Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: malcolmbebb on June 18, 2014, 11:16:17 PM

Title: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 18, 2014, 11:16:17 PM
Not sure if here is the right place, but I thought tacking this on the French thread was maybe a bit too much. It kinda follows on from that, though.

So if you were entering the UK melodeon making market as a new entrant - for argument's sake, you have freedom of choice to build in quantity, you have freedom to build quality, no constraints... except your imagination...

...what would be your sales pitch? Why are people going to buy your boxes instead of Hohner, Scarlatti, Castagnari etc. What are you going to offer the market to get your new business established?

(Thought I'd better include Welsh as Rees knows where I live. )
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 18, 2014, 11:22:45 PM
Quantity strategy needs tooling up, gigs, lasers, you really have to know about manufacture. But nevertheless I think the key is to deliver good quality in high quantity. The bespoke market is already well supplied :|glug
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: robotmay on June 18, 2014, 11:45:32 PM
I'd probably aim to perfect a single model initially; a 3 row/12 bass/2 voice box with a sound somewhat like the Bergflødt boxes, light and punchy enough for English music. Keeping it to one model initially would help keep production time down if identical components can be made for multiple boxes at once. Built mostly from wood (maybe a metal soundboard), it'd be ideal to have a laser cutter for more complex designs for grills etc, but I'm sure there are reasonable alternatives which don't take too much longer. If possible, build up a few boxes in spare time before opening the business so you can sell a few immediately to get them out there. With one model it'd hopefully be much easier to form your own production line, producing the standard parts for each box much quicker due to not having to alter your tooling every time.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: rees on June 19, 2014, 12:37:50 AM
Before this gets too deep and bewildering.
I really do feel queasy when quoting ex British Prime Minister, John Major, but in this case and in my case and especially in your case, "market forces will prevail"
Here are the categories:
1. Castagnari sell themselves, no problemo.
2. The Independents like Gaillard, Briggs, Savoy, Van Der Aa, me and lots of young French makers and good things happening in Ireland and many more, blah .........
3. Baffetti, Saltarelle, Giustozzi, etc. Good cheap boxes.
4. The Sandpiper.
5. Other shite.

Bring your price in under the Sandpiper and you're on a winner (quality control notwithstanding).
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: martin p on June 19, 2014, 10:01:42 AM
How about going back to basics and totally redesign the instrument using modern materials and styles i.e. Do what Dyson did to vacuum cleaners. Then you can charge a premium price if the product sounds good. It worked for Dyson.

Problems to address are Key Clatter and the fragility of many modern boxes. You could also include internal microphones etc.

Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Theo on June 19, 2014, 10:19:27 AM
Yes interesting idea,  James Dyson saw the potential for a fundamental change by replacing the heart of the machine with a completely new process. Can anyone envisage such a fundamental change for a box?  To me the heart of it is the reeds.  Every box maker in the world (I think) uses reeds from the same few reed makers.  What would be really revolutionary would be for a new maker to produce their own reeds,  and to re-think the design of the reed too.  If you have such an idea you better patent it before describing it here. ;)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 19, 2014, 10:28:13 AM
I have considered making reeds, but the tooling involved put me off. It would require an enormous amount of skill to pull off. Also, I don't know enough about reeds. Wheatstone experimented with all shapes and sizes of reeds and decided that the rectangular one was the best. It would be interesting if someone did come up with an alternative, but it won't happen without a lot of investment.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Matt (Kings Norton) on June 19, 2014, 10:35:38 AM
It seems like a lot of people in this country play mainly in sessions.  Would there be any market for a box that was very responsive, airtight, etc, lightweight, one voice, no basses.  I was thinking in terms of quality vs cost.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 19, 2014, 10:37:57 AM
It seems like a lot of people in this country play mainly in sessions.  Would there be any market for a box that was very responsive, airtight, etc, lightweight, one voice, no basses.  I was thinking in terms of quality vs cost.
The Wesson Coracle? Or is that two voice?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: george garside on June 19, 2014, 10:46:12 AM
.  Would there be any market for a box that was very responsive, airtight, etc, lightweight, one voice, no basses.
quote


The castagnari Lily BC more or less fits that spec as most BC players either don't use the bass or use it in a very limited way.   Presumably they would be more than happy with one sans bass provided it was significantly cheaper?

george 
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 19, 2014, 10:55:09 AM
As a hobby or as a living?

If you're going to compete with the Sandpipers then you're looking at a sale price around £800.  Making a traditional wooden box, is it possible to make (and sell) enough?

Off the top of my head I would look at 3D printing for as much as possible and find someone with spare laser capacity for cutting what needs to be wood.  Two voice with very limited options (complexity breeds cost).  As far as reeds are concerned I suspect that if there was a better shape we'd be using it by now.

Steve
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Clive Williams on June 19, 2014, 11:01:13 AM
How about going back to basics and totally redesign the instrument

I'm surprised nobody's had a real go at pitch bending technology; it's already developed at bluesbox.biz, but Tom's technology has been around for almost 20 years; no one has commercialised it or anything similar.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Ollie on June 19, 2014, 11:03:40 AM
It seems like a lot of people in this country play mainly in sessions.  Would there be any market for a box that was very responsive, airtight, etc, lightweight, one voice, no basses.  I was thinking in terms of quality vs cost.

I know they're completely different instruments, but I would have thought that the answer to wanting something like this would be to play the concertina. Now there's a market with some significant gaps in it...
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Anahata on June 19, 2014, 11:16:17 AM
the concertina. Now there's a market with some significant gaps in it...

Yes, mostly the gap between good enough to play and cheap enough to afford  :(
(it seems even worse than for melodeons)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Anahata on June 19, 2014, 11:19:52 AM
How about going back to basics and totally redesign the instrument using modern materials and styles

I take it you've read the 21st Century Box thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7840.0.html), which addresses exactly this issue and has some interesting ideas in it. Still open for new suggestions...
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 19, 2014, 11:20:53 AM
Ridiculous prices ::)  My Linota sold (20 years on) for 9x what I'd paid for it, albeit in slightly better condition.  Biggest inflation I've seen on a melodeon has been 2.5x. Generally I'm well chuffed to have the pleasure of playing a box for 7-8 years and just get back what I'd paid :|glug
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 19, 2014, 11:30:57 AM
I was thinking, from the French thread, that you can buy melodeons across a spread of prices and qualities, and tunings.

As others have said, the design of the melodeon as we know it seems pretty stable with no significant innovation and, broadly, only incremental improvement of late.

Hence, in part, the original question.

The concertina pond is, IMO, much smaller. Maybe due to the gap for an affordable, decent beginners box (£300 to £600?). £1500 for a melodeon is not that unusual now, that money buys you a decent hybrid concertina.
But in the Black Diamond to Pokerwork price range, the only new box that seems to get regular recommendations is the functional but less-than-pretty Rochelle, plus its English siblings.
A grand plus is a big leap for a beginner. So yes, a clearly identified gap for concertinas. But whether the market is big enough to fund filling it?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 19, 2014, 11:47:52 AM
If my box ends up good then I would consider selling a few. But I'm not intending earning a living from it - more supplementing my hobby. Making is fun.

It did occur to me that cheaper than a sandpiper would be a good market, but I don't think that it is possible. By the time you've bought bellows, reeds and hardware, you are already skimping on your profit margin. If you make all those things yourself then it will take longer and longer to make and it will be more and more expensive to tool up. Basically, small scale manufacturing (which is what I am doing) cannot compete with large scale manufacturing in terms of cost. I think that the niche is slightly bespoke (i.e. key, layout etc) decent boxes as a cheap competitor to the £2000-2500 level. I personally don't think much of many of the boxes retailing for that sort of money and I think that it is very possible to make a decent instrument for far less than that, whilst still being significantly better than the sandpiper.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 19, 2014, 11:55:32 AM
The thing that strikes me about the discussions here is that demand is getting more sophisticated, as players become older and more experienced.  But also, perhaps this idea has a limited life, because (and I regret to say this!) the spread of melnetters' ages is well skewed towards the upper end.

The other thing that occurs to me is that there seems to be a clash of design ideas, in that many experts have advised that the use of wood as a material doesn't much affect the sound, but nevertheless most boxes exhibit much craftsmanship being devoted to the use of attractive timbers.  Perhaps there's a younger market for cheaper plastic-moulded 'designer' construction and looks, performing much the same job?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 19, 2014, 11:57:44 AM
It seems like a lot of people in this country play mainly in sessions.  Would there be any market for a box that was very responsive, airtight, etc, lightweight, one voice, no basses.  I was thinking in terms of quality vs cost.

I think you've just described a harmonica......... >:E
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Clive Williams on June 19, 2014, 12:00:38 PM
Bernard Loffet strikes me as a good role model for anyone starting out; to emulate him, build high quality boxes perhaps directly competing with Saltarelle rather than Castagnari or Gaillard - volume of production being an important consideration. Outsource initial construction to Italy, finishing and tuning the instruments yourself, and only once you've got this going well consider building your own boxes from scratch. Finally, pay very close attention to the electronics side of things, such as amplification. Bernard is as much a master of this as he is making melodeons. When he was starting out, he had the choice of building accordions or concentrating on amplification - Bernard chose to do both. Shrewd move, and a very shrewd chap.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Ollie on June 19, 2014, 12:05:42 PM
the concertina. Now there's a market with some significant gaps in it...

Yes, mostly the gap between good enough to play and cheap enough to afford  :(
(it seems even worse than for melodeons)

Indeed, as I am discovering having fallen for the Maccann duet!
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Matt (Kings Norton) on June 19, 2014, 12:30:02 PM
I think you've just described a harmonica......... >:E

Oh yeah... nice instruments, harmonicas... and don't cost a lot...
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 19, 2014, 02:09:57 PM
I think the bulk UK market is in 2 row / 8 bass D/G's the box of choice for most sessions playing English tunes.
No basses would, in my opinion, be like having a bicycles without wheels! Having basses is the whole reason I switched from concertina to melodeon.
There are people with ideas, often some prominent players who having played for a long time realise what their box lacks, and need a bespoke maker to apply their design ideas.
I think a maker trying to appeal to the Home market needs to think how in general terms we play. I.e. Using bass and chords and most players seem to want he Holy Grail of 2 row boxes, something small, light and loud yet with a very good left hand end to enable solid loud accompaniment.
Well, that's my wish!
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: jerfish on June 19, 2014, 04:57:03 PM
The 3D printing idea could be the best I've heard. Cost and reproducibility is there. You can create complex internal designs without carving or opening a thing. How to apply it would be the real innovation. I saw a Kickstarter for 3D printed highland pipes that looked pretty fantastic, and they were able to expand the range of the pipes using the design. But how to expand to a melodeon?  Finger boards and buttons, sure. But where else?  Arched/curved internal walls to change volume?  Hybrid with wood to decrease weight?  A waterproof melodeon for playing in the rain?  If you can find a way to 3-D print the reeds....but thinking "outside of the box" (pun intended) is what's necessary to bring these things up to 21st century standards.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: robotmay on June 19, 2014, 05:02:29 PM
A waterproof melodeon for playing in the rain?

That there be crazy talk; it never rains in the UK ::)

(the ever present question of why an instrument made of cardboard became so popular here)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Anahata on June 19, 2014, 05:32:05 PM
The 3D printing idea could be the best I've heard.

First suggested over here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14590.0/nowap.html). There's nothing new under the sun!

3D printed stuff isn't as strong as it might be, but it might be OK for a melodeon, and it's a very new technology that will become more useful as it gets faster and cheaper and better materials, so yes, at some point...

That thread also introduces the idea of milling a reed block/pallet board combination from solid Al.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 19, 2014, 05:39:30 PM
3D printing - reed blocks?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: 911377brian on June 19, 2014, 05:47:31 PM
Leaping smartly from the 'French' thread, why has new material for bellows not been taken up here? I just don't believe that the design of the melodeon can be improved much, the leap forward has to be in the materials used, and cardboard and tape for bellows really could do with a rethink; I find it hard to believe that there isn't a better material available for the job..
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 19, 2014, 06:11:45 PM
May I suggest that we reopen the "21st Century Box" thread referred to by Anahata. We are now talking in those terms rather than about young British luthiers, per se

 > link to copied over ideas (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7840.msg184350.html#msg184350) <

If you look at earlier posts there, I've cc'd other melnet "good ideas" as they came up :|glug
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 19, 2014, 07:02:23 PM
So - is there a consensus, I wonder. Keep the box pretty much as it is - don't change anything much - just look for newer materials and construction methods?

Will the 2114 Pokerwork or Sandpiper or Castagnari look, sound and feel like the present ones - except that they're made and tuned to individual perfection by robots out of materials we've not yet heard of?

I suppose they might all be electronic. But wouldn't that be sad?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: jerfish on June 19, 2014, 07:42:30 PM
So - is there a consensus, I wonder. Keep the box pretty much as it is - don't change anything much - just look for newer materials and construction methods?



I would have to agree.  Is it really broken and needs fixing beyond modernizing the materials (again, the bellows maybe)?  Ah, but what fun to tinker!

I'm intrigued and hesitant to go the Roland digital route, to be sure.  There's something always to be said for tradition, to an extent.  I wonder what some of the first box makers would say to all of this.  They didn't have a tradition beyond coming from other instruments, so they would make them out of what they had.  We have new materials and methods now - that an original maker would likely have used, given the access.  As long as the sound and playability is there, and durability, it doesn't matter beyond aesthetics and what it looks like/made out of.

Someone mentioned carbon fiber bellows...I'm sure that'd be $$$ however.  I'm sure there are many an answer to this, but what of leather?  I see concertinas have them, or a faux leather, does it not upscale in size well/too stiff?  Forgive my Naivety.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 19, 2014, 10:11:48 PM
I wonder if the question is the wrong way round.

What would a new maker have to offer for the people here to consider purchasing from them?

Steve
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 19, 2014, 10:22:34 PM
Thought that _was_ what I asked?  ???
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: squeezy on June 19, 2014, 10:42:56 PM
I wonder if we're looking also at expanding the number of players - whether a slightly better version of the chanson type kiddies melodeon could be looked at???

I've just spent a week with a bunch of nine year-olds on a project about William Kimber ... and I have 8 cheapo generic chinese kids melodeons and they absolutely loved them.  I got 90% of them to be able to play the Headington version of Old Mother Oxford (A part) within 2 days and they loved them and could do it fine.  I'm fairly convinced it could be as useful as the ukulele as a cheap gateway instrument if only it held enough air.  The kids were getting frustrated with them by day 2!!!!

What would be amazing is some kind of suped up version of it for £30 rather than £15 that held a bit more air and took less air to drive the reeds.

I don't think I've ever been as inspired as seeing their enthusiasm for the instrument ... but also so disappointed that the instrument is failing them almost immediately.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 19, 2014, 10:50:59 PM
Don't start us on Chansons.  :|||: Although i agree.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: squeezy on June 19, 2014, 10:58:25 PM
I know it's dangerous territory!!!

But imagine the person buying the instrument/toy has no knowledge on how to improve the instrument at all ... it's such a small step to something really playable from the place they are at the moment. 

I'm pretty convinced after this week that these things, if only improved a little, could inspire a whole generation of players ... it's a completely affordable and non-tapped in to thing that could get loads of kids playing with the right schemes.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: jerfish on June 20, 2014, 05:48:20 AM
I wonder if the question is the wrong way round.

What would a new maker have to offer for the people here to consider purchasing from them?

Steve

I want something English made akin to a high end Castagnari in quality (not necessarily the bells and whistles and non-functional bits as far as importance) but with the price of a poker work and available now in DG as I want to obtain a DG box to go with my GC  ;D
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 20, 2014, 06:20:30 AM
Thought that _was_ what I asked?  ???

OK, but it seemed to me that most of us have been talking in general terms about pricing, manufacturing etc rather than what it would take for us to buy one.

Steve
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 20, 2014, 07:30:01 AM
Thought that _was_ what I asked?  ???

OK, but it seemed to me that most of us have been talking in general terms about pricing, manufacturing etc rather than what it would take for us to buy one.

Steve
Ah, I see.  Yes. 
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: ladydetemps on June 20, 2014, 08:44:19 AM
Well i'd like more small (ladies size) affordable boxes. A smaller box would be great for children to learn on too and better than the 'toy' one. ;)
I doubt anyone is gonna buy a tommy or lilly streight out.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Theo on June 20, 2014, 08:50:31 AM
Taking the small box idea there is one possible design that I've never seen.  For a high pitch box like DG one could simply loose the top octave leaving 7 and 6 buttons.  Now that would save a lot of size and weight. 
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Helena Handcart on June 20, 2014, 08:55:57 AM
I wonder if we're looking also at expanding the number of players - whether a slightly better version of the chanson type kiddies melodeon could be looked at??? ...
What would be amazing is some kind of suped up version of it for £30 rather than £15 that held a bit more air and took less air to drive the reeds.

I think this is a great idea, having started out with one of these myself and subsequently accumulated a small selection during the heady days of the chanson craze on here I know how much fun these things can be and also how frustrating. 

I've modified a couple of mine and passed them on to friends' young children and they love the boxes and also the speed at which they can start to pick out tunes. Inevitably the boxes then disappoint and there is no better toy or entry level box to move on to.  A cross between the current toys and a sort of latter day Liliput could fill the gap and potentially encourage youngsters and not-so-youngsters to move beyond playing with a toy towards playing an instrument. 

Even as an adult unless you know a box player it can be frustrating to find a box on which to get started. 

Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Anahata on June 20, 2014, 09:00:48 AM
Taking the small box idea there is one possible design that I've never seen.  For a high pitch box like DG one could simply loose the top octave leaving 7 and 6 buttons.  Now that would save a lot of size and weight.

Nice! From low A (missing a B) to high B would fit a *lot* of tunes.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 20, 2014, 09:11:06 AM
Following Theo's comments:
I am recently the happy owner of a Giordy, tuned in the lower octave, courtesy of Mr Wesson of this parish.
It did involve being in debt to a Welshman (again - different Welshman, same reason)  :o but I'm getting over it  :||: Not to mention of the shock to the system when my better half saw me noodling on it and said "Go on, get it."

Anyway, it's a bit sobering, but I can play every Morris tune I know and pretty much all my present repertoire on this little box. It shares the "just pick me up and play" appeal of the concertina, with even more portability.
Ticks most of my personal boxes.

The downsides - the basses take some getting used to - and the Castagnari price tag. And, no matter how you start off, it does NOT do quiet.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Helena Handcart on June 20, 2014, 09:17:59 AM
I thought about the Giordy you bought at Chipp when I read Theo's comments TBH.  As you say the price tag (ouch) would put it out of the reach of many, particular for parents of youngsters who want to give the box a go but I guess it is about the right size and range.

Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Lester on June 20, 2014, 09:31:47 AM
I thought about the Giordy you bought at Chipp when I read Theo's comments TBH.  As you say the price tag (ouch) would put it out of the reach of many, particular for parents of youngsters who want to give the box a go but I guess it is about the right size and range.

I have a Castagnari Mignon (1 row version of the Giordi) which I bought many years ago thinking it would be a great box for my kids to learn on if they wanted. I was wrong, it is a fabulous little box but entirely unforgiving to play. Any button press with even the though of bellows makes an enormous sound, so every time one of the kids tried it all they could hear was their mistakes. They got on better with my Erica before moving on to something/anything cooler  :(
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 20, 2014, 10:09:40 AM
1.3 row, four bass buttons (no thirds).  In G, lose most of the high notes, fourth button start but I want a low E in there.  The 3 buttons to be F, Bb, C#, unisonoric (I know it's wasting buttons but I could handle most session tunes and would allow easier runs using them) and positioned next to the notes they'd be replacing.

Steve
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Lester on June 20, 2014, 10:16:18 AM
1.3 row, four bass buttons (no thirds).  In G, lose most of the high notes, fourth button start but I want a low E in there.  The 3 buttons to be F, Bb, C#, unisonoric (I know it's wasting buttons but I could handle most session tunes and would allow easier runs using them) and positioned next to the notes they'd be replacing.

Steve

My Mignon  (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2XfXA1bzM8)is laid out thusly:


D/F#

G/A
             D/E
B/c
            d/c#
d/e

g/f#

b/a

Only two basses.


Used it as sole musician on a number of Morris tours  (:)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 20, 2014, 10:54:10 AM
I know it's dangerous territory!!!

But imagine the person buying the instrument/toy has no knowledge on how to improve the instrument at all ... it's such a small step to something really playable from the place they are at the moment. 

I'm pretty convinced after this week that these things, if only improved a little, could inspire a whole generation of players ... it's a completely affordable and non-tapped in to thing that could get loads of kids playing with the right schemes.

I am convinced that this would be an excellent thing, but there is a reason why these are so cheap and the good small boxes mentioned are so expensive... Good reeds cost, bellows cost, material costs. Using old hohner reeds would cut down the price considerably, having limited layouts (1.5 row) would reduce the price, making out of laser ply and hacking it all together would reduce the price, making your own bellows would reduce the price. But the cost isn't just materials, it is also labour. It would take a great deal of effort to make a tiny box that worked and you'd end up charging a fair bit for it sadly. My first box, a Delicia Popular, I got for £180. It lasted me for a year or two before I got sick of it (and it took another four years after that to get a better one), but I shouldn't think that a small box would be able to compete unless it was factory built.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Theo on June 20, 2014, 11:13:24 AM
I know it's dangerous territory!!!

But imagine the person buying the instrument/toy has no knowledge on how to improve the instrument at all ... it's such a small step to something really playable from the place they are at the moment. 

I'm pretty convinced after this week that these things, if only improved a little, could inspire a whole generation of players ... it's a completely affordable and non-tapped in to thing that could get loads of kids playing with the right schemes.

I am convinced that this would be an excellent thing, but there is a reason why these are so cheap and the good small boxes mentioned are so expensive... Good reeds cost, bellows cost, material costs.

Yes I agree with that.  Materials costs do scale down with size, and number of reeds can be minimised by having fewer buttons but for some components the cost is nearly all labour - bellows for example.  The cost of buying a traditionally built bellows for a 120 bass PA is almost the same as it would be for  a Chanson sized bellows. And the labour cost of building a small box will not be less than for a larger one, and it could even be greater.

What this means in practice is that the only way to get a Chanson sized box with better playing qualities but still at a relatively cheap price is to persuade a volume manufacturer to produce a superior version.  Quite a lot of design and development work would be required, and you probably have to place an initial order for many 100s or even 1000s of items to make it worthwhile for the factory to set up for your design.  So it is difficult, but not impossible.  It is more or less what Wim Wakker has done in producing the Rochelle (http://www.concertinaconnection.com/rochelle%20anglo.htm) and Jackie (http://www.concertinaconnection.com/jackie-jack.htm) starter concertinas.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: jerfish on June 20, 2014, 08:25:06 PM
If I may drift really quickly here, I was interested in picking up a concertina to mess around with.  I had heard the Anglo style is more akin to a diatonic 2-row accordion.  Is this true?  And, for those with first-hand experience, would that Rochelle be a good starting point for me?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 20, 2014, 08:33:59 PM
In simple terms, yes and yes. Join concertina.net. Second hand Rochelles are sometimes available, especially if you ask. 
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 20, 2014, 08:57:55 PM
Yes an Anglo is like a melodeon in action, but I'm amazed at how many on Melnet are or have been English concertina players!
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: rees on June 21, 2014, 01:24:30 AM
I am a bespoke maker. In labour and materials each instrument costs £3500. I sell them for £1850.
............. and you wonder why Oakwood stopped making them???
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 21, 2014, 08:48:43 AM
A sobering comment from Rees, telling it as it is.

Rees - if you could click your fingers and instantly, magically, suddenly scale up from a 1 row to making a whole range of boxes  would the factors of scale reduce costs?
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Anahata on June 21, 2014, 10:08:37 AM
if you could click your fingers and instantly, magically, suddenly scale up from a 1 row to making a whole range of boxes  would the factors of scale reduce costs?

From what I've read around here (and which makes sense to me) I think the only way to reduce costs would be confidence in a huge market for exactly one type of box, then the production could be automated and the labour costs thus reduced.

A whole range of boxes implies a whole range of different components (apart from very basic bits like buttons), hence less economy of scale.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: rees on June 21, 2014, 01:48:57 PM
A sobering comment from Rees, telling it as it is.

Rees - if you could click your fingers and instantly, magically, suddenly scale up from a 1 row to making a whole range of boxes  would the factors of scale reduce costs?
Q

Quite possibly, but I have no interest in pursuing that line of work.
I really enjoy what I do on the scale that I do it. Anything more would be like having a proper job.  ;)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Theo on June 21, 2014, 01:56:43 PM
And their are financial advantages to being small - principally the VAT threshold.  One of the more intelligent tax breaks in the UK which means a small business with annual turnover under the threshold (currently £81,000) is not compelled to register for VAT.  This is very valuable where the main input is labour.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 21, 2014, 03:59:11 PM
Anahata - yes, I can see more models would increase parts variation and you'd be back to square one.

Fair enough Rees, and Theo has another advantage of being 'small but beautiful'!
It justs feels like being small and compact is mutually exclusive to larger where the economies of scale kick in.
It's difficult innit?
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 21, 2014, 04:10:18 PM
... and Theo has another advantage of being 'small but beautiful'!


Take your word. Only seen photos...  :o

No reason why small can't give you economies of scale, that's just down to quantities, but the labour cost doesn't scale like the materials cost. Possibly the opposite.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 21, 2014, 04:21:16 PM
We'll let Theo sort that last comment out  ;D

I suppose labour is a constant, as you say, but if cost of production = labour + materials, then the saving  would be on material if scales allow?
It just starts looking like, as Rees says previously, it costs more to produce a box than is realistic to sell.
It feels like labour intensive things, as often shown up in craft industries, where if you added in the true cost of labour the product would be outrageously expensive and no one would buy it.
We might be finding out why we have only a couple of indiginous makers, and why, as IanD says, people like Oakwood shut up shop.

Perhaps if labour is the problem, more people might go down the Pariselle route as there your labour is at your own cost.
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Theo on June 21, 2014, 04:34:15 PM

We might be finding out why we have only a couple of indiginous makers, and why, as IanD says, people like Oakwood shut up shop.

With Oakwood I think the problem was that making boxes was not their core activity.  I am quite sure that it would be possible for a one person UK based melodeon builder to make a decent living making boxes.  You would probably do repairs too, and I strongly believe that doing repairs and tuning is the way in.  It allows you to build skills and a reputation, and both are essential.  Nobody will pay a realistic price for a box off someone unknown.  Colin and Rosalie Dipper have done it with concertinas and that is a much harder road than making melodeons.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 21, 2014, 04:40:43 PM
Carrying out tuning and repairs will increase your skill level and knowledge, that makes perfect sense.
I would think it also allows you to get a good look around other maker's boxes and see if a particular type of construction has advantages or inherant weakeness and faults.

Oakwood - as yousay, why choose a hard route if you've alreay an easier path to tread with more profit on the end.
Shame though.....
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: melodeon on June 22, 2014, 12:54:40 AM
Observation:


A 2 row box, slightly larger than a Lilly...
however two reed.. with button spacing for an adult.
Not as "precious" as a Tommy, flat keyboard, thumb groove.

As to bellows.
Ridiculously complex with archaic construction technique and materials.
Going back 20 plus years.. the RIP owner of ABC Music in So Calif and I.. completely redesigned bellows to used modern materials and construction techniques.. we were about to go ahead when he decided to have a terminal heart attack.  Still could be done.

There other advancements to be made in the "action" ( really nothing new if you present the current technology to an engineer, or free thinking tinkerer, inventor) with respect to buttons, levers, pallets etc.

Think outside the box.  ( pun intended.)

What is the word for "box" in Welsh ?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Lyra on June 22, 2014, 03:55:41 AM
what is this? (http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Yamaha-Chromatic-Accordion-No-40-in-Case-Made-in-Japan-/121367710686?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item1c42144bde)
I only ask because it ticks some of the boxes (sorry) on the want list (although clearly not others as far as I can tell from the somewhat contradictory description) but seems to have sunk without trace. I just wonder if they were ever any good.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: michik on June 22, 2014, 08:42:31 AM
It would be nice to have a box with easily exchangable reed blocks. The read blocks are enclosed in their own housing and can be exchanged quickly, for example to
switching from D/G to Eb/Bb. Maybe the reed block's housing could be designd is like drawer of a cupboard.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 22, 2014, 10:03:31 AM
melodeon, what were your ideas with regards bellows? I can easily imagine ways of building a better mechanism (I'll give it a go once this one is finished) but bellows I think are more tricky.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: rees on June 22, 2014, 10:25:52 AM


What is the word for "box" in Welsh ?

"Bocs" pronounced box
"Scwisbocs" pronounced squeezebox  (:)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: IanD on June 22, 2014, 11:09:31 AM

We might be finding out why we have only a couple of indiginous makers, and why, as IanD says, people like Oakwood shut up shop.

With Oakwood I think the problem was that making boxes was not their core activity.  I am quite sure that it would be possible for a one person UK based melodeon builder to make a decent living making boxes.  You would probably do repairs too, and I strongly believe that doing repairs and tuning is the way in.  It allows you to build skills and a reputation, and both are essential.  Nobody will pay a realistic price for a box off someone unknown.  Colin and Rosalie Dipper have done it with concertinas and that is a much harder road than making melodeons.
When he was building Hilda's 38 key baritone G/D concertina, Neville Crabb told me that the only thing that kept them solvent was repairs and rebuilds. He said that when he added up the time needed to make a concertina it would have to sell for roughly double what the market would stand to make a viable business, and I doubt that this has changed in the last thirty years.

The position isn't as bad with melodeons because you can buy in many of the bits (reeds, action, bellows) which are made economically in larger volumes by firms whose sole business that is and who supply many box builders -- though I doubt that many of them become rich as a result. But it's easy to spend a vast amount of time making the wooden bits -- internal and external -- and then realising that when you divide the number of hours by the profit you're getting a pretty lousy wage for a skilled artisan...
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: 911377brian on June 22, 2014, 11:18:00 AM
I clearly remember when working in the North Sea seeing bits of equipment in meter lengths of very flexible plastic on a wire frame that looked and handled just like squeezebox bellows . They sat under my desk for weeks until the Production team collected them. Never thought to ask what their use was...... ???
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: melodeon on June 22, 2014, 02:32:34 PM
The bellows we designed were one piece and to be  "molded"  but did have a look like traditional bellows.

The pallet opening mechanism was originated in combustion engines.. a long , long time ago.

Additionally the pallets were reconfigured for better sealing.

Also think BOSE.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Sebastian on June 22, 2014, 02:56:59 PM
It would be nice to have a box with easily exchangable reed blocks. The read blocks are enclosed in their own housing and can be exchanged quickly, for example to
switching from D/G to Eb/Bb. Maybe the reed block's housing could be designd is like drawer of a cupboard.
(http://www.wuerziworld.de/Smilies/lol/lol20.gif)

The bellows we designed were one piece and to be  "molded"  but did have a look like traditional bellows.
Interesting. Did you produce prototypes? How durable where they?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Theo on June 22, 2014, 03:16:42 PM
A moulded bellows would free up the design of the whole box.  With folded card you are in practice limited to rectangular boxes, well ok straight sided boxes with a small number if sides.  Moulded bellows could have curves!
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: ladydetemps on June 22, 2014, 03:36:02 PM
What about 3d printing? Would that make elements easier to manufacture?
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Matt (Kings Norton) on June 22, 2014, 06:12:52 PM
It would be nice to have a box with easily exchangable reed blocks.

Cooperativa do this on their (high quality) compact piano accordions and CBAs.  I forget the details but there's a kind of casing where the reed block sits that seems to rule out problems with airtightness.  You couldnt swap it out between tunes in a session though, it's quick and easy but not that quick.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 23, 2014, 01:40:10 PM
from LdT: ' what about 3D printing....'
Dunno I can't print  ;D
( apologies, couldn't resist!)
Q ( 3d! )
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Lester on June 23, 2014, 02:47:32 PM
from LdT: ' what about 3D printing....'
Dunno I can't print  ;D
( apologies, couldn't resist!)
Q ( 3d! )

She's far too young to understand your half a tanner joke  ;)
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 23, 2014, 02:57:03 PM
I suspect Mr Ellis (of this parish and Wensleydale) would offer no quarter in this respect either?  >:E
{my 3Dth worth} ;) C
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 23, 2014, 04:48:56 PM
Good point.   :-\
Oh well, you can but try.............
Q
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 23, 2014, 06:05:36 PM
what is this? (http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Yamaha-Chromatic-Accordion-No-40-in-Case-Made-in-Japan-/121367710686?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item1c42144bde)
I only ask because it ticks some of the boxes (sorry) on the want list (although clearly not others as far as I can tell from the somewhat contradictory description) but seems to have sunk without trace. I just wonder if they were ever any good.
Yamaha accordion - never heard of them. Wonder if they made them or badged them.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 23, 2014, 06:15:24 PM
The Yamaha badge on motorbikes are 3 tuning forks crossed, and I think they originally made their name making organs and musical instruments. My daughter's flute is a Yamaha.
I'd have thought it likely they made it.....
Q guessing
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 23, 2014, 07:14:53 PM
The Yamaha badge on motorbikes are 3 tuning forks crossed, and I think they originally made their name making organs and musical instruments. My daughter's flute is a Yamaha.
I'd have thought it likely they made it.....
Q guessing

See para 4 http://www.accordions.com/index/his/his_jp.shtml (http://www.accordions.com/index/his/his_jp.shtml).  Yamaha are still one of the biggest musical instrument makers in the world.

Steve
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 23, 2014, 09:35:49 PM
Implying that, if it has a Yamaha label on it, it is probably well made.

I think the ad says chromatic, but the article suggests diatonic.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: Lyra on June 23, 2014, 10:50:52 PM
yes, the label also says chromatic but its looks (and the article wot I also read) suggest otherwise. But then the description is quite odd (nothing loose/reeds rattling about)...
Yamaha are big makers of band instruments - my flutes are Yamaha and, while not of the class of the (insert Japanese version of costalotti) makers like Miyazawa, Muramatsu or even Sankyo, have been known as quality built. Until they moved production to Indonesia. So I'd expect it to have originally been quite a decent thing, whatever it was. Sadly not any more.
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 27, 2014, 10:45:20 PM
Returning to topic  (:)  I honestly think my advice would be "Don't bother".  Certainly not as a way to make a living in the near future.

I note that Theo has had a couple of Pariselle boxes for sale for a while now, why no takers?  The Albrecht boxes started out really competitively priced and even now I'm not sure how much he's actually making.  Rees reckons he sells his boxes at half price.  Is there really a living in it?

Now given a large enough starting investment (I'm talking at least £50k probably nearer £250k) then it might be possible to upgrade the toy melodeon or design/make a cheaper/better Sandpiper but I'm not sure I see a gap in the market that enough people will pay good money for to make it viable.

Steve
Title: Re: Ideas for a new English (or Welsh) melodeon maker?
Post by: rees on June 27, 2014, 10:51:53 PM
Returning to topic  (:)  I honestly think my advice would be "Don't bother".  Certainly not as a way to make a living in the near future.

I note that Theo has had a couple of Pariselle boxes for sale for a while now, why no takers?  The Albrecht boxes started out really competitively priced and even now I'm not sure how much he's actually making.  Rees reckons he sells his boxes at half price.  Is there really a living in it?

Now given a large enough starting investment (I'm talking at least £50k probably nearer £250k) then it might be possible to upgrade the toy melodeon or design/make a cheaper/better Sandpiper but I'm not sure I see a gap in the market that enough people will pay good money for to make it viable.

Steve

In a nutshell, Steve.

Look, if you enjoy making melodeons and hearing other people playing them, then make melodeons. There is no other reason to do it (unless you want to own a big factory and pay minimum wage).
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal