Thanks a lot. It helps to gain more insight. I see many tunes played in one row. For BC that would always be the C-row than, (for playing in G D a Em Am and theoretically C) and the B-row only is for providing an extra B and E and three half tones. It is never used for playing in one row. The Ais and Dis are merely “accidentals”.
Is that correct?
Yes, correct, in the context of Irish music.
More generally, in a kind of mirror effect, it is possible to use the B row as your 'home row' and get the missing notes from the C row. Examples:
- To play in G, use the C row (for G, A, B, C, D, E) and get F# from B row
- To play in F#, use the B row (for F#, G#, A#, B, C#, D#) and get F from C row
- To play in F, use the C row (F, G, A, ooops, C, D, E) and get the ooops missing Bb from B row
- To play in E, use the B row (E, F#, G#, ooops, B, C#, D#) and get A from C row
Notice the trend: what you can do working from the C row you can usually replicate half-a-step lower working from B row (including - duh - playing on-the-row in C and B !). Anyway, I'm not for a second suggesting you learn to play in F#, just hoping it helps you better understand the layout and its possibilities - it is both simple and confusing.
Consider beginning playing on the row to familiarize yourself with the note layout. All the push notes are 1, 3 and 5 of your scale (C, E and G for key of C) and the remaining notes 2, 4, 6, 7 are on the pull (D, F, A, B). This disparity of 3 push notes vs 4 pull ones accounts for the changing pairing of button notes from one octave to the next (ex: C/D on button 3, C/B on button 6, C/A on button 9)
https://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21modernbass.gifNext you can try tunes in G, for which you would only need one note (the F#) from the B row. The key of F (not much used for Irish) also needs only one note (Bb) and provides the added interest (don't think of it as a difficulty

) of being 'in reverse' i.e. F, the tonic note is on the pull, which can be disconcerting. It can be good preparation before trying the key of D which is also on the pull, and with 2 notes to get from the B row.
Main thing: Keep it fun !