Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andrew Roche on June 09, 2013, 11:01:17 PM

Title: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 09, 2013, 11:01:17 PM
Having pretty much settled on a design for a high quality 2 voice 8 bass D/G made to a simple fixed specification in order to keep the price down to £1425 for the English market, I want to do the same for Irish players. Both models will share the same chassis, a 26x15cm box with a closed flat keyboard and Tipo A Mano reeds, but I'd like to ask a couple of questions to help me tailor it to the needs of B/C players...

From what I've seen, a lightweight bass end is prized and the basses are used mainly for rhythmic emphasis so not having thirds in the chords and omitting the low bass reed would be no great loss and maybe even desirable. Is that correct?.

Are 21 buttons adequate or are 23 a must have?.

Are there any particular features, (button size, spacing, keyboard angle, etc), that would suit Irish style players that should be incorporated?, particularly ones the bigger manufacturers aren't doing or won't do.

Anything else anybody would like to suggest?.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: sine labore on June 10, 2013, 01:10:42 AM

...............and the basses are used mainly for rhythmic emphasis....................
[/quote

I think it is more like occasional even unexpected notes rather than the regular rhythmic notes of Scottish?
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 10, 2013, 12:18:09 PM
What I meant by them being used for rhythmic emphasis was that rather than being used to provide constant chord accompaniment, which in band and session contexts seems to usually be provided by a guitar or something else, or big driving bass notes, B/C players mostly seem to use them more sparingly in little rhythmic jabs. Removing the thirds and low bass reeds wouldn't compromise that style too greatly and would make the bass end lighter and easier to throw around.

For the right hand keyboard I was thinking of a slightly reduced button height, (2 or 2.5mm instead of 3mm), with slightly larger buttons a little closer together to facilitate sliding, say, 16mm buttons spaced 18mm apart instead of the de facto standard of 14.5 or 15mm buttons with 19mm spacing. However, I'm not a B/C player so I'd appreciate the insight of experienced players in case I'm way off the mark.

Even though it has to be a set specification I don't want it to be a generic "that'll do" design, if there's anything I can do to accommodate any needs that aren't being met in most off the shelf boxes then I'm all ears.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: tedrick on June 10, 2013, 12:40:25 PM
I personally am perfectly happy with 21 instead of 23 - I never needed the 4 extra low notes on my previous box and am perfectly happy with just 21 on my Mini -

3rds removed on the basses is fine for me too -

as far as the button spacing, the Cairdin spacing is nice for me - I'm not sure on the specs though -

maybe a quickly detachable grille would be a nice touch - something that doesn't require screws or tools - snap on/snap off -
Reed
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Clive Williams on June 10, 2013, 12:54:13 PM
My understanding is that C#/D players tend to want 23 buttons (because the pitch puts an important note (low G I believe) just off the end of the keyboard on a 21 button, but it's not a problem for B/C players. If I were you though, I'd engineer for 23 buttons assuming it doesn't increase the workload/size significantly; you've got a more flexible instrument that you just need to put different reeds in to address the different market.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Gromit on June 10, 2013, 01:17:32 PM
Quote
with slightly larger buttons a little closer together to facilitate sliding

Not too sure about that as I don't slide that much (not sure what others do) and I wouldn't get on with buttons too close there's quite a bit of finger swapping on the same button going on (if thats the right term) when I play - I would imagine that buttons too close and large would get in the way.

I'd go with Reed with a detachable grille.

Perhaps you could whack in some small mechanical tonewheels like on a Hammond organ (:) - joke
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: boxer on June 10, 2013, 01:24:26 PM
I'm not sure there's a single formula for a good B/C box. 

From a purely personal perspective, any feature that makes it easier to play the melody crisply, with a good steady pulse, is desirable.  To that end, a light right hand side is great, and as I seldom use the basses, loss of thirds and low reeds isn't an issue.

Button travel should be as short as possible, and the springs should be set to be as light as they can.  Hohner spacing is ok.  The bellows should be very easy to move and the reeds should speak readily.  I find wetter-tuned boxes easier to play well in company, because I can hear what I'm playing, even when I play the box lightly.

Although 21 buttons are enough for B/C, 23 would give more scope for other tunings as the post above says.

Having said all that, a player can get used to almost anything.

Good luck with your project.

Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 10, 2013, 01:49:29 PM
Anything else anybody would like to suggest?

Give up making boxes and be a consultant in marketing? This sort of research before launching into manufacture is quite commendable, I wish more would do it :D

Not my area of experience but not bothering with chords and installing monosonoric basses has been discussed here, and makes a lot of sense on a halftone box. It might even be cheaper?

[edit 2] and a decent airhole ;) arguable more imortant here than on the Morris Man's "Mondeo" Melodeon?  [edit 3] I bow to Steve's greater knowledge below, I use the air hole on a big way on my c#d part of the 3 row, but that's Bb or F blues 90% on pull, but as I say above Irish ain't my field and the balance will surely be different.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Stiamh on June 10, 2013, 02:09:50 PM
Andrew please ignore what Chris says and don't put a huge airhole on your Irish boxes. An Erica-style appetite is perfect for the constant fine bellows adjustment needed for semitone-box playing. Anything more voracious makes the essential technique of using the airbutton to adjust the bellows while playing r/h notes much more difficult, on a 2-v box anyway, in my experience. The airhole takes too much air from the reeds and you lose control over the volume.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 10, 2013, 02:44:38 PM
If there was sufficient demand I'd do a dedicated a C#/D version as well with 21 buttons but arranged 10/11 to allow a low G at the end of the inside row so scope for other tunings isn't really a consideration; they all have to have a uniform layout anyway.

Fancy features like a quick release grille, whilst the kind of thing that shouldn't be a problem for a custom job, aren't really compatible with what I'm trying to achieve with this design as they don't do anything to improve playability but would cost more and take longer to do. For example, on Ian Dedic's Oakwood he achieved a significant improvement in playability and suitability for his style simply by repositioning the bass strap and strap brackets and increasing the keyboard angle slightly and all that cost to do was a little consideration and attention on the part of the maker. It's little things like that that would benefit Irish style players that I'm interested in.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Theo on June 10, 2013, 02:55:13 PM
Andrew, if you get a chance to examine one of the Cardin models you might find that helpful.  I think it occupies the same sort of niche in the Irish market that the Oakwood did in the English.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: tedrick on June 10, 2013, 04:11:13 PM
just double checked my Cairdin Mini 21:

Hi Andrew -
I sent some measurements to my tuner here in the states, Michael Usui at Irish Dancemaster Accordions -

I thought they might be useful to you -

below are the measurements -


25cm wide - left to right - grill 22.25cm wide 9.5cm high

20.75cm long (billows closed and fastened)

27.75cm long from top edge of keyboard - to left side of bass end

14.75cm high measured at grill where keyboard connects to frame

my mini weights just an ounce under 7 lbs on a digital postal scale
with no straps

buttons are 14 mm wide
and spacing is:

look to be 20 mm center to center
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: LDbosca on June 10, 2013, 04:32:08 PM
If there was sufficient demand I'd do a dedicated a C#/D version as well with 21 buttons but arranged 10/11 to allow a low G at the end of the inside row so scope for other tunings isn't really a consideration; they all have to have a uniform layout anyway.

Fancy features like a quick release grille, whilst the kind of thing that shouldn't be a problem for a custom job, aren't really compatible with what I'm trying to achieve with this design as they don't do anything to improve playability but would cost more and take longer to do. For example, on Ian Dedic's Oakwood he achieved a significant improvement in playability and suitability for his style simply by repositioning the bass strap and strap brackets and increasing the keyboard angle slightly and all that cost to do was a little consideration and attention on the part of the maker. It's little things like that that would benefit Irish style players that I'm interested in.

You can't have an inside row that's longer than an outside row for Irish music; a lot of players use 5-note rolls which make it necessary to have a lower note than the melody note on the outside row. Due to mistake in translation Bertrand Gaillard made one for Jackie Daly; I don't think the stuck with it for long.

If you end up doing a 23 button B/C then have a pull D,, on the outside row (lowest button) and a push D'' on the outside (highest button) as standard. Gives a full 3 octaves in D.

Button travel's been mentioned - I'd recomment 2.5mm or 3 as standard. I use 2.5, any lower'd be crazy IMHO.

Light action as been mentioned - also important but there is such a thing as too light. These are difficult things to discuss in the abstract, of course.

Big(ish) buttons are always nice.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: LDbosca on June 10, 2013, 04:38:39 PM
Also, there are more important things in the world than a light box. People often think a box is lighter than it is if it is responsive.

The Briggs gets lots of attention from amateurs as a really light, repsonsive box but only a few pros play them.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 10, 2013, 04:52:31 PM
The Briggs gets lots of attention from amateurs as a really light, repsonsive box but only a few pros play them.

I'd noticed that. Why is that do you think?
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: blackdot1234 on June 10, 2013, 05:15:03 PM
hi i spoke to martin Quinn recently he said briggs boxes would not suit him and his style of playing so horses for courses I think fast light touch triple one button rolls suit a briggs but no good for slow airs a lot of really great box players have got briggs boxes ie jos Kelly of jp trio
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Stiamh on June 10, 2013, 05:30:20 PM
You can't have an inside row that's longer than an outside row for Irish music; a lot of players use 5-note rolls which make it necessary to have a lower note than the melody note on the outside row.

Sorry Luke but that doesn't stand up to scrutiny. On a 21-button C#/D, the only note you wouldn't be able to roll in that way would be the low G.

Not a problem for me and really, how many players would rather have no low G at all rather than one you couldn't do one of those yokes on? Can you even think of a tune that has a low G on which a 5-note roll would be crucial? Fiddlers can't do a proper roll on that note and all the trad. tunes that use that note are fiddle tunes.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Mike Averill on June 10, 2013, 05:36:31 PM
As 21 buttons is insufficient for a playable DG with 4th button start why not fix on a standard 23 button box for all the keys.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Lester on June 10, 2013, 05:47:39 PM
As 21 buttons is insufficient for a playable DG with 4th button start why not fix on a standard 23 button box for all the keys.

I play quite happily on a 21 button 4th button start with no problems, I have 3 full octaves in G?

Can you explain the deficiency?
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Mike Averill on June 10, 2013, 06:02:52 PM
The deficiency is quite simple. It lacks all the note at the top end that I and many others have learned to use and play on a standard boxes such as pokerwork or Erica.




Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Keithypete. on June 10, 2013, 06:13:58 PM
I'm no expert, but I would like a high D, biggish buttons, thumb groove on the side of a fairly deep keyboard, which is ventilated or pierced - front & back. Made out of Wenge or similar.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: boxer on June 10, 2013, 07:13:47 PM
Saltarelle used to do a 4-voice 25 button 2 row with 13 buttons inside, 12 outside.  This (in B/C) gave a low draw D on the inside row I guess.  I don't think they make them at present so perhaps they didn't sell well.

The lower limit of spring weight is determined by the player's style - the higher he or she pumps up the pressure for press notes, the sooner one or all of the pallets will lift of their own volition.  Makers usually don't bother setting spring weight and leave keyboards heavy as lead - probably to avoid complaints from heavy handed players.

The lower limit of key travel is governed by how high the pallet needs to lift in order to allow the reed to breathe fully and sound clearly.  This I suspect may differ from box to box.  Most boxes are sold with far more key travel than absolutely required.

Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: blackdot1234 on June 10, 2013, 08:54:17 PM
button travel is a balance between minimum pallet lift if pallet does not lift enough sound is compramised I have enlarged holes in sound boards on Erica and black dot to allow for this 
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: LDbosca on June 10, 2013, 09:03:27 PM
You can't have an inside row that's longer than an outside row for Irish music; a lot of players use 5-note rolls which make it necessary to have a lower note than the melody note on the outside row.

Sorry Luke but that doesn't stand up to scrutiny. On a 21-button C#/D, the only note you wouldn't be able to roll in that way would be the low G.

Not a problem for me and really, how many players would rather have no low G at all rather than one you couldn't do one of those yokes on? Can you even think of a tune that has a low G on which a 5-note roll would be crucial? Fiddlers can't do a proper roll on that note and all the trad. tunes that use that note are fiddle tunes.

I was mainly thinking of the low G. I like being able to roll it and it's nice to have the option. I can think of a jig that starts with a low G roll, maybe the fiddlers I've heard play it cran it using two different grace notes, they're certainly doing something and it's not a bowed triplet. Don't for get that most players like "those yokes."

Also, there are more important things in the world than a light box. People often think a box is lighter than it is if it is responsive.

The Briggs gets lots of attention from amateurs as a really light, repsonsive box but only a few pros play them.

IMHO they lack character and, to some degree, dynamic range. I reckon that the extra speed and response they have over some boxes becomes less of an issue when a player reaches a certain point and that the shortcomings of the briggs become more of a problem. I don't think I've ever heard anyone rave about the Briggs' sound either. It seems to suit a few players; such as Dermot Byrne with his even, precise style.

Colm Gannon sold his. There's other players who have them and don't use them as their main box.

Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Stiamh on June 10, 2013, 09:25:24 PM
You can't have an inside row that's longer than an outside row for Irish music; a lot of players use 5-note rolls which make it necessary to have a lower note than the melody note on the outside row.

Sorry Luke but that doesn't stand up to scrutiny. On a 21-button C#/D, the only note you wouldn't be able to roll in that way would be the low G.

Not a problem for me and really, how many players would rather have no low G at all rather than one you couldn't do one of those yokes on? Can you even think of a tune that has a low G on which a 5-note roll would be crucial? Fiddlers can't do a proper roll on that note and all the trad. tunes that use that note are fiddle tunes.

I was mainly thinking of the low G. I like being able to roll it and it's nice to have the option. I can think of a jig that starts with a low G roll, maybe the fiddlers I've heard play it cran it using two different grace notes, they're certainly doing something and it's not a bowed triplet. Don't for get that most players like "those yokes."

Fair enough. I wasn't going to raise the issue of the 11/10 C#/D configuration in this thread, because it was about B/C, but then Andrew himself did.

I stick to my guns: If Andrew is looking for a way to make a 21-button box attractive to C#/D players, 10/11 is very sensible. Here's the equation:

Subtract useless top button on outer row -
Add useful button on bottom of inner row  +
                     Result: a better C#/D box =

This is better than the usual option of sticking low D/G on the bottom of the outer row, because that sacrifices the low Bb, which is useful occasionally.

If C#/D players are really pining not only for a low G, but the ability to do 5-note rolls on one, then they'll have to get a 23-button box. But they'll still have a useless top button on the outer row  ;)

So... if Andrew is still listening... one step better for C#/D would be 22 buttons: add a bottom button on each row and scrap the top outer one.  :|glug But I would be happy with 11/10. And 12 lightweight basses!
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 10, 2013, 10:12:01 PM

So... if Andrew is still listening... one step better for C#/D would be 22 buttons: add a bottom button on each row and scrap the top outer one.  :|glug But I would be happy with 11/10. And 12 lightweight basses!

Hi guys,

Thanks for all the interesting discussion here.  Steve, I have a list of box specs in mind for a custom box project someday, and coincidentally a 22 or 24 button keyboard is part of the plan.  Of course, I would never assume that the ideas I propose would find wide popularity, it's just an experiment I would like to see tried. With an internal design modification from the typical construction, to stagger the reedblock-attachment hardware, this could allow a box with reedblocks in extra keys (such as B/C, C/C#, C#/D, D/D#) to do without redundant treble reedblocks for each key (e.g. a total of 5 rather than 8 blocks for a 2-voice, in my example, or 10 rather than 16 blocks for a 4-voice).

PG
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 11, 2013, 01:08:58 AM
Ok, where to start.

Reed, thanks very much for going to the effort and providing those details of your Cairdin. Most interesting.

The more I think about it, the more I like the idea of going for 23 buttons, without the low bass reeds and thirds there'd only be a very small cost increase, (probably to £1450). and it would leave the door open for a C#/D should there be sufficient demand. Things like the low and high Ds and the 5 note roll issue are exactly what I need to know as someone unfamiliar with the finer points of Irish style. 23 buttons would add noticeably to the cost on the English model and the highest notes on a D/G are not necessary in the English traditional repertoire and never used by the vast majority of players in that idiom. If I may offer my personal opinion as well, they're also thoroughly unpleasant on the ears and only suitable for confusing bats. ;D

This and the similar D/G aren't my main line of interest, they're a sideline to my full service, anything you want bespoke boxes starting at £1900. I can get the price down to £1425 by, (aside from the fairly generous tax situation for a sole trader invoicing below a certain amount per annum in the UK...), making them in batches all to the same spec, using Tipo A Mano rather than A Mano reeds and simplifying some details, (flat grille, no inlay, velcro bass strap, etc), but without compromising quality of construction and playability. I'm aiming these at the kind of people who might be considering something like the Saltarelle Irish Bouebe and may be tempted by the prospect of having a handmade box with better reeds and quality control for only a couple of hundred more. I'm only anticipating one batch of 4-6 depending on demand per year and as a one man operation I can't make much more than 30 instruments at full output each year anyway. Basically, players are getting the option of a handmade instrument for the price of a factory one and I'll be getting business from people who otherwise probably wouldn't be in the market for a £2-3k custom box, which is a fairly good deal for both IMO.

Thanks everyone for your contributions so far.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: sine labore on June 11, 2013, 01:18:50 AM
Anything else anybody would like to suggest?.
[/quote]


Many Irish box players are only interested in the sound that 3 voice tremolo delivers.
I see a lot of the younger players turning to Paolo Soprani and indeed some of the older
players have returned to the Paolo

[/quote]

Yes, the Paolo Soprani in its 3 voice has a special place in my sensory perception, and I hear the sound I like from time to time without being able to pinpoint what it is. Is there any comprehensive sound bank on line for the Paolo that would help, rather than making retailers and tuners the first point of call?

(Sorry to post this after Andrew Roche's latest posting by way of recap.)
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Pat. on June 11, 2013, 04:18:02 PM
[NEW WAVE ] Irish music (:) QUOTE from Aradru.As for bases I like the option  to or take out thirds, the rest is personal to the player but 3 voice is a must as far as I would be concerned.Good luck anyway.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: LDbosca on June 11, 2013, 05:02:35 PM
I suppose the small, light-weight market is something in itself; the 3-voice classic tremelo sound has been perfected and never successfully imitated.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 11, 2013, 05:05:12 PM
Now that I've slept on it and had a look around I've noticed a lack of affordable high quality 3 voice boxes out there. In Saltarelle's range, for example, the price between the Irish Bouebe and Nuage almost exactly doubles, (well, at the Music Room anyway).

Something I was concerned about was offering something that was still not exactly cheap but with features that might be deemed inadequate or typically associated only with beginner or budget models. The thing I was initially concerned about was 21 vs 23 buttons but now I'm wondering if 2 vs 3 voices might be one of those things. I think I'll go for 23 buttons anyway but what I'm now considering is making 2 prototypes, one 2 voice for about £1450 and one fixed 3 voice MMM for about £1650 and see which one is better received...
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: deltasalmon on June 11, 2013, 06:19:50 PM
I must be in the minority. I had a 3-voice accordion (granted it was LMM not MMM) and didn't care for the sound. I like the semi-dry because it sounds closest (for me) to what the Irish fiddle sounds like.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: LDbosca on June 11, 2013, 06:22:11 PM
...... the 3-voice classic tremelo sound has been perfected and never successfully imitated.

Aye indeed. That's what I was getting at! I wish someone would replicate the old grey sound.
Surely it's not rocket science?

The current attempt at it is pretty damn poor if you ask me. I heard that Colm Gannon was having the inside of his measured etc by someone, possibly with the intention of replecation, this is second hand and I don't know any more.

The type of steel available at the time and the techniques used to make reeds may not be on hand at the moment. I'm also not sure if there's any record of how things were done.

Also, some of these boxes were from the 40s/50s so there's decades of playing on the reeds, which'll have affected the sound and response. Even on early recordings of grey paolos (McMahon's first album for example) there'd be a lot of playing-in done already.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: blackdot1234 on June 11, 2013, 06:32:17 PM
I have spoken to tuners /repairers on this and poor quality timber was used and ply sound board also tea chest quality reeds standard paolo soprani but played for 60 years also best greys made by pancotti steel on reeds is Swedish all info from nils nielson
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 12, 2013, 12:39:12 PM
Have you considered a celluloid finish?
Yes it adds cost, but we have a liking for celluloid. Especially grey celluloid.

Afraid not. Applying celluloid and storing and disposing of the materials and chemicals is both a health risk and fire hazard so I won't even consider it.

Tuning can be whatever a customer specifies.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: DaveCottrell on June 12, 2013, 02:01:14 PM
Also take into account the experience of Jim Coogan and John Nolan. Their foray into Irish accordion marketing may be an interesting case study.

The Boxeen is an attempt to replicate the Old Paolo sound (and look) . I have a 4 voice BC 5 coupler and it is better than any Paolo made after 1970. It has more volume than my 1950s LMM Paolo, but is not as sweet.  I don't know how successful or popular they were, but the price was under $2500 for a pretty good box. 

On my BC I would want 3 reeds, a RH bass voice stop or coupler, 23 buttons, ability to switch bass thirds on and off (I do use the thirds occasionally), and a high D on the last B row button press.   I have a Shamrock, the 25-buttoned Saltarelle, and find the hi D draw on the C row easy to play.  That box has 4 reeds and 12 basses it is a monster but I love it. I have it voiced LMMH so it sounds Quebecois.

Also consider having the inner row voice the upper pallets.  Most Irish playing (BC and C#D) is done on the inside row and having it set up thus makes the pertinent reeds seem louder.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 12, 2013, 03:14:06 PM
Also take into account the experience of Jim Coogan and John Nolan. Their foray into Irish accordion marketing may be an interesting case study.

The Boxeen is an attempt to replicate the Old Paolo sound (and look) . I have a 4 voice BC 5 coupler and it is better than any Paolo made after 1970. It has more volume than my 1950s LMM Paolo, but is not as sweet.  I don't know how successful or popular they were, but the price was under $2500 for a pretty good box. 

On my BC I would want 3 reeds, a RH bass voice stop or coupler, 23 buttons, ability to switch bass thirds on and off (I do use the thirds occasionally), and a high D on the last B row button press.   I have a Shamrock, the 25-buttoned Saltarelle, and find the hi D draw on the C row easy to play.  That box has 4 reeds and 12 basses it is a monster but I love it. I have it voiced LMMH so it sounds Quebecois.

Also consider having the inner row voice the upper pallets.  Most Irish playing (BC and C#D) is done on the inside row and having it set up thus makes the pertinent reeds seem louder.

DaveCottrell,

Great comments about the Boxeen.  Interesting to compare that project with the (series of different models of the) recent Paolo Soprani reissue.

I have a Saltarelle Shamrock also and they are great boxes for "all the options" players. They aren't lightweight, but then, heavy boxes such as 9-coupler Paolos have been played at times by pros such as Paddy O'Brien, James Keane, Kevin Keegan, John Whelan, etc. A box like the Shamrock would be much more expensive to produce than the box that Andrew is designing, however they are an example of how much can be crammed into one reasonably compact accordion. My Shamrock is LMMH like yours, but mine is a C#/D.  Relating the Shamrock to your point that the outer button row of many 2-row boxes has a different timbre than the inner row: if you're interested, maybe you & I could get after-market keyboard plates made up for the Shamrock with extra fretwork to open up the sound from the somewhat "buried" pallets of its outer row.

PG
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 12, 2013, 03:14:43 PM
Have you considered a celluloid finish?
Yes it adds cost, but we have a liking for celluloid. Especially grey celluloid.

Afraid not. Applying celluloid and storing and disposing of the materials and chemicals is both a health risk and fire hazard so I won't even consider it.



Hi all,

I agree with aradru that a celluloid finish has a great 20th century vibe for an accordion played for Irish music, and very practical to maintain the finish over hard use.  The celluloid seems to unify the appearance of the wooden casework (especially if the corners are rounded for comfort, the casework joinery tends to show there if not covered or painted, and a patterned celluloid skin can help the roundness look natural). One way to deal with that finish in a small shop would be to contract out the celluloid-skinning step to a factory set up to do it safely.  Maybe no other manufacturers do this anymore in the UK, but I suppose it's still done on the continent, and China of course.

Back to why some people like celluloid, it may be imaginary but I have read speculation about acoustic effects (maybe subtle buzzes, resonances, or frequencies absorbed by the body+celluloid?), based on the fact that accordions from the 1930s with wood bodies and thick celluloid seem to have a particular sound when wet-tuned.  These kinds of effects of materials on musical timbre and response are often denied and hard to study, but I always say "absence of proof is not proof of absence" when it comes to scientific measurement of phenomena that may influence the psychological perception of music.  Appropriate double-blind studies can be difficult to conduct, due to problems in setting up the experimental "controls."  It's hard enough to create two identical boxes except for the celluloid, but almost impossible for the musician not to know that one box, but not the other, is celluloid-finished.

PG
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Stiamh on June 12, 2013, 05:09:44 PM
AFAIK Boxeens were all 21-button models. Not an issue for John Nolan, a B/C player, or Jim Coogan, who played D/C#, of course, but I don't understand why, if they were seeking to produce a replacement for the classic Paolo, they didn't go for 23.

A friend of mine has a Shamrock B/C LMMH. I love the variety of sounds this configuration allows, and I find it a very playable box. (Although the owner said he had to do a lot of tinkering with the treble mechanism to get it into that state of playability. Conveniently he is a mechanical whizz - toolmaker for an aircraft engine manufacturer.)

Andrew, if you make a 3-v prototype, will you allow for a low voice and a stop to cut it out?   

PS regarding the acoustic properties of celluloid - Martin Quinn might have some insights into this, since he routinely strips the celluloid off his hotrodded Hohners. They sound great. The 3v Double-Ray he did up for Sean McComiskey (stripped down to the bare wood) sounds as gorgeous as any old Paolo to my ears.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 12, 2013, 05:52:14 PM
AFAIK Boxeens were all 21-button models. Not an issue for John Nolan, a B/C player, or Jim Coogan, who played D/C#, of course, but I don't understand why, if they were seeking to produce a replacement for the classic Paolo, they didn't go for 23.

A friend of mine has a Shamrock B/C LMMH. I love the variety of sounds this configuration allows, and I find it a very playable box. (Although the owner said he had to do a lot of tinkering with the treble mechanism to get it into that state of playability. Conveniently he is a mechanical whizz - toolmaker for an aircraft engine manufacturer.)

Andrew, if you make a 3-v prototype, will you allow for a low voice and a stop to cut it out?   

PS regarding the acoustic properties of celluloid - Martin Quinn might have some insights into this, since he routinely strips the celluloid off his hotrodded Hohners. They sound great. The 3v Double-Ray he did up for Sean McComiskey (stripped down to the bare wood) sounds as gorgeous as any old Paolo to my ears.

Hi Steve,

Agree with all your points, especially the last.  Martin would have experience that could be very informative on that question, if he would share it.  He's a wonderful tuner (and player) and his website shows pics of many vintage celluloid boxes as well as his stripped and hot-rodded Hohners.  The idea that the celluloid-on-wood boxes from the 1930s have unique tonal properties is quoted from another forum member here.  I'm agnostic on that subject, but very interested.  I like the sound and look of both wood finished and celluloid finished boxes, and actually every individual accordion that's a few decades old or more sounds unique to me.

PG
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Andrew Roche on June 12, 2013, 05:54:27 PM
Andrew, if you make a 3-v prototype, will you allow for a low voice and a stop to cut it out?   

No. The only way I could afford to offer a box at that price as a one-man operation building to a high standard is if they're made to a fairly simple design in uniform batches with no variation, (including the layout as the reeds have to be ordered in quantity and in advance enough to be on hand), from one instrument to the next to streamline production. I'm only too happy to make boxes on an individual basis to whatever specification and with whatever features the customer desires, (provided they're feasible, would not compromise quality and not in poor taste or hazardous to me), but they have to be priced accordingly.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 12, 2013, 06:14:59 PM
Andrew, if you make a 3-v prototype, will you allow for a low voice and a stop to cut it out?   

No. The only way I could afford to offer a box at that price as a one-man operation building to a high standard is if they're made to a fairly simple design in uniform batches with no variation, (including the layout as the reeds have to be ordered in quantity and in advance enough to be on hand), from one instrument to the next to streamline production. I'm only too happy to make boxes on an individual basis to whatever specification and with whatever features the customer desires, (provided they're feasible, would not compromise quality and not in poor taste or hazardous to me), but they have to be priced accordingly.

Makes sense to me to go no-coupler and keep the price low, without compromising the reeds, action, or workmanship. Some of the best and most valuable boxes ever sought by Irish musicians are MMM no-coupler.  The slider and stop / couplers add a lot to the technical hassle of design and construction, and in fact a lot of MMM players think that those features can hurt the sound. If the reedblocks aren't glued in, the player has the option to open up the box and silence the middle reedblock with a strip of paper to go MM for a session.  I don't have a 3 voice grey Paolo (anymore) but I love a good Hohner Double-Ray Deluxe, with or without celluloid. I guess you might think about those MMM no-coupler models as the "competition" in a very general sense (though at radically different price points). Here's another wonderful sounding MMM B/C with 23 keys and no switches.  This model can be found really cheap (at least this one was), but to me it has features impossible to find in any new box under $2000.  Usual caveats here -- I'm not Irish or a pro player on the accordion myself, but have had a keen interest in them for years now, and decent ears from my experience playing other instruments.

PG
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: tedrick on June 12, 2013, 06:44:26 PM
Has anyone looked into a carbon fiber/composite construction for the case/body of a button accordion? Could that be done? Are the hohner compadre boxes made out of a synthetic material?
Reed
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 12, 2013, 10:08:30 PM
Hi all,

Thanks to a question from Reed, I just remembered another box that some of us really like.  Although again it's a factory-made celluloid box, it has some design features in common with those proposed above.  I mean the Swiss-made Hohner Amatona III BC, with no couplers in MMM. Unlike (most?) double-ray deluxes,* these had a 23 button treble keyboard. As far as I know, the Amatona III has not been made in recent years and is uncommon to find.  I once had one and sold it years ago to a member of this forum.  He posted a photo in post # 10 (I think) of this thread:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7215.msg89786.html

PG

* the "most" was written because I believe there were some 3 voice Hohner BCs made in the 1930s - 1940s with 23 (pearl) melody keys.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: pgroff on June 13, 2013, 04:12:40 AM


I hereby declare you an Honorary Irishman.

Thanks buddy & right back at you :-)

Just meant to make clear I was not trying to speak for the Irish accordion players to whom Andrew might be marketing his B/C box.  But on the other hand I was interested in the subject and in the discussion . . . as always from the limitations of my own vantage point.  Very grateful myself for all the music and ideas shared with me by my friends and teachers past & present.

PG
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Keithypete. on June 13, 2013, 08:41:45 AM
I agree with Aradru - offer a choice of colours for a celluloid/pearloid. Personally I really like the green-ish Paolos that appear from time to time. Flowers & rhinestones not so much.


By the way - there's nowt wrong wi' PLYWOOD.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: tedrick on June 13, 2013, 12:20:37 PM


By the way - there's nowt wrong wi' PLYWOOD.

I Agree Pete - as long as it's light - my Paolo Elite II was make from 3/8" ply and was 13 lbs - my Cairdin is made from 1/8" ply and is 7 lbs - I was just wondering if there was a way to use carbon composite - if it would negatively affect the sound of the box thought then it would not be desirable -
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2013, 03:31:23 PM
CFRP is a great material and probably wouldn't negatively affect the sound, but it is extremely expensive...
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: strad on June 13, 2013, 04:22:29 PM
Re carbon fibre - The fiddle bow I use most is carbon fibre and is a joy to use. It's more responsive than the same value wood bows I have, so perhaps a carbon fibre case would be interesting re the sound. A good bow greatly enhance the sound on a good fiddle.

Nigel
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2013, 10:05:45 PM
CFRP is nice and stiff so would probably make a decent box case. Good and light too.
Title: Re: Calling B/C players...
Post by: tedrick on June 13, 2013, 11:41:42 PM
If you can make drums out of the stuff, why not accordions!

from: http://www.mingdrum.com/royal.htm (http://www.mingdrum.com/royal.htm)
Quote
General speaking, traditional wooden drums are heavy. In order to have a light wooden drum, we need to decrease the thickness in shell and the weight. Therefore, thin wooden layers can not create a quality sound as well as a good strength in marching snare drums for sale. Voice verse, to have a good quality sound, the wooden layers need to be packed and heavy.

Using carbon fiber and other composite materials can solve the problem of weight and the sound quality at once. It's not only light weight, but the density is 20 times higher than traditional wooden drum shells. The shell thickness of 1.6~1.8 mm for the carbon fiber drum set has a strong body structure and powerful sound quality. Unlike wooden vintage drum sets, carbon fiber drum doesn’t cause hydrous in the body layers. The parts and accessories are not easily to be rusty caused by weathers or humidity. Winding and woven weave textures make the looks of carbon fiber vintage drum sets streamline and modern.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal