Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: rileycat on February 01, 2019, 06:44:46 PM
-
A friend has told me that he varnished the inside of his Hohner and it made a noticeable improvement to the tone. Not sure what to think. He lives away so I can't verify this opinion. Has anyone else tried this? Might it work, any thoughts folks?
-
Some people varnish the insides of drumshells, claiming it improves focus and tone projection,... whether its true or just a "perceived" improvement I'm unsure, others more expert than me will doubtless be along soon to advise you whether it might work on melodeons.
-
Before making any change I would be asking myself if I am happy with the sound now. If yes do nothing. If no do the well understood mods first such as tuning.
-
May just have made it more airtight ;)
SJ
-
A friend has told me that he varnished the inside of his Hohner and it made a noticeable improvement to the tone. Not sure what to think. He lives away so I can't verify this opinion. Has anyone else tried this? Might it work, any thoughts folks?
It's possible that it might make the sound brighter by reducing absorption of high frequencies into the wood -- for example, this has been found to be true for concert halls and recording studios.
It's equally possible that it will make no notieable difference, given Strasser's comments about different box materials making no difference to the sound -- see https://www.harmonika.com/en/interesting
What's certain is that you can't just take the word of somebody who claims it's made a difference when they know it's been done, there are literally thousands of cases like this in many fields -- when people expect there to be a difference they'll often find one, it's called "expectation bias".
Musical instruments are unfortunately a field like hi-fi where much superficially plausible claptrap is spouted as if it's the gospel truth -- and very often under close examination turns out to be wrong...
-
[
Musical instruments are unfortunately a field like hi-fi where much superficially plausible claptrap is spouted as if it's the gospel truth -- and very often under close examination turns out to be wrong...
Yes, melodeon fake news.
I have varnished Hohner, Paolo Soprani and my own Wesson reed-blocks and compared them directly with equivalent unvarnished blocks and can honestly say that "sometimes it makes a difference and sometimes it doesn't". Is that clear?
-
It does mean that wax doesn’t stick so well to reed blocks.
-
Seemingly, the big Russian bayans all have varnished insides. If nothing else, they look great and must be easier to keep clean.
-
It does mean that wax doesn’t stick so well to reed blocks.
True dat
-
It does mean that wax doesn’t stick so well to reed blocks.
True dat
Castagnari varnish the internal floor of the reed chambers and possibly the side walls (can't remember off-hand without opening up one of my boxes) but the top edges of the reed chamber walls are left unvarnished. So the wax sticks OK.
-
Seemingly, the big Russian bayans all have varnished insides. If nothing else, they look great and must be easier to keep clean.
Yes, maybe we need a thread about how often we dust the insides of our boxes..
-
"Yes, maybe we need a thread about how often we dust the insides of our boxes.."
Only if we want to send half of the melodeon world on a guilt trip!
-
"Yes, maybe we need a thread about how often we dust the insides of our boxes.."
Only if we want to send half of the melodeon world on a guilt trip!
I blow the dust ut of mine every time I play it.
-
true castagnari varnish the inside of the reed blocks only so wax will bond to hold the reeds in place i was talking to martin quinn and he recently coated the inside of reed blocks with pearl glue and has for years coated the inside of the treble end of the hohner accordions that he turbos with great results
-
A friend has told me that he varnished the inside of his Hohner and it made a noticeable improvement to the tone. Not sure what to think. He lives away so I can't verify this opinion. Has anyone else tried this? Might it work, any thoughts folks?
Many, many years ago, I read a very detailed and technical book on guitar construction.
The received wisdom there was (I paraphrase), the internal surfaces of the body of the
instrument, including the strutting should be as smooth as possible. This was to be achieved
by sanding the surfaces with the finest paper obtainable, rather than by varnishing, but I
guess the principle is the same?
-
I'm anything but technical, but the pearl glue job sounds like the way to go, to me.
Purely subjective of course, and no science at all to back it up. But the dry old pearl glue I've come across in the few instruments which I've had to bits seems very hard, and very smooth. I'm certain that sound waves must just bounce off it, without losing any of their "life-force".
If I wasn't so lazy, I might even have given it a try.
-
[
Musical instruments are unfortunately a field like hi-fi where much superficially plausible claptrap is spouted as if it's the gospel truth -- and very often under close examination turns out to be wrong...
Yes, melodeon fake news.
I have varnished Hohner, Paolo Soprani and my own Wesson reed-blocks and compared them directly with equivalent unvarnished blocks and can honestly say that "sometimes it makes a difference and sometimes it doesn't". Is that clear?
My bet (like Strasser) would be that varnish on the inside of a case doesn't, but I'd be happy to be proved wrong. Note the word "proved", opinions don't count no matter whose they are. With reed blocks it's more likely to make a difference becuase the SPL inside a reed block is way higher than inside a case, and a small amount of sound absorption is more likely to make a difference because of this.
I suppose that when you did the comparison, you got somebody else to swap them over and did a blind A-B-X comparison so you didn't know which one you were listening to?
Because if you didn't I'm afraid it still proves nothing -- there are literally *hundreds* of cases in many different fields (e.g. ultra-expensive cables, musical instruments, food and drink) where people have been absolutely 100% convinced that they could tell the difference, when blind trials proved that they couldn't. Sorry to go on about this, I'm in no way accusing you of deliberately making things up, people are genuinely convinced that they can tell the difference. Also knowledge and experience in the field has nothing to do with it, the most experienced instrument maker/cook/hi-fi nut is just as susceptible to this as a novice -- you expect it to make a difference, so it does.
So you might well be right, but if you knew which you were listening to you haven't proved it. If you didn't, well done for making a (rare!) scientifically valid comparison ;-)
-
A friend has told me that he varnished the inside of his Hohner and it made a noticeable improvement to the tone. Not sure what to think. He lives away so I can't verify this opinion. Has anyone else tried this? Might it work, any thoughts folks?
Many, many years ago, I read a very detailed and technical book on guitar construction.
The received wisdom there was (I paraphrase), the internal surfaces of the body of the
instrument, including the strutting should be as smooth as possible. This was to be achieved
by sanding the surfaces with the finest paper obtainable, rather than by varnishing, but I
guess the principle is the same?
Not at all the same, because in a guitar the body and the resonances within it are fundamentally responsible for making the sound of the instrument -- so if it did make a difference in a guitar, this doesn't mean it would in a melodeon.
Also received wisdom has been shown on many occasions to be basically fairy tales -- and in other cases, to be true. No way to tell which is the case for smooth guitar surfaces, it's one of those things that sounds plausible at first but might well not be true.
Having said all this, if you want to varnish the inside it's unlikely to do any harm and might just possibly make a difference -- or at least you're convinced it does, which amounts to the same thing as far as you're concerned :-)
-
true castagnari varnish the inside of the reed blocks only so wax will bond to hold the reeds in place i was talking to martin quinn and he recently coated the inside of reed blocks with pearl glue and has for years coated the inside of the treble end of the hohner accordions that he turbos with great results
I'm sure the boxes he turbos sound great. Whether any of this is due to varnishing the inside of the treble end is the point in question, and so far the jury is out as far as I can see...
-
Not at all the same, because in a guitar the body and the resonances within it are fundamentally responsible for making the sound of the instrument -- so if it did make a difference in a guitar, this doesn't mean it would in a melodeon.
Aye, that was what I wasn't really sure about - I 'knew' what was supposed to happen with a
guitar - not so sure about what goes on inside a melodeon...
-
Most grateful for the thoughts, folks. I should have said that my friend also sanded the inside smooth prior to varnishing. I failed to ask him what sort of 'varnish' was used - was it a cellulose spray type or plain old yacht varnish? I'm very aware of Ian's wise words about subjective impressions, but I think I might try it out on my old Erika, but not on the reed blocks. Inevitably, though, it'll be a subjective view as I don't have a clue how to measure the 'improvement' or lack of same in any meaningful way except how I feel about it! Any thoughts on varnish type before the deed takes place!!?
-
Theo varnished my red cedar reed blocks for me. Didn't change the sound as far as I can tell. That was about 5 years ago and no wax problems. Did smell for a while of course. My Brandoni accordion was also varnished. Great sounding box.
-
Any thoughts on varnish type before the deed takes place!!?
If your box is dull-sounding, use high-gloss varnish to brighten it. If too brash, try satin or matte. ;)
-
[
Musical instruments are unfortunately a field like hi-fi where much superficially plausible claptrap is spouted as if it's the gospel truth -- and very often under close examination turns out to be wrong...
Yes, melodeon fake news.
I have varnished Hohner, Paolo Soprani and my own Wesson reed-blocks and compared them directly with equivalent unvarnished blocks and can honestly say that "sometimes it makes a difference and sometimes it doesn't". Is that clear?
My bet (like Strasser) would be that varnish on the inside of a case doesn't, but I'd be happy to be proved wrong. Note the word "proved", opinions don't count no matter whose they are. With reed blocks it's more likely to make a difference becuase the SPL inside a reed block is way higher than inside a case, and a small amount of sound absorption is more likely to make a difference because of this.
I suppose that when you did the comparison, you got somebody else to swap them over and did a blind A-B-X comparison so you didn't know which one you were listening to?
Because if you didn't I'm afraid it still proves nothing -- there are literally *hundreds* of cases in many different fields (e.g. ultra-expensive cables, musical instruments, food and drink) where people have been absolutely 100% convinced that they could tell the difference, when blind trials proved that they couldn't. Sorry to go on about this, I'm in no way accusing you of deliberately making things up, people are genuinely convinced that they can tell the difference. Also knowledge and experience in the field has nothing to do with it, the most experienced instrument maker/cook/hi-fi nut is just as susceptible to this as a novice -- you expect it to make a difference, so it does.
So you might well be right, but if you knew which you were listening to you haven't proved it. If you didn't, well done for making a (rare!) scientifically valid comparison ;-)
The point I was making and you apparently missed was that I actually proved nothing!!!
-
You proved it’s more work I’m sure.
When talking about varnish here, are we taking about several coats ( sand and tack and all that 3 or four times ) or just a sealer coat?
-
The point I was making and you apparently missed was that I actually proved nothing!!!
You proved that some reed blocks, in your perception, sound better than others, Rees.
-
Or do they, or is it the reeds or the box or the fairies in the music?
-
...Any thoughts on varnish type before the deed takes place!!?
I would have thought that yacht varnish (with which I do have some experience) was a bit 'heavy-duty'
for an application such as this?
-
FWIW Just to update. I took out the reed blocks etc., masked, then cleaned, smoothed (a very small amount) and lightly sprayed some matt varnish inside my Erika. Result - no detectable difference to my ear, just a slightly different smell for a few playings!! Told friend and he said 'oh' - so that ends my experiment, but at least nothing got spoiled and it's now very clean inside :D.
-
I think that might be called (in footballing parlance) a "result"!
-
I suspect that removing the "Hohner" logo and replacing it with a "Castagnari" one might have the same effect on some boxes. Ears are very unreliable measuring instruments. Boxes have been built for long enough for the cardinal points of good design and construction to have been established. If internal varnishing (which wouldn't add greatly to production cost) made any significant improvement, it would have been widely adopted long ago.
-
I might try polishing inside my mistreated D/G Erica, aka Dent, to try to diminish the smell of cigarettes.
I do wish my husband had not thrown away the huge tin of furniture polish I had - the smell was pure nostalgia and used to combat my father's smoking habit for several days each week.
Removing the cloth from the grille has made a big difference, but now that the smells from the work I did with various glues and fillers are dispersing the pong of nicotine is becoming apparent again.
-
I might try polishing inside my mistreated D/G Erica, aka Dent, to try to diminish the smell of cigarettes.
I do wish my husband had not thrown away the huge tin of furniture polish I had - the smell was pure nostalgia and used to combat my father's smoking habit for several days each week.
Removing the cloth from the grille has made a big difference, but now that the smells from the work I did with various glues and fillers are dispersing the pong of nicotine is becoming apparent again.
Try Febreze (https://www.supersavvyme.co.uk/brands/febreze/) fabric deodoriser. It's often the bellows which retains the smell of cigarette smoke. Spray lightly inside the bellows and leave to dry naturally. Just a slight dampening is all that's needed. Don't saturate the folds otherwise they might disintegrate!
Repeat a day or so later if necessary. You can also treat the outside of the bellows the same way.
If you want to similarly treat the wood interior of the casework, remove the reed blocks first. Don't spray those.
-
A nice “parfum†of your choice can also be used and might suit the olfactory sense better, though cost is more!
I have used retro 80’s male fragrances that have a bit more staying power than today’s metrosexual eau de toilettes. (Another acquisition disorder.)
Stinky boxes down at the session. 8)
-
A nice “parfum†of your choice can also be used and might suit the olfactory sense better, though cost is more!
I have used retro 80’s male fragrances that have a bit more staying power than today’s metrosexual eau de toilettes. (Another acquisition disorder.)
Stinky boxes down at the session. 8)
Hmm, shall I go for the Brut or the Karate?
-
A treatment I use for stinky bellows is to wipe all surfaces inside and out (especially the bellows) with a cloth dipped in a detergent solution and then squeezed out. I think this is effective because it removes a lot of surface dust as well as other contamination.
-
A nice “parfum†of your choice can also be used and might suit the olfactory sense better, though cost is more!
I have used retro 80’s male fragrances that have a bit more staying power than today’s metrosexual eau de toilettes. (Another acquisition disorder.)
Stinky boxes down at the session. 8)
Hmm, shall I go for the Brut or the Karate?
Aramis, Kouros or Lapidus pour homme. ;D
-
A nice “parfum†of your choice can also be used and might suit the olfactory sense better, though cost is more!
Hmm, shall I go for the Brut or the Karate?
Aramis, Kouros or Lapidus pour homme. ;D
D & G of course.
-
Not certain of the practicality with melodeons but apart from it's affinity with superglue, bicarbonate of soda powder absorbs all sorts of long term smells, our various thermos & other containers are treated to a spoonful or two after washing & drying and are fresh and ready for use next time needed. Also pretty effective in my workboots, trainers and wellies - although it is recommended to empty out before you put them on the next time.
A long shallow tray folded up from ali foil or a cloth 'sock' might be worth trying.
-
This discussion (and others about whether this or that parameter has an influence on the sound) almost makes me want to design a big experiment where we'd test each parameter one-at-a-time on a neutral and repeatable set-up.
-
I think you'll find that yacht varnish is significantly higher tech and more costly than the rather crude cellulose "varnish" which is really a lacquer. Indeed, in the guitar world, Gibson brag ad nauseum about how their guitars are cellulose sprayed. I suspect it's cheaper than the polyurethane used on the Epiphone budget copy...
Rob.
-
Does polyurethane shine all the way through, like cellulose? I used to love to see the shine on black cellulose paint deepen with each application of Mepo!