-
Now this cutie is the further development of the Tulskaya garmoshka. It is named (Череповка) after the city Cherepovtsy where artisans started making them in around 1860 - 1870. They went out of popularity around 1920, and one seldom sees one. I am therefore not able to add any clips to the post.
Usually they have seven keys (in the beginning only 5). They have russian tuning (that is, inverted compared to the german one row). I do not know on which button the scale starts, but probably the second. They have only two bass buttons (tonic and dominant).
They were fitted with three to four choruses and the height of the instrument is around 30 centimeters.
-
Interesting. Is there any video, with this model really playing, sounding? (:)
-
I would also bee very keen to hear one playing, but it seems very difficult to find. I have been trying to find something on the 78:s. But they are usually just marked "garmon" or "garmoni" if there is several playing. But do not despair, there is going to bee very sonore illustrations to some of the garmoshkas to come.
If I were to guess it would have had a kind of sharp voice with much timbre (but not as much timbre as an saratovka). The music played would have been rhythmic, a bit repetitive and very fast for dancing and singing typical Russian rhyming-games called chastushki. This is just my personal romantic idea of the use of the instrument. Russian musical traditions tend to vary quite a lot from place to place.
-
I do enjoy this series of threads. Stupid question: Is the left hand also inverted compared to the one row 2 basses that I know?
-
I do enjoy this series of threads. Stupid question: Is the left hand also inverted compared to the one row 2 basses that I know?
If my Saratov box is anything to go by, yes.
It wouln't work very well otherwise.
-
Well that's what I was thinking, just checking. I was trying to think through what it would mean for how you played one.
-
We should talk more here about the Russian boxes, and about their style playing it also. I like a looot the way they play. And have been searching for many another aspects of Russian culture, music, traditions and including the simply AMAZING Russian Literature. (:)
-
Then it might interest you to know that Sergey Yesenin played a one row melodeon. I do not know which particular type. But many of them have the same layout. I will try to check that later. I do remeber someone telling me about his wiew of the music. It was something about these tunes in major sometimes being in very sad spirit. As if the major harmonics added to melancholy. I guess it is something in the style of the feeling you get when you are sad a sunny day. I sometimes play a song called Na Pankraci, and it has a very sad feeling to it. Let us remember that the idea of one tonality being happy, sad, weird or whatever is a type of cultural social construction. Sorry for drifting. It is just such a day.
-
Now this cutie is the further development of the Tulskaya garmoshka. It is named (Череповка) after the city Cherepovtsy where artisans started making them in around 1860 - 1870. They went out of popularity around 1920, and one seldom sees one. I am therefore not able to add any clips to the post.
Usually they have seven keys (in the beginning only 5). They have russian tuning (that is, inverted compared to the german one row). I do not know on which button the scale starts, but probably the second. They have only two bass buttons (tonic and dominant).
They were fitted with three to four choruses and the height of the instrument is around 30 centimeters.
Alfred Mirek says of these that they "were manufactured with the double row of the reeds, tuned in unison" seeming to suggest that they were double-reeded, with no tremolo...
-
Alfred Mirek says of these that they "were manufactured with the double row of the reeds, tuned in unison" seeming to suggest that they were double-reeded, with no tremolo...
From that passage I wouldn't infer, that there was no tremolo.
-
That Garmoshka looks an awful lot like a one row, with square piano like keys. I wonder why they put the square edged keys on, rather than buttons?
-
Two reeds tuned in unison is dry tuning, i.e. no tremolo.
Are you saying otherwise?
Yes.
-
Two reeds tuned in unison is dry tuning, i.e. no tremolo.
Are you saying otherwise?
Yes.
Unison is defined as "identity in musical pitch" - tremolo therefore cannot be unison because it relies on the pitches being close but not identical.
-
That Garmoshka looks an awful lot like a one row, with square piano like keys. I wonder why they put the square edged keys on, rather than buttons?
You're right to point out the similarity with German accordions, it seems to be very much modelled on one, right down to the soundbox covering the treble pallets like you'd see on many earlier examples of them. But the rectangular, or bar-shaped, keys are actually the older style, going right back to the original accordions by Cyrill Demian of Vienna (the inventor of the instrument), like this one that I own:
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Demian1829.jpg)
I also have early French accordions ("flutinas"), and German accordions (melodeons), with those keys.
-
Two reeds tuned in unison is dry tuning, i.e. no tremolo.
Are you saying otherwise?
Yes.
Unison is defined as "identity in musical pitch" - tremolo therefore cannot be unison because it relies on the pitches being close but not identical.
No.
-
That Garmoshka looks an awful lot like a one row, with square piano like keys. I wonder why they put the square edged keys on, rather than buttons?
You're right to point out the similarity with German accordions, it seems to be very much modelled on one, right down to the soundbox covering the treble pallets like you'd see on many earlier examples of them. But the rectangular, or bar-shaped, keys are actually the older style, going right back to the original accordions by Cyrill Demian of Vienna (the inventor of the instrument), like this one that I own:
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Demian1829.jpg)
I also have early French accordions ("flutinas"), and German accordions (melodeons), with those keys.
Now that I look at it, it looks like it is a flutina with a bass side.
-
That Garmoshka looks an awful lot like a one row, with square piano like keys. I wonder why they put the square edged keys on, rather than buttons?
You're right to point out the similarity with German accordions, it seems to be very much modelled on one, right down to the soundbox covering the treble pallets like you'd see on many earlier examples of them. But the rectangular, or bar-shaped, keys are actually the older style, going right back to the original accordions by Cyrill Demian of Vienna (the inventor of the instrument), like this one that I own:
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Demian1829.jpg)
I also have early French accordions ("flutinas"), and German accordions (melodeons), with those keys.
Now that I look at it, it looks like it is a flutina with a bass side.
All accordions ultimately evolved out of the Demian model in my photo.
-
Two reeds tuned in unison is dry tuning, i.e. no tremolo.
Are you saying otherwise?
Yes.
You'd find yourself at odds with the likes of the Piano Technicians Guild then, an association of piano technicians who have exams to qualify technicians.
The tuning exam has many parts, including a unison part.
In this part, the examinee will tune 24 unisons from C3 to B4.
The examiners measure the difference between all three strings of each unison. If they are out by more than 0.9 cents, (100 cents = a semitone) then the examinee will lose 2 percent off their marks. The unison is measured for left to centre, right to centre, and left to right, meaning that an examinee can lose 6% on one note. 80% is a pass, meaning an examinee can not have more than 10 unison pairs greater than 0.9 cents off.
-
I believe that most russian single row boxes with only two choruses would be tuned one octave apart. Something in the style of a bandoneon. Wet tuning with heavy tremolo is not that common in Russia.
The design is indeed very close to the german one row, but as this one is the development of the Tulskaya, which was the first russian offspring of the german one-row, there is important differences. First of all the layout and the number off keys. Furthermore, the Cherepovki were built by hand by artisans (which might explain variation in tuning, design and number of choruses), and not as in Germany by big factories.
The most used one-row box used in Russia today has round buttons, but some models still being made have the square type. In russian terminology difference is also implied. The round ones are called 'knopki' (buttons) and the square ones 'klavishi' (keys).
I remember hearing something about Mirek pointing out, that the accordion first appeared in Germany because of the numbers of masters, but in Russia there appeared masters where there appeared accordions.
-
I would also like to remind, that the Cherepovka is not to be confused with the Tulskaya, particularly considering to the difference in number of choruses.
-
I belive that the 3:d garmon being shown in this clip is a Cherepovka.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zado1hHzI0A
-
I belive that the 3:d garmon being shown in this clip is a Cherepovka.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zado1hHzI0A
Though that one has 10 treble keys, not the 7 (or earlier 5) that you mentioned initially, and Mirek describes it as having.
However, practical experience (and a large collection of antique accordions and concertinas) has taught me that numbers of buttons have never been as standardised as some writers would have us believe, so that though Demian's Patent is illustrated with an instrument that has only 5 keys, and everyone therefore assumes that that is the number that his ALL had, that was only the most rudimentary version and both the text of the Patent and his contemporary advertisements show that he was selling them with 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 or 10 keys (and the one I have is the 8-keyed version).
In the 19th century German accordions were regularly made with 6, 8, 10 or 12 keys (before 10 became the norm), and toy models could have as few as 4 keys.
-
That Garmoshka looks an awful lot like a one row, with square piano like keys. I wonder why they put the square edged keys on, rather than buttons?
You're right to point out the similarity with German accordions, it seems to be very much modelled on one, right down to the soundbox covering the treble pallets like you'd see on many earlier examples of them.
And the one in the YouTube clip looks very, very German in style - so much so that I'd reckon it was either made in Germany for the Russian market, or very closely copied from a German original.
-
Oy, I am sorry, you are indeed right about the numbers of keys. I should have counted them and I did got exited and jumped the conclusions. But there is something about the finger-board, that I find "exotic". I have had the chance to look at the early Gessner-boxes, which were once very common in Sweden and therefor I tend to look as them as "standard" german style. I also find it strange that it does not have the stops.
I also know that there where export of german one row boxes to russia. They were usually called "odnoryadki" or "nemki". It is a fact that most early russian boxes were copies of german ones, but the only types still in widespread use is the saratovka and the vyatka, both of them quite diffrent from the german boxes. This is the reason why it is so difficult to find them.
I would love to see the Demian´s patent description. He is one of my heroes. Is it possible to find on the internet?
it is also interesting with the number of keys. I still find it strange when looking at a box with more or less keys than 10. The saratov type where also being made with twelve keys and cassoto, and were called "konsertnye".
-
You'd find yourself at odds with the likes of the Piano Technicians Guild then
I don't think so. Please consider context.
-
I would love to see the Demian´s patent description. He is one of my heroes. Is it possible to find on the internet?
Here are the drawings, which are all that most people have seen of the Patent:
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/demian4.jpg)
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/demian5.jpg)
The text is in archaic German and it was to be seen in full, with a translation, on the website of The Classical Free-Reed, Inc., as Demian's Accordion Patent (http://www.ksanti.net/free-reed/history/demian.html), but that link seems not to be working now and I can only find the full translation here; http://www.scribd.com/doc/250577016/Demian-s-Accordion-Patent-pdf#scribd (http://www.scribd.com/doc/250577016/Demian-s-Accordion-Patent-pdf#scribd)
But anyway, a lot of the text is summarised in the Wikipedia article on Cyrill Demian (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian)
-
You'd find yourself at odds with the likes of the Piano Technicians Guild then
I don't think so. Please consider context.
You may not think so, but you would be.
From a tuner's perspective "unison" and "tremolo" are mutually exclusive terms.
-
Here are the drawings, which are all that most people have seen of the Patent:
Thank you very much for the drawings, I have never seen them before. I am very happy about the translation as well, this is going to be my bedtime-read tonight.
-
Thank you very much for the drawings, I have never seen them before. I am very happy about the translation as well, this is going to be my bedtime-read tonight.
The only image that most people have seen of a Demian accordion is this one;
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/demianps.jpg)
but that's not an original example - it's a replica that I understand was made in more recent times by Paolo Soprani apprentices and based on the drawings in Demian's Patent. Apart from being made of the wrong materials (as evidenced by surviving examples), they were evidently unaware that the originals were made with pallet boards that slid off, like the lid of an old-fashioned pencil box or suchlike, not screwed together like a German melodeon.
And I don't suppose the replica looks anything like this on the inside either;
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Demianreedpan.jpg)
-
Now, this is just amazing! The "compartments" makes me think of a concertina. It surprises me that so little attention has been given the interiors of the early types.
-
Now, this is just amazing! The "compartments" makes me think of a concertina. It surprises me that so little attention has been given the interiors of the early types.
Not many people have access to, or have taken the trouble to examine, the innards of the earliest examples of these instruments and compared them. I've gone out of my way (and to not inconsiderable expense) to search out the oldest examples I could find - so that I now possess four Demian accordions and what I believe are the three earliest concertinas in existence.
You should take a look at my 1999 Michaelstein Symposium Paper; An Annotated Catalogue of Historic European Free-Reed lnstruments from my Private Collection (http://www.concertina.com/chambers/michaelstein/) and please ignore the word "Private" in the title, which was added, against my wishes, by the German editor (I guess it's the German concept of a Privatsammlung) - my collection is open to anyone with a genuine interest in these things.
-
You may not think so, but you would be.
I am in fact pretty much amazed, nearly bewildered that you don't understand the problem. "Unison" has a broad variety of possible meanings. It would be important to determine the antonym, even if it is not made explicit, the author thought of. I wouldn't consider it as absurd to suppose that "unison" is used in contrast to "tuned an octave apart".
The term "unison" in fact is used with different meanings according to different contextes. Often it means that two voices sing simultaneously not in an intervall of a fifth or a third or a second, but in the intervall of a prime (or even of an octave, or two octaves, or three ...). In this context it contains no - I repeat: no - information about the purity of the intervall.
From the passage you quoted - "were manufactured with the double row of the reeds, tuned in unison" - it cannot be inferred whether they were tuned with tremolo or without. From the passage itself it wouldn't even possible to exclude octave tuning with certainty.
-
I am in fact pretty much amazed, nearly bewildered that you don't understand the problem. "Unison" has a broad variety of possible meanings. It would be important to determine the antonym, even if it is not made explicit, the author thought of. I wouldn't consider it as absurd to suppose that "unison" is used in contrast to "tuned an octave apart".
The term "unison" in fact is used with different meanings according to different contextes. Often it means that two voices sing simultaneously not in an intervall of a fifth or a third or a second, but in the intervall of a prime (or even of an octave, or two octaves, or three ...). In this context it contains no - I repeat: no - information about the purity of the intervall.
From the passage you quoted - "were manufactured with the double row of the reeds, tuned in unison" - it cannot be inferred whether they were tuned with tremolo or without. From the passage itself it wouldn't even possible to exclude octave tuning with certainty.
I'm sorry but I'm pretty much amazed and bewildered that you perceive there to be a problem at all.
Since Mirek is evidently writing in the context of how the instruments in his bilingual book ("Справочник к cxeмe гармоник" / "Reference Book on Harmonicas' diagram") are tuned, we can rule out other meanings of unison than that of two or more instances of a given note sounding together WITHOUT a discernible beat. The octave of each of them is technically immaterial - though it is usually the same one.
But tremolo is composed by definition of two or more instances of a given note sounding together WITH a discernible and deliberate beat tuned between them.
Elsewhere in the book Mirek contrasts (for example) how examples of the same "two part sound" Moscow Bayan accordion were tuned "in unison" from the Moscow, Leningrad, Rostov, Kirov etc. factories, but "at the Rostov-on-Don factory the tuning was with musette" - whilst with some other models he mentions octave tunings and quint ones.
-
Elsewhere in the book Mirek contrasts (for example) how examples of the same "two part sound" Moscow Bayan accordion were tuned "in unison" from the Moscow, Leningrad, Rostov, Kirov etc. factories, but "at the Rostov-on-Don factory the tuning was with musette"
Thank you. You corroborate my reasoning: It would be important to determine the antonym, even if it is not made explicit, the author thought of. Otherwise it simply is not possible to see which of the possible meanings of the term "unison" is itended by the author.
- whilst with some other models he mentions octave tunings and quint ones.
This further corroborates that "unison" might have been a term to describe tunings in the intervall of a prime (in contrast to tuning in the intervall of an octave or a quint). Tremolo is only possible, if two reeds are tuned in the intervall of a prime.
Therefore from the quoted passage itself -- "were manufactured with the double row of the reeds, tuned in unison" -- I would not infer, that there was no tremolo. Without further context this passage contains no information whether the reeds were tuned with or without tremolo.
-
Since Mirek is evidently writing in the context of how the instruments in his bilingual book ("Справочник к cxeмe гармоник" / "Reference Book on Harmonicas' diagram") are tuned, we can rule out other meanings of unison than that of two or more instances of a given note sounding together WITHOUT a discernible beat.
I don't have the bilingual edition. In his Spravochnik (1968) he wrote about the Cherepovka, p. 43:
Ðти гармоники имели вначале пÑть клавиш, а затем, как правило, Ñемь, изготовлÑлиÑÑŒ двухголоÑными и по Ñтрою и раÑположению звуков напоминали руÑÑкую Ñемиклавишную гармонику, но в более громоздком корпуÑе (около 30 Ñм выÑотой). Ð’ начале нашего века череповки Ñтали делатьÑÑ Ñ‚Ñ€ÐµÑ…- и четырехголоÑными (то еÑть Ñ Ð¾Ð´Ð½Ð¾Ð²Ñ€ÐµÐ¼ÐµÐ½Ð½Ñ‹Ð¼ звучанием трех или четырех голоÑовых Ñзыков), но форма корпуÑа оÑталаÑÑŒ прежней.
(My translation:)
These accordions/melodeons/harmonicas had in the beginning five keys, and later, as a rule, seven. They were made two-voiced and according to order and arrangement of the notes reminded of the russian sevenkey-accordions/melodeons/harmonicas, but in a more broad corpus (ca. 30 cm high). In the beginning of our century [i. e. the 20st c.] the Cherepovkas were made three- and four-voiced (i. e. with the simultaneous sounding of three or four reeds), but the form of the corpus remained the former one.
I don't find a note on unison there. :(