Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Martin J on January 09, 2009, 11:14:00 AM

Title: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 09, 2009, 11:14:00 AM
If a musician is paid to play does that payment remove him/her from 'Folk Music' in it's purest form and move them into the professional or semi professional arena and therefore by definiton also invalidate them as Folk performers ?


See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.0.html.  Thread drift has sparked my query.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: joe on January 09, 2009, 01:51:58 PM
As a member of a team I have been paid to play, however the money has never ended up in my pocket (with the exception of fuel costs on occasion). The main 'event' for our team is local, and the only money involved is the collection, which funds some of the other events throuhout the year, plus costs of guest teams' accomodation etc.

I have been fed and given the odd free drink as part of a session that attracts a crowd, does that count?

I have also been asked to play proper slots at the pub (as opposed to sessions) in exchange for money. I am a bit wary of this as I feel it may take away from what the music is about. On the other hand it may justify some of the time I would have to spend rehearsing, which I feel would be necessary in order to play the said slots. I dont think I have made the issue any clearer and my mind is split.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Stiamh on January 09, 2009, 02:07:36 PM
If a musician is paid to play does that payment remove him/her from 'Folk Music' in it's purest form and move them into the professional or semi professional arena and therefore by definiton also invalidate them as Folk performers ?

"Folk performer"? If you're going to be a purist, isn't there something incongruous about this term?
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Matthew B on January 09, 2009, 02:17:33 PM
I'm quite comfortable getting paid to play.  Sadly, it doesn't happen nearly often enough.  But then again, I'm not sure what distinguishes a folk musician from any other kind of musician: no tail coat, perhaps?
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 09, 2009, 02:43:57 PM
"Folk performer"? If you're going to be a purist, isn't there something incongruous about this term?

I don't think so.  If someone performs in his local folk club for the entertainment and enjoyment of his friends and visitors he fulfils both parts of the term.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: TomB-R on January 09, 2009, 03:51:55 PM
"He who pays the piper calls the tune!" Paying traditional musicians is a pretty ancient thing, I think.

Surely the essence of folk music is the transmission and learning process, not whether you get paid or not.

Having said that, I think it is quite possible for a performer to cease to be strictly a "folk musician" irrespective of where they started from, and the same for a music genre - traditional American peoples' music transforms into "Country"!

Tom
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 09, 2009, 03:53:59 PM
If a musician is paid to play does that payment remove him/her from 'Folk Music' in it's purest form and move them into the professional or semi professional arena and therefore by definiton also invalidate them as Folk performers ?


See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.0.html.  Thread drift has sparked my query.
Interesting questions....
I have various comments:

1. I play as an orchestral clarinettist in the Sheffield Chamber Orchestra. We play classical music.
http://www.sheffield-chamber-orchestra.org.uk
We give 3 concerts a year at which people pay to come and listen. The annual turnover of the orchestra is something in the region of £10K. That's what it costs to run an orchestra. The orchestra members do not get paid for this. We PAY an annual subscription, currently £70, for the privilege and enjoyment of playing in a reasonably good amateur orchestra. For myself, I am also on the committee which runs the orchestra. None of us gets paid for the hours of time we all spend on this.

2. I play melodeon in a couple of ceilidh bands for which I and the other band members get paid. Nothing huge, perhaps between £60 and £100 per gig. But it helps go towards the cost of sound equipment and travelling expenses plus a bit extra. We play traditional tunes suitable for ceilidh dancing. We provide a service - people book us for parties, weddings, birthdays, etc. We give them a good evening's entertainment, we get some financial remuneration and everyone has a good time. Nothing wrong with that and it does not compromise the 'folkiness' of the traditional music that we play. We all play by ear and the tunes (hopefully) are as good and spontaneous as ever.

3. I am a musician (melodeon) for Lizzie Dripping, a Sheffield-based womens' dance team performing clog and stepping type dance as street entertainment, similar to morris. We all pay a subscription which helps to cover our expenses, principally the hire of a hall for weekly practices. There is usually very little surplus at the end of the year, but if there is any, we sometimes use it to subsidise the costs and expenses of guest teams on weekends of dance, etc. We do not get paid as individuals for performances, but sometimes the team will be paid a modest fee for appearing at events such as festivals, carnivals, etc. This goes into the team funds for use as above. Again, we use mostly traditional music for the dancing, played by ear, with all sorts of spontaneous variations, and I don't think the traditional 'folkiness' is affected at all by any payment.

4. I often play in pub sessions, almost entirely traditional music. As usual in sessions no-one gets paid, but sometimes the pub landlord will provide a free plate of sandwiches for the musicians halfway through the evening, on the grounds that he has increased trade from ordinary punters who come to listen on session nights.

5. I occasionally teach traditional instruments (melodeon and concertina) mostly to beginners at festival workshops. I usually provide music and/or recorded material in advance of these workshops. Yes - I get paid a fee for this but I am giving my time and expertise for this and I think it is a fair exchange, particularly when I have to travel some distance and have to book in at B&B accommodation.

So - I leave it up to you to decide whether I am a 'folk musician' or not. I have no doubts in my own mind.

Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 09, 2009, 04:41:54 PM
If we ran our music as business many of us would be bankrupt or at best playing music we do not particularly enjoy.

I find that the odd gig fee, or sound engineering fee or ceilidh fee helps a little to defray the costs of a stupidly expensive obsession.  I am fortunate not to suffer MAD, but I have the analogous frets complaint.

I find the people who complain most about paid musicians not being true folk persons are the ones who don't perform in such a manner that people would wish to pay them.  Could be jealousy I suppose.

It is traditional that dance musicians are paid, back to the days when courtly music and peoples music were not far separated.

I also suspect that the ones who moan loudest are the egalitarian types who think that everyone should have a go (which I agree with) and that because it is folk, there is no practical difference between (say) John Kirkpatrick and young Stan who got his melodeon last week and is still trying to decide which way up to hold it.

One of the things which has done for the folk revival is the attitude of so-called pros who manage to be expensiv and second rate at the same time.  Your professional musicians, folk or not, must be significantly better than the good amateurs.  I have been to too many folk clubs over the years where the floor singers have been technically better than the pros and more committed to the music.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Stiamh on January 09, 2009, 05:41:56 PM
I find the people who complain most about paid musicians not being true folk persons...

Oh, so there are such people then? I wondered why No Strings was even bringing it up (as in, who cares?).

I'm not interested in applying labels to myself, or the music I play - prefer to let others worry about that - and I've never been to refuse money for musical activities! * I did spend a few minutes this morning pondering whether "folk" was still a valid term for most of what goes on in the field of traditional music and dance these days.  I gave up after a minute but I think it's probably not a useful term any more.

* Actually for a period a few years ago, when people asked me for fiddle or whistle lessons I did insist on not taking money. This was after a friend who taught highland pipes told me he never took money for teaching, and that this was a long-established tradition in piping, which I thought was admirable. Generally it had the effect of discouraging students who couldn't deal with the idea of not paying for lessons - which suited me anyway  ;D



 
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 09, 2009, 06:25:39 PM
The feedback so far seems to support the view that true folk is not profitable and the meagre fees involved barely cover the costs.  So far no feed back from pro's or semi pro's.

To answer Steve Jones as to 'who cares', my thinking was an extension of the thread "morris dancing is dying out apparently" (on the news again this evening).  Will folk clubs die if there are no paid performers ?  Will standards drop if there are no paid performers ?  Should our performers be paid as much as more commercial musicians ?  Falseknight has highlighted instances where the fees do not reflect the skill or performance level.

Steve Freereeder has highlighted an area where great skill is not financially rewarded.

I have been told that some other countries pay anyone who performs, which includes floor spots.  Perhaps our overseas members can deny or confirm.  If paying is the norm, are the standards higher or lower ?
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: ACE on January 09, 2009, 06:34:25 PM
I started playing at folk clubs. I was asked to play at other clubs, pubs and festivals sometime for expenses sometimes as wages.  I done it for over 30 years, not enough cash to give up the day job. I just play at pub sessions now. Am I a folk singer/musician? No. I'm a Landscape gardener who happens to like folk music.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 10, 2009, 12:27:33 PM
I thought I ought to give this a more considered response:

My background (and probably most abiding love) is song, but I have cultural interests in a wide range of other music.

Our notion of folk, I believe, owes virtually everything to the middle class body of men and women who did the first great rescue at the turn of the last century (folk is dying out, we have to go and record this original part of our heritage for posterity).  This exercise  has been repeated with similar desperation every twenty years which should tell us something:  last time they collected Ewan McCall's "Freeborn Man" and "Forty Foot Trailer" as traditional songs - which should tell us a lot more.

The same types of people who attempted to preserve our heritage, also took it on themselves to look to improving the cultural development of the working man.  Hence factory and mine brass bands, BMG (Banjo, Mandolin and Guitar) Orchestras, Male voice (and mixed) choirs, Morris Sides...

By the time our particular revival came about only Bampton and Britannia Coconut Dancers had any real claim to a continuous tradition (discounting local ritual days) , so although sides may have a glorious history, they all stem from a revival getting on for 40 years ago - same as a lot of song.

What's all this to do with payment and folk?

Essentially, our attitude to money is synthetic, coloured by the grand traditions of endowed amateur music (and dance) and a revival which relied on the sources of the early 20th Century collectors.

In 1800, industrialisation had just got into stride.  There was no mass transport, no national communications and most people never moved more than the range of a horse from their place of birth.  Music was local, embedded in the community and musicians (folk or otherwise) were prized.  Songs however, were not deamed up by local poets, common consciousness or any of that - much of what we regard as "traditional" was churned out by the printing presses of 7 Dials and set by (paid) hawkers of songs.  This isone of the reasons tunes recycle round several sets of words and material is often lurid (scandal sells!).  Music crossed between theatre and tradition freely right up to the time of the demise of the music halls, which is how it should be.

I don't believe there has ever been a view, or a tradition that "folk" musicians should not be rewarded for what they bring.  I don't think there has ever been (until now) an attitude that ANYONE should and must play.  The people have always valued excellence and if you are not up to the mark, you are not welcome.  Come to think of it, I don't think our forebears would even recognise the concept of "folk" - that is a distinction made by the collectors.

What has done for us is the determination to make music a product and us passive consumers.  Possibly in this is the reason for the distrust of paying performers.  It makes us consumers rather than particpants.  You haev got to say though, that the workman is worthy of his hire and musicians and singers should be rewarded for what they do.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: press on regardless on January 10, 2009, 11:17:27 PM

There's been quite a few occasions where i've been bought a pint or two to stop me playing, does that count?
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: ACE on January 11, 2009, 11:25:01 AM


What has done for us is the determination to make music a product and us passive consumers.  Possibly in this is the reason for the distrust of paying performers. 

I will read and digest the rest of the post when I have finished War and Peace ;D. But distrust! I might not have been received very well, if the audience was expecting something else but never distrusted.

We had a fall out when we started using microphones back in the early seventies, as the 'finger in the ear purists' said it was not real folk. But what went in the microphone came out of the speaker the same, but louder. Yes distrust might have crept in there but only from a bigoted few. Who, when asked to do a turn were very quick to get up and perform.

When we had electric guitars, a melodeon played through guitar effect pedals and a driving rock beat from a mad drummer, I would not call it folk at all. We used traditional lyrics along with a wall of sound, had a lot of fun, even got a small fan club. I cannot remember any distrust there either.

Perhaps it is you that distrusts change, I could if it was watering down the tradition, but I could never see that happening. As bands like we had come and go in a few years. Folk music in a purer sense has been going on for centuries.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 11, 2009, 12:20:41 PM
I also had long involvement with "electrics" in folk in the 80s.  and have used (and still use) PA at any gig that requires it.  I sit firmly in the camp of the modernisers and will do whatever is necessary to get clarity and understanding of the source music.  My attitude in this respect is closer to the Irish approach than the traditional English approach in that I want a living contemporary music grown from our own musical cultural heritage (similar position incidentally to Martin Carthy and Richard Thomspon),  For the record, I am a guitarist and frets played first and foremost and play melodeon primarily for fun, rather than public performance.  Most of my musical output now is actually in front of a rock band.

I think the issue over remunerating musicians is somewhat different to the issue over electrics and PA though.  It may be bad experiences colouring my views, but at grass roots level and by some of the comments on this thread there is the feeling that if it's folk, it is somehow "of the people" and therefore loses it's purity if it is paid.  "War and Peace" (yes, sorry about the length) was aimed at questionning HOW we had got to this weird position that amateur (and often amateurish) was good, and paid was bad.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 11, 2009, 12:25:11 PM
Distrust of paying performers" was put badly grammatically.  I meant distrust of the concept of performers being paid, in that it steals the authenticity of the music.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: ACE on January 11, 2009, 01:51:09 PM
We used to go and see the original Copper Family near Brighton, they were paid. Also very informative and entertaining. But I would also be first out of the room if Fred Jordan was on as I could not stand his style of singing. They are both folk legends.

So two examples of good and bad, but only in my opinion. These views could be totally opposite from somebody sat besides me.

So it is down to personal choice really. Those that can sit through an evening of free unaccompanied folk singing and have a great evening, might not be the same people that pay a fortune and go and see Bellowhead. But they have made their choice. So there is no good or bad really.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 11, 2009, 02:13:05 PM
And that brings us back to square one:  Is "folk" a meaningful or relevant term?
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: IanD on January 11, 2009, 02:28:55 PM
And that brings us back to square one:  Is "folk" a meaningful or relevant term?

So what would you call it?

Incidentally, I believe the term "world music" was coined when Gordon Potts was working at the Virgin Megastore and he was in charge of "all that non-rock non-jazz non-classical non-pop non-easy-listening stuff" and they needed a shorter label to hang on it, I think he and Ian Anderson came up with it over a lunchtime beer. Now every record shop in the world uses it and everyone understands what it means (or thinks they do).

Ian
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 11, 2009, 03:40:51 PM
I'm inclined to call it music and let it lie.  I think that the years have been very cruel to the term and stepping away from it would do a service to all and might even level the playing field.

For example, is the late, great Cyril Tawney a folk musician?

He has an archive at Cecil Sharp House so he must be, but his songs were authored by him, recognisable as his, in copyright to him and he got paid for performing them by bodies up to and including the BBC.  By the definition of "No pay for folk musicians" that excludes him on just about every count.

Perhaps the term "Home Brewed Music" to indicate it's origins would be most appropriate?
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Mike Higgins on January 11, 2009, 04:11:53 PM
We human beings seem to have an overwhelming desire to name things. If something does not have a name then a must be found. I have been wondering why it is important to call folk music "folk music" perhaps someone can tell me why we need these labels? I know the sort of music the Beatles used to make, or Leadbelly or Haydn for that matter. Knowing the music's type has not greatly increased the considerable enjoyment I get from listening to and playing all of these composers' works.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 11, 2009, 04:54:42 PM
Time to fes up.  I had hoped to provoke one or two of the many full time and part time musicians who frequent this site into giving their opinion of Folk Music and pay for the same.

Some years ago I became so busy (20 to 30 gigs a month) that I considered going full time.  I had two reasons for not doing it.  Firstly after a busy month (which included matinees) I never wanted to play ever again and I know that my bored and disinterested performances near the end of each busy month were not what I was capable of.  Secondly I didn't want to travel and be away from my family.

As an observation most of my work was for 'lay' audiences not folk audiences.  Our band had an agent and he couldn't get the same size fee in folk as he could in the more commercial world.  On the plus side, although we were rarely booked by folk festivals or clubs we took more folk to more people than many of our great bands on the folk scene who do not play commercial venues.  It may even be argued that the general public should pay a proper going rate; why should we subsidise their pleasure ?

Having been careful not to express a personal view earlier in the thread I have to say that I believe many folk artists are worth a great deal more than their pop equivalents, particularly with today's packaging of pop acts where the ability to sing or play is second to appearance.  I believe it is uncontroversially the case that performance is the measure of folk not the look of the player or the band, although many bands are now making great strides in their stage presence.  Certainly I agree with the earlier comment that big pay does not guarantee a good performance but that's the same in any industry  Peanuts may get monkeys but big pay only guarantees that some monkeys are rich.  In a country where there is always someone looking for anything good that they can package and sell to the people who were already getting it for nearly nothing (water is a good example) it is amazing we have lasted so long.  The concept of a professional morris team is as alien as, now let me think, oh yes, paying rugby players.  Now that will never catch on, rugby is for amateurs.

I may still get a few pro and semi pro opinions as the weekend is nearly over and they return home from their gigs in the far flung quarters of the kingdom.  Lets hear it from the returning heroes.  Time away, well spend, properly rewarding or an indulgence.

PS.  Cyril was a great folkie.  Many people will testify to the wonderful after concert singing sessions in the back room, pub, hotel bar etc., something I suspect never happens in popular music.  (I may be wrong, no experience)

PPS.  No labels, Cyril was just great.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Falseknight on January 11, 2009, 05:06:50 PM
Yeah, I'd pretty much agree with all that, though I get really fed up with the worthies of traditional folk.

I am trying to work on a retrospective of my years in the music - might be out for the next significant anniversay - 40 years of guitar.

Working title is "And 5 walked out...", from the joke, "How many folkies does it take to change a lightbulb?"

And Yes, Cyril was great, and uncategorisable.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Howard Jones on January 11, 2009, 06:42:17 PM
It is wrong to imagine that "folk" music was invariably unpaid.

The best traditional singers and musicians were well aware of their position and value in the community.  Good singers would frequently be rewarded, whether in cash, beer or kind.  Many musicians played for dances all around their local area, and were similarly paid - just like modern ceilidh bands. The Bulwers, Billy Bennington, Bob Cann and Scan Tester are just a few that spring to mind.  Scan Tester in particular had a number of bands going, and would vary his repertoire depending on whether he was playing in his local, for a village dance, or to entertain a charabanc trip.

Then there were the morris teams, mummers, plough jags etc for whom collecting money was an integral part of their performance

The idea that folk music ever existed in a world of pure unsullied amateurism, or that singers or musicians weren't "performers", is just fanciful nonsense.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: joe on January 12, 2009, 02:53:28 PM
So it is down to personal choice really. Those that can sit through an evening of free unaccompanied folk singing and have a great evening, might not be the same people that pay a fortune and go and see Bellowhead. But they have made their choice. So there is no good or bad really.

I wouldnt say 'a fortune'. Compared to what I used to pay to go and see some questionable rock bands give an average and tired performance, Bellowhead offer a lively, energetic performance (and the musicianship is probably a hundred times better than a lot of the bands I used to go and see) for a quarter of the price! Folk is good value for money! Then there are the intangible values, feeling like part of the community and all that...
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: ACE on January 12, 2009, 04:30:18 PM
So it is down to personal choice really. Those that can sit through an evening of free unaccompanied folk singing and have a great evening, might not be the same people that pay a fortune and go and see Bellowhead. But they have made their choice. So there is no good or bad really.

I wouldnt say 'a fortune'. Compared to what I used to pay to go and see some questionable rock bands give an average and tired performance, Bellowhead offer a lively, energetic performance (and the musicianship is probably a hundred times better than a lot of the bands I used to go and see) for a quarter of the price! Folk is good value for money! Then there are the intangible values, feeling like part of the community and all that...

Quite agree, What I said was really just using a comparasion between two types of audience. I saw Bellowhead at proms in the park £25 for the whole afternoon and evening also featuring many famous musicians and singers in the 'classical' world. There's another genre that is suss. I also paid £75 to see Leonard Cohen, cheap again when a 74 year old man can entertain for over 3 hours solid. I come from a part of the country that is famous for rock festivals and from my house I hear them free. I certainly would not pay a fortune nowaday to see 'Ice pop daddy' Rappin away to himself. Hmm. Rap! is that folk of a sort? ;D
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: mrjulian on January 13, 2009, 04:21:57 PM
Hi everyone.  I'm glad I found this forum - it makes fun reading.

I'm not sure whether I'm supposed to say something non-controversial for my first post, a bit like your maiden speech in the House of Lords ;), but here goes...

Looking back at the original question - does payment remove a musician from Folk music in its purest form - I'd say you're on a hiding to nothing here.

First, how do you define Folk music?
Is 'Speed the Plough' folk music?  Certainly.  Most English!  Especially when played Cajun-style on a 4 stop 1-row with horseshoe percussion, which then slides into New Orleans with saxophone lead!
I'd say any term trying to define any sort of music cannot be used with the word pure, since as soon as a musician takes the dots off the page and plays them, they assume the character of the musician.  That's what being a musician is all about.  Anything else might as well be played by a machine.

As for payment - is accepting a pint from the landlord any less a 'payment' than getting a fee that can go towards sustaining you in full-time employment?
If the greater the fee, the further from 'pure folk' you get, then the purest folk music is where it costs you to play.

Myself, I'm proud to use the term 'folk music' to describe (some of) what I do.  People understand the term and it gives them an idea of what I do - although I guess few non-folkies could guess the wide range of styles that are encompassed in those 2 words.
And if anyone wants to put money in my hand to do it, I'm happy to accept.

Julian
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 13, 2009, 06:16:26 PM
Hi Julian

Welcome to melodeon.net

Glad to hear your views.  I don't think it works quite like Parliament.  I'm sure we are far more democratic although we will adhere to the principle of not interupting your maiden speech.

If mel.net were modelled on Parliament it would indeed be very simple.  We would hold a referendum and if it didn't get the result we wanted then we would hold it again (and again) until we did get the result we wanted - that's fair, it too is called democracy.  Not to be confused with the real thing.

Disclaimer:  In using the term we, the writer in no way infers any connection with or instruction from the management of this site and wishes to stress that the views are his and his alone and are not to be construed as being those of the duly elected members. Phew, just got my umbrella up there.

If you want to be non controversial you will need to confer with our mediator C age ing
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Quebecois on January 13, 2009, 06:21:29 PM
We human beings seem to have an overwhelming desire to name things. If something does not have a name then a must be found. I have been wondering why it is important to call folk music "folk music" perhaps someone can tell me why we need these labels? <snip>

"All music if folk music. I ain't never heard no horse sing a song."
-- Louis Armstrong
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: rees on January 13, 2009, 11:11:05 PM

"If Music Be the Food of Love... Then Prepare for Indigestion"
.......... Dave Dee, Dozy, Beaky, Mick and Tich.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 14, 2009, 10:01:52 AM
We human beings seem to have an overwhelming desire to name things. If something does not have a name then a must be found. I have been wondering why it is important to call folk music "folk music" perhaps someone can tell me why we need these labels?

By extention we should call this place thing.net where we all play 'things' in the key of ???   !!! thing !!!

I know you are committed to this lack of nomenclature Grittie as you couldn't even bring yourself to use 'name' here "then a must be found".  A what ?  No, no, I can't say it.

Hhmmm, maybe labels could be useful.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: joe on January 14, 2009, 10:18:43 AM
Without names we could all get a bit confused, turning up at a session expecting folky type stuff (but we cant call it that), and finding that it is actually a glam rock jam session .....
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: mrjulian on January 14, 2009, 10:19:25 AM
Labels (aka the N word) are useful - so long as you don't get too upset when people use them to mean what they want.

It's a bit like people mis-quoting the parrot sketch really - it's bound to happen.  The best remedy is to get the drinks in ;-)

Julian
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Theo on January 14, 2009, 10:45:38 AM
The best remedy is to get the drinks in....

... and then play some more tunes. 
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 14, 2009, 11:52:21 AM
I agree with what I think is your point, Theo, that the whole point of doing this is because we enjoy it.  I also agree that commercial considerations have the potential to subvert that.

On the other hand, I feel that there is an underlying cultural problem in England and we are perhaps missing its importance:  the media and the public treat folkies as weirdos.  So come on, what's their answer to our rich cultural heritage - that it's just to be laughed at?  Contrast that with the Breton tradition for example, where their cultural heritage is mainstream, and therefore promoted with funding.  And it's not just in order to promote tourism, it's because local people believe it's important.

Many years ago, I got involved with a small and short-lived music festival in Essex, and the enlightened cultural advisor to the local Council managed to persuade them to put a few thousands of pounds into the folk festival element of it, in support of local organisers.  But he also persuaded them to put about double that amount into paying a high profile national conductor to come down for one afternoon to lead a schools orchestra!  (£8k fee). This is an insidious form of cultural favouritism, and to be fair to him, he fully recognised it.

I suggest that folkies enjoy what they do mainly because for them it is important culturally.  I believe we deserve greatly increased public support, because that is a worthy aim.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: george garside on January 14, 2009, 12:33:21 PM
 traditional music, song & dance should have the same status and funding as the National Trust as we, like them, are preserving  a part of the Nations heritage.

george
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Pete Dunk on January 14, 2009, 12:54:18 PM
By extention we should call this place thing.net where we all play 'things' in the key of ???   !!! thing !!!

Oi! I've been playing in the key of thing for years, what's wrong with thing? As long as I'm playing in the key of thing nobody will pay me to do so which makes me one of the few true folkies around here. 8)

I bet you're one of those geezers who noodles around in H modal.  ;D
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Matthew B on January 14, 2009, 02:16:28 PM
traditional music, song & dance should have the same status and funding as the National Trust as we, like them, are preserving  a part of the Nations heritage. 

Well, that's one way to look at it.  But part of the thing that makes the music special is that its open to everyone who wants to join in: participation and innovation are essential parts of the process.  Just by showing up on this forum and sharing ideas we're changing the way things are done.  Whether it's your sage advice on "red hot" bass technique, Theo adding notes to a retuned vintage box, the contributions from people beyond the UK, or any one of the endless  (and fascinating!) debates about tunes, tunings, keys, techniques and so on, its all a bit more dynamic than just "preservation".  And because no-one is paying (or charging) us to participate in the music --- even if some people get paid to perform, teach, or work on instruments --- it's very democratic.  Anyone can get involved.  There's no central authority telling any of us what constitutes the acceptable canon, we get to decide that for ourselves.  For me the pleasure I take in the music, the freedom it allows me, and the communities like this one are sufficient rewards.

I heard the singer George Papavgeris interviewed a few weeks ago.  He said something like "A forty eight-year old folk singer isn't in it for the chicks or the money.  I do it because I enjoy it, and I want to leave something behind for my grandchildren to remember".  I suspect that sentiment would apply to most of us here. 

And if someone is in it for the "chicks and the money" (substitute objects of desire as necessary) I'd love to hear how that's working out.   
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 14, 2009, 02:31:49 PM
And if someone is in it for the "chicks and the money" (substitute objects of desire as necessary) I'd love to hear how that's working out.   
Come on you pro's, ditch the dirt.  What is it really like to be a melodeon player and have folkie chicks throw themselves at you after receiving vast fees to strut your stuff.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Skipy on January 14, 2009, 05:22:06 PM
Quote
Come on you pro's, ditch the dirt.  What is it really like to be a melodeon player and have folkie chicks throw themselves at you after receiving vast fees to strut your stuff.

Ditch the dirt? or Dish the dirt? Either way I'm no Pro but I'm pleased to say, I have had chicks throwing themselves at me (well, falling over me) whilst I'm playing, albeit unpaid. Mind you they are normally paralytic, struggling to stand, let alone dance and sloshing a pint around in one hand whilst waving a mobile phone around in the other!

Still, one step nearer to fame!

Skipy
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Hasse on January 14, 2009, 08:14:30 PM
I would like to quote the Danish traditional fiddler Hans Tinus that states this in an interview in the book "Hans Tinus - Beretninger og melodier", ("Hans Tinus – stories and tunes"):

 " … I did it because I needed the money. Back then you didn't get any money for manual labour, and we didn't get that much money for playing either.”
And the interviewer Thorkild Knudsen ask him again: “But I don't believe that Hans. That it's only was because you needed the money”
Hans Tinus answers: “ But it was, that’s why I did it, I promise you. Why would I stay out all night? Oh no, believe me, it wasn’t always fun.”

Hans Tinus got paid for playing folk music, so by your definitions he might not be a true folk musician (spillemand). But I regard him as one of the biggest entertainers and folk musicians that ever walked the surface of the earth.

Lot of old folk musicians in Denmark and Sweden, would claim that being a folk musician is a traditional trade, and that folk music is nothing but a tool to make people dance and sing.

So maybe getting paid playing folk music really is what makes it true folk music and you a true folk musician. The rest of us might just be plain folk performers.  :)

If I understood the original questions correctly?
If a musician is paid to play does that payment remove him/her from 'Folk Music' in it's purest form and move them into the professional or semi professional arena and therefore by definiton also invalidate them as Folk performers ?
See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.0.html.  Thread drift has sparked my query.

Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: rees on January 14, 2009, 08:57:18 PM
And if someone is in it for the "chicks and the money" (substitute objects of desire as necessary) I'd love to hear how that's working out.   
Come on you pro's, ditch the dirt.  What is it really like to be a melodeon player and have folkie chicks throw themselves at you after receiving vast fees to strut your stuff.

I'm single and skint.  :D
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 14, 2009, 10:56:04 PM
And if someone is in it for the "chicks and the money" (substitute objects of desire as necessary) I'd love to hear how that's working out.   

I'm single and skint.  :D
Not good it would seem.

But I think the chicks actually throw themselves at you Rees  ;D
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: Martin J on January 14, 2009, 11:01:01 PM
Lot of old folk musicians in Denmark and Sweden, would claim that being a folk musician is a traditional trade, and that folk music is nothing but a tool to make people dance and sing.  So maybe getting paid playing folk music really is what makes it true folk music and you a true folk musician.  :)
I think I will use this on the door person at folk clubs
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: wildman on January 29, 2009, 07:12:57 PM
traditionally, folk musicians have a cap or whip round. Payment of any kind does not change the value of the music, a musician playing "popular" melodies for a singalong in the pub is still providing entertainment and be he paid in drinks or cash makes no matter. I have heard the occasional comment about prostituting one's self for the art but we all have to live. Instruments are not cheap and any labourer is worthy of his hire.
Title: Re: No pay for Folk Musicians
Post by: mikesamwild on February 24, 2009, 12:37:13 PM
Street singers and buskers often sold ballad sheets that are now regarded as folk songs.  Some got paid to go away too!  (Can you play Over the Hills and Far Away' ?)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal