I shared this discussion with my daughter (28 and visiting the 'olds') , who is a classically trained violin player. She immediately commented that she thinks being able to play music by ear (without any recourse to written music) is a great skill. However she also made a point about the value of learned musicianship by asking my husband, a pianist (strictly amateur)if he had recently bought any new music. He brought out a book of Roger Quilter songs which he had had for a week or so. My daughter got out her violin, opened the book randomly, put it onto the piano, counted her and her father in, and they played the piece beautifully together by sight reading it. She had never seen or heard the music before. To suggest that because neither of these people had seen people dance to the music, could sing it, had listened to a range of musical interpretations of it before they played it, or that reading music is 'restricting', that therefore there must be something lacking in the performance or interpretation of it is missing the point I think. Playing by ear is indeed a useful and meaningful skill, but should it be validated at the expense of other skills which are equally valid and useful?