Stumbled upon this old thread recently. Wildly interesting stuff! In the past I’ve posted here about troubles I had with boxes having too harsh overtones, but at the time there was hardly response making me think It was my particular problem.
It’s reassuring to hear that others have similar experiences. I actually sold four accordions because I found their sound too harsh: a four voice Hohner PA, a three voice Bugari CBA, a small three voice Hohner CBA and a two voice Ballone Burini. The latter I’ve shown here with different grilles; I found that a thick wooden grille diminished the overtones significantly.
I’ve been wondering for a long time what causes these shrill overtones; I always found that with the reed out of the instrument the reed sounded ‘normal’. I thought maybe it had to do with having an aluminium ground plate instead of wood; I even suspected plastic valves being a possible cause.
This post about reed blocks sheds a new light on the matter. I may try to repeat the test of diminishing reed chamber size. But first I have to fully tune the three voice CBA which I just successfully finished replacing all valves.