... the cop looking to give some of the young bucks a good thrashing is all the more puzzling, assuming this isn't all artistic liberty at work.
Coincidentally, after Paul reviving this old thread because of an early melodeon on eBay, another friend posted a link to a bunch of early film clips from New York on facebook, and if you watch the (similarly dressed) policeman walking up the street at 1.15 you'll see him whip out his nightstick and wave it around (presumably to demonstrate his "authority") until he disappears out of shot at 1.24, so perhaps it was seen as typical behaviour for New York cops...