Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: Club accidentals  (Read 2454 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Club accidentals
« Reply #20 on: February 25, 2024, 05:07:21 PM »

While I understand that it was constructed "brick by brick", I think the full 3rd row makes very little sense: the accidentals are useful, but they're not set up according to at least the same "3 on the push, 4 on the pull" logic as the other rows. It's very difficult to develop an intuition of where a given accidental will be, as it keeps on changing throughout the row. In that respect, any continental 3rd row layout always seemed superior to a full 3rd Club row.

That’s kind of the point I was making, but when you go through the steps outlined above as the people at Hohner would have, you can see how those particular choices were made…

I have a modified club ii, which in principle has a 3 push/4 pull matrix on the accidental row (G# C# Eb push, F# G# C# Eb pull), although it only has 4 buttons so I nudged the first F# up one button, sacrificing pull G#. This is possible with Dutch reversal, but would still be missing the push Bb found on standard club (were I to upgrade to a club box with 7+ accidental buttons)…
« Last Edit: February 25, 2024, 05:42:25 PM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Club accidenta
« Reply #21 on: February 25, 2024, 06:29:09 PM »


    Perma-thirdless 🤔 yet another English word that got its first outing on melnet!  it's been much discussed.  In essence that is a decision to express most of your music on the right hand, and to use the left more for rhythm and to set the modal frame of your music. The ear usually takes that from the base note.

   A big plus is that your left-end no linger defines whether you're playing in major or minor. So what?  That was implicit in  whatever you are doing on the right, anyway.  And if you really want eg a Cm chord … just play that thirdless C5 and stick a spare finger onto a suitable Eb on the other end 😉

  There is another gain:  with respect to cross-base chords. While minor/major always works, eg A/C=Cmin7 the same as not true when you are making a major chord.

   T

I agree with Theo when he says a diatonic box has inherent limitations and will never do everything, so you choices will always have compromises to get the best that suits your own playing. 

Adding a full third third row to the RH keyboard, or a fourth one, or even a fifth, will not change that. And even instruments with 18 or 24 basses, if you play melodies that are chromatic in nature,  will still remain limited. The only step that could help is switching to the in line basses, like in the instruments that were used in the early French musette and the early Italian liscio, but even those hybrid instruments, that could virtually play in any key, but were agile  only in a few, were supplanted by the piano accordion and its button counterpart, that offered more flexibility and could cope with the chromatic melodies.

Given this, as I said in my last post that can be read above, I don't like to mute the thirds, but I do when I cannot avoid it on my G/C box, although as I made clear my D chord is  a D5  and my E chord is an Em chord, and that helps when I play in C, G, and in general in F, avoiding the G chord that should be a Gm, so I am already accepting a minor compromise.

Why I don't like to mute the thirds? Because in a well conceived harmonic progression that uses five or six of the diatonic triads the different moods that the major and the minor chord express add depth, and - no matter what you play with your right hand - muting all the thirds flattens everything out.

It's like just printing a colour photograph in black and white. If it's a portrait, the results could look artistic, like in fact a chord progression built using just the tonic, the subdominant and the dominant/dominant7 will remain consistent even if you use the 5 chords in place of the full major triads.  If you have an articulated harmonic progression that uses both the major and the minor chords, muting the thirds is just like printing in black and white the photo of a rainbow. And for those who don't have a colour blind musical ear this makes a huge difference.

By the way, on the G/C box I occasionally use the C major chord to compensate a missing Am chord on the push, or the G pull chord to compensate a missing G minor chord on the pull. I do it after I've played the root or the fifth of the chords as a bass, and after I've played at least once the full minor triad. That way I can trick even a well trained musical ear into thinking I've first played the minor triad, then I have added the seventh, incidentally subtracting the root, changing the chords from the minor triad to the extended minor7 chords. The price I have to pay, of course, is that the minor7 chords, since they are actually very unstable chords, need to resolve quickly, and the number of chords that can follow them is limited, but usually I am able to cope with it. The trick would not work muting the thirds, since the A5  corresponds to the A and E notes, while the C5 to the C ad G notes, and the E5 chord to the E and B notes, while the G5 chord corresponds to the G and D notes. No notes in common, no way to trick a well trained musical ear into thinking the chords remain the same.

 

Logged
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal