Just been to a session at Whitby where there were at least five melodeons. The tunes played came from England, Ireland, Scotland, Canada, USA, France, Sweden, Portugal that I know of. That broad interest seems to reflect the discussion here.
If we did have sub forums for each genre then I can just imagine the "discussions" about which genre tune X belongs to. And beating in mind that at present some members seem to have difficulty deciding between the existing forum headings then I think we just stick with the present structure. If it ain't broke don't fix it.