I did try PA myself as an attempt to not fall into the trap of buying Melodeons in multiple keys (fail!). With intermediate keyboard skills, eg being able to play through a couple of Bach inventions, it seemed like the obvious choice, but I found having the same old keyboard layout a bit too familiar and boring to inspire me really, but possibly by that point the preference for bisonoric buttons was already too far ingrained. I had a Starlet myself for a little while but even that is somewhat bulkier and heavier than say an early Hohner Club… There are of course huge advantages to PA or CBA, but for those I turn to other instruments eg guitar or mandolin. Definitely if squeezeboxes were my only thing, I’d have to get something chromatic though…