Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: tedrick on November 16, 2013, 06:36:58 PM

Title: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: tedrick on November 16, 2013, 06:36:58 PM
Hi Everyone -
I have been interested in moving towards a 3 voice MMM for quite some time. I would like as lightweight a box as possible - something along the lines of a Tommy -

How practical is it to modify an Erica to add a 3rd set of reeds?

Would it be worth it? Or would it be easier to just find a 3 voice MMM Corso/Double Ray Deluxe?

Reed
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Lester on November 16, 2013, 06:38:55 PM
Microbot of this parish is your man.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 16, 2013, 07:42:31 PM
Thanks Lester ... and Hi Reed!

I am currently half-way through making two MMM Ericas ... but first some background ...

Over the past 2 years I've made a number of standard 2-voice Hohners into 3-voice boxes, including 3 PressedWoods in D/G, 3 Erikas in D/G (the wooden bodied 2.4 row), 3 student 1 Melodeon conversions ... all have been LMM ...

I have also made, this year, one Erica 3-voice - it's also an LMM and is a red Box in C/F with pull-stop to go from LMM to MM, 12 basses with bass end stop to take out the thirds .... it's currently on loan to Ollie King...

You can see a photo and hear it on my soundcloud (with a number of the other 3-voice models listed above) on ...

  https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2

(... there are some twenty recordings on my site and the red Erica is a fair way down the page...)

You can hear the instrument being played far better, by a far better player, on Ollie King's website ... notably this tune, which is quite majestic ...

https://soundcloud.com/olliekingbox/rain-tune

And finally to get to the point .... I am so pleased with this C/F LMM Erica (which was the first Erica I'd 3-voiced), that I am currently building 2 more Erica 3-voices.

....... Both will be MMM... one is for myself (Black 3-voice D/G MMM) and the other for Steven Jones ... (Grey MMM 3-voice C#/D MMM)

On both of these instruments I am not fitting a slider/pullstop to go from MMM to MM (although this would be easy, as with the LMM C/F box). This derives from the much-discussed observation that fixed 3-voice MMM instruments (without slider/stop to go to MM) deliver a fuller sound and better response. Besides, we've all GOT 2-voice boxes we can use if we want that sound - I want to find out just how good a non-slider 3-voice Erica can be.

cheers
 
Mike R


Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: tedrick on November 16, 2013, 09:19:58 PM
Hi Mike -
Thanks for your quick reply - I recall now reading about your upgrades and modifications earlier here on the forum. I agree with your point re: a 3 voice without a mechanism - I already have a 2 voice I like, I'm happy to lug it around and switch to a 2nd box when I want that sound -

I'm looking forward to hearing the sound samples out on soundcloud - for some reason they wouldn't play for me from your web site -

How much does your 3 voice Erica weigh?

Thanks!
Reed
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2013, 11:16:23 PM
I think that a grey Erica in MMM would look fantastic. All the Paolo-ists would be quite taken aback!
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: pgroff on November 16, 2013, 11:46:34 PM
I think that a grey Erica in MMM would look fantastic. All the Paolo-ists would be quite taken aback!

Grey is probably my favorite color for Ericas, and not the most common color. I was saving the very original one at left in the pic below for a project such as Mike describes but don't know if I'll get around to it this decade . . .  might consider a trade or attractive offer for it.  The Corona is gone though.

PG
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: melodeon on November 17, 2013, 05:52:47 AM
Paul,

What key is the two row and what would be an "attractive" offer?

PM ok.
J
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: malcolmbebb on November 17, 2013, 09:27:04 AM
Mike,
Just curious - presumably they are externally identical?
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 17, 2013, 09:55:54 AM
Hi Reed, Malcolm, Owen and Paul,

I'm not sure of the exact total weight but an Erica treble reedblock+reeds weighs 5 ounces ... count that as the additional weight of the 3rd reedblock and add that to the weight of an original Erica, which is a pretty lightweight box.

yes, they're externally identical. The whole concept was to retain as much of the original instrument and sound as possible.

The original soundboard is removed and a new soundboard (holes already CNC routed) is fitted .... the new soundboard is designed to accommodate the original reedblocks, with the addition of a 3rd reedblock inbetween. The original fingerboard and action are retained ... larger pallets are of course needed.

I'll put a photo up later of the black and grey Erica 3Vs under construction showing the new soundboard...

cheers

Mike R

 
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Owen Woods on November 17, 2013, 04:50:13 PM
I think that a grey Erica in MMM would look fantastic. All the Paolo-ists would be quite taken aback!

Grey is probably my favorite color for Ericas, and not the most common color. I was saving the very original one at left in the pic below for a project such as Mike describes but don't know if I'll get around to it this decade . . .  might consider a trade or attractive offer for it.  The Corona is gone though.

PG

Gorgeous! And original boxes! /nerd
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Lars on November 17, 2013, 08:00:41 PM
Interesting thread, especially since I just found 3 blocks from a scrapped Corso lying dangerously close to a beaten-up Erica... I did convert a 2 v. Busilacchio to a 3 voice a few years back, lovely to have that extra swing to the sound:)

What material do you use for soundboards Mike? I would think plywood around 5 mm., but have you ever tried aluminium?
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 17, 2013, 08:32:23 PM
Hi Lars,

I am using 4mm marine ply. I do not subscribe to the view that the material of the soundboard has no impact on tone and volume ... indeed, quite the contrary.

The density and construction of the soundboard ply in Hohner instruments varies, but in the better instruments I've worked on it tends to be harder and tighter-grained ... thus, I am using a dense hardwood ply (all layers Sapele or Gaboon) - it is not only very hard but lends itself to cutting/routing.

Yes, I considered aluminium but I don't have your experience with Paolos etc to call on ... by erring on the side of harder wood for the soundboard, I considered I might be moving in that direction. At any rate, the red Erica I made, which I describe in the post above (which has the same hardwood soundboard) has a great tone.

I intended to post a photo of the Grey and Black Ericas with their new soundboards this eve, but it will have to wait till tomorrow - I prefer taking photos with decent light!!!

How did you go about making your Busilachio a 3-voice? Hey - I salute a brother in arms!
 
cheers!

Mike R
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Lars on November 18, 2013, 08:19:00 AM
Mike,

I've had a lot of Paolos through my hands, but only one with alu soundboard - all the ones I have myself are plywood soundboarded. Not hardwood, but pretty close grained.

For the Busilacchio the original soundboard was damaged by water when I got it, so it was just a matter of placing a few knocks with a hammer, and it came out. Made a new from 5mm model aircraft plywood (birch 5 ply), and glued it in. I did what you descibed, and made a middle block to go between the two original, and added new pallets to the original action.

The reason why I consider alu is just a matter of sound - though I think plywood will sound great, I can't help wonder what alu would sound like. Crisp? Bright? Shrill? I suppose it's a matter of trying it to find out:)

I have a drill press and jigsaw, but no CNC, so I would be making by hand. I recently made a soundboard and blocks for a different box (alu board and walnut/mahogany blocks) with good results to the sound, so I can't help it wonder what it would sound like in an Erica.

Ah, plans, plans. Just need the time now:)
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Owen Woods on November 18, 2013, 09:17:13 AM
I'm not sure that it is a matter of saying "Alu palletboards will sound like this, ply soundboards will sound like that". There are too many variables. Alu is stiffer for a given mass, so the response of the palletboard will be different. This would include taking less energy out of the reed than a ply soundboard of identical dimensions. The exact affect of this would vary depending on how many reedblocks there are, whether they are glued down, what type of reeds are used and so on. Some alu palletboards would result in an sound unpleasantly shrill and harsh sound, some ply palletboards would result in a stodgy, sluggish sound. But a good maker would be able to get good results with either material. Personally I would use ply.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Lars on November 18, 2013, 02:36:10 PM
Ukebert,
I base my thoughts only on personal experience, and never in a Hohner. I too prefer the sound of ply for my MMM boxes, but I still think it could be interesting to hear what sound it would produce in an Erica, especially with only slight tremolo. The initial plan was to either use Corso blocks, or make a 3rd block myself, and put them in the usual Hohner way, with felt on the base of the blocks.

Btw, you might know this, or have a theory on it: How would the SIZE of the soundboard effect sound, if at all? I can't help wonder that the small size of an Erica might reduce some lower frequency harmonies, especially with alu soundboard.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Owen Woods on November 18, 2013, 05:39:12 PM
I have a theory! Basically the impedance of a plate varies with frequency, depending on where the modes of resonance are placed. So different sizes of soundboard would have different impedances at different frequencies. The impedance ratio between two systems is a measure of how easily vibration can pass between them. If too much energy passes from the reed-block system into the soundboard, it would sound muffled and stodgy. If too little passes then it could sound harsh and brittle. Having a larger soundboard means that the energy that is absorbed will be at different frequencies and magnitudes.

However, nothing is that simple. In actual fact, changing anything about the system changes everything. That is only really true for free areas of soundboard, which rarely occur. Having strong or weak coupling between the block and soundboard changes the impedance ratio and the impedance of the plate isn't meaningful unless you take into account the blocks. So everything is interconnected. Vague generalisations are about all I can manage.

Personally, I find that Hohner reeds can be a little harsh, so I would prefer a wooden soundboard to an alu one.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 18, 2013, 05:41:02 PM
Hi Lars and Owen!

below are a couple of photos of the 3-Voice Ericas under construction ... new ply soundboards installed.

For now, I'll stick with wood soundboards - though I do use aluminium for sliders...

Lars, if you are intending using the Corso reedblocks etc - beware! Remember that the chambers/reed/action spacings of the Corso are different from the Erica and Pokerwork. So the Erica action wouldn't marry with the Corso reedblocks ...

But its a problem that is probably 'negotiable'!
 
(By the way - if you look closely at the Grey Double-Ray, you can see it's designed as a 22 button instrument (11+11) ... Steve likes an extra button on his C#/D boxes ... low D/G)

cheers!

Mike
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2013, 05:45:04 PM
I have a theory! Basically the impedance of a plate varies with frequency,  ...

However, nothing is that simple. In actual fact, changing anything about the system changes everything.

And I have a hunch that another significant change would be the volume of free space inside the instrument which might also have an influence on the sound.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 18, 2013, 05:47:45 PM
I have a theory! Basically the impedance of a plate varies with frequency,  ...

However, nothing is that simple. In actual fact, changing anything about the system changes everything.

And I have a hunch that another significant change would be the volume of free space inside the instrument which might also have an influence on the sound.

absolutely agree with that Theo!

Mike
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Anahata on November 18, 2013, 05:55:50 PM
Quote from: Theo
And I have a hunch that another significant change would be the volume of free space inside the instrument which might also have an influence on the sound.

absolutely agree with that Theo!

Mike

If that were true, there'd be a significant change in sound as the bellows moved close to the fully closed position. I can't say I've ever noticed that happen.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 18, 2013, 06:13:14 PM
If that were true, there'd be a significant change in sound as the bellows moved close to the fully closed position. I can't say I've ever noticed that happen.
It does happen. With a sensitive electronic tuner (e.g. one of those strobe types) and playing a single steady note, you can see a change in pitch - perhaps 0.5 to 1 cent - as the bellows move into, or away from, the fully closed position. It's not normally detectable during ordinary playing and most people can't distinguish pitch changes that small anyway. But it can be something you need to take into account when trying to set up an instrument with 'Dedic/Viennese' tuning and where small pitch changes can have a noticeable effect on the tremolo rate, especially on the higher-pitched reeds.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 18, 2013, 06:18:27 PM
Quote from: Theo
And I have a hunch that another significant change would be the volume of free space inside the instrument which might also have an influence on the sound.

absolutely agree with that Theo!

Mike

If that were true, there'd be a significant change in sound as the bellows moved close to the fully closed position. I can't say I've ever noticed that happen.

Good spot Steve ... also (more in line with Theo's point I'd guess) if you remove the mid-reedblock from a 3-voice instrument with 3 reedblocks - blocking off the soundboard holes for that reedblock - there is a noticeable change in tone. This suggests it is less the total internal volume (which does of course increase/decrease with bellows movement) and more the space immediately around and inbetween the reedblocks ... ie the space within the casing.

In other words, occupying the internal space with additional reedblocks affects tone.

cheers

Mike
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2013, 06:39:59 PM
I was thinking along the lines Mike describes, the region adjacent to the reeds is where sound is first reflected, and the distance might have some influence.  I certainly am aware that a large three voice box eg a Mory, has a much different tone from say a Tommy, both of which have the same configuration if treble reeds.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: tirpous on November 18, 2013, 07:59:33 PM
Any particular reason for the square holes for the 3rd block ?
(other than having the CNC to do them !)
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Stiamh on November 18, 2013, 08:04:48 PM
I certainly am aware that a large three voice box eg a Mory, has a much different tone from say a Tommy, both of which have the same configuration if treble reeds.

In this respect it will be interesting to see whether the MMM Double-Ray has very different characteristics from a Double-Ray deluxe. Sean McComiskey has one of the deluxe jobs, set up by Martin Quinn, that has a magnificent sound - a sound to rival an old Paolo, in fact. That's what Mike is shooting for with this particular "old grey" (the box, not me).

BTW ukebert did you mean "nodes of resistance" rather than modes? Not that I understand what you are saying - I just wanted to let you know that someone was reading carefully. (:)
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 18, 2013, 08:23:03 PM
Any particular reason for the square holes for the 3rd block ?
(other than having the CNC to do them !)

Actually, the CNC prefers round holes! Getting the square holes requires a very fine cutter ... the reason for designing them is that, for any given required area - a square hole has smaller external dimensions than a circle - the circular holes in the soundboard are to match with the original reedblocks (with round holes), the square holes to match with the new (third) reedblock ... and by using square holes in this, the dimensions of the reedblock can be minimised ...

... which if you think about it relates directly to Theo's point, and the quest of trying to retain the original tone!!!!

cheers

Mike
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Christopher K. on November 18, 2013, 08:53:08 PM
That is an interesting point regarding how the 'open' surface area surrounding the reed blocks can affect the accordion's tone and volume. I once had a celluloid covered Weltmeister two-row such as the one below. They used the same body dimensions to make a three-row, and possibly a PA. Before I played the two-row, my instinct was that a bellows large enough to drive a three-rower should push a very big sound from 2/3 as many reeds, but it was exceedingly quiet in spite of having the reed gaps adjusted. It had other problems and was a very "bad" instrument, but that's another issue. The three-row I inspected was considerably louder. Mystery solved?

(http://www.netinstruments.com/pics/38364.jpg) (http://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/MTI4N1gxNjAw/z/bZQAAMXQO21RnjaJ/$T2eC16R,!)sE9swmZpfGBRnj,CnJ!!~~60_35.JPG)
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Owen Woods on November 19, 2013, 09:32:32 AM
I certainly am aware that a large three voice box eg a Mory, has a much different tone from say a Tommy, both of which have the same configuration if treble reeds.

In this respect it will be interesting to see whether the MMM Double-Ray has very different characteristics from a Double-Ray deluxe. Sean McComiskey has one of the deluxe jobs, set up by Martin Quinn, that has a magnificent sound - a sound to rival an old Paolo, in fact. That's what Mike is shooting for with this particular "old grey" (the box, not me).

BTW ukebert did you mean "nodes of resistance" rather than modes? Not that I understand what you are saying - I just wanted to let you know that someone was reading carefully. (:)

Nope, modes of resonance. Any plate will resonate at particular frequencies. This is a Bad Thing for accordions. But the amount of vibration which a plate will absorb at the frequencies that we are interested in depends on the positions of those resonances. If that makes sense.

I did make the point about free area of soundboards - although looking back it wasn't made clearly enough. This is what comes of dashing off posts just before I leave work! Yes, having a large area of unused palletboard makes a huge difference to the tone, because in simple terms, there is suddenly much more material which can absorb lower frequency vibration. For a tauter instrument I think that you want less free area.

But as I said, nothing is that simple. It really depends on the reeds that you've got in there and on the design of the block and all sorts of other things. Everything is interconnected.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Lars on November 19, 2013, 03:23:02 PM
It could perhaps be done, but tricky. To fit three blocks you'd need them to be slim, and close together (to ensure the inside row of pallets will open enough if using the original mechanism). By just adding holes to the existing soundboard, the outside block will be very close to the bellows and might not fit, and the middle block will have to be rather wide to use the existing holes. I found that making a new soundboard made most sense.
Title: Re: adding a 3rd voice to an Erica
Post by: Microbot on November 19, 2013, 03:50:03 PM
Hi Aradru,

Hmmm ... I've not worked on a Busilacchio - but if the soundboard is ply, you can meet significant problems in attempting to drill/ream out additional holes. There is a tendency for the wood to splinter. It's not just a selection of the right tools, it's a process you need to be thoroughly familiar with before you can do a neat job. I do it on bass soundboards of Pressed Woods and Erikas to make 12-bass conversions. But believe me - I've learned the hard way - I've made my mistakes and had to replace entire soundboards! If you are doing this for 'first time' - one or two slips and you can badly damage a beautiful instrument ...

Also, you need to consider the overall feasibility and plan the conversion - which will depend on the internal spacing of the casing and the bellows, reedblock dimension, the dimensions of the action and its function, including the critical matter of adequate pallet-lift etc ...

This all sounds negative - sorry! I am not trying to put you off - I want to urge caution and forethought. There's nothing worse than doing a 'passable' job, only to conclude - Hmmm if I had another of those Busilacchios I could do it really welll!!!

I'd definitely get in touch with Lars, who has himself converted a 2 to 3 voice Busilacchio.... aah whilst I was writing this Lars, has just added his reply above!!! I agree with all his points...

In terms of the soundboard, you could experiment on an old breaker instrument with similar grade of wood???

cheers

Mike
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal