I missed seeing this thread until today - really interesting discussion.
I have been to only two workshops, each three days long. They were very different from each other, both were enjoyable with good and less good elements. I was about in the middle of each group, in my level of ability.
The first workshop was quite technical and we concentrated on one tune. We were given a recording of the tune, with instructions on where to push/pull and which bass/chords to play. We were expected to learn the tune beforehand, but not to work on it beyond that. By the end of the workshop, I could play a lovely Italian mazurka with quite impressive left hand accompagnement! We also learned a fair bit of theory about how to make up right hand chords in various positions of the keyboard, chord scales and lots about tempo and rhythm - rhythmic variations of right and left handed chords, arpeggios etc. These are some of the good points about the course. I received some useful critique, with pointers on how to improve. Weaker points: very little ensemble playing; those who had not learned the tune, or maybe just the different levels of ability, I would have enjoyed playing with a partner or a couple of people at about my level; it was very intensive, I would have enjoyed the odd break, just playing together.
The second workshop was much less formal and less structured. We learned to play as an ensemble with counter melodies, drones, and variations. In the evenings, local musicians were invited to join, with an excellent variety of instruments and the tutor led us through various arrangements. There was a little bit of theory, mainly about rythmes and counter-rythmes. We worked outdoors, played together or in small groups and the atmosphere was cheerful and relaxed. On the weaker side, I am not sure that I actually learned very much! There was no personal feedback on my playing other than generally positive and being put in the higher group.
So there is a summary of my limited experience of workshops. I don’t think I will go to another workshop with either tutor, but I enjoyed them both. I do know more about what to look for in a workshop for the future. For what its worth and bearing in mind that I am a 65 year old who is serious about improving my ability, here are some of my wishes for a workshop in the future:
To know the tunes in advance and to be expected to be able to play them, without sheet music;
To receive feedback and personal advice;
To have some periods all working together and some in pairs and groups of similar ability/learning speed;
To learn the theory that underpins the practical learning;
To come away playing generally a bit better and at least one tune quite well, with new techniques that I can apply elsewhere;
To have fun, feeling relaxed and part of a cohesive and friendly group.
Maggie
