Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Howard Jones on August 22, 2009, 09:27:40 AM

Title: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 22, 2009, 09:27:40 AM
OK, I'm going to take the bait...

In the "What do you wish you knew" thread Rees suggested "Use 3 not 4 fingers on the right hand".  Now Rees knows his stuff and I take what he says seriously, but I'm puzzled by this.  I was watching my playing last night and I use the little finger all the time.  It seems natural for playing octaves or arpeggios - since the scale fits neatly under 4 buttons it seems obvious to use 4 fingers.  It's natural when playing right-hand chords, or when holding down a low note with the index finger while the others play a phrase of the tune.  It's natural for big jumps up and down the keyboard.  It's useful when cross-rowing eg to get the pull G on the D row without moving your other fingers out of position on the G row.

Why wouldn't you want to use all four fingers?  What are the advantages in restricting yourself to just three?

NB I'm talking about the right hand.  I'm a three-finger man on the basses - a (possibly) bad habit I developed too long ago to change, but I don't find it limits my playing at all.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: risto on August 22, 2009, 11:17:58 AM
Quote
3 fingers or 4?

No. It's 5 fingers (cba)  :D
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Lester on August 22, 2009, 11:41:04 AM
Quote
3 fingers or 4?

No. It's 5 fingers (cba)  :D

Think you will find one is a thumb so still 4 fingers    :P
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: risto on August 22, 2009, 03:22:13 PM
Quote
3 fingers or 4?

No. It's 5 fingers (cba)  :D

Think you will find one is a thumb so still 4 fingers    :P

Lester, are you from The Mountains? In these parts we have 10 fingers instead of 8 fingers and 2 thumbs   :D
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 22, 2009, 03:26:25 PM
In the "What do you wish you knew" thread Rees suggested "Use 3 not 4 fingers on the right hand".  Now Rees knows his stuff and I take what he says seriously, but I'm puzzled by this.....
I'm exactly of the same feeling as you, Howard.
I've also been analysing my playing and I find that I use the little finger a lot for octaves, just as you say. But the bulk of my RH finger work is done by the first 3 fingers.

I think some of the rationale behind the '3-finger' philosophy is that the little finger is the weakest of the four and so may not have the dexterity achievable with the first three. I can see the argument for this, but I think a lot of it also depends (a) on the individual and (b) on the style of music being played.

Playing with only 3 fingers instead of 4 may mean that you have to shift your hand up and down the keyboard more. At first sight this could be thought of as a disadvantage, but perversely, it might not be so and could in fact lead you to become more skilled and confident in moving around the keyboard.

Very interesting....
Going to go and play more tunes now and think about this some more.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Andrel on August 22, 2009, 04:13:36 PM


Playing with only 3 fingers instead of 4 may mean that you have to shift your hand up and down the keyboard more. At first sight this could be thought of as a disadvantage, but perversely, it might not be so and could in fact lead you to become more skilled and confident in moving around the keyboard.

Exactly, Steve. It's a question of confidence, and better intimacy with the keyboard, I feel. And I do use my little finger all the time on my one-row when I play Cajun (the octave system), but when playing fast-paced Irish or Cape Breton or Quebecois, it's the three-finger rule that applies for me, bearing in mind there are times when you do need to use the pinky. There's no going back ! And by the way, a couple of hours trying the 3-finger way of playing won't get you anywhere. It's like trying to learn a language in a week! It took me a few weeks to get used to it, and I wish I had done it from the start.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 22, 2009, 05:47:51 PM
Quote
Lester, are you from The Mountains? In these parts we have 10 fingers instead of 8 fingers and 2 thumbs
LOL!!! No mountains in Lester's part of the world ;D
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 22, 2009, 06:32:41 PM
I think some of the rationale behind the '3-finger' philosophy is that the little finger is the weakest of the four and so may not have the dexterity achievable with the first three.
That comes with practice.  I was an Anglo concertinist before I was a melodeonist and on Anglo it's definitely an advantage to used the little fingers on both hands. I used to be able to touch-type using all the fingers, although it's a skill which seems to be deserting me!

I can understand people who don't have that dexterity getting by with 3 fingers and not finding it a limitation, but Rees was talking about unlearning a 4-finger style.

The style of music you play is of course a consideration.

Quote
Playing with only 3 fingers instead of 4 may mean that you have to shift your hand up and down the keyboard more. At first sight this could be thought of as a disadvantage, but perversely, it might not be so and could in fact lead you to become more skilled and confident in moving around the keyboard.

I don't get this.  I don't see a benefit in moving your fingers from where they need to be when you could just reach out with another finger.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Simon on August 22, 2009, 07:58:26 PM
I think some of the rationale behind the '3-finger' philosophy is that the little finger is the weakest of the four and so may not have the dexterity achievable with the first three.
Never met a pianist who doesn't use the little finger though. Actually I once was taught a couple of tunes using three fingers, but it was the index finger I didn't use. Reason was to use the index finger later on for a lower countermelody. So which three fingers are we talking about?  (:)
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 22, 2009, 09:43:26 PM
I don't get this.  I don't see a benefit in moving your fingers from where they need to be when you could just reach out with another finger.
I was trying to say something to the effect that it might be possible to become more proficient and accurate at moving your whole hand around the keyboard if you are partly forced to do so by using only 3 fingers rather than 4.

Usually, I too prefer to make the minimum hand movement and 'reach out with another finger'.

The main time I move my hand significantly along the keyboard is mostly when playing on a one-row melodeon when using the little finger to 'peck' the melody and then have 1st, 2nd and 3rd fingers free to put in a lower arpeggio or countermelody type of accompaniment.

Quote
I was an Anglo concertinist before I was a melodeonist and on Anglo it's definitely an advantage to used the little fingers on both hands
Me too! I definitely agree with you here.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 22, 2009, 11:13:57 PM
. So which three fingers are we talking about?  (:)
Good point.  I'd assumed Rees was talking about first, middle and ring fingers and leaving out the little finger - to do anything else would really be perverse!

I too often use the first finger for a counter-melody, and then I really need all the other fingers to play the tune with.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2009, 11:43:45 PM
And don't forget those of us with Corona-style buttons who (occasionally) use the thumb for the accidentals.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Quebecois on August 23, 2009, 01:35:55 AM
Whetever works for you! I use all fingers and sometimes the thumb.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: RGF on August 23, 2009, 04:13:28 AM
Coming from a piano accordion background,  it seemed to me a bit odd, at first, to use my thumb for nothing more than maintaining my hand position. But I've got past that and am now relativlely comfortable using "just" four, as it was kind of a functional reassignment. The pinky, however, has served so well for so many years, I see no practical reason to put it out to pasture at this early stage.

Bob
(who will accept all the help he can get)



Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on August 23, 2009, 05:40:58 AM
There's no reason to give up on the thumb Bob.All the Slovenianians use it now as do many Italian Organetto players and at least one prominent Swedish two-rower.


I've been playing button accordion for 16 and only started using my thumb two years ago. I've found the thumb to be huge asset for three row playing and I use it all the time now.Though I do find that there are tunes or passages where I find it helpful to have my thumb on the edge.

Chris
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: risto on August 23, 2009, 08:23:51 AM
... Playing with only 3 fingers instead of 4 may mean that you have to shift your hand up and down the keyboard more. At first sight this could be thought of as a disadvantage, but perversely, it might not be so and could in fact lead you to become more skilled and confident in moving around the keyboard. ...

Using 4 came by nature to me as a left handed guitarist. Steve J. & co on this board suggested using only 3 after which I started to arrange fingerings so that when ever possible I use 3 + jumping. It felt comfortable but using the 4th is sometimes reasonable, no reason to exclude it totally. Some 5-row players who also play the diatonic-row boxes speak for the thumb, so there you go.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 23, 2009, 08:30:42 AM
Quote
There's no reason to give up on the thumb Bob.All the Slovenianians use it now as do many Italian Organetto players and at least one prominent Swedish two-rower.

I use the thumb & little finger of course when playing PA so it was perfectly natural for me to translate this onto whatever other box I am playing. Just using three fingers seems so limiting. The important thing to remember, if you are using the whole hand to play with, is to have a strong wrist position. Watch good Slovenian box players and see how they arch the fingers like a pianist to get a good attack.

