I
still can't square criticism with absolute objectivity.

Regardless of what one may cite to justify your own likes/dislikes, the guy reading your perfectly constructed (and one might consider, justified) reasoning still might think you're talking cobblers... and feel the primal desire to ask - "who are they to pass judgment?".
Take comedians as a prime example to excite subjective opinion.
Arthur Atkinson anyone? Can of worms... big wriggly can of worms. Interesting subject though...
Back on topic...
Best way to decide what system you want, is to listen to players. Find out what they use/prefer. Find out the sound you like, and the repertoire you prefer... e.g. the way polkas seem to bounce along on a D box seems so distinctive, yet the facility of the B/C for G minor tunes is infinitely better...
Personally (
and speaking from experience), I reckon a C#/D is a better bet if you are looking to learn by yourself. The intuitive logic of the simple harmonica like press/draw style is built in - you can get results quicker just scooting along the row just playing D tunes for a bit... then begin to build on this foundation.
However, if you can get hold of a good personal tutor, why not start with the B/C? Yet it may not suit everyone... the requirement to row cross from square one, the kind of backward logic of the D scale... I feel this has the tendency to fry the brain (well, it fried my brain a bit for the best part of a year... the perverse logic of the damn thing...

), and lengthen the learning curve. Logical it may be, but intuitive it ain't...
Remember, whatever system you choose, get a decent box. European made if you can. And if it's a modestly priced machine, see about getting it fettled - whilst a factory set Hohner is OK for morris use, it needs a bit of work to set it right for Irish music (where a gentler, more precise tone generally tends to fit in better) - e.g. reduce keyboard travel... power down the tremolo... check/regulate the valves/springs/pads...
Speaking from experience (struggling with a factory set Delicia B/C for a frustrating few months

), this is important - you need to be able to make the right noises to keep your interest engaged.
Ed J