the UK according to government figures, road accidents kill several thousand every year, but you don't hear many calls to ban beds or cars...

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #44 on: October 05, 2011, 04:02:07 PM »

Are you suggesting that all scientific research should be closed down to prevent the nasty consequences, ignoring the good ones?

No, what makes you think that?  

Quote
I suppose you'll quote the atomic bomb as an example of science gone mad. Well, in the past 66 years nuclear science killed about 200,000 people at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and all the peacetime nuclear accidents including Chernobyl are estimated to have killed less than five thousand people -- all of which are tragedies. On the other hand replacing coal power stations with nuclear ones has saved the lives of tens of thousands of miners, and peaceful uses of radiation (CT scanners, radiotherapy, smoke detectors) have saved the lives of millions. However few of the positive factors make headlines in the same ways as the negative ones -- but you can't concentrate only on the negative consequences of something without also looking at the positive ones.

200,000 people dead from nuclear weapons. So far, Ian, so far. The potential for millions to be exterminated by them is still with us.

Actually nuclear power provides a pretty good example of scientists foolishly assuming that they can solve any problem. When power stations started to produce nuclear waste, we were reassured that science would soon find an answer to the problem of neutralizing the stuff, or at least disposing of safely and cheaply. Last time I looked, and this is what, 50 years on, no such answer has been found, and increasing amounts of nuclear waste are being shuffled round the world on trains travelling through heavily populated areas, and on ships.

The thing that nobody seems to talk about with regard to nuclear power stations - the elephant in the room - is that by building them you are condemning future generations to deal with them. Which assumes that the technical, financial and human resources to do so will always be there. A very big, and stupid, assumption, in my view.

Anyway... I think we are getting a long way away from soundboards in accordions.




Talk about cherry-picking your facts...

As far as I'm aware, not only has nuclear waste never killed anybody, but all the waste produced by all the reactors on the world could be crammed into one deep mine where it's unlikely to hurt anyone for a very long time. The problem is that nobody wants said mine to be near them. Yes it can't be guaranteed to be 100% safe for 10,000 years, but then what can be?

Before conjuring up the possibly deadly nuclear waste monster, you might want to consider what to replace it with. Not only all the certain -- not possible -- deaths that have resulted from fossil fuels, but the environmental impact of definitely dumping massive amounts of CO2 into the atmosphere -- or don't you believe that global warming exists either?

Or are Chinese miner's lives really worth so much less than those of anti-nuclear protesters, none of who have ever died due to nuclear waste?

You're right, this isn't the right forum to discuss this. However, as long as you keep coming up with irrational statements I just can't seem to resist the temptation to shoot them down with good old hard facts ;-)

Ian

P.S. Have you read the paper about violins yet? I know it doesn't agree with your views, but you could always still claim that you're right and a long carefully conducted scientific study by experts in the field is wrong...

P.P.S. Does this qualify as the new "thread drift" champion?
« Last Edit: October 05, 2011, 04:04:26 PM by IanD »
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #45 on: October 05, 2011, 04:03:07 PM »

[...] as an engineer, I find it sad that people have views like this. [...]
Changing one variable at a time and seeing whether it makes a difference *is* science and engineering, and is exactly what I was suggesting -- but the results are only valid if you do the tests in a way that avoids observer bias.

As for the first statement, fair enough.  But you need not insult non-engineering approaches to improving quality of life.

Before the term "engineering" -- and the creation of the title "engineer" -- there were plenty of applications of the method that I described (which you claim for engineering) in the "techne" of farming and artisan-craft work.  

I understand the benefit of avoiding observer bias, but the problem with applying methods that attempt to eliminate observer bias is that the thing being made -- whether it is wine or a melodeon -- is ultimately observed, by an uncontrolled plethora of observers.
Add to that the notion that a given product may have a large degree of tolerance for inconsistencies in some characteristics and not in others. I think that a more approachable notion of techne is more appropriate to melodeon building, unless your goals are to replicate identical instruments, for instance, or to eliminate inefficiencies in production.  

I guess it boils down to whether you want to resemble Hohner (or some high-end version of Hohner) or Castagnari, and that is very much a matter of personal preference, and does not necessarily boil down to the superiority of engineering over non-engineering manners of acquiring knowledge and skill.  Apparently, what constitutes "properly" means something different for you and perhaps other engineers than it does for someone like Gaillard.  I'm sure that Gaillard is not attaining his results "randomly," but I also belief that he has not eliminated observer bias, or other biases, in a manner that would satisfy an engineer who works in a high-tech field.  I'm reminded of some woodworkers I know who make reproductions of Chippendale furniture etc who use incredibly accurate machinists' tools for measurement, and machines rather than "inefficient" hand labor in as many operations as possible. And yet, even if adjusted for inflation, their product is not as efficient, economically, as Chippendales, and Chippendale and his fellows never had access to machinery or measuring tools approaching that level of precision.

I believe that several of the accordion builders whom I admire have acquired knowledge about soundboard materials and their relative effects on sound (and other outcomes), and this is simply not available to the rest of us, except in the form of the decisions that the builders ultimately make, which may be as much, if not more, based on economics of the choice.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #46 on: October 05, 2011, 04:26:38 PM »

[...] as an engineer, I find it sad that people have views like this. [...]
Changing one variable at a time and seeing whether it makes a difference *is* science and engineering, and is exactly what I was suggesting -- but the results are only valid if you do the tests in a way that avoids observer bias.

As for the first statement, fair enough.  But you need not insult non-engineering approaches to improving quality of life.

Before the term "engineering" -- and the creation of the title "engineer" -- there were plenty of applications of the method that I described (which you claim for engineering) in the "techne" of farming and artisan-craft work.  

I understand the benefit of avoiding observer bias, but the problem with applying methods that attempt to eliminate observer bias is that the thing being made -- whether it is wine or a melodeon -- is ultimately observed, by an uncontrolled plethora of observers.
Add to that the notion that a given product may have a large degree of tolerance for inconsistencies in some characteristics and not in others. I think that a more approachable notion of techne is more appropriate to melodeon building, unless your goals are to replicate identical instruments, for instance, or to eliminate inefficiencies in production.  

I guess it boils down to whether you want to resemble Hohner (or some high-end version of Hohner) or Castagnari, and that is very much a matter of personal preference, and does not necessarily boil down to the superiority of engineering over non-engineering manners of acquiring knowledge and skill.  Apparently, what constitutes "properly" means something different for you and perhaps other engineers than it does for someone like Gaillard.  I'm sure that Gaillard is not attaining his results "randomly," but I also belief that he has not eliminated observer bias, or other biases, in a manner that would satisfy an engineer who works in a high-tech field.  I'm reminded of some woodworkers I know who make reproductions of Chippendale furniture etc who use incredibly accurate machinists' tools for measurement, and machines rather than "inefficient" hand labor in as many operations as possible. And yet, even if adjusted for inflation, their product is not as efficient, economically, as Chippendales, and Chippendale and his fellows never had access to machinery or measuring tools approaching that level of precision.

I believe that several of the accordion builders whom I admire have acquired knowledge about soundboard materials and their relative effects on sound (and other outcomes), and this is simply not available to the rest of us, except in the form of the decisions that the builders ultimately make, which may be as much, if not more, based on economics of the choice.

I'm not insulting non-engineering methods to improve the quality of life, it's something that too little attention is given to. And just because craftmen didn't know the meaning of the term engineering (because it hadn't been invented) didn't prevent them improving things by trial and error, I expect there was a big heap of smashed-up failed violins behind Stradivarius's workshop.

You're still missing my point -- I've got absolutely nothing against craftmanship, or the emotional attachment to music and/or the instruments it's played on, and wouldn't want everything to be soullessly and mechanically churned out.

Maybe some accordion builders genuninely have knowledge that we can't share about many things including soundboards. Somehow I doubt that they've done the kind of experiments we've been talking about because that's not how most artisan instrument manufacturers work or think, but I could be wrong. Even so it's very easy for people to convince themselves of something when it isn't backed up by facts, even if they have years of experience.

All that I'm against is people stating *as fact* things like "the wood of a pallet-board has a strong effect on the sound quality" with no evidence to back this up.

If they precede the statement with "I think that..." and follow it up with "even though I can't prove it" than that's fine by me --it's no longer being presented as a fact, it's a belief -- like religion, but let's not get into that...

(people can hold what beliefs they want, so long as they don't claim that they're factually true)

The problem with the Internet is that claims like this stated *as a fact* get replicated and copied and spread around and can become accepted as received wisdom when they're nothing of the sort, they started out as one man's (or several men's) opinion.

The instrument will indeed be played to an uncontrolled audience, and everyone can agree that it is truly a fine instrument. But when somebody states that this is because of the resonance properties of the pallet board wood they'd better be able to back this up.

It's no different to cosmetic adverts saying we have a wonderful product which contains secret ingedient X and that this prevents wrinkles -- the Advertising Standards Authority would be down on them like a ton of bricks unless they can back up their claim with facts.

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: Soundboards again
« Reply #47 on: October 05, 2011, 04:31:39 PM »

[[[ Good grief. That's quite enough; offending post removed; thread locked. Abusive posts will not be tolerated. -- Clive ]]]
Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal