Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: diatonix on August 10, 2013, 09:28:31 AM

Title: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: diatonix on August 10, 2013, 09:28:31 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmHOUY47p4o
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 10, 2013, 10:14:23 AM
Oh God.    Don't  >:E
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Rog on August 18, 2013, 09:55:08 AM
So he ended up with too much vibrato on his voicing? I mean it doesn't sound too good at the end, but which bits of the tuning process did he screw up? I suspect this kind of tuning goes on all over Latin America where accordions are v common. My Spanish is not fab so can anyone précis what he says?
Does anyone know what app he was using on his iPad?
Also his, er, what are they? Valves? Don't look too healthy.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: YorkieKen on August 18, 2013, 10:11:38 AM
His App is called Peterson's iStrobosoft, Iv'e got it on my iPhone and can highly recommend it ! cost around five or six quid, but that's much less than other tuners and far more accurate

Ken.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Rog on August 18, 2013, 10:15:47 AM
His App is called Peterson's iStrobosoft, Iv'e got it on my iPhone and can highly recommend it ! cost around five or six quid, but that's much less than other tuners and far more accurate

Ken.
Thx... I'll take a look at it.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Theo on August 18, 2013, 03:06:55 PM
Yes the Oeterson tuner app is great, I use it every day.  It is the power tool for grinding the reeds that is the problem.  Hand tools allow you to develop a feel for how much metal you are removing.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Kimric Smythe on August 18, 2013, 07:40:50 PM
I think you are being a bit to harsh on this guy. Tuning the reeds in the box the way he is will give an accurate tuning (even better than a table) but it takes FOREVER.
 From the way he is using he dremel I can't see that he is harming the reeds in any way, the trick is to move the tool as you grind, you don't want a dent in the reed, that would be a weak spot. You can control how much you remove by using a low speed and a fine diamond stone.
The instrument he is working on is most likely 60 yrs old and the valves are shot.
 You can't imagine the stuff that comes into my shop, this guys work would be a major improvement over the outside work that I see.

Kimric
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Christopher K. on August 18, 2013, 09:53:13 PM
A lot of tuners in the States use power tools to tune reeds, to good effect. A skilled worker, as noted above, shouldn't damage the reeds no matter what he's doing. Especially if he's being paid, it's a fast way to lose business. In addition to tuners for the conjunto/tejano crowd, I've spoken with a number of experienced PA tuners here who use the same technique on very expensive reeds.

Still scares me to death, though, and power seems like overkill given how easy it is to use a file.  ;D
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: diatonix on August 18, 2013, 10:55:05 PM
A skilled accordion technician is able to tune both pull and push reeds, raising or lowering their frequency, with their valves in place while   the reed block (unless certain circumstances prohibit it) stays in the accordion. When tuning a tremolo no electronic device is needed. "Tuners" who are dependent on a dremel tool do not necessarily do irreversible damage to every reed they come across. However, this "method" reveals a significant lack of proper training and skill which will make it impossible to do first class work. And first class work is what paying customers expect.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: an bosca ceoil on August 19, 2013, 01:28:05 AM
Whilst this chaps style of working and choice of rotary tool bit may leave a lot to be desired does he profess to be a skilled technician capable of first class work or is he merely demonstrating an alternative for those who cannot afford to pay one?
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 19, 2013, 07:20:56 AM
I suppose a Dremel has to take off the same amount of metal as a file to get the same change so it's difficult to see any fundamental reason for avoiding it.
The main drawback, as I see it, is the risk of overdoing it. That comes down to the workman's familiarity with his tools. 

As long as they practice on PAs I don't see any big problem.  ::)
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: diatonix on August 19, 2013, 10:20:07 AM
In case someone can't afford getting his instrument tuned or otherwise serviced by an expert, I can't  see how he then can afford having it damaged by someone who doesn't really know what he is doing. After such a treatment, the accordion is likely to be considerably less worth while  subsequent proper re-tuning/repair will turn out even more costly.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 19, 2013, 10:26:46 AM
I didn't realise an Accordian was an instrument.  >:E
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on August 19, 2013, 02:37:08 PM
A well known and highly respected concertina maker once told me that his only justification for the use of power tools was to muck things up more quickly....     >:E >:E >:E

Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: blafleur on August 19, 2013, 02:43:48 PM
A well known and highly respected concertina maker once told me that his only justification for the use of power tools was to muck things up more quickly....     >:E >:E >:E

That's pretty much been the story with me and any high speed rotary tool.  It allows me to destroy nice things in the blink of an eye.  As a woodworker, it's made some expensive firewood.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: forrest on August 19, 2013, 03:26:56 PM
There is certainly a place for a rotary tool in box repair, but the video is showing probably the worst instance of it. All to often , I have found old instruments that had been "tuned" as shown. The result was reed tongues ground far too thin at the tips, and with the cross sectional profile totally disrupted. This made the reeds distorted, less responsive, and left little material with which to correct, in some way, the situation. Also, any rotary tool used either for wood or metal should have an infinitely adjustable speed control, to perform tasks without the danger of being out of control. Everything on reeds can be accomplished with hand filing, and with complete control. There is no gain in expertise or economy by using a rotary tool.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Kimric Smythe on August 19, 2013, 05:45:57 PM
A skilled accordion technician is able to tune both pull and push reeds, raising or lowering their frequency, with their valves in place while   the reed block (unless certain circumstances prohibit it) stays in the accordion. When tuning a tremolo no electronic device is needed. "Tuners" who are dependent on a dremel tool do not necessarily do irreversible damage to every reed they come across. However, this "method" reveals a significant lack of proper training and skill which will make it impossible to do first class work. And first class work is what paying customers expect.

  It is true when I was working at Seagate (hard drives) doing QC ,that the BEST hard drives were made secretly in a separate building. The workers did not wear regular clean suits, they all wore bifocals (whether they needed them or not) and worked at hand hewn wooden benches, while wearing canvas work aprons. They were not permitted electric lighting , work was done by natural lighting  and candles.  They were permitted to use hand crank drills when it became to difficult to purchase gimlets in sizes under #30 wire size. Discs were cut using a hammer and chisel and carefully hand lapped using monazite sand obtained from the beaches in nearby Santa Cruz.
Of course using hand files for all the most delicate work. These drives were not available to the general public and were usually purchased by Steve Jobs or Bill Gates personally.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Stiamh on August 19, 2013, 08:08:35 PM
I came up against this difference of opinion a few years ago when my regular repairman was busy and I got some retuning done by a less experienced tuner who used a Dremel. My regular fellow reacted strongly when he found out - thought that this was definitely not kosher! But the lady who did the job had been trained by a very experienced tuner well known in the PA and CBA world in these parts. (Incidentally he recommended using a battery-powered Dremel since this was far less likely to produce ruinous results.) I must say I was very happy with the results that were obtained in spite of my usual man's imprecations.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Mike Averill on August 19, 2013, 08:11:56 PM
Is the dremel any worse than the power tool used to make the reed in the first place ? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgYYyn72HLI
2 minutes in
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Adam-T on August 19, 2013, 08:13:59 PM
looks a far easier controlled device than a spinning Dremel
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: streb on August 19, 2013, 10:07:40 PM
My approach is to consider what Stradivari would have done if power tools had been available to him. To paraphrase, it is not the high speed router bit that is the problem but the nut that is holding it.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: forrest on August 19, 2013, 10:24:00 PM
Is the dremel any worse than the power tool used to make the reed in the first place ? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgYYyn72HLI
2 minutes in

   The grinder being used is part of the manufacturing process, the operator knows exactly what he is doing. If he somehow makes an error, the reed goes into the scrap bin. Not a big loss.
   Much different for a tuner in some far corner of the world with a 10,000 rpm dremel trying to do freehand grinding on a reed that might be very difficult to replicate. I have nothing against power tools, but I have seen them wreak havoc in the wrong hands.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: an bosca ceoil on August 19, 2013, 11:34:19 PM
I can wreak havoc with a file in the wrong hand.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on August 20, 2013, 05:10:05 AM
I have nothing against power tools, but I have seen them wreak havoc in the wrong hands.

Not only IN, but ON the wrong hands....
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 20, 2013, 06:43:35 AM
Is the dremel any worse than the power tool used to make the reed in the first place ? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgYYyn72HLI
2 minutes in

The carefully regulated abrasive action of the flat linishing belt with a pressure pad to keep things constant is quite different from the aggressive cutting action of a high-speed rotary tool, especially one which depends solely on its operator's steadiness of hand.

