Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Tuning process  (Read 1695 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Telemorris

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 405
  • C/F Preciosa
Tuning process
« on: July 18, 2012, 12:23:06 AM »

I've run across a very interesting description recently of how a professional harmonica tuner goes about the process.

I'd like to ask the professionals here to weigh in with a description of how they deal with ensuring accurate intervals in, say, a two row instrument.

I've been working out my own process but it's very slow because I'm coming from a self imposed level of perfection that may, ultimately, be impossible. I always tune the reeds in the instrument itself though I separate the bass and treble sides from the instrument's bellows and bed them against a tuning bellows with a soft leather surface that provides a reasonable air seal.

I start by tuning the bass fundamentals, the tenor first, then tune the low fundamental to the tenor, trying to ensure no beats between the two.

I then tune the tonic in the related chord to the tenor reed, again, aiming for no beats. After that comes the fifth for the chord tuned to a beatless interval with either the tenor reed or the tonic of the chord. Then, finally the third tuned to the tuning meter - here's where I don't really know what to do - how to sweeten the beating between the tonic and the third.

I progress through the four basses and four chords, trying to match up the notes in each chord with the same note in a different chord. To do this, I use my feeler gauges to prevent unwanted reeds from sounding - not always an easy task on the pull note.

Given that this is my first time through this new process, I haven't figured out how to couple the treble to the bass without use of the pins to ensure a beatless agreement between the reeds in the chords. Is this overkill?

Anyway, my expectation is to use a few of the reeds on the bass side as standards against which I tune the concert pitch reed in a pair of reeds. I'll block off the M+ reeds with a piece of tissue paper between the palletboard and the reedblock shoe. My expectation is to start with the tonic for each row, make sure it's in pitch with the bass, tune the fifth to a beatless interval, tune the octaves of the tonic and the fifth, then the third based on whatever I decided to use for the temperament of the third in the bass end. Once the push is done, then I'll start on the pull and I'm not sure how to tackle them.

Theo, Martyn, Lester, anyone, what kind of tolerance do you use for accuracy of your tuning? I've been using a Dirk's tuner which seems to give an accuracy of 0.1 cent though I don't know if it's really accurate to that level. I also have a Korg Orchestral tuner (recommended in another thread) and can get a pitch accurate to the point where the indicator hovers over the "0" and the flat and sharp lights both light up and say the note is in tune but the Dirk's tuner might indicate it's off by about one or two cents. Hence the interest in tolerances.

Once the concert pitch reeds are, theoretically, in tune, I'll take the blocks out of the instrument and tune the tremolo based on a beat profile. Final tuning of the beating happens with the blocks in the instrument.

I welcome comments, additions.

Ed

Logged
Ed Stevens
Bridgetown Morris Men
Portland, Oregon, US
Erica D/G, Presswood Pokerwork G/C, Preciosa C/F

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Tuning process
« Reply #1 on: July 18, 2012, 02:00:39 PM »

I've run across a very interesting description recently of how a professional harmonica tuner goes about the process.

I'd like to ask the professionals here to weigh in with a description of how they deal with ensuring accurate intervals in, say, a two row instrument.

I've been working out my own process but it's very slow because I'm coming from a self imposed level of perfection that may, ultimately, be impossible. I always tune the reeds in the instrument itself though I separate the bass and treble sides from the instrument's bellows and bed them against a tuning bellows with a soft leather surface that provides a reasonable air seal.

I start by tuning the bass fundamentals, the tenor first, then tune the low fundamental to the tenor, trying to ensure no beats between the two.

I then tune the tonic in the related chord to the tenor reed, again, aiming for no beats. After that comes the fifth for the chord tuned to a beatless interval with either the tenor reed or the tonic of the chord. Then, finally the third tuned to the tuning meter - here's where I don't really know what to do - how to sweeten the beating between the tonic and the third.

I progress through the four basses and four chords, trying to match up the notes in each chord with the same note in a different chord. To do this, I use my feeler gauges to prevent unwanted reeds from sounding - not always an easy task on the pull note.

Given that this is my first time through this new process, I haven't figured out how to couple the treble to the bass without use of the pins to ensure a beatless agreement between the reeds in the chords. Is this overkill?

Anyway, my expectation is to use a few of the reeds on the bass side as standards against which I tune the concert pitch reed in a pair of reeds. I'll block off the M+ reeds with a piece of tissue paper between the palletboard and the reedblock shoe. My expectation is to start with the tonic for each row, make sure it's in pitch with the bass, tune the fifth to a beatless interval, tune the octaves of the tonic and the fifth, then the third based on whatever I decided to use for the temperament of the third in the bass end. Once the push is done, then I'll start on the pull and I'm not sure how to tackle them.

Theo, Martyn, Lester, anyone, what kind of tolerance do you use for accuracy of your tuning? I've been using a Dirk's tuner which seems to give an accuracy of 0.1 cent though I don't know if it's really accurate to that level. I also have a Korg Orchestral tuner (recommended in another thread) and can get a pitch accurate to the point where the indicator hovers over the "0" and the flat and sharp lights both light up and say the note is in tune but the Dirk's tuner might indicate it's off by about one or two cents. Hence the interest in tolerances.

Once the concert pitch reeds are, theoretically, in tune, I'll take the blocks out of the instrument and tune the tremolo based on a beat profile. Final tuning of the beating happens with the blocks in the instrument.

I welcome comments, additions.

Ed
Regardless of how accurately you can measure pitch (or tune reeds!) you need to think about what you can actually hear...

A semitone around middle C is a pitch difference of about 16Hz, so 1 cent error between a pair of reeds is 1 beat every 6 seconds which I think most people would call unison or dry tuning -- 0.1 cents on Dirk's tuner is 1 beat per minute!  For absolute pitch errors on a solo note (as opposed to tuning between two reeds) nobody can hear an error this small, and for chords ET has errors up to 14 cents (major third) and we take this for granted.

Anyway there's no point trying to get very accurate reed tuning (<5 cents) outside the instrument because the pitch can change several cents inside the box due to changes in acoustic loading on the reed -- unless you're using the calibration features of Dirk's Tuner to compensate for the difference between inside and outside, in this case you could in theory do all the tuning outside (including the calibrated offsets) and get exact pitch inside -- but I don't know if this works in real life...

Also if you're tuning to concert pitch with a tuning with reeds offset either side (like "Dedic" tuning) you'll find your method is a real pain, as Nielsen did -- on my Oakwood he used to tune one reed bank up to concert (because that's what his tuning references could do), then the second bank 2 beats sharp of this, then the first bank 4 beats flat from the second one, which is a lot more tuning than needed. And once he forgot to take the first bank back down from concert so I got a "traditional" tuning back i.e. out of tune :-(
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: Tuning process
« Reply #2 on: July 18, 2012, 02:25:12 PM »

Another factor in trying to tune accordion reeds is that the pitch will vary substantially according to the air pressure on the reed. 
Logged

forrest

  • Other Places::
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1009
  • digits still functioning
Re: Tuning process
« Reply #3 on: July 18, 2012, 03:27:14 PM »


 -- unless you're using the calibration features of Dirk's Tuner to compensate for the difference between inside and outside, in this case you could in theory do all the tuning outside (including the calibrated offsets) and get exact pitch inside -- but I don't know if this works in real life...

Also if you're tuning to concert pitch with a tuning with reeds offset either side (like "Dedic" tuning) you'll find your method is a real pain, as Nielsen did

I'm certainly no expert on tuning, but I have some info to share, take it as you will. Using Dirk's, if you have the additional 'Record and Report' feature, it's possible to record the status of the treble reeds in situ, and the data will be assembled in a chart showing the pitch and beating values that are existing. The report also shows the error of each tone based on a goal which is inherent in the "beating chart" you select for the outcome of your tuning job. It is quite easy to fabricate or amend this beating chart, so you could model an existing tuning of your friend's great sounding box, and emulate that, all skills etc. being equal.
    Once you know the error of each note, you can apply that shift (in either 'cents'  or Hz) to the reeds sounded outside the box. I have used this method, and its a real time saver. My aim is to tune the reeds to within one to three cents of the goal (considering the shift) outside the box, where it is easier to make large changes. After the reeds are re-installed, the fine tuning begins, and it is a much lighter job at this point. I have found this method to work quite well. In the situation of Dedic tuning, you merely tune one treble note flat of zero and the other sharp to the same degree. When the reeds are back in the box, they should be fairly close to your goal. I find that it is a great saving of effort over using a meter on each and every single reed. The advantage of Dirk's is also evident that you can meter the reed pair and see it's relative position against a zero reference which clearly shows you how much north or south to adjust the individual reeds. Of course, after all this is said and done, it's up to the ear to make the final judgement........ ::)

edited for clarity
« Last Edit: July 18, 2012, 03:51:45 PM by j.w.forrest »
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal