I would like to quote the Danish traditional fiddler Hans Tinus that states this in an interview in the book "Hans Tinus - Beretninger og melodier", ("Hans Tinus – stories and tunes"):
" … I did it because I needed the money. Back then you didn't get any money for manual labour, and we didn't get that much money for playing either.”
And the interviewer Thorkild Knudsen ask him again: “But I don't believe that Hans. That it's only was because you needed the money”
Hans Tinus answers: “ But it was, that’s why I did it, I promise you. Why would I stay out all night? Oh no, believe me, it wasn’t always fun.”
Hans Tinus got paid for playing folk music, so by your definitions he might not be a true folk musician (spillemand). But I regard him as one of the biggest entertainers and
folk musicians that ever walked the surface of the earth.
Lot of old folk musicians in Denmark and Sweden, would claim that being a folk musician is a traditional trade, and that folk music is nothing but a tool to make people dance and sing.
So maybe getting paid playing folk music really is what makes it true folk music and you a true folk musician. The rest of us might just be plain folk performers. :)
If I understood the original questions correctly?
If a musician is paid to play does that payment remove him/her from 'Folk Music' in it's purest form and move them into the professional or semi professional arena and therefore by definiton also invalidate them as Folk performers ?
See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1214.0.html. Thread drift has sparked my query.