Graham
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Colombia20102018 on August 21, 2013, 03:59:44 PM
I am not sure how accordions are tuned in Mexico. The guy in your video is Mexican. In Colombia we have "Técnicos Afinadores" to do this kind of job. It is very common to change the tune of your accordion for professional accordionists in Colombia (acordeoneros). They change the tunes to add more color or variety to their songs. In Colombia we have thousands of songs played with the accordion. This causes that after a while, many songs started to sound very similar, then they change the tune to make them sound different. The most common accordion used in Colombia is the Hohner Corona III which is a three row diatonic accordion. The stores sell them in the basic tones GCF, ADG, and BEbAb. Each letter meaning the tune one each row. It is very common to convert a GCF to a CFBb, a ADG to a DGC, a BEbAb to a BEA, etc. Basically you can changed it to any combination as long as you keep the harmony of (I, IV, V). Middle row = I, outside row = V and inside rom = IV. The link below is part of a Colombian documentary with subtitles in English where they show how the tune of the accordion is changed. The technician in the video lives in a very small town in Colombia near a desert but Colombia is mostly green, so please do not think that all the Country is like this  ;). You can watch the full documentary in youtube. Let me know what you think.
Video title: Acordeón del Diablo (Francisco el Hombre - Pacho Rada) Part 6
Link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4y3pQINzKY0
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: rees on August 21, 2013, 04:23:09 PM
Great video - thanks for posting.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: diatonix on August 21, 2013, 04:58:30 PM
A professional tuner will always try and leave as few traces as possible, not only for aesthetic reasons but also in order to traumatize the reed as little as possible. We try and get it right the first time!  When I come across instruments that were "tuned" with a dremel or similar tools I very often notice that there are ugly marks both near the base and on the tip of the reed (and very often about half way in between, whatever the purpose of such an action may have been) which means that the "tuner" first went too low, than too high , repeating  this procedure probably several times before getting it, with some luck,  right (or, more often, making it worse than it was before...).
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: waltzman on August 21, 2013, 06:59:50 PM
You keep referring to "professional tuners" and "proper training".  All of the accordion tuners I know of are self taught.  What is "proper training"?  I think the idea that dremel use is a reliable indicator of ignorance is simply wrong.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: rees on August 21, 2013, 07:15:45 PM
You keep referring to "professional tuners" and "proper training".  All of the accordion tuners I know of are self taught.  What is "proper training"?  I think the idea that dremel use is a reliable indicator of ignorance is simply wrong.

True, but all of the accordion tuners (including myself) whose work I know and respect prefer the file and scratcher.
Whereas the bad ones, whose work often adorns my tuning table, all seem to use a Dremel.

Just sayin' ..............
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Theo on August 21, 2013, 07:45:30 PM
Same here.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Lester on August 21, 2013, 08:14:06 PM
Even I don't Dremel!    (:)
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Mike Hirst on August 21, 2013, 08:14:37 PM
I use a file and a still manage to f*** it up  :(
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: deltasalmon on August 21, 2013, 08:19:28 PM
I use a file and a still manage to f*** it up  :(

I recently started "practicing" tuning reeds with a few chansons I had laying around the house.

I'm in the same boat. I don't need a fancy dremel to mess up some reeds, I do a fine job with just a file.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Adam-T on August 21, 2013, 08:21:44 PM
Even I have started out the right way with a set of Files . checkout the File thread  for suggestions of best buys

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12909.0.html
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Rog on August 22, 2013, 02:48:45 PM
I am not sure how accordions are tuned in Mexico. The guy in your video is Mexican. In Colombia we have "Técnicos Afinadores" to do this kind of job. It is very common to change the tune of your accordion for professional accordionists in Colombia (acordeoneros). They change the tunes to add more color or variety to their songs. In Colombia we have thousands of songs played with the accordion. This causes that after a while, many songs started to sound very similar, then they change the tune to make them sound different. The most common accordion used in Colombia is the Hohner Corona III which is a three row diatonic accordion. The stores sell them in the basic tones GCF, ADG, and BEbAb. Each letter meaning the tune one each row. It is very common to convert a GCF to a CFBb, a ADG to a DGC, a BEbAb to a BEA, etc. Basically you can changed it to any combination as long as you keep the harmony of (I, IV, V). Middle row = I, outside row = V and inside rom = IV. The link below is part of a Colombian documentary with subtitles in English where they show how the tune of the accordion is changed. The technician in the video lives in a very small town in Colombia near a desert but Colombia is mostly green, so please do not think that all the Country is like this  ;). You can watch the full documentary in youtube. Let me know what you think.
Video title: Acordeón del Diablo (Francisco el Hombre - Pacho Rada) Part 6
Link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4y3pQINzKY0

Hey thanks for that. I love the accordion duet...
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: IanD on August 22, 2013, 06:00:55 PM
You keep referring to "professional tuners" and "proper training".  All of the accordion tuners I know of are self taught.  What is "proper training"?  I think the idea that dremel use is a reliable indicator of ignorance is simply wrong.

True, but all of the accordion tuners (including myself) whose work I know and respect prefer the file and scratcher.
Whereas the bad ones, whose work often adorns my tuning table, all seem to use a Dremel.

Just sayin' ..............

It's not the tool that's the problem, it's the tool holding it...

(and they can either mess things up faster with a Dremel, or more slowly with a file or scratcher)
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: waltzman on August 24, 2013, 06:03:43 PM


I wonder how many on this forum who are making fun of this guy have actually tried to get proficient using a dremel or are just speculating.  Just to be clear, my preference for tuning is sandpaper glued to flat wooden sticks and a scratcher made from a needle file.  But I have used a dremel and found it very precise and easy to control and, even as a rank beginner, I never ruined a reed with it.  The reason I tried it in the first place was because I already had a dremel and Marc Savoy uses one on a video I saw.  He builds some of the most sought after cajun accordions in the US and has tuned hundreds of accordions.  In that respect I think he likely has as much "proper training" as anyone on this forum.   In the spirit of sharing useful information there is, in my opinion, one task where a dremel is superior to files and sandpaper and that is raising the pitch of a large reed by a semi tone or a whole tone.  You can make a nice little dimple in the tip of the reed with a dremel and never touch the perimeter of the reed.  This neatly raises the pitch without any effect on reed response or harmonics.  It also leaves a very nice spot for a bit of solder if you wish to reverse the process.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Theo on August 25, 2013, 10:37:49 AM
I've tried using a dremel type tool, and I can make it work without damaging the reed, but I find it needs more effort to keep it under control than do hand tools and it takes longer to use.  It is much heavier to pick up, and you have to wait while the tool spins up before you can apply it, and you have to wait for it to spin down after use.   With file or scratcher I can keep the tool in my hand all the time, no picking up and no waiting.  If you are only tuning the occasional reed this would not be significant, but  for example there is getting on for 200 tongues in a 2 row, 3 voice, 12 bass and when doing a full re-tune the difference becomes highly significant in terms of time and effort.  There is also the horrible buzzing noise.  When I'm tuning I need as near as possible complete silence, even noises in between sounding reeds are a distraction.

Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: rees on August 25, 2013, 11:06:02 AM
I've tried using a dremel type tool, and I can make it work without damaging the reed, but I find it needs more effort to keep it under control than do hand tools and it takes longer to use.  It is much heavier to pick up, and you have to wait while the tool spins up before you can apply it, and you have to wait for it to spin down after use.   With file or scratcher I can keep the tool in my hand all the time, no picking up and no waiting.  If you are only tuning the occasional reed this would not be significant, but  for example there is getting on for 200 tongues in a 2 row, 3 voice, 12 bass and when doing a full re-tune the difference becomes highly significant in terms of time and effort.  There is also the horrible buzzing noise.  When I'm tuning I need as near as possible complete silence, even noises in between sounding reeds are a distraction.

Exactly.  (:)
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 25, 2013, 12:16:01 PM
I wonder how many on this forum who are making fun of this guy

I don't agree that questioning whether a technique is advisable constitutes "making fun of" someone. I hope none of us on here would be so insensitive.

Graham
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 25, 2013, 12:18:23 PM
Wot GPS said  ;D
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: waltzman on August 25, 2013, 01:54:14 PM
I wonder how many on this forum who are making fun of this guy

I don't agree that questioning whether a technique is advisable constitutes "making fun of" someone. I hope none of us on here would be so insensitive.

Graham

Check the title of this thread and several earlier posts.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: waltzman on August 25, 2013, 02:29:24 PM
I've tried using a dremel type tool, and I can make it work without damaging the reed, but I find it needs more effort to keep it under control than do hand tools and it takes longer to use.  It is much heavier to pick up, and you have to wait while the tool spins up before you can apply it, and you have to wait for it to spin down after use.   With file or scratcher I can keep the tool in my hand all the time, no picking up and no waiting.  If you are only tuning the occasional reed this would not be significant, but  for example there is getting on for 200 tongues in a 2 row, 3 voice, 12 bass and when doing a full re-tune the difference becomes highly significant in terms of time and effort.  There is also the horrible buzzing noise.  When I'm tuning I need as near as possible complete silence, even noises in between sounding reeds are a distraction.

I don't like it for those same reasons.  One of the things I found that really improved the control was to round the tip of the grindstone.  The dremel conical grindstone tips have a sharp edge at the tip when new.  Rounding this off helps a lot.  It really does work a treat for raising the pitch by a semitone or whole tone.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Theo on August 25, 2013, 02:49:02 PM
I've never had any problems raising the pitch by that amount with a good sharp file.  For me the dremel is a solution in search of a problem.  I think they are useful tools for many other things, but on reeds? Not for me.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: syale on August 25, 2013, 03:21:56 PM
I have always protected my ears. My wife makes jewelry and occasionally I have to break out the Dremel with the diamond bits to ream out a hole in beads. I wear ear protection whilst doing it because of the high pitch of the motor. I have not tuned a reed yet (still building equipment) but if I were using a Dremel for 200 reeds I would probably want ear protection on and that would be another obstacle at the tuning point to take them on and off 200 x "How often I need to make changes to a reed" times... As we get older the high frequencies go first.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Colombia20102018 on August 26, 2013, 05:28:14 PM
Great video - thanks for posting.
Thanks. The duet is the best part.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 04:13:20 AM
I have found a comfortable middle ground between the Dremel & diamond bit grinder and the file & scratch methods that I will share for your consideration.

There are some very nice rotary polishers made for both the manicure industry and for dental crown touch up and polishing. They are smaller and less powerful than Dremel tools. Here are some photos:
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 04:15:00 AM
These are beautifully made with two separate sections: a DC motor portion with a drive coupler; and a nose-piece tool chuck portion with its own set of two precision ball bearings. This allows you to grip the tool very near the working tip for excellent control. In the first picture I’ve split the two halves and am showing the cross drive coupler. You can also see the rear ball bearing on the nose-piece on the right.

The second picture picture shows the nose-piece disassembled. The upper portion is the housing and still contains the front ball bearing (out of sight inside). The lower portion is the tool chuck showing the rear ball bearing and the plastic drive coupler. It also displays a bag of rubber abrasive polishing bits in 5 different grades between fine and coarse. I believe these were first manufactured for polishing tool steel molds used for plastic injection molding. These rubberized abrasives are perfect for tuning accordion reeds! They remove metal very slowly. Another great feature is, due to the rubber binding, the contact area gets bigger the harder you push on it so has much less tendency to dig in or gouge. I still move the bit in either a circular or left/right oscillating motion that produces a large even contact area. 
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 04:20:28 AM
Here is a picture in use. The reedblock is on my tuning table and the reed below the shim tool is sounding.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 04:32:32 AM
Picture 1 shows the shim is behind the reed ready for tuning.  Picture 2 shows the rubberized abrasive bit ready to work. This is a simulated photo as I would need three hands to hold the shim, polisher and camera – hence the bit is not rotating. Also my right fingers would be in the photo holding the tool very near the end.

I assure you this is a big improvement in control and results versus the dremel and rigid diamond bit.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 04:48:14 AM
The bit shaft is 3/32" diameter so quite small. Having two ball bearings supporting the nosepiece makes the bits run very smooth without shake or runout. Another advantage is that the rubberized abrasive can easily be re-trued or shaped quickly using an aluminum oxide dressing stone (pic 2). Pic 1 shows a polisher and a two button footswitch. I have wired this up so that I can control the direction of the polisher (clock-wise or counter clock-wise rotation) hands-free. This is needed since it is a disaster if you are working on the tip of the reed and the bit catches the edge and instantly curls the reed metal back permanently. (don't ask how I know:) By controlling the direction, this situation can be avoided entirely.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 05:46:16 AM
Here I show some of the results. I pulled rusty reeds from my junk pile to help accent the polished area for the photographs. First pic shows the polish patch when lowering the pitch. Notice that it is possible to stay mostly clear of the edges so as to not alter the important reed/reedplate gap characteristics as mentioned by others earlier in this thread. The second pic shows pitch raising, again with the ability to avoid the edges.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 06:18:25 AM
This pic shows a broken reed with the common straight break across the width of the reed. This is the result of a stress fracture. As shown in the video earlier in this thread, the manufacturing process involves sanding the reed across the width. This, unfortunately leave minute scratches in the surface. Consider the middle G reed on a DG box. It is vibrating at 785 hertz. The reed reaches a million cycles within 22 minutes of use! If one of the surface scratches is a little deeper than the surrounding ones it is possible for the scratch to slowly propagate through the reed as a crack eventually resulting in a break.

A side benefit of polish tuning is that these minute scratches are polished out greatly reducing the chance for a stress fracture.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 06:29:41 AM
I continue to use files at times myself- especially if I need to raise the pitch of a mounted inner reed a good amount. I will file the tip of the reed until close but I will finish up with the polisher because it is so controllable and repeatable. The rubberized abrasive tools are a real boon for tuning. I appreciate the melnet community and thought others here would be interested in this polishing method as a middle ground between grinding and filing.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 28, 2013, 08:54:19 AM
Thanks for going to so much trouble to provide an interesting set of photos and descriptions.
I'm sure that you have learned to control your rotary polisher very carefully and can use it on reeds without causing damage.

But even so, in my opinion, several problems appear to remain:

1. Compared with files/scratchers which are thin and manoeuvrable, the relative bulk of the polisher suggests that it is difficult or impossible to use when tuning reeds in situ on the reed block and in the instrument. Therefore, not so good for the final fine tuning process which really needs to be carried out with reeds and blocks in the instrument.

2. The polisher tips are too large for working on the underneath 'pull' reeds through the reed plate slots. So - you can only work on about half of the reeds in an instrument using this method. How do you get around this, other than by removing the reed plate from the block and turning it over? Again, this precludes precision tuning work in situ in the instrument.

3. There would also be the same spin-up/spin-down times and the noise mentioned by earlier contributors.

I can see that the tool might be useful for gentle and rapid removal of rust when renovating old reeds which are not mounted in reed blocks, but otherwise I am not at all convinced it is a good idea, sorry. I will stick with my files and scratchers.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Theo on August 28, 2013, 09:40:03 AM
The smooth finish and ability to polish out cracks is definitely a plus, but I expect that to reduce the chances of fracture you would have to do rather more polishing than is strictly necessary for tuning.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 02:56:20 PM
Good points. Steve-You are right in that I’ve left out an important part of the story- the inner reeds in situ. (points 1 & 2)
I am most often working on older Hohners that require full removal from the reedblock for valve replacement anyway so I am tuning the push reed in my fixture using rubber abrasive bits (shown in recent photos), flipping the reedplate in the fixture and tuning the pull reed with the same bit. This usually gets the pitch within +/- 2 cents after remounting on the reedblock. The final tuning is done on the reedblock. Outer reeds are as I have described earlier. Inner reeds usually require different bits. In this picture I’m showing some of the other bits. The left three are 3/32” shaft diamond bits with spherical, oval, and straight with hemispherical tip from left to right. The narrow profile is required to access the back side of the inner reeds.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 03:01:00 PM
This picture shows how lowering the pitch is done using either the spherical or straight/hemisphere bits. This is accomplished while on the tuning table right over the air hole so the tune-check interval is quick. I don’t have a picture of raising the pitch but that does require pivoting the reedblock onto one side allowing insertion of a brass rod or wooden tool (bamboo BBQ skewers work well on larger reeds) through the air hole to lift the inner reed tip. Once lifted the oval diamond tip can be used to remove metal- again away from the edges.

If the valves are good and an inner reed pitch needs to be raised quite a bit, rather than removing the reedplate I will use a file on the reed tip to remove most of metal but tend to final tweak the last 1 or 2 cents with the polisher just because for me it has become fast and reliable. It is very rare for me to overshoot the target pitch requiring reversal. The very highest reeds are the most tricky and most prone to overshoot.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 03:06:02 PM
Point 3- spin-up/spin down time & noise.
These are small, low inertia tools that can go from 0 to 25,000 rpm in about ½ second. I’ve never experienced any delay in my tuning due to this. Spin down may be 2 or 3 seconds but I’m either still holding the polisher in my right hand while I look at the tuning meter or placing it onto a cradle where the bit is held up in the air anyway. On my dual footswitch model, due to the polarity reversal wiring, it actually shorts the motor leads together when turned off providing electronic braking.
Concerning noise, these are designed for manicurists where both customer and manicurist are chatting away within 2 feet of the tool. They are quiet. I will make a video some time to demonstrate. I often leave the motor running during the quick tune/check cycle since it doesn’t disturb the tuners.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on August 28, 2013, 03:09:35 PM
Theo-
I totally agree that most reeds don’t get polished down through all the manufacturing scratches so the benefit is low. I would state that it is not harming the reed by polishing at the base of the reed. I have examples where the reed broke about half way from tip to root which is not in the area used for tuning so it wouldn't have helped in that case regardless.

Scott
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Kimric Smythe on August 29, 2013, 06:02:46 PM
 On the battery unit I use, spin up is less than a second and the volume is less that the reed playing. As the above person noted There are MANY different types of wheels for dremel type devices. I found using the face of a small saucer shaped wheel (not the edge) leaves a very nice finish. It is very difficult to gouge a reed this way. With a little practice one can put a bevel on a machine reed to duplicate a missing/broken "hand finished" reed if one of the right dimension is not available. Spreading out the area you remove material from also prevents weak spots.

I do a lot of work on tex mex boxes, and reed breakage is a common problem. One would think the tuning spots would be the common point of breakage, but it can be anywhere from the base near the rivet ,or 1/4 of the way down from the tip. Quality of reeds seems to not be an issue and the breaks as often as not are on a point of tuning.

 I was on a project with an art group I work with where we were building a 5 ft valved pulse jet. The valve was a piece of blued spring steel about 5 inches across, that looked like a steel daisy. Each petal covered a 3/4 inch hole that admitted a fuel air mix between "pulses". The engine worked fine for about 15 min before performance fell off and it started to flame back into the mixing chamber.
 Upon disassembly we discovered that the valve had shattered and frayed, no matter where petal was on the daisy the cracks ran in one direction as if it had been made of thin wood veneer. It was pretty clear at that point what was meant by metal sometimes having a grain. Wish I had a pic of it, but here is a link showing someone else's similar problem...https://www.google.com/search?q=pulse+jet+valve+design&client=firefox-a&hs=N26&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=Fn0fUq-tFuK9sQS714CQBw&ved=0CAkQ_AUoAQ&biw=1280&bih=583#facrc=_&imgdii=_&imgrc=KB9aqnhkW49QXM%3A%3Bof3wpUrmL1814M%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Faardvark.co.nz%252Fpjet%252Fimages%252Frvd3.jpg%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Faardvark.co.nz%252Fpjet%252Fvalvelife.shtml%3B283%3B300
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: ChrisLDD on February 28, 2014, 11:12:31 PM
I just came across this video showing a guy using a rotary tool to tune reeds.
I like the setup, and he appears quite proficient, but I would have liked to see how he lowered the pitch of an internal reed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9W0YxFTI
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: Christopher K. on February 28, 2014, 11:35:42 PM
Quote
It was pretty clear at that point what was meant by metal sometimes having a grain. Wish I had a pic of it, but here is a link showing someone else's similar problem..

I started an interesting thread about grain direction in steel accordion reeds a few years ago. It can be found here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=7160.0). It concerned me that grain in accordion reeds always runs perpendicular to the length of the reed, and this is (in my experience) always where a reed breaks. Seems to make more sense, from a usage but not necessarily production perspective, to make the grain run perpendicular to the reed's 'axis of flex' (a term I just invented.. :o).

Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: gettabettabox on March 01, 2014, 01:39:38 AM
I just came across this video showing a guy using a rotary tool to tune reeds.
I like the setup, and he appears quite proficient, but I would have liked to see how he lowered the pitch of an internal reed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9W0YxFTI

love what looks like sparks at 6.40 into vid...dremel dream fettlin'   !!!
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on March 01, 2014, 05:31:41 AM
I just came across this video showing a guy using a rotary tool to tune reeds.
I like the setup, and he appears quite proficient, but I would have liked to see how he lowered the pitch of an internal reed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9W0YxFTI

If you look back on Reply #57 (page 3 of this thread) there is a photo of bits. The leftmost is a spherical tipped diamond bit that is smaller in diameter than the shaft of the bit. This works well for lowering the pitch of an inside reed. I sort of use the same motion as a scratcher only less pressure is required. It makes a small grind line in the middle of the reed. The smaller head prevents accidentally grinding the sides of the reed slot. I find it controllable and quick.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: diatonix on March 01, 2014, 04:12:10 PM
I can't detect anything that would make him "appear proficient" and I'm afraid the title of this thread applies also for his way of "tuning".
Again, no problem as long as he damages his own boxes, but if he does this for a living it's a different story...
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: IanD on March 01, 2014, 04:54:31 PM
Quote
It was pretty clear at that point what was meant by metal sometimes having a grain. Wish I had a pic of it, but here is a link showing someone else's similar problem..

I started an interesting thread about grain direction in steel accordion reeds a few years ago. It can be found here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=7160.0). It concerned me that grain in accordion reeds always runs perpendicular to the length of the reed, and this is (in my experience) always where a reed breaks. Seems to make more sense, from a usage but not necessarily production perspective, to make the grain run perpendicular to the reed's 'axis of flex' (a term I just invented.. :o).

Steel doesn't really have a "grain" like wood -- it might seem to if you look at it under the microscope, but in spite of this the material is pretty much anisotropic (same properties in all directions), unlike wood there is no significant weakness at the grain boundaries.

Are you sure that what you think is "grain" isn't just machining/filing marks running across the width of the reed? These do act as stress concentrators unless very shallow which can lead to the reed breaking, which is why you should never leave grooves across a reed when scraping or filing it.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: ChrisLDD on March 02, 2014, 04:51:00 PM
I can't detect anything that would make him "appear proficient" and I'm afraid the title of this thread applies also for his way of "tuning".
Again, no problem as long as he damages his own boxes, but if he does this for a living it's a different story...

I'm just an enthusiastic amateur, but based upon the look of the tuning table, I would guess that this guy is probably a professional tuner!

If you look back on Reply #57 (page 3 of this thread) there is a photo of bits. The leftmost is a spherical tipped diamond bit that is smaller in diameter than the shaft of the bit. This works well for lowering the pitch of an inside reed. I sort of use the same motion as a scratcher only less pressure is required. It makes a small grind line in the middle of the reed. The smaller head prevents accidentally grinding the sides of the reed slot. I find it controllable and quick.

Actually, based upon your recommendation, I bought a Foredom SR pendant drill with a rotary hand-piece and a selection of rubberised abrasive tips - I'm really pleased with the results. For work through the reed-plates I use a GRS850 with a small diamond burr.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: hickory-wind on March 03, 2014, 04:32:59 PM
Chris-
For raising the pitch of inside reeds I use a 200k rpm pneumatic dental handpiece. That works out to 3300 SFM (@ 1.6mm dia.)-reasonable for diamond coated bits. These are nice because the bit is 90 degrees from the handle. I am having special bits made (1.6mm shank) that only cut on the tip, not the sides so there is no danger of damaging the inside of the reed slot. If you would like to try one in your GRS 850, PM me and I will send one to you. Did you get the variable speed foot pedal with it? I'd like to know how well that works. I have an on/off pneumatic foot switch at the moment.

Scott
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: ChrisLDD on March 03, 2014, 11:10:09 PM
Scott:
I did get the variable speed foot pedal, but the control is nowhere near as fine as on the pendant drill. I tend to find that I either use it full on, or for finer control, press and release the pedal and use it during the 2 second spin down time.

I would love to try my GRS 850 with one of the special bits you are having made - I will PM you.

Chris.
Title: Re: How to efficiently ruin an accordion
Post by: diatonix on March 03, 2014, 11:28:17 PM
These last 3 posts fit just perfectly into this thread.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal