Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: Different ideas of 3-row layouts  (Read 4810 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

emcintosh

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #20 on: November 24, 2016, 12:57:11 PM »

Let's suppose one took the LHS off an 18 bass DGAcc, and attached to a BCC# RHS, is there anything preventing a skilled BCC# player from sounding exactly the same as a DGAcc  player who uses reversals regularly in playing?  Presumably all the notes are there in both push and pull (whereas they aren't on a DGAcc).

You don't *quite* have all the notes in both directions: G is only on the push, and A, Bb (twice!) and D are only on the pull.

[I don't think you could get everything in both directions with three standard diatonic rows, as you only have three push notes per row and there are twelve notes to cover. If I wanted to add a comprehensive reversals row to a BC box, it would have to have C#, D, F, G#, A & Bb  on the push and C, Eb, F# & G on the pull. So the width of an octave on the pull would be the same as the other rows, but you probably would only get about an octave and a half of push reversals (six to the octave) on a reasonable-length keyboard (2.5 if you modified a 46-key Shand Morino). You *could* do it, but I don't think anyone apart from me would actually consider such a monstrosity.]

Presumably the 18 DGacc basses give you more notes/chords than a similar size of Stradella bass, but some only in one direction? http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/Evo%20note%20plan.jpg has D, G, A in both directions, but Bb only on the *push*. I really don't have enough knowledge to say whether your hybrid would be [un]sympathetic at similar points to playing on a DGacc.
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #21 on: November 24, 2016, 01:20:30 PM »

OK.  My DGAcc has on the RHS:

C - both
C# - pull only
D - both
Eb - push only
E - both
F - pull only
F# - both
G - both
G# - pull only
A - both
Bb - both
B - both

whereas the BCC# layout has:

C - both
C# - both
D - pull only
Eb - both
E - both
F - both
F# - both
G - push only
A - pull only
Bb - pull only
B - both

So, if that's right, therefore there are four limitations on each system.  But how on earth do BCC# players cope with the absence of one direction on D, G and A, which are all very frequent notes in the home keys, if they are playing in the DG home keys (compared with the limitations on the DGAcc system, which are much less frequent)? Surely they must therefore have more bisonoric basses, which will probably kill their speed?  I think I'm just beginning to understand why BCC# may not quite be as flexible as it's cracked up to be.
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #22 on: November 24, 2016, 01:24:55 PM »

emcintosh, I ought to say that your point about three push notes per row is not true of the Atzarin layout, which is fully chromatic in both directions, on three rows.  The limitation is conferred only by the convention.
Logged

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #23 on: November 24, 2016, 02:02:05 PM »

But how on earth do BCC# players cope with the absence of one direction on D, G and A, which are all very frequent notes in the home keys, if they are playing in the DG home keys
...
Surely they must therefore have more bisonoric basses, which will probably kill their speed?

Most B/C/C# accordions have Stradella basses which are unisonoric.
I don't understand the part about killing the speed though, whichever you meant.

The main speed limitation on the B/C/C# is the weight of the LHS because of the Stradella mechanism and being a large box generally.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #24 on: November 24, 2016, 02:43:29 PM »

Yes, I realise that BCC#s usually have stradella basses, presumably because of the opportunities to play in lots of keys - but I was just referring to the idea of an 18-bass rectangular layout with a BCC# RH, for comparative reasons. My point about killing speed was that if you are restricted to only certain bellows directions by the RHS, you would need extra reversed basses to achieve the same flexibility as the DGAcc layout, and the extra LHS weight and/or bellows cross-sectional area would probably then reduce playing speed, other things being equal.

I have a hunch that the quint layout has advantages that are not generally spelled out, and I'm trying to understand what they are, if indeed it's true.  It was surprising to me that the BCC# layout was deficient in the respects that emcintosh referred to, because I had previously thought of it as some kind of ideal, as I think many contributors in the past have assumed.
Logged

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #25 on: November 24, 2016, 02:59:50 PM »

The lack of those key reversals (which inhibits cross row flexibility) and a lack of a row to play up and down (inhibiting the bounce I was looking for) is what steered me towards my D/G/Acc system. I can imagine that if you are already familiar with B/C adding that C# row would add a lot of flexibility, in the same way that adding an Acc row to a D/G does. I think one of the deciding factors for a lot of people is what system you started with and where you want to get to without learning a new system. I started with a D/G system and quickly started to think about transferring to dutch reversals before I got too accustomed to having a straight G row, and ended up with a D/G/Acc 3 row with a fully "dutch reversed" G row (and 18 mostly unisonoric basses).

Since folks are talking about what they've got in what direction, my system is:

C - both
C# - both
D - both
Eb - pull only
E - both
F - both
F# - both
G - both
G# - pull only
A - both
Bb - push only in low and high octaves, but both in the middle octave
B - both
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #26 on: November 24, 2016, 03:05:48 PM »

If the goal is all notes in all directions why not play a piano or continental button acciordion?

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #27 on: November 24, 2016, 03:57:47 PM »

D/G players speculating on whether B/C/C# is all it is cracked up to be is like (to borrow a metaphor I heard recently) eunuchs discussing the experience of, er, married life.

And of course the same is true of semitone players wondering about life as a D/G player, which is why I don't do that. Not publicly anyway.

However, there is a difference - unlike our mutilated brethren we can easily acquire the missing equipment and experience the joys currently denied to us. If curiosity is so strong, why not pick up an old Black Dot or Trichord and find out?

Edited to say: sorry, that's a simile, not a metaphor.

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #28 on: November 24, 2016, 04:09:59 PM »

If the goal is all notes in all directions why not play a piano or continental button accordion?

BURN THE HERETIC!  >:E

But seriously, that's a good point, and is the reason why I've never had a great desire for a box with more than two rows (except for an ongoing flirtation with the Club system) .
I've done piano accordions and B/C/C#, and had a 2.5row Saltarelle for a while (so Stiamh's remarks don't apply  ;)), and for some reason decided not to continue with them. Less is more! (i.e. "more than enough for me") and I'm sure I'll be able to spend the rest of my life learning new tunes that can be played on two rows and a couple of accidentals.

I have occasionally considered getting a small PA or CBA for doing tunes in minor and remote keys. Maybe as a retirement project...
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #29 on: November 24, 2016, 04:20:07 PM »

In answer to Lester, because there's lots of benefits from the quint system, which at the end of the day, sounds far less mushy for some reason.

And in answer to Stiamh, I've not been a eunuch , so I wouldn't know!  However, you may have missed the point I was recently making, which for home keys at least, seems to counter your assumption.  My original request was for illustrative examples, however, and I'm still interested in anything anyone may like to post.
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #30 on: November 24, 2016, 04:51:41 PM »

But how on earth do BCC# players cope with the absence of one direction on D, G and A, which are all very frequent notes in the home keys, if they are playing in the DG home keys (compared with the limitations on the DGAcc system, which are much less frequent)? Surely they must therefore have more bisonoric basses, which will probably kill their speed?  I think I'm just beginning to understand why BCC# may not quite be as flexible as it's cracked up to be.

My flippant answer was not that flippant, Chris. It's easy to ascertain that the other system can't do certain things that you really like about the system you know well. Perhaps less easy to understand what the other system can do that you haven't thought of. Surely you would need to try the other system seriously, for an extended period, to find out what it can do.

I don't see why you think not having D, G and A in both directions is such a huge problem. (BCC# basses are almost always unisonoric.) One of the advantages of a 2-row B/C is that you have a string of 5 notes in the middle of the scale on the pull (ABC#DE) and one of its frustrations is that you have to change directions to get arpeggios of D and G (not for Dm or A maj or Emaj/min or Bb maj/min though - or B or C maj/min (:) ). BCC# adds one more note to the string on the pull and allows you to get D and G arpeggios in the same direction.

Add to this the fact that on B/C you already have a wider range of keys easily or relatively easily playable than on a 2-row D/G, and when you add a C# row you can just shift across a row and get those B/C keys a semitone up. Then add that you can do a lot more one-direction runs... What's not to like? Apart from the bulk and weight of course, which is why I don't think I'll ever try BCC# or C#DD# (unless someone gives me one).

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #31 on: November 24, 2016, 04:54:34 PM »

Nothing against semitone systems or players implied on my end, I love the sound of a B/C or C#/D, or anything in between. I also love the sound of a chromatic. If I had the time and flexibility of brain, I'd learn them all! If there was one box that could do it all, we'd all play that and none of these fun discussions would exist.
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #32 on: November 24, 2016, 05:32:21 PM »

Yes, I suppose I feel much the same, Baron.  I don't anticipate being around for another 40 years to develop the expertise in another system from what I'm used to , so I regret that it's not a realistic option for me.

Stiamh, I think your telling point is that most BCC# basses are unisonoric, so that my suggestion of the bisonoric LHS is somewhat unfair.  However the point of my earlier suggestion was to try to understand what precisely it is that sets a quint box and a semitone box apart, because if you can play 'quint' on  a semitone, why don't players seem to do so?  I fully understand about being able to play in other keys (and indeed I have a Roland V-accordion which makes this feasible with the same fingering).  It's just that I don't see many players around doing BCC# playing in dance bands these days, and I'm beginning to wonder why not. 

On a DGAcc, having the D, G and A in both directions seems such an advantage because it allows combinations of legato and 'choppy', at will, in the home keys.  I'm always open to persuasion, though - would a semitone player perhaps play Jimmy Allen (as per another thread), to let us listen?
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #33 on: November 24, 2016, 06:32:48 PM »

However the point of my earlier suggestion was to try to understand what precisely it is that sets a quint box and a semitone box apart, because if you can play 'quint' on  a semitone, why don't players seem to do so?  I fully understand about being able to play in other keys (and indeed I have a Roland V-accordion which makes this feasible with the same fingering).  It's just that I don't see many players around doing BCC# playing in dance bands these days, and I'm beginning to wonder why not.

Has anybody said they can play "quint" on a semitone? If so, I don't get it. On a 2-row semitone box you have exactly 2 reversals. That doesn't sound like much, and indeed it isn't, but it adds a welcome measure of flexibility in phrasing/avoiding bellows changes, and has to be used for certain chords. And that's it. We get all the notes but fewer choices.

BCC# gives you another two reversals on the main row and some between the 1st and 3rd rows. How that works out in practice... ask George. (:)

Why aren't BCC# players seen in bands much these days? Well they probably never were in England. In Ireland they were quite common in the 50s and 60s but younger players seem to have decided the weight and bulk aren't worth it and you can do everything you want with a 2-row semitone box. And when you listen to S Shannon, D Byrne or M O'Connor it's hard to disagree with that assessment.

If you want to know what Jimmy Allen sounds like on a C#/D, just play it in G on your D row. And on a B/C, just play it in A on your D row. As my québécois friends are fond of saying, "Dats it dats all".

waldoB

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 126
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #34 on: November 24, 2016, 07:29:15 PM »

If you watch and listen to the player in particular you will see that there is rather more going on than 'playing the tune ' . The melody, counter melody, harmonies, chords, variations, decorations plus quite a lot else. All at the same. And on both ends. In meticulous time. The treble end, being bisonoric, needs reversals to play all the notes. 4 1/2 chromatic octaves on the treble end from 34 buttons to go with a chromatic bass on the fundamentals plus chords must be worth learning a few scales.
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #35 on: November 25, 2016, 03:02:16 PM »

The point of this thread for me is to understand more about the merits of the completely different systems - I'm trying not to grind any axes, and hopefully to keep an open mind.  It has perhaps been accepted wisdom amongst quinters that their system will never be able to do what a BCC# system can.  However the genuine question I'm now asking is whether it is the case that the BCC# is superior in all respects?  I'm tentatively suggesting that a well-designed DGAcc system, with its useful reversals, allows choice of dynamics in practice, which is highly valuable musically (see playandteach's thread on this very matter), but this is not so easy with the BCC#, because the reversals you often need for this purpose are not there.  With the Atzarin system, with which I had a passing acquaintance, it does have the merit of (almost) full RHS chromaticity in both directions.  Stiamh made the telling point that semitone systems tend to have unisonoric basses.  In theory this might mean that it would allow any combination of LH chord and RH melody note.  However, the snag with this is that you may still have to reverse bellows to achieve it, and that could adversely affect the dynamics of a piece of music - particularly if you have to chop up a nice legato passage to do it.

(For me, there is no question that a BCC# has superiority in playing in non-DG home keys, by the way.  Also, discussion about semitone vs. quint two-row systems is really a separate issue, and I wasn't really wanting to go there.)
Logged

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #36 on: November 25, 2016, 03:53:45 PM »

Stiamh made the telling point that semitone systems tend to have unisonoric basses.  In theory this might mean that it would allow any combination of LH chord and RH melody note.  However, the snag with this is that you may still have to reverse bellows to achieve it, and that could adversely affect the dynamics of a piece of music - particularly if you have to chop up a nice legato passage to do it.

If you really don't want to risk bellows changes in any legato passage, the only answer is a fully unisonoric accordion. The bellows changes are necessitated by the fact that not all RH notes are available in both directions. I don't see how unisonoric basses would make that problem any worse.
Actually, I don't think that's a problem anyway; with practice it's possible to play legato enough with the occasional bellows change.

Quote
For me, there is no question that a BCC# has superiority in playing in non-DG home keys, by the way.
Well, that is the main difference.

Another significant difference is the B/C/C# is a heavy instrument so it's hard work getting up much speed (though I don't know that they are typically much heavier than some 3 row 18 bass melodeons).
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Different ideas of 3-row layouts
« Reply #37 on: November 25, 2016, 04:17:02 PM »

If you really don't want to risk bellows changes in any legato passage, the only answer is a fully unisonoric accordion. The bellows changes are necessitated by the fact that not all RH notes are available in both directions. I don't see how unisonoric basses would make that problem any worse.

Actually, I don't think that's a problem anyway; with practice it's possible to play legato enough with the occasional bellows change.

My local repairman fulfilled an unusual request a few years ago: a customer had asked him to put bisonoric basses on a CBA!
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal