in answer to the original question, I can only share my own experience which is that, owning both a saltarelle and a castagniari, both appeal to me from time to time. That is to say, after a month or two of playing one, the other seems suddenly more attractive. So if you're as fickle as I am, aim for one of each. When it comes to playing in sessions or elsewhere, I usually leave both at home, and take a Hohner along, because it's louder (I don't advocate deafening people, but you can play lightly on a Hohner and still cut through a racket of guitars and drums).