Having said that sometimes - when I'm feeling lazy - I just use the minimum fingers necessary to get the tune out of the box!
AL
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 23, 2009, 01:31:45 PM
I've never thought seriously of using the thumb for playing.  I need the thumb to brace the instrument. I don't like having it strapped too tightly to my body in any case, and to have it fixed solidly enough not to shift around with the bellows movement would probably prevent me from breathing!

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Stiamh on August 23, 2009, 03:38:56 PM
Quote
Playing with only 3 fingers instead of 4 may mean that you have to shift your hand up and down the keyboard more. At first sight this could be thought of as a disadvantage, but perversely, it might not be so and could in fact lead you to become more skilled and confident in moving around the keyboard.
I don't get this.  I don't see a benefit in moving your fingers from where they need to be when you could just reach out with another finger.

This is the benefit that I see. To me it seems quite clear that, quite apart from the issue of the little finger's strength and length, there is a stronger connection between the stronger fingers, your brain, and the rest of the body. Well my brain and body anyway. Coordinating the left and the right hand - lots of in and out for us C#/Ders - works better when you leave the little 'un out of it. Not sure that what I see as this neurological weakness could be overcome by practice, but 3 fingers works so well for me that it would be absurd for me to devote years to finding out the answer to that question.

Actually I use 2 fingers for many passages, particularly arpeggios. Here's an example:

(http://www.rogermillington.com/steam/PaddyFahysLowGreel.jpg) (http://www.rogermillington.com/steam/PaddyFahysLowGreel.jpg)

Click the pic for a larger version...

At the start of this tune I don't use the 3rd finger until I reach the high A. All (apart from the Cnat) played on my D row, of course. But D arpeggios, and scales up and down the row, are definitely much faster and more reliable for me when I use just two fingers.

Pour le reste, I agree entirely with André L. And with those who say that the style of music has a bearing on this. And of course it's what works for you, there can be no argument there.

BTW Theo, trying to attach the above pic I got a message to say that "the upload folder is full."

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: mikesamwild on August 23, 2009, 05:32:05 PM
Just come back from our regular session and I found I was using my little finger all the time for all sorts of reasons on both sides of the melodeon/button accordion. (D/G + accidentals Saltarelle Connemara )  It's become second nature

It has been invaluable in learning Anglo Concertina too as the strength has been built up over the years on the bigger box.  Although I have a ganglion on my little finger (pinkie) on the right hand which will require microsurgery and I nearly severed the left one on a broken glass serving in our pub a few years back.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Andrel on August 23, 2009, 05:44:58 PM
Amusant, Steve ;). Well, I use both my pinkies on the concertina, of course. And I use the left one on the bass side of my two-row. But only sparingly on the right side. I used it all the time before, say for about four years, then  I switched to the 3-finger thing, (you have to keep at it for a while to get anywhere), and I progressed by leaps and bounds from then on. After all, we always have the 4th one in reserve. Like a safety device. Improves your self-confidence...
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 23, 2009, 06:28:06 PM
Steve, if I understand you correctly, you seem to have developed a 2 or 3 finger style because you don't feel you have sufficient control over the little finger.  Perhaps a teacher might criticise you for not working harder at it, but I won't - if it works for you, and you don't find it a limitation, then stick with it.  Also, I note you play a C#/D which I imagine imposes different constraints from a D/G. which I play.

I'm a bit surprised you find 2 fingers better for scales and arpeggios.  To me, it's natural to keep my hand in the home position and use all four fingers. So D-F#-A-D is a simple 1-2-3-4 up the buttons.  A scale is 1-1-2-2-3-3-4-4.  But, like I said, if it works for you...

Andrel, I'm not sure whether you stopped using the little finger for the same reason, or because you found a real advantage in using just 3 (which is what Rees seemed to be suggesting).  If it is the latter, could you please expand on why you find it better?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: risto on August 23, 2009, 06:47:44 PM

... Actually I use 2 fingers for many passages, particularly arpeggios. ...


Not so far away from the '1 finger approach'.   (:)
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2009, 06:55:43 PM
There are doubtless occasions when using 3 fingers is an advantage, they are the strongest fingers after all and for some tunes they are all you need.

However I have always been a 4 finger person, since I started on Piano and played it fairly seriously for 14 years. Nowadays at university I have less chance to play it unfortunately, so I'm playing box more and more.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Stiamh on August 23, 2009, 07:04:13 PM
Steve, if I understand you correctly, you seem to have developed a 2 or 3 finger style because you don't feel you have sufficient control over the little finger. 

No, actually when I started playing I naturally used all four fingers (having been a fiddler and being well aware of piano technique). I stopped because the first person to give me a lesson insisted that I stop using the little finger. If he hadn't been a brilliant player, and if he hadn't insisted so strongly, I probably would have disregarded the idea as ridiculous, as I had done when another relative beginner first told me that he had been given this advice.

The changeover made an immediate and dramatic difference to everything, and my theories about the little finger's weak connection to the brain came after, as a result of the experience.

Quote
I'm a bit surprised you find 2 fingers better for scales and arpeggios.  To me, it's natural to keep my hand in the home position and use all four fingers. So D-F#-A-D is a simple 1-2-3-4 up the buttons.  A scale is 1-1-2-2-3-3-4-4. 

Irish tunes tend to move about so much that the idea of a home position isn't useful. And when a tune does move beyond four buttons, then when your little finger is on the fourth one it's just in the way... Two fingers for scales and arpeggios - I admit the idea looks daft, but it certainly does work for me. Up and down the row, mind you, as soon as you start using both rows for anything you have to use three fingers. Unfortunately.  >:E
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: jonm on August 23, 2009, 07:31:46 PM
One of the advantages of playing left handed upside down? You can save the little finger for adding low octave notes. :M
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: ganderbox on August 23, 2009, 08:35:32 PM
The answer does seem to be that it depends on what you play. I never really thought about it before, but I seem to use my little finger a lot when cross-rowing, playing french tunes, mazurkas, schottisches etc, but rarely do so when playing for ceilidhs (except as above), or morris.

It was Rees who instigated this debate, and there hasn't been a peep out him in this thread.
Come on, Rees! Tell us all why 3 fingers is best!  (and no getting side-tracked into a discussion about grammar >:E)
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 23, 2009, 09:28:25 PM
I stopped because the first person to give me a lesson insisted that I stop using the little finger...
The changeover made an immediate and dramatic difference to everything,

Thanks for clarifying that, Steve.  In what way did it make a difference?  That's the bit I'm struggling to understand. Is this a usual feature of Irish melodeon style?

Quote
when a tune does move beyond four buttons, then when your little finger is on the fourth one it's just in the way...
Of course, it's not rigid and if the tune moves further up the keyboard then I'll shift my hand.  Somewhere near the top of the tune's range I'm quite likely to use the little finger, though.

English tunes can move around a fair bit, too, and in some decidedly odd ways.  Unlike Ganderbox, I often use the little finger for English ceilidh and morris tunes.  I would be absolutely lost without it, and I cannot imagine how deliberately not using it would help me at all.  But my style includes a lot of right hand chords and general fiddling about, so I often need that finger to play the tune while my other fingers are doing something else.

I'm also hoping Rees will contribute, and I've PM'd him to draw the thread to his attention.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 23, 2009, 10:39:01 PM
Here's a reason to use all the fingers.  The way I play the tune is often dictated by the bass chords I want to play.  These determine the bellows direction, so the way I play the melody isn't always the most obvious.

Here's an example: in Sir Sidney Smith's March there's a phrase which goes (in ABC):

e/2g/2 e/2g/2   d/2g/2 d/2g/2   c/2g/2 c/2g/2   B/2g/2 B/2g/2


I play this against the chords of C (pull) Bm (push) A (pull) and G (push).  To play the G note against the pulled chords I use the G pull on the D row, which is a 3-button stretch from the pull E and four buttons from the pull C (all the other notes are played on the G row).  By using the little finger to play the pull G, I can play this without having to reposition my hand - I can simply drop the fingers onto the appropriate buttons.  This make it faster and more accurate, especially as the phrase then repeats.

In Tab (CADB system*) it's:

   momo mama  io io    i a i a         
P|        5'6'5'6'         4'6'4'6'   
T|5'85'8         4'84'8
   C      Bm     A      G 

Hope this makes sense!

* See http://diato.org/exptab2.htm (http://diato.org/exptab2.htm) for an explanation.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2009, 01:25:51 AM
Will you look at the time! I've just landed back home from the mud and bullets of Pontardawe festival to find all this going on.

I shall pontificate further tomorrow after I've had some sleep. Suffice it to say for now that two of my greatest melodeon heroes, Katie Howson and Jackie Daly, are strictly three fingers.

Yawn.. zzzzzzzzzz..... snore.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 24, 2009, 08:30:47 AM
Quote
Yawn.. zzzzzzzzzz..... snore.
yes..that sounds like 'Bont'!
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2009, 11:25:04 AM
OK, depending on what style I'm playing I will sometimes use 3 and sometimes 4.

Legato style cross-rowing (think French waltz in E minor) my little finger is employed reaching across to the upper notes and playing all kinds of harmonies. Cajun/Zydeco one-row style, the little finger plays octaves and other fancy stuff. Tex-Mex/Jazz/Blues whatever, anything goes including the thumb.
So, 4 fingers for all the above.

If playing straight ahead dance music, particularly East Anglian or Sliabh Luachra, which are my favourite styles, then I'll be trying to use 3 fingers as best I can. I find that the tunes flow much better this way.
For instance, I'd been playing Percy Brown's Schottische (Page 70 - Before the night was out. Track 42, disc 2, Pigeon on the gate CD. Also in Townsend as Percy Brown's Barn Dance) for many years with 4 fingers. It never sounded right, particularly the triplets over a 4 button stretch.
I changed to 3 fingers and voila, all became clear. Still not an easy tune to play but certainly less nerve racking with 3 fingers instead of 4.
Similarly, revisiting some Jackie Daly tunes, I find that they work much better with the three finger system.

Overall then, use as many fingers as you've got but if you find you are struggling with a particular tune then perhaps a 3 finger re-think may be in order.  :Ph
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 24, 2009, 12:00:41 PM
I agree with the 'whatever suits you' camp, but there's something else that I find to be an advantage with the four finger style, and that is that it reduces the number of position jumps- this is more of a  memory thing for me than a finger-speed thing.  I've realised recently that perhaps the most difficult aspect about the box is that because there are so many ways of playing the same run of notes, you need to remember the best way - or if you read while you're playing, you need to develop a way of reminding yourself which way you want to use.  Once you know a tune so well that you don't even think about it, it's no longer a problem, but that takes me many months to do, and for many of the tunes I 'know' I haven't reached that stage and I do still need a memory prompt to stop my fingers getting twisted.  The four finger style seems to allow me to remember patterns of fingers more easily than if I keep changing position.

I really wish I could learn a foolproof 'way of learning', but so far I haven't been able to work out what it is.  I tend to put reminder push/pull arrows over the change points in the music, but it doesn't always work. I sometimes envy people who play instruments where you can only play a tune in one way, because learning a tune must then be a doddle.

Has anyone else worked out a better reminder system?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 24, 2009, 12:04:49 PM
Thanks Rees, that makes more sense to me.  Your comment in the other thread (which was admittedly very brief, and perhaps a bit throwaway) suggested to me that you were advocating using 3 fingers rather than 4 as a general rule.

The little finger is never going to be as strong or as accurate as the others, and I would never suggest it should always be used on particular buttons, or for difficult phrases.  There will always be tricky bits in a tune where it is clearly better to use the strongest and most dexterous fingers.  However the little finger definitely has its uses, and if you are able to bring it in to play I find it opens up all sorts of opportunities for the other fingers to do something else.  That's not to say that there aren't many excellent players who manage very well without it.

If we're talking melodeon heroes, then I'd have to bring in Tony Hall, who not only uses all four fingers but who seems to have several more which we mere mortals lack!
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 24, 2009, 12:26:09 PM
I really wish I could learn a foolproof 'way of learning', but so far I haven't been able to work out what it is.  I tend to put reminder push/pull arrows over the change points in the music, but it doesn't always work.
My suggestion would be to try to break away from relying on the music and your written annotations.  If you can get the tune into your head it may then become more instinctive.

I find that for a lot of my tunes, I haven't actually memorised the fingering - as long as I know how the tune goes I can then play it.  Most tunes (especially folk tunes) are made up for the most part of fairly straightforward phrases which can be played with a repertoire of standard fingering patterns.  Of course, there are usually a few tricky phrases where I really do have to have worked out (and remembered) a particular fingering sequence, but it is a lot easier to remember a few short phrases in detail than remember all the fingering for a lot of tunes.

With this approach I am usually able to play half-remembered tunes in sessions even though I don't have worked-out fingerings for them.

As I mentioned in an earlier post, often my choice of right-hand fingering is dictated by the choice of left-hand chord.  If you are thinking about the chords, and therefore the bellows direction, then this rules out at least some of the possible right-hand options straight away.  Again, I now find I can often throw in different chords (and choose a melody fingering to suit) on the fly.

It is something else to think about, compared with an instrument which doesn't offer these choices.  But that's part of the fascination of the melodeon, and it can lead you to some interesting ideas and sounds which you wouldn't perhaps discover with a more logical instrument.

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Stiamh on August 24, 2009, 01:10:51 PM
Howard, thanks for starting this thread, taking an interest, and raising the level of debate far beyond that of previous forays into the subject. Not having a "quint box" (horrid expression, is there anything more elegant?) it won't be easy for me to apply your Sidney Smith example but I'll have a go at deciphering when I get a quiet half-hour.

The fact that I don't play QB, and the fact that most of what I play is "straight ahead dance music" probably explains why I can get through 95% of tunes without needing the little finger. Nowadays I find myself using it more often, but I think the decision to go "cold turkey" on it for a couple of years was a tremendous benefit.

To answer your question about what made the difference when I changed: first, certain tunes in which I was relying on the 4th finger for repeated jumps, and which remained frustratingly unreliable, immediately became almost a piece of cake when I did the reaching with the 3rd finger. One example that I remember was the second part of Andy Cutting's Flatworld in Am (not the most obvious tune for a beginner on C#/D). The difference really was dramatic. Second, as a result of improvements like this, my confidence increased manifold. Third, I began to develop mobility and the basics of my fingering, er, "system" . All this was very, to use another horrid and trendy word, empowering!

Below is another tune snippet to demonstrate another advantage I thought of yesterday. The first part of this tune could very easily be played without moving the hand from your "home position" on the D row of a C#/D (and I assume D/G as well) since it stays within an octave and one-finger-per-button will work. However, using 3 fingers only, one can play it with a constant finger-shuffling motion that I really enjoy. Yesterday it struck me that playing like this, your hand is a boxer, dancing nimbly on his feet anticipating the next move required (like Muhammad Ali), rather than standing there flatfooted waiting to get thumped (like so many of his opponents).

(http://www.folktunefinder.com/image/22976.png) (http://www.folktunefinder.com/image/22976.png)

This is how I would finger the first part:

Code: [Select]
T:The Heathery Breeze (for C#/D)
M:C|
K:G
DGBG dGBG | DFAF cFAF | DGBG dGBG | BdAc BGGG |
1231 3132   1231 3132   1231 3131   2323 2121

A tune that we probably both play mainly on the D row is the Morpeth Rant. That works very well for me with 3 fingers and the shufflings are very logical. Want to compare notes?

Cheers
Steve

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2009, 01:26:10 PM

To answer your question about what made the difference when I changed: first, certain tunes in which I was relying on the 4th finger for repeated jumps, and which remained frustratingly unreliable, immediately became almost a piece of cake when I did the reaching with the 3rd finger.



Exactly Steve, that hits my nail on the head most admirably.

Use as many fingers as you like, but if you're struggling with certain little finger passages, remember that there may be an easier way.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 24, 2009, 01:29:29 PM
Quote
As I mentioned in an earlier post, often my choice of right-hand fingering is dictated by the choice of left-hand chord.  If you are thinking about the chords, and therefore the bellows direction, then this rules out at least some of the possible right-hand options straight away.  Again, I now find I can often throw in different chords (and choose a melody fingering to suit) on the fly.

Thanks, Howard for your advice - I'm taking it as read that the LH chords will often rule the direction of the RH fingering, and I guess I have also learned to do that automatically - but there are of course still many alternative fingerings for a run of notes, for example in or out with a D chord (on a D/G box that is), and for off-beat notes where you're not playing a LH chord.  The choice of RH button can then depend on whether you want an overall legato or staccato sound.  But I find the problem is that if I start a run in the wrong way, I will find that the fingering turns out to be impossible, (or perhaps impossible to play at the right speed) later on in the run.  So my idea was that when I start to learn a tune one of the first things I need to learn is how to start a run of notes, and I didn't see a good reason why I shouldn't remind myself of that somehow.

I'm interested in how you have learned to play most tunes rather than fingerings, which presumably means that you have also learned ways of escaping from a tricky fingering sequence, or rules to determine how you start the sequence.  Are you able to expand on this, at all?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2009, 01:30:18 PM
Thanks Rees, that makes more sense to me.  Your comment in the other thread (which was admittedly very brief, and perhaps a bit throwaway) suggested to me that you were advocating using 3 fingers rather than 4 as a general rule.


Throwaway, moi?  :D :D :D
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: paulq on August 24, 2009, 01:32:56 PM
Was sitting in a sunny London garden only yesterday comparing notes with my mate Allan Kelly (Bon Temps Playboys one-row player) and this 3 v 4 fingers thing came up. He uses 3 and reckons that if you watch players like Flaco, they do too - and also that old Cajun players in the US would often learn the basic tunes using just one finger and get used to moving the hand around.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2009, 01:35:04 PM
Marc Savoy plays some amazing stuff with one finger.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: baz parkes on August 24, 2009, 01:35:41 PM
This is all very well, but I'd like to know how you all work out how many fingers you're using whilst playing at the same time.  There must be some serious cases of melodeon face out there... ;)

Baz
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 24, 2009, 06:30:03 PM
This is all very well, but I'd like to know how you all work out how many fingers you're using whilst playing at the same time.  There must be some serious cases of melodeon face out there... ;)

Baz

It's called "counting", Baz  ;D
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 24, 2009, 08:01:07 PM
However, using 3 fingers only, one can play it with a constant finger-shuffling motion that I really enjoy.

I know exactly what you mean!  Some phrases like that just feel good to play - it's nothing to do with whether or not it's the best fingering.  However, that sort of thing can also help you to keep a steady rhythm and drive in the music.

The Morpeth Rant has a lot of these, and they feel good to play.  However, I certainly do use 4 fingers. For example, in the second bar of the A music:

BGBd c#Ac#e

The first four notes are all on the push against a G chord, the next four are all on the pull against an A chord.  I play the BGB on the push on the G row using the middle and first fingers respectively, but drop to the D row push for the high D, using my third finger. This leaves that finger in place for the C# on the pull.  I'm using the index finger on the G row for the pull A, then back to C# still on the third finger, so it then seems natural to use the little finger for the high E.  Otherwise I'd either have to switch to the middle finger for the C# to free the third finger for the E, or jump the third finger from C# to E.  There are other alternatives, but they all involve a clumsy and unnecessary (to my mind) switch of fingers, whereas my preferred fingering falls neatly on to the buttons.  I'm also using the same finger each time I play a particular note, which I find leaves less scope for confusion.

Likewise for the final phrase of the A music:
d2 ef# gf#ec# | A2 d2 d4

I play the high G with my little finger, and the gf#ec# run finishes on the middle finger, leaving my first finger free to drop onto the pull A on the G row against a pull A chord, before coming back to D on the push. I were to use just three fingers I would have a bigger stretch to reach the pull A.

However, I must admit that I do seem to play most of the B music with just 3 fingers.

I'm working out the logic and justification of this retrospectively from my playing, I probably didn't think about it in these terms when I first started to play it this way, I just played what felt right.  I don't have any difficulty playing these notes with the little finger. 
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 24, 2009, 08:18:22 PM
[I'm interested in how you have learned to play most tunes rather than fingerings, which presumably means that you have also learned ways of escaping from a tricky fingering sequence, or rules to determine how you start the sequence.  Are you able to expand on this, at all?

I'm not sure!  For a start, I play by ear rather than from music, so my approach is always to learn the tune in my head first, and then to try to transfer it to the instrument.  I don't think I have any "rules", but I probably have learned ways of getting out of trouble.

Most folk tunes are made up of simple phrases which keep cropping up in tune after tune, so you'll often find if you've learned a fingering for one tune you can reuse it, or adapt it slightly, for another.  Within a tune, the same phrases are usually repeated a number of times with slight variations so the same thing applies.

I find I have a mental library of different ways of playing short phrases which I can call on without too much mental effort.  Of course, I have a "default" preferred way of playing most of these, but if that doesn't work too well I can try another.  Sometimes none of these work and I'll have to stop and experiment with different ways of playing it.  These have to work not only when practicing that phrase in isolation, but when it's part of the tune - sometimes I'll then have to change the way I play the lead-in and lead-out phrases so that they all work together without tripping over my fingers.

In the same way I can busk a tune in a session which I only half-know, or in some cases which I've never heard before. 

However it sounds as if your problem is more to do with remembering which choice of fingering you've settled on.  I still think you're depending too much on the written music and your annotations - by all means make a note so that you have a reference, but put it aside when you're playing and learn to rely on your memory.  If you have the music in front of you then you won't train your memory.  Concentrate on remembering those sections where you have to get it right or you get into trouble - the rest of the tune can by and large take care of itself.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 25, 2009, 08:13:16 AM
Howard, thanks for that - I think we are actually doing much the same thing, in practice - certainly I recognise the 'familiar phrases' process, and busking by ear.  My aim is always to play without music, but the trouble I find is that it does take a long time to learn a complex piece of music to that stage, and life is short, and in the meantime I still want to be able to perform the tune with the band. 

And the difficulty in learning stems from the opportunities the box offers, which then means the brain gets confused as to which one to use, and its all too easy to become set on the wrong one, and then have to unlearn it.  I envy the single note instrument players who can play a score perfectly at full speed with expression straight from a score, and I don't really see why a box player shouldn't be able to do the same, provided that we could develop a suitable mnemomic to put where necessary with the score and written chords.   I have found 'push/pull' arrows help, but it's not the end of the problem.

It is a bit strange, isn't it, that all the other band instruments can play from dots or chords or whatever, and the poor old box player has to learn the tune!  I feel there must be a way round this, if only we could come up with some sort of standard mnemonic notation rules for each box layout (eg G\/ might indicate a push on the G row).  I do prefer score and guitar chords to other notation formats, because I have found it as simple as its alternatives, visually easier to read quickly, and of course it's universally available.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Stiamh on August 25, 2009, 02:10:15 PM
The Morpeth Rant.... second bar of the A music:

BGBd c#Ac#e

The first four notes are all on the push against a G chord, the next four are all on the pull against an A chord.  I play the BGB on the push on the G row using the middle and first fingers respectively, but drop to the D row push for the high D, using my third finger. This leaves that finger in place for the C# on the pull.  I'm using the index finger on the G row for the pull A, then back to C# still on the third finger, so it then seems natural to use the little finger for the high E.  Otherwise I'd either have to switch to the middle finger for the C# to free the third finger for the E, or jump the third finger from C# to E.  There are other alternatives, but they all involve a clumsy and unnecessary (to my mind) switch of fingers, whereas my preferred fingering falls neatly on to the buttons.  I'm also using the same finger each time I play a particular note, which I find leaves less scope for confusion.

Likewise for the final phrase of the A music:
d2 ef# gf#ec# | A2 d2 d4

I play the high G with my little finger, and the gf#ec# run finishes on the middle finger, leaving my first finger free to drop onto the pull A on the G row against a pull A chord, before coming back to D on the push. I were to use just three fingers I would have a bigger stretch to reach the pull A.

However, I must admit that I do seem to play most of the B music with just 3 fingers.

I'm working out the logic and justification of this retrospectively from my playing, I probably didn't think about it in these terms when I first started to play it this way, I just played what felt right.  I don't have any difficulty playing these notes with the little finger. 

Thanks for this insight into how an experienced D/G player would attack this tune. It didn't occur to me that you would use the G row so much or that the basses dictate your phrasing quite so much. I could actually play the tune exactly as you do using the reversals on my 2½-row C#/D. However I don't think I would like the smoothness I'd get from playing those entire G-chord and A-chord phrases in one direction. My bass playing is pretty rudimentary (though I'm working on it a lot these days) but I don't mind syncopated gaps in the accompaniment when basses aren't available. (Anyway I have G and A basses in both directions so I could still play a constant bass staying on the D row.)

Playing on the D row, in your first phrase (BGBd c#Ac#e) I'd be using the same fingers as yourself as far as the d, but I would shuffle to the 2nd finger for the c# and I'd shuffle again on the same button to play the ensuing d with my first finger, setting me up nicely for the phrase dfaf. What would you use to play the d that follows your final 4th-finger e ?

In your second phrase, I'd play the high g with my 3rd finger. This means I have to shift my first finger down from the d to play A, but I have no theoretical objection to doing this. I could avoid it by using the 4th finger but so what.  (:)

Turning to Chris' remarks about the box player having to learn the tune rather than read the music makes me wonder whether this style of D/G playing isn't partly the culprit in this situation?

I mean, if you are concerned to get the best possible bass accompaniment immediately, and this will dictate which buttons you use, and thus complicate fingering, the task will be that much more arduous, won't it? I used to rail against the fact that C#/D allows you next to no choice of buttons and therefore phrasing, but perhaps it makes attacking a tune a lot simpler. At any rate I don't find reading the average straightforward dance tune at a moderate pace much more challenging on box than on other instruments. 

Cheers
Steve

[Edited to make this post, which contained special characters, visible again.]




Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 25, 2009, 05:44:18 PM
First of all, I would like to say just how interesting this whole thread is; one of the very best there's ever been in my opinion. Just shows what this forum is all about. Many thanks to all the contributors so far.  (:)

Thanks for this insight into how an experienced D/G player would attack this tune. It didn't occur to me that you would use the G row so much or that the basses dictate your phrasing quite so much. .......
<snip>
..... I mean, if you are concerned to get the best possible bass accompaniment immediately, and this will dictate which buttons you use, and thus complicate fingering, the task will be that much more arduous, won't it? I used to rail against the fact that C#/D allows you next to no choice of buttons and therefore phrasing, but perhaps it makes attacking a tune a lot simpler.
I guess it also demonstrates that there are two valid approaches to playing on a D/G or other 'quint' box (I hate that term too, and anyway the interval from the D-row to the G-row is a fourth, not a fifth).
You can either work out the harmonic structure first - decide on on what chords you want and then fit the RH row and bellows direction to those chords, which is the methodology Howard describes for Morpeth Rant.

Or, you can treat the two-row box as if it were a one-row most of the time and play on the appropriate row for the tune. For example, a D/G player could choose to play Morpeth Rant entirely on the D-row and just use the chords which sounded mostly OK for the RH bellows direction - mostly D push, A pull of course, but with the occasional foray into B push, Em pull. What you end up with is a very rhythmic drive, but not necessarily with the harmonically 'correct' chords which doesn't matter. And on a 1-row box you've got no choice as to LH chords anyway.

Both approaches are OK.

Not being a semitone box player, I am curious to know whether this seems an advantage for the 'fourth-tuned' box ('quad box?') player.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 25, 2009, 08:55:43 PM
Quote
the interval from the D-row to the G-row is a fourth, not a fifth
Five whole tones G up to D though?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 25, 2009, 09:26:47 PM
In reply to Steve Jones, the "smoothness" of these chords in Morpeth Rant only lasts for half a bar each, so it's not losing any of bounciness one associates with melodeon.  All I'm doing by choosing a fingering which allows the whole phrase to be played in one direction is avoiding breaking up the chord within that half-bar. 

That's a choice for this particular tune - there may be others where I'm quite happy to do the opposite, or to do as Steve Freereeder suggests and play it like a one-row - there are some tunes which just cry out for this approach, even if harmonically you are playing the "wrong" chord.

It's just one approach to playing.  Some people just thump out the three chord trick, some play whatever chord the box offers them.  But even the three-chord trick in D requires the use of the G row to play against the G chord.  Sometimes I want to add a bit of variety by playing different chords.  As soon as you start to plan the tune around the chords, rather than vice versa, you are forced into different right-hand fingerings which may then (to bring this back on-topic) suggest the use of the fourth finger. 

Quote
Playing on the D row, in your first phrase (BGBd c#Ac#e) I'd be using the same fingers as yourself as far as the d, but I would shuffle to the 2nd finger for the c# and I'd shuffle again on the same button to play the ensuing d with my first finger, setting me up nicely for the phrase dfaf. What would you use to play the d that follows your final 4th-finger e ?
I use the middle finger for the D. That's a slight shift of the hand along the keyboard, and sets me up to play the following phrase with my middle and little fingers.

In reply to Chris Brimley
Quote
It is a bit strange, isn't it, that all the other band instruments can play from dots or chords or whatever, and the poor old box player has to learn the tune!
But is that really true?  Many other instruments besides melodeon have alternative ways of playing the same note - eg guitars and fiddles and other strings; wind instruments often have alternative fingerings; anglo concertina has the same problem as melodeon (but more so); hammered dulcimers.  Only a few instruments have a strict one key/button/string to one note - eg pianos etc, harp. 

It's not just melodeon players who face these problems.  A guitarist seeing a written chord "G" still has several choices of how that chord can be played.   Even the full notation won't necessarily tell him which fingering to use.  A fiddler seeing a phrase of music will still have to choose which position to play in, at what point in the phrase to change from one string to the next, and what bowing to use.  Only the pianist can look at the dots and see immediately which key to press, but he still has to choose which finger to use.

There are tab systems for melodeon (I posted a link to CADB in a previous post) although personally I don't find them easy to play from, but sometimes useful as an aide-memoire.

If you need a written prompt, then any system which works for you is fine. Otherwise, just practice more and try to develop your memory.  If you're playing complex tunes, then try to focus on memorising the complex parts and let the simpler parts take care of themselves.  You may find that all you need to remember is the fingering for the start of a difficult phrase and the rest will flow from there.  Try to break it down rather than attempt to memorise the whole tune in every detail.




Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: joe on August 25, 2009, 10:26:26 PM
  If you're playing complex tunes, then try to focus on memorising the complex parts and let the simpler parts take care of themselves.  You may find that all you need to remember is the fingering for the start of a difficult phrase and the rest will flow from there.  Try to break it down rather than attempt to memorise the whole tune in every detail.

I am finding now that I know most of a lot of tunes without having ever sat down and learnt them, but there is always that little bit I dont know, and always forget to learn! Will take the above advice and try harder in future!
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 25, 2009, 11:15:57 PM
Quote
the interval from the D-row to the G-row is a fourth, not a fifth
Five whole tones G up to D though?
No - a D/G melodeon has the 2 rows rows rising in pitch from lower D to higher G, which is a fourth. Compare that with a G/D (note order of letters) anglo concertina where the 2 rows rise in pitch from lower G to higher D, which is a fifth. Similarly with a G/C melodeon and a C/G anglo.

So if we must use these terms (and I prefer not to), the melodeon is a 'quad box' and the anglo is the true 'quint box'.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Falseknight on August 26, 2009, 07:50:17 AM
But a guitarist of fiddle player does not get a different note out of his box dependent on whether he is up or down picking (or bowing).  A hammer dulcimer player only gets one note from one string sector.  No-one but bellows players have to work out which press/draw melody notes fit with which press/draw basses.

This is what makes melodeon (etc.) unique.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 26, 2009, 09:09:16 AM
Quote
Many other instruments besides melodeon have alternative ways of playing the same note

Yes, (although as Falseknight has pointed out it is usually not as complicated for them, because the position changes are less frequent) but they have often developed score notations to advise on which position to use at which point. 

I'm suggesting perhaps it would be useful if we could do the same.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 26, 2009, 09:27:54 AM
Again slightly off topic, but on the alternative fingerings issue, it's not always about trying to smoothe out a difficult tune, sometimes it's the opposite.

I've always found the first few bars of Soldiers Joy to be a prime example.  So often I've heard several G/D boxes (or D/G, depending on your preferred name) playing this together all on the D row, and making it degenerate into a rhythmless mess.  I'm thinking of the bit that goes: A F# D F# A F#D F# A (All push on the D row).  So much better, and easier on the fingers, to play all the A's on the D row, and the rest of the notes on the G row:  A F# D F# A F#D F# A.  The sound is immediately much more rhythmic, and you get some nice choppy basses too.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 26, 2009, 10:48:54 AM
Oscar Woods solved this problem in his version of Soldiers Joy which he called Soldiers Dream.
"Before the night was out - page 57"
He plays the first couple of bars (on a one-row melodeon) as A G F# B - A G F# B - A D D.

Funky and rhythmic - good ol' boy.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 26, 2009, 11:00:43 AM
But a guitarist of fiddle player does not get a different note out of his box dependent on whether he is up or down picking (or bowing).  A hammer dulcimer player only gets one note from one string sector.  No-one but bellows players have to work out which press/draw melody notes fit with which press/draw basses.

This is what makes melodeon (etc.) unique.

We make a big thing of the push-pull, because it is an obvious feature of our instrument and probably the one we struggle most with when first learning.  But we shouldn't assume that players of other instruments don't have their own particular issues to overcome.

Every instrument, not just melodeon, has it's own unique difficulties.  I also play guitar, anglo concertina, hammered dulcimer and recorder, so I have some insight into this.  True, the bowing or picking doesn't affect the note on a stringed instrument (although it may affect the timbre), but that note could be played on several different strings.  Likewise, on a hammered dulcimer most notes are repeated in different places, so there are several choices to be made, particularly when playing a pattern of notes.  Even wind instruments may have alternative fingerings for the same note, or choices about tounging.  Even on the piano, with one key per note, the player still has to decide which finger to use.  Usually the written score alone doesn't offer the players any clues.

The particular issue with melodeon is the push-pull. On the other hand, on a two-row D/G most of the notes only appear twice, so the choice is usually only between one button on the push and another on the pull.  The more difficult choices are whether to play a phrase push-pull or legato, and which fingers to use, but players of other instruments face similar choices appropriate to their own instruments.

The reason some musicians can play at first sight with full expression from a score, as Chris commented in an earlier post, is that they have the experience to choose the best fingering (or if not the best, at least a fingering which works) the first time.  Even so, to play it properly they'll then take the time to work out particular passages.  There is no reason why a melodeonist who can play from music shouldn't be able to do the same.  It comes down to familiarity with the instrument and full awareness of what choices are available.

There are several methods of annotating a score - there are various systems of melodeon tab, while some people use violin bowing marks to represent bellows direction.  Whatever you use is personal to the player, and depends how much information you want to record - bellows direction? which button? which finger?  Do we need a standardised system?  Probably not, imo, except possibly for teaching purposes, but that really demands another topic of its own.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 26, 2009, 11:12:44 AM
Again slightly off topic, but on the alternative fingerings issue, it's not always about trying to smoothe out a difficult tune, sometimes it's the opposite.
Absolutely!  In fact, I would argue that alternative fingerings should primarily be used for musical reasons, rather than because they're easier to play (sometimes they'll be harder).

I know what you mean about Soldiers Joy, and it applies to any long phrase where there is not a natural bellows change.  However, the mushiness is due to poor right-hand technique, and there is no reason why it could not be played crisply in one direction.  A better reason (which your example illustrates) is to get more out of the basses by changing direction, otherwise that too can degenerate into a turgid oom-pah on the same chord.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 26, 2009, 11:21:59 AM
No-one but bellows players have to work out which press/draw melody notes fit with which press/draw basses.

On re-reading my reply I've realised I didn't address this point about the basses.

The limited choice of chords actually makes it easier.  If you want to play a "G" chord, then you have to play the melody on the push.  If you substitute an Em chord, you've got to play on the pull.  No choice.

C and D chords are available in either direction, so then the decision will probably be based on where you want the bellows to be positioned at the end of the phrase.  This just requires a bit of forethought.

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Stiamh on August 26, 2009, 02:51:06 PM
Taking the discussion back a few steps - sorry to be a little anal about this -

Quote from: me
Playing on the D row, in your first phrase (BGBd c#Ac#e) I'd be using the same fingers as yourself as far as the d, but I would shuffle to the 2nd finger for the c# and I'd shuffle again on the same button to play the ensuing d with my first finger, setting me up nicely for the phrase dfaf. What would you use to play the d that follows your final 4th-finger e ?
I use the middle finger for the D. That's a slight shift of the hand along the keyboard, and sets me up to play the following phrase with my middle and little fingers.

I couldn't figure this out until it dawned on me that we must be playing different settings. Is your next note (after c#Ac#e) an f# ? So you're shuffling from 4th to 3rd between e and f# ?

A quick check at folktunefinder.com shows a few versions and that would be the first setting shown. ( http://www.folktunefinder.com/search/query/?title=morpeth+rant ). I seem to be playing what is given as the Billy Pigg setting, not sure how I came by that, but I really need to have my first finger on the d that starts the next phrase in his version.

Returning to the subject of notation raised by Chris, doesn't the tablature widely used in France address all these questions? Except of course, note duration, meaning that you have to have the conventional notation on top of the tab. Personally I would see tablature as a very restrictive system - useful for learning exactly what someone else does, but otherwise stifling, and presumably slow into the bargain.

Again for teaching purposes, Damien Connolly's tutor (http://www.damienconnolly.com/tutor.html) uses added a few signs and symbols to both staff notation and a variant of ABC: highlighting to indicate bellows direction, marks to indicate finger shifts, and so on. For B/C system, where there are fewer possibilities than on a D/G, mind you.

However for general purposes I think that time put into mastering alternative notation systems like this would be better spent mastering one's own keyboard, learning by ear, and conventional notation. A lot more work at the beginning maybe, but work that would pay big dividends later on.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Pushpull on August 26, 2009, 03:27:17 PM
Quote
Many other instruments besides melodeon have alternative ways of playing the same note

Yes, (although as Falseknight has pointed out it is usually not as complicated for them, because the position changes are less frequent)
In folk music maybe
Quote
but they have often developed score notations to advise on which position to use at which point. 
In years gone by, I played viola. I don't remember ever buying music which had the fingering already noted (apart from elementary tutor books and some studies). It's something you decide on by playing the piece. I'm in a similar situation now with my main instrument - oboe. There are many alternative ways of playing some notes depending on the note you are coming from or going to and perhaps the tone colour you are after or a slight change in intonation you might want depending on the key being played. I'm at the stage where I can apply some of the required fingerings on auto pilot whilst sight reading but in many cases I need to play through a passage and pencil in the fingerings.

Better players that me can sight read much harder stuff and get the correct fingering immediately (even swapping mid note if they get caught out). I don't think the melodeon is much different. I can play simple stuff sight reading and get reasonable chords but generally need a couple of goes to decide whether I'm going to push or pull - and that applies to reading from the dots or working out a tune by ear.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 26, 2009, 03:53:44 PM
Taking the discussion back a few steps - sorry to be a little anal about this -

Quote from: me
Playing on the D row, in your first phrase (BGBd c#Ac#e) I'd be using the same fingers as yourself as far as the d, but I would shuffle to the 2nd finger for the c# and I'd shuffle again on the same button to play the ensuing d with my first finger, setting me up nicely for the phrase dfaf. What would you use to play the d that follows your final 4th-finger e ?
I use the middle finger for the D. That's a slight shift of the hand along the keyboard, and sets me up to play the following phrase with my middle and little fingers.

I couldn't figure this out until it dawned on me that we must be playing different settings. Is your next note (after c#Ac#e) an f# ? So you're shuffling from 4th to 3rd between e and f# ?

I'm not sure if I'm playing any particular setting, this is a tune I've learned by ear from many different players.  I probably don't play it the same way each time, anyway.

Here's the ABC for the A part as I've described it above (I think!):

X:1
T:Morpeth Rant
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:D
(3ABc|:"D"d2AG FDFA|"G"BGBd "A"cAce|1"D"d2 ef "G" gfed|"A"c2 e2 e2 (3ABc:|2"D"d2 ef "Em" gfec|"A"A2 "D"d2 d4|


The first time through, in the third bar I'd use the middle finger on the push G (G row) against the G chord, on the repeat I'd use the little finger for the pull G on the D row (against the pulled Em chord).  But if we ever find ourselves in the same session, I can't guarantee I'll play it like this!

Quote
Returning to the subject of notation raised by Chris, doesn't the tablature widely used in France address all these questions? Except of course, note duration, meaning that you have to have the conventional notation on top of the tab.
Another way is to show just the note stems, without the staff or the dots, to show duration.

Quote
Personally I would see tablature as a very restrictive system - useful for learning exactly what someone else does...
Or for recording what fingering you've worked out, so that when you come back to the tune later (possibly after having not played it for some time) you can see what you did.

Quote
However for general purposes I think that time put into mastering alternative notation systems like this would be better spent mastering one's own keyboard, learning by ear, and conventional notation. A lot more work at the beginning maybe, but work that would pay big dividends later on.
Conventional notation still won't help you with fingering question.  I think playing by ear helps, but ultimately it's down to familiarity with the keyboard, so that these choices become instinctive.  That only comes from experience and practice.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Falseknight on August 26, 2009, 04:02:41 PM
On other instruments, the aim is to make the flow of a sequence of notes as efficient as possible.

Many melodeon players use bellows reversals to add "bounce" to the music, which can mitigate against the most efficient fingering patterns.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 26, 2009, 05:08:45 PM
Quote
Returning to the subject of notation raised by Chris, doesn't the tablature widely used in France address all these questions? Except of course, note duration, meaning that you have to have the conventional notation on top of the tab. Personally I would see tablature as a very restrictive system - useful for learning exactly what someone else does, but otherwise stifling, and presumably slow into the bargain.

I have to confess I'm not very familiar with French tablature (except for finger-picking guitar, where Marcel Dadi used it remarkably effectively.)

Damien Connolly's system is not entirely clear from the link, but I think his idea of colour-coding rows has some merit.  I know it's not always the case (and I'm sure someone is going to point out some obvious examples!), but of the many hundreds of different button layouts available for boxes, it seems to be generally the case that for each row, repeated notes are relatively rare.  This means that a system that told you which row to play would actually be a pretty efficient and useful way of communicating a unique fingering method - the bellows direction would follow automatically.  This would link with the 'cross-row' concept, which I had previously thought wasn't general enough to have much application.

Now of course the snag is that since there are so many different button layouts, there would be no point in writing down one set of annotations for a given tune - they would differ depending on what box you had.  But looking at this thing as a system, it does also mean some computer whizzo could develop an algorithm that might predict the likely easiest fingerings for a given tune (or midi file?), on a given box, using the info available on box layouts on melodeons.net!  You could feed in the characteristics of a human hand, and the software could work out various useful fingerings for you to try out on each tune!  Does any systems analyst or programmer fancy the challenge?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 26, 2009, 05:16:12 PM
On other instruments, the aim is to make the flow of a sequence of notes as efficient as possible.
Partly, but the aim might also to get the right tone (an open string versus a stopped string, for example), or to add bounce to the music from a particular picking or bowing pattern.

Quote
Many melodeon players use bellows reversals to add "bounce" to the music, which can mitigate against the most efficient fingering patterns.
True, but that's not the only way to bring bounce to the music.

I just don't buy this idea that melodeon players are somehow uniquely hard done by.  Yes, we face certain problems inherent in our instrument, and there any number of ways of overcome these - including allowing the instrument to impose a certain way of playing, and accepting it.  But players of other instruments face their own difficulties.

Whatever instrument you play, you'll have to work out the best fingering for a particular piece.   Even if you're a singer, and don't play an instrument, you still have to think about breathing and phrasing. It takes time to work on a piece, and you then have to learn and remember it, with or without written annotations.  That's all part of being a musician, regardless of what you play - no one said it would be easy.  

As for those who make it look easy, remember that's the result of hours of study and practice, and often raw talent as well.

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 26, 2009, 05:28:52 PM
Chris, the CADB tab system shows the button numbers above ("P" = poussez - push) or below ("T" = tirez - pull) a line.  The rows are indicated by apostrophes next to the number so 3 indicates the third button on the first row, 3' the third button on the second etc.  Which finger to use can also be identified (the system uses French abbreviations but you could adapt it to English).

It's all explained here:

http://diato.org/exptab2.htm (http://diato.org/exptab2.htm)

If you are playing from someone else's tab then it assumes you have a similar button layout but if it's just for recording your own arrangements it doesn't matter if you have a non-standard keyboard.

The TablEdit program will create tablature for diatonic accordion as well as many other instruments.  Unfortunately it's not based on a D/G box (I can't recall what the tuning is, but I think it's G/C).  You could use it if you transposed the tunes first.  Whether the computer can also work out the best fingering is doubtful, as it's a question of musical judgement as well as technique.

www.tabledit.com (http://www.tabledit.com)
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Falseknight on August 27, 2009, 10:25:27 AM
For the record, I don't think melodeon players are hard done by.  It's like anything else - you play to the strengths of your instrument and technique.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Tyker on August 27, 2009, 12:59:19 PM

Quote
The TablEdit program will create tablature for diatonic accordion as well as many other instruments.  Unfortunately it's not based on a D/G box (I can't recall what the tuning is, but I think it's G/C).  You could use it if you transposed the tunes first.  Whether the computer can also work out the best fingering is doubtful, as it's a question of musical judgement as well as technique.



The default tuning is G/C though you can create your own layout . This is fraught , though , as spaces have to be deleted . ... The best fingering is not worked out ,as far as I can tell .
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 27, 2009, 01:29:38 PM
Thanks Tyker, I was relying on memory as I don't have TablEdit and it's some time since I looked at the trial version.  I didn't realise it was possible to specify another tuning for melodeon, but I don't doubt you're right that it's rather complicated to do.

I don't see how any computer could work out the "best" fingering, since no two players will agree on what is "best" - in any session, just watch the bellows going in different directions as people play the same tune in different ways.  It's a matter of taste and judgement at least as much as it is about technique.

[dragthethreadkickingandscreamingbackontopic]
The computer would also have to know whether the player favoured three fingers or four  ;)
[/dragthethreadkickingandscreamingbackontopic]
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Stiamh on August 27, 2009, 02:33:23 PM
X:1
T:Morpeth Rant
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:D
(3ABc|:"D"d2AG FDFA|"G"BGBd "A"cAce|1"D"d2 ef "G" gfed|"A"c2 e2 e2 (3ABc:|2"D"d2 ef "Em" gfec|"A"A2 "D"d2 d4|


The first time through, in the third bar I'd use the middle finger on the push G (G row) against the G chord, on the repeat I'd use the little finger for the pull G on the D row (against the pulled Em chord).  But if we ever find ourselves in the same session, I can't guarantee I'll play it like this!


OK Howard, I give up  ;D. In suggesting the Morpeth Rant I was thinking I might be able to show you how the 3-finger method works in practice on a one-row tune we have in common so that you could try it and understand what people such as Rees and Andre and myself see as the benefits. But I'm stymied with the cross-rowing, since I don't have a "QB" and can't try the 3-finger approach using the same buttons as you. But thanks again for starting the topic, it's been illuminating.

Chris - I wondered whether you might be joking in throwing out the challenge to a programmer to devise "best fingering." I don't think the result would be very satisfactory, for the reasons Howard mentioned, and also because we all have different sized hands! But even if it were possible, I would hate the idea. Whatever way I end up playing any instrument in the folk tradition, it's important to me that it's my technique, that I have experimented with and worked on and made my own, regardless of any help and pointers received. I'd really encourage you to study what works for you and go down the path Howard recommends - building up a toolkit of patterns and habits that do the job.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 27, 2009, 04:49:52 PM
Surely both?  The three-finger approach is more akin to the playing of scales, i.e. runs, on a piano allowing the wrist to turn easily when repositioning the hand.  When there is a good stretch between notes, then sometimes the little finger comes into play, else you miss the jump.  That is particularly suited when stretching momentarily from the high notes back to the accidentals on a two row. Taking a recent example from the forum, try playing the accidentals in the B part of In the Toyshop without using that little finger!  Incidentally, it's a bitch on the Castagnari reversed accidentals.

Rob.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 27, 2009, 06:34:43 PM
Steve, I'd be equally stymied with a half-step box, so it's not surprising we can't really share our approaches to the tune.  I hardly ever play a tune on just one row, unless I'm deliberately going for a "one-row sound", which can  really suit some tunes.  Usually I'll be playing runs across the rows, right hand chords, octaves, and random twiddly bits.

I've just tried playing Morpeth Rant on just one row, and I agree it's much harder to bring in the fourth finger, and I'm far less tempted to do so, than when I play it on two rows.

I can absolutely understand why 3 fingers are better for anything fast or complicated, and for anything like that I'll usually be using 3 fingers too. The fourth only comes into play (a) when there's a good reason and (b) when it's not too difficult. 

Especially (b)  ;)

Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 27, 2009, 06:39:06 PM
That is particularly suited when stretching momentarily from the high notes back to the accidentals on a two row.

Tell me about it!  I play a 23-button Saltarelle Nuage, which has the low notes and accidentals - useful to have both, but a loooong stretch to reach past the low notes to reach the accidentals.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 28, 2009, 03:08:29 AM
While some might think this off topic - I can personally recommend mowing your lawn as a means to improving manual dexterity. You know that time when the grass blower vent on the petrol mower blocks? Well a finger flicked into the slot can free it without the bother of stopping the engine.

One fortunate side effect of this practice is when you get the flick wrong and the blade tips jams onto the tip of your index finger. While this can be exquisitely painful - it is well worth it as you then have to refinger all your melodeon tunes for fingers 2-3-4 for the next month or so.

So I'd like to personally recommend motor mowing to all here as the perfect way to get that pinky (sorry) moving in the tunes. The 'obvious' alternative of simply sitting down and force-playing those tunes with the outer fingers also works, but it won't get that lawn cut.

.. worked for me  ???

What's a grass blower?

I did say "grass blower vent" - the hole on the side whence the grass cuttings come into the collecting basket (until it blocks)  >:E
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Falseknight on August 28, 2009, 07:42:43 AM
What's a grass blower?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 28, 2009, 08:41:18 AM
By the end of the summer (summer? what summer?) you'll have a perfect lawn, and the ability to play all your melodeon tunes with a single finger.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 28, 2009, 10:20:30 AM
I remember attending a workshop on Zydeco accordion run by Roy Carriere, a well respected Louisiana musician. I couldn't work out what he was doing with the right hand until it dawned on me that his index finger was missing!
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: rees on August 28, 2009, 10:26:32 AM
I've just been watching the Charlie Harris clips on the Bellows Tape thread. He's most definitely a three finger man and what a player!
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 28, 2009, 11:02:09 AM
Hemeto Pascoal, as seen in the video Andy Cutting linked to, appears to use three fingers.

I wonder whether it's something to do with the mechanics of the hand, and trying to use the little finger when playing really fast actually slows down the other fingers, so it's better to keep it out of the way.  I don't think I've noticed that effect, but I don't play anything nearly as fast as Hermeto is doing in that video.  I wouldn't use the little finger as much if I were playing reasonably fast, simply because I can't control it so well at speed. 
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 29, 2009, 08:31:57 AM
Quote
Hemeto Pascoal, as seen in the video Andy Cutting linked to, appears to use three fingers.
Obviously Hermeto also has a lawn and a dodgy lawn-mower ;D
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: waltzman on August 30, 2009, 08:07:14 PM
I find it interesting that four fingers are recommended for the left side of the box which has 8 buttons and three fingers are recommended for the right side which has 21.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: george garside on August 31, 2009, 09:13:25 AM
I find it interesting that four fingers are recommended for the left side of the box which has 8 buttons and three fingers are recommended for the right side which has 21.

only by some players!  I & many others advocate using 4 fingers on the treble end & 2 on the bass for most of the time or as the 'default method' so to speak.  The important thing is that neither is right or wrong.  To play well there is also the need to avoid any  dogmatic rules and in essence to use what you have got to best advantage .  This does not apply to playing particular tunes as a whole but more to how you vary the use of fingers according to the need of particular bits of tune.

george
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Theo on August 31, 2009, 11:11:05 AM
... three fingers are recommended for the right side which has 21.

My  impression is that it's mainly B/C and C#/D players who favour three fingers, and D/G etc are more likely to use four.   There is a reason for this.  If you play across the rows on a D/G then there is a longer stretch to reach some common combinations of buttons than there would be on a semitone box.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 01, 2009, 04:56:10 PM
Just returned from Towersey, to read many interesting points of view.

In response to Steve and Howard, I don't advocate the idea of fingering notation as giving a 'best' answer, and I don't think that is the way forward.  My original suggestion was that it might be a way of reminding yourself as a player how you had decided was how you wanted to play it, which might cut down learning time. 

The programming idea was certainly serious, though I don't think it very likely it would ever be developed!  Again, it wasn't ever intended to predict the 'best' fingering, for the very good reasons which everybody has set out - but I bet there are still some underlying rules to how buttons and hands work (like not getting you to play button sequences which no hand could ever reach), and I bet a whizz kid could research this and come up with some useful predicted easiest fingerings, which could then be used to try out and practice from.

I looked at the French system that people have suggested, but from the examples I found it seems that there is rather too much duplicated information for it to be quick enough to understand in fast playing mode - my concept was more that you annotate the difficult bits only with rows or fingering, as a reminder.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Hello on September 08, 2009, 09:59:56 PM
I think this question, 3 fingers or 4, is somewhat influenced by the age-old thumb on the edge or behind the keyboard debate.
With the tip of the thumb on the edge, it seems that the little finger is too far off the keyboard which may encourage 3-fingered use?
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Theo on September 09, 2009, 08:40:14 AM
I think this question, 3 fingers or 4, is somewhat influenced by the age-old thumb on the edge or behind the keyboard debate.
With the tip of the thumb on the edge, it seems that the little finger is too far off the keyboard which may encourage 3-fingered use?

Almost always I have my thumb on the edge of the keyboard, and have never found it difficult to use the pinkie.    But its not the tip of my thumb on the edge, the thumb is almost lying flat on the edge.   It feels quite natural and relaxed to me.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 09, 2009, 09:25:28 AM
There are two situations where I find the 4th finger particularly useful.  The first is where there's lots of stretch necessary - I accept you could often just move your whole hand instead, but then you risk losing exact position.  There are even some combinations that seem to me to be would be just about unplayable, unless you make huge hand jumps at a very fast speed.   The second is there are a number of common triplet runs that seem easy to play fast using say 3rd, 4th, and 2nd finger on say G row, D row, third row, (all push or all pull) leaving you in position to play the next note with the first finger.  Perhaps it's just the shape of my hand, but these rolls just seem to fall naturally into place.  I find them easier and cleaner than a slide technique, for many note combinations.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: george garside on September 09, 2009, 10:21:28 AM
its not realy a question of either or or even of a different style of playing. Some tunes (or parts thereof) are easier/ simpler with 3 fingers & others are greatly assisted by using the pinky  .  Its also down to what works best for the individual but its probably best to avoid the 'i'm a 3 finger player' and he's' a four finger playr' aproach.

provided you are using 2 straps its also possible to make maximum use of what you've got by playing the melody in the top octave and using the thumb to add nice low notes in much the same way as an organist does with the foot  keys, lumps of wood or whatever you call them.  Works well for waltzes

george
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Howard Jones on September 09, 2009, 11:09:03 AM
With the tip of the thumb on the edge, it seems that the little finger is too far off the keyboard which may encourage 3-fingered use?

When I use the edge it's just the tip of the thumb, but I simply don't recognise this problem.  I angle my hand and wrist so all four fingers fall easily onto the keyboard.  See the attached photo.

Perhaps it's just me, or perhaps it's because I'm so used to using the little finger, but after some experimentation I've found it quite hard to find a position which leaves the little finger too far off the keyboard which doesn't involve an uncomfortable and unnatural wrist position. 

The only time this might arise is if I stretch my hand down the keyboard while leaving the thumb in place - but in that situation I simply slide the thumb down the edge of the keyboard as well.
Title: Re: 3 fingers or 4?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 09, 2009, 12:37:41 PM
A classic case of needing the fourth finger for ornamentation has just cropped up on another thread, where Rees asked for the name of a tune which is called the Grand Hornpipe and someone else provided the sheet music for it. I don't think I would be able to play the grace notes in the first three bars of the B music if I didn't use my little finger to flick the high A on the D row.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal