Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6   Go Down

Author Topic: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...  (Read 34643 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #80 on: December 20, 2008, 02:01:43 PM »

Quote
Was it only yesterday Waltham asked how to tune reeds reasonably accurately out of the box
Errr, no, maybe someone else?

Quote
I noticed on a friends very expensive chest organ that he had a stop which gave a very sweet tone.  He told me the stop redirected the air through a much longer route than would be the norm.  Sorry I don't know the name of this stop - accordionists help please and can you confirm the changed sound (and my understanding of it)
The chamber in question is called a cassotto, not often used on melodeons, though Castagnari used to offer it as an option on one of their bigger boxes, and Serenellini do/did one.  Has anyone here tried one?  I gather they add a fair bit of weight, complexity and expense, which may be why us push-pullers tend not to go for them.

I played one on one of the occasions I visited Castagnari; it gave a quieter sweeter more mellow tone, which is great if that's what you like (I don't, but that's my personal opinion).

It was however about the size and weight of a wardrobe, my arm was aching within a minute or two.

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #81 on: December 20, 2008, 03:22:13 PM »


...
And if a "better" melodeon ever emerges as a consequence (likely or not), don't buy it.
...
Ian

Because of this discussion?  HO-HO. I always love a good joke.

Not the most positive post in the world Risto, old bean.

Why do scientists and people in all sorts of technical fields travel to conferences to hear what people have been doing, meet, chat etc? Surely it's partly to spark new ideas and directions that wouldn't have happened without that sharing.  Given that an international Melodeon Construction Symposium is unlikely to happen anytime soon, why not achieve part of the process here?
Tom

This is *precisely* what I was trying do do :-)

Unfortunately many more people seem to want to shoot any such ideas down in flames than to make a positive contribution -- a pity, but this often seems to be the way that discussion groups work, probably because it's much easier to criticise than to be creative :-(

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

an bosca ceoil

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 347
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #82 on: December 20, 2008, 06:48:04 PM »

Quote
Unfortunately many more people seem to want to shoot any such ideas down in flames than to make a positive contribution -- a pity, but this often seems to be the way that discussion groups work, probably because it's much easier to criticise than to be creative :-(
That stands to reason because, especially within a discussion group, it is far easier to be a "talker" than a "doer".
For that reason alone I think you will be lucky to find that "someone" you refer to, who is prepared to put your notions to the test for you, simply because they might produce the results you hope for.
Even if you were to increase that pile of patents by succesfully proving the ideas youself, I doubt that such radical concepts would meet with much enthusiasm, even from low volume manufacturers.
I am trying to be realistic rather than dismissive of creative thinking but at least all that critiicism must at least give you an inkling how the Jehovas Witnesses must feel when you rubbish their ideas.



Logged

Falseknight

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 449
    • False Knight
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #83 on: December 20, 2008, 08:01:02 PM »

let's try some logical thinking on this (I'm bored so turning to thought  ;))

I'd guess that the current layout - internal reed-blocks opening into the bellows and closed by lift-off pallets on the front actuated by cranked levers - was arrived at as a result of manufacturing expediency rather than acoustic efficiency.  Who in their right minds would put the pallets in the acoustic path

There are now different mass manufacturing techniques available though.  It is not difficult to imagine a system where the reeds are piped up from the bellows.  it is easy to imagine in-line injection moulded piston or rotary valves (costing pennies in the volumes that Hohner (say) would use them).  You would get fairly massive attenuation at the bellows side of the reed, but an unimpeded path out the front of the box.

Would it still be a melodeon?  Probably, on the grounds that a Streb is still a melodeon - the operation is unchanged.

What would it sound like?  Heaven only knows  ;D.
Logged

an bosca ceoil

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 347
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #84 on: December 20, 2008, 09:02:57 PM »

Think you have to bear in mind that the current design evolved from something that had to be built with the materials available at the time it was conceived. If the melodeon was to be "invented" now the design, materials and manufacturing techniques might well be totally different.
Your idea of a manifold and "injector pipes" would certainly seem to be more practical than trying to make mechanical linkages into the bellows airtight. Whether you would still have a melodeon is debatable but it would certainly qualify as a Handhamonika (or perhaps a hand Melodica).
Question is, would a firm like Hohner go for it, even if it worked and was possibly cheaper to produce? They still suffer an unjustified (IMO) for producing Chinese crap and I think they would have their work cut out convincing the traditionalists that such an advance was not just a cost cutting change.
Logged

Falseknight

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 449
    • False Knight
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #85 on: December 21, 2008, 12:25:22 PM »

Here lies the problem of playing an instrument which is associated so completely with "the tradition".

The melodeon has been around in relatively unchanged form for what, 130 years?  It is of a maturity that grandfathers remember their grandfathers having a melodeon much like what we have no, so the instrument is perceived as constant and unchanging since time immoral.

Nothing could be further from the truth.  The complexity and similarity of the parts, coupled with the size of the production runs possible made the free reed instruments eminently suitable for industrial, rather than craft production.  The German factories particularly seized on this and we have what we have.

Since the instruments were mass produced they rapidly percolated into all musical areas (music, even folk music was considered improving to the masses) and so free reed instruments became the accepted norm for accompanying traditional music and dance. (with some equally interesting exceptions).

Fast forward to the late 60s and the folk revival and the free reed instruments have a hallowed place, timeless and unchanging in English music.  I still clearly remember the distrust with which I was regarded in traditional music circles as a guitarist, and when I first started playing melodeon (in 1982) the confusion from the average folk club melodeon player that I didn't treat my C/G  as two single rows welded together.

There is a massive inertia,  the weight of English tradition, which means that some instruments will always be "in" and some always "out" and radical innovation will not be very forthcoming either in production engineering advances (cheapening the instrument/Chinese rubbish) or improvement (It's not the same as a Pokerwork).

The Irish seem much more open to innovation, possibly because they do not see the music as under perpetual threat by change, and have embraced over the years all manner of different fingering systems, the use of appropriate public address systems in performance, radical changes in fretted instrumentation (fretted instrumentation itself?), new music in the tradition, rich harmonic structures - in short the works.

I would guess that any radical design changes are more likely to be embraced on this front than in English traditional music.
Logged

finnhorse

  • Guest
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #86 on: December 21, 2008, 01:42:18 PM »

Reflecting on the "reeds out" idea (going out on a limb here, haven't reread the thread for a few days, this could have been addressed):

Wouldn't putting all the weight (mass) of the blocks outside of the bellows make handling the instrument more difficult?  I practice and often play in a sitting position, melodeon on my left knee.  I don't use a shoulder strap while sitting, but rather the thumb strap (which is why I think the early Hohners didn't come with factory installed shoulder strap brackets).  While standing, of course, I use a shoulder strap and occasionally the thumb strap if I'm feeling lazy.  I'd think that with all the extra mass above the keyboard, outside of the bellows, this would be unwieldy.  With the reed blocks inside the bellows on both the bass and treble ends, the box is more balanced because the most massive components stay more centralized while playing.  With a two-voice instrument it's not quite as dramatic but take a four-voice box and the effect is multiplied.  You're tying big heavy weights onto opposite ends of a paper tube by reversing the reed block position -- yes, I'm aware the bellows is a rigid structure connected with stiff paper but the bellows are the lightest part of the instrument.

The idea of pallets on a "reeds in" box was hanging me up.  As for the pallets, I don't think anything like a conventional "reeds in" pallet (pallet out?  :D) would be required.  Airtight seals make things complicated.  At the risk of becoming slightly more complicated, mechanically speaking and depending on how you look at it, the pallets could go on the outside of the bellows between the blocks and the board.  They could be flat slats, similar to the slider for a stop, and maybe buffered with felt or vulcanized rubber or something.  Instead of rethinking and redesigning the whole keyboard-action-soundboard-pallet relationship, only a new mechanism for sliding these "pallets" to open the sound holes would have to be devised.  Going a step beyond that, I've seen some old (ancient, really) boxes on ebay lately, German boxes from before Hohner ruthlessly gobbled up the competition.  Some of them had a keyboard in the middle of the box instead of shooting off the bottom.  Given, you might also lose some projection that way but if you needed room to move a lever down instead of out then there you go.

My previous post wasn't trying to shoot anything down in flames.  I was only commenting on the enthusiasm that could be expected from such a box, and the nature of improvements since 1900.  The old ones have a charm, which is what I was getting at but failed to articulate.  New and improved boxes have a charm too, but are more like newer, shinier, old boxes.  Anyone making a "reeds out" box would doubtlessly find buyers, especially if it were to sound as good as you say it could.  But I don't think it would replace the old standbys we know and love, nor do I believe the "problems" presented by those boxes are really what warrants such a new design.

I disagree that radical improvements require radical changes.  Look at how much of a difference limited key travel makes in terms of speed and control.  That's such a minor change that many players go without it, yet it radically alters a box's playability.  Or consider how hard it is to play a stiff bellows compared to ones that have been broken in.  If you want to talk autos, then you know how just a tiny change in tires can peel seconds off the clock in a 1/4 mile drag race.  I wash my car for better gas mileage.  It works.  Nothing radical about that.

As I've said before, I think the most "radical" improvements should come at the manufacturer's level.  I eagerly anticipate the day when I can find consistency, quality, and affordability for an accordion just like a guitar, mandolin, or just about anything else.  The market for it is all over the world.  I guess these things take time.  ::)
   
« Last Edit: December 21, 2008, 01:46:39 PM by finnhorse »
Logged

Martin J

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 902
  • Poole, Dorset
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #87 on: December 21, 2008, 07:56:06 PM »


Quote
PS. There is already a way of predicting the difference between in box and out of box tuning
I am indebted to you for bringing this to my attention.  Might I ask what it is?
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #77 on: December 20, 2008, 01:31:55 PM »
Your's unless someone's impersonating you.
Logged
Castagnari, Weltmeister, Giustozzi, Streb, too many Hohners.  No Strings Attached ceilidh band

risto

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 317
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #88 on: December 21, 2008, 08:26:47 PM »


Not the most positive post in the world Risto, old bean.

Why do scientists and people in all sorts of technical fields travel to conferences to hear what people have been doing, meet, chat etc? Surely it's partly to spark new ideas and directions that wouldn't have happened without that sharing.  Given that an international Melodeon Construction Symposium is unlikely to happen anytime soon, why not achieve part of the process here?
Tom

Old bean or not, to me the Melodeon is far from anything like science where research is done and results shared amongs the scientists. So far I haven't seen any posts telling what is so badly wrong with the melodeon. It is the result of development done during a couple of hundreds of years, just like most instruments.

Ian wanted to mention his pantents, well, I also have a company patent(s) and a price won in the Scandinavian invention contest, but each of these were an answer to a real problem to which a solution was worked out. I don't see any such problem with the melodeon; it is a concept which allows a ton of variations for individual builders, anything mentioned here sofar incuded.  This discussion is more like someone wanting to develop something just for the sake of it. Define the problems and then let's have another go.

EDIT: typos...
« Last Edit: December 21, 2008, 08:35:25 PM by risto »
Logged
Paolo Soprani 5-row, Roland FR1B-digital CBA button accordion. Guitar, 5-string OT banjo, mandolin, piano...
My one man band recording: https://apari.fi/Bonaparte_Crossing_The_Rhine_Risto.mp3

Waltham

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 198
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #89 on: December 21, 2008, 10:12:36 PM »


Quote
PS. There is already a way of predicting the difference between in box and out of box tuning
I am indebted to you for bringing this to my attention.  Might I ask what it is?
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #77 on: December 20, 2008, 01:31:55 PM »
Your's unless someone's impersonating you.
Ah, what I was asking was for the details of the method you were claiming to know.  Still interested, if you've got time.
Logged

Falseknight

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 449
    • False Knight
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #90 on: December 21, 2008, 11:33:04 PM »

Problem with melodeon:

Would we have started from where we did in 1857 if we had known where we would have ended in 2008, given what alternatives would be open?

Knowing what we know, where should we have started from?

Come to think of it, why is "Club", with accidentals on a half row not the default layout for two (ish) row diatonic?
Logged

Martin J

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 902
  • Poole, Dorset
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #91 on: December 22, 2008, 08:57:00 AM »

Hi Waltham

Reply 75, second paragraph, I've yet to try it myself.
Logged
Castagnari, Weltmeister, Giustozzi, Streb, too many Hohners.  No Strings Attached ceilidh band

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #92 on: December 22, 2008, 01:40:55 PM »


Not the most positive post in the world Risto, old bean.

Why do scientists and people in all sorts of technical fields travel to conferences to hear what people have been doing, meet, chat etc? Surely it's partly to spark new ideas and directions that wouldn't have happened without that sharing.  Given that an international Melodeon Construction Symposium is unlikely to happen anytime soon, why not achieve part of the process here?
Tom

Old bean or not, to me the Melodeon is far from anything like science where research is done and results shared amongs the scientists. So far I haven't seen any posts telling what is so badly wrong with the melodeon. It is the result of development done during a couple of hundreds of years, just like most instruments.

Ian wanted to mention his pantents, well, I also have a company patent(s) and a price won in the Scandinavian invention contest, but each of these were an answer to a real problem to which a solution was worked out. I don't see any such problem with the melodeon; it is a concept which allows a ton of variations for individual builders, anything mentioned here sofar incuded.  This discussion is more like someone wanting to develop something just for the sake of it. Define the problems and then let's have another go.

EDIT: typos...

OK, my personal ones would be:

-- I'd like a melodeon which produces more sound for a given amount of effort
-- I'd like a melodeon which uses less air to produce the same amount of sound
-- I'd like a melodeon which is smaller and lighter (for a given number of reeds and buttons)
-- I'd like a melodeon with a wider dynamic range (louder at top end or better played quietly or both)

All of these pretty much come down to the same thing, a melodeon which gets more sound out of a given amount of air.

The Oakwood I play now is pretty good in these areas, especially in getting a big sound without having to thrash it, but I'm fairly certain it could be improved on. Having looked at why this could be (large pallets and sound holes, very open grille, almost no "box" outside the action), there's little that could be done with a conventionally structured box to go any further in this direction -- and as was said earlier, if you look at it dispassionately it seems crazy to put all those obstructions to sound between the reeds and the listener's ear.

And it would be nice to have a box with more rows and/or reeds without ending up with something too big and heavy to "throw around" while playing it like I do the Oakwood. And stops that could be added without making the result quieter (the sound holes have to be smaller with sliding stops because the holes have to be smaller than the strips of wood between them).

Then I could have something which was more versatile in both sound and playability without losing out on size and weight.

One obvious way of doing all this would seem to be to put the reeds on the outside, hence my suggestion.

Regarding finnhorse's comment about the weight distribution, I don't think this would change so much, and in fact having the weight more "within" the end instead of hanging off it into the bellows might make for a better balance rather than a worse one.

Pallets might still be the best solution instead of a rotary or sliding valve -- these are better where high pressures are involved (brass instruments) but it's difficult to make them as low friction as a lifting valve like a pallet, and more difficult to keep them low friction over the lifetime of an instrument. I don't thing sealing will be so difficult -- imagine them all passing near the pivot through a sheet of silicone rubber (doesn't perish or crack or lose flexibility over time or temperature) with the rubber forming a sealing grommet around each lever.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Sandy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1007
  • 'Musical Landlady'
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #93 on: December 22, 2008, 11:42:23 PM »

My brain hurts!!!!!

Waltham

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 198
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #94 on: December 22, 2008, 11:57:35 PM »

Quote
I don't thing sealing will be so difficult -- imagine them all passing near the pivot through a sheet of silicone rubber (doesn't perish or crack or lose flexibility over time or temperature) with the rubber forming a sealing grommet around each lever.
I'd still worry about the joins where the rubber meets the action and the box, particularly as these seals are going to be alternately blown in and out every time the bellows changes direction.

For myself I remain convinced that a full size Preciosa would be the best way to a louder box, particularly as my RH fingers are now too clumsy to play mine much.
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #95 on: December 23, 2008, 12:49:21 PM »

Quote
I don't thing sealing will be so difficult -- imagine them all passing near the pivot through a sheet of silicone rubber (doesn't perish or crack or lose flexibility over time or temperature) with the rubber forming a sealing grommet around each lever.
I'd still worry about the joins where the rubber meets the action and the box, particularly as these seals are going to be alternately blown in and out every time the bellows changes direction.

For myself I remain convinced that a full size Preciosa would be the best way to a louder box, particularly as my RH fingers are now too clumsy to play mine much.

If they're near the pivot the seals only have to accommodate about a mm of motion, so they don't have to be very big at all -- in fact you can get ready-made grommets intended for things like flexible mountings of fans and disk drives in PCs which might do the job perfectly.

A full-size Preciosa would be a partial solution, but there's one significant problem which is (according to Theo) the difficulty of tuning the reeds even compared to a "normal" box with removable reed blocks -- more so compared to "reeds out".

And this flat-mounted reed solution would probably run out of space with either 3 rows or 3 reeds even in a bigger box, and certainly with both.

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

finnhorse

  • Guest
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #96 on: December 23, 2008, 05:10:15 PM »

Instead of the plywood used to construct so many boxes, why don't more builders opt for solid wood construction?  Is it to reduce costs?  I've never played a box that didn't have a laminated cabinet.  All materials absorb and diffuse sound waves differently, which together create the overall tone and volume of the box.  Wouldn't solid wood or even metal over a rigid frame allow more sound to escape from the box, or at least vibrate more consistently?  I understand how the instrument makes a sound is different, but I can't understand why the "sound box" characteristics of stringed instruments aren't experimented with when it comes to accordions.  It seems that with the exception of the cassotto and interior varnishing of some boxes, the principles of acoustic design are totally overlooked.

About reed block construction (something I know even less about..) -- what were the results of Hyde's experiments with foam and other materials?  I've always thought that making them out of metal would make the sound project more.
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #97 on: December 23, 2008, 05:12:37 PM »

Instead of the plywood used to construct so many boxes, why don't more builders opt for solid wood construction?  Is it to reduce costs?  I've never played a box that didn't have a laminated cabinet.  All materials absorb and diffuse sound waves differently, which together create the overall tone and volume of the box.  Wouldn't solid wood or even metal over a rigid frame allow more sound to escape from the box, or at least vibrate more consistently?  I understand how the instrument makes a sound is different, but I can't understand why the "sound box" characteristics of stringed instruments aren't experimented with when it comes to accordions.  It seems that with the exception of the cassotto and interior varnishing of some boxes, the principles of acoustic design are totally overlooked.

About reed block construction (something I know even less about..) -- what were the results of Hyde's experiments with foam and other materials?  I've always thought that making them out of metal would make the sound project more.


Given recent exchanges I'm going to resist answering this "soundboard" question -- any else want to have a go?

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #98 on: December 23, 2008, 05:32:24 PM »

Instead of the plywood used to construct so many boxes, why don't more builders opt for solid wood construction? 
Solid wood warps, checks and splits. Plywood is more stable. Also costs less!
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

finnhorse

  • Guest
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #99 on: December 23, 2008, 06:21:31 PM »

Instead of the plywood used to construct so many boxes, why don't more builders opt for solid wood construction?  Is it to reduce costs?  I've never played a box that didn't have a laminated cabinet.  All materials absorb and diffuse sound waves differently, which together create the overall tone and volume of the box.  Wouldn't solid wood or even metal over a rigid frame allow more sound to escape from the box, or at least vibrate more consistently?  I understand how the instrument makes a sound is different, but I can't understand why the "sound box" characteristics of stringed instruments aren't experimented with when it comes to accordions.  It seems that with the exception of the cassotto and interior varnishing of some boxes, the principles of acoustic design are totally overlooked.

About reed block construction (something I know even less about..) -- what were the results of Hyde's experiments with foam and other materials?  I've always thought that making them out of metal would make the sound project more.




Given recent exchanges I'm going to resist answering this "soundboard" question -- any else want to have a go?

Ian

I wasn't referring to any "soundboard."  I was referring to the entire cabinet surrounding the reed blocks.  The effect of the "soundboard" on the overall sound is negligible almost by itself, but the cabinet through which all sound must pass is not.

I've never had a guitar or violin that is built of solid wood and has split open or warped. 
« Last Edit: December 23, 2008, 06:26:51 PM by finnhorse »
Logged
Pages: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal