I'm in agreement with all of the above, from Bob and Boxer. If I wanted everything in every direction, I'd have gone for a PA or CBA, neither of which have ever done it for me when I've had a go on them. I'm a contra dance musician, and the bounce is where it is at if you want to keep the dancers happy and energized. That said, I do love the flowing cross row stuff that presents itself when you have reversals to work with
I guess part of my (again, conceptual) interest in swapping out the redundant notes is to, as Boxer pointed out, allow the left and right hands to work together in more combinations. For example (and this is an observation not a criticism of Bob's excellent layout), there are F's on the pull only and a Bb in the left hand on the push only, which would be solved with the swap I outlined above.
It really comes down to each persons idea of a perfect layout, and having a sense of where you want your box's strengths and weaknesses to lie. Oddly enough, the thought of swapping out the redundant E pulls holds no interest to me at all, even though you could go down the same rabbit hole and make them Bb's.
Much like the ongoing thread about playing the box or playing the music, it's fun to do both. This is the lesser side of the equation for me. Plus, what else am I supposed to do when not learning to play the thing? Probably something sensible like consume food...

Thanks,
Baron