Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Chris Marriott on November 05, 2020, 03:40:15 PM
-
My "squeezebox" background is firstly the Anglo concertina which, although a diatonic instrument, can be played chromatically over almost three octaves, and secondly the chromatic button accordion, which is chromatic over four octaves. I've just bought a DG melodeon and I find myself curiously and probably entirely needlessly "stressed" about the fact that it isn't a chromatic instrument :).
I know there are chromatic versions of the melodeon around, like the Irish B/C layout, and some of the 2 1/2 and 3-row instruments too. Is the relative scarcity of such instruments simply a reflection of the fact that the standard folk music repertoire of the melodeon doesn't require the "missing" notes? Probably a completely daft question to ask, I know, and I apologise in advance for that. I'm still trying to get my head around what I can and can't play on it.
Cheers,
Chris
-
Um..... I think I'd say relax, it doesn't matter..... much!
There tends to be two types of 2 row DG's, one with the first botton on each row under the chin as accidentals or the other with low notes.
The accidentals give you choromaticity within the stave - G#, Bb, (C# on the D row ) D# and Fnat.
The one a lot of us miss is a low Fnat just below the stave.
There are tons of English tunes that don't need an accidental, or can be accommodated with the ones on the accidentals you have on the two rows.
If you have a tune needing an accidental you don't have means you have choices - fudge it by skipping over it, harmonising, or ignoring it to list a few.
Transposing the key from G to D will raise a pesky low Fnat to a C# in a tune, or keeping it in the key of G but playing a phrase up an octave can utilise the higher Fnat.
Or..... simply choose another of the thousands of tunes out there!
Part of the fun of a 2 row is embracing it's flaws and working out how to get round them.
It took me a while to understand this concept but I got there in the end!
Cheers.
Q
-
....ps .
Chris, no question is too daft, though I appear to frequently test the accuracy of this statement ::)
-
Yes, it really does matter. DG wasn't adopted in England because it was a 'good system', but for quite other (and quite interesting) reasons. And all the 'accidentals' and 'helper rows' still don't (IMHO) turn it into a 'good system' though clearly large numbers of people are having tremendous fun playing them.
I've just been playing the 'Lament for President Garfield', the last US president, so far, to be shot. Apparently in B mixolydian. Not a problem on a semitone box, I genuinely don't know whether it is as straightforward on a DG? Maybe someone can try it?
-
They’re different instruments with different strengths and weaknesses. Melodeons weigh about a quarter of a similar chromatic squeezebox. With artful use of the chin end accidentals there are many tunes which can be played in full, although the corresponding basses and chords are a bit thin on the ground. If you start looking at two and a half and three row instruments with umpteen basses then the weight approaches a small CBA, so you’re back where you started.
In my opinion the melodeon should be enjoyed for what it is, lightweight, easily portable, but eventually best used to play diatonic melodies. If you want to play jazz and complicated tunes which modulate through several keys then stick with your CBA. Horses for courses.
-
Um..... I think I'd say relax, it doesn't matter..... much!
There tends to be two types of 2 row DG's, one with the first botton on each row under the chin as accidentals or the other with low notes.
My Pokerwork seems to be of the latter type. On the G row I have B/D and on the D row F#/A, so no additional accidentals.
Chris
-
They’re different instruments with different strengths and weaknesses. Melodeons weigh about a quarter of a similar chromatic squeezebox. With artful use of the chin end accidentals there are many tunes which can be played in full, although the corresponding basses and chords are a bit thin on the ground. If you start looking at two and a half and three row instruments with umpteen basses then the weight approaches a small CBA, so you’re back where you started.
In my opinion the melodeon should be enjoyed for what it is, lightweight, easily portable, but eventually best used to play diatonic melodies. If you want to play jazz and complicated tunes which modulate through several keys then stick with your CBA. Horses for courses.
Thanks, Chris, that makes a lot of sense. The reason I went from a piano accordion to a CBA was because the CBA was so much lighter (and more rationally arranged), and the melodeon is far lighter than the CBA. I need to learn to appreciate the melodeon on its own merits (although I may still buy a B/C box to quell my chromatic urges...).
Cheers,
Chris
-
Those low reeds can easily be swopped for accidental reeds.
My preferred system which I have used for the last 45 years is to have B/D on the G row and accidentals G#/A# on the D row.
I can live without D#/F but B/D is absolutely essential for the stuff that I play.
-
'For the stuff that I play....' Rees has it in a nutshell!
The tunes that I play, my D# is probabley my most used accidental.
Essentially we all play our own set of tunes we've assembled - because that's what we like playing. Therefore our requirements to be able to play those tunes will differ.
-
They’re different instruments with different strengths and weaknesses. Melodeons weigh about a quarter of a similar chromatic squeezebox. With artful use of the chin end accidentals there are many tunes which can be played in full, although the corresponding basses and chords are a bit thin on the ground. If you start looking at two and a half and three row instruments with umpteen basses then the weight approaches a small CBA, so you’re back where you started.
In my opinion the melodeon should be enjoyed for what it is, lightweight, easily portable, but eventually best used to play diatonic melodies. If you want to play jazz and complicated tunes which modulate through several keys then stick with your CBA. Horses for courses.
Thanks, Chris, that makes a lot of sense. The reason I went from a piano accordion to a CBA was because the CBA was so much lighter (and more rationally arranged), and the melodeon is far lighter than the CBA. I need to learn to appreciate the melodeon on its own merits (although I may still buy a B/C box to quell my chromatic urges...).
Cheers,
Chris
Don’t speak too freely about the CBA or they’ll all want one.🤫
-
Not me 😁
-
...although I may still buy a B/C box to quell my chromatic urges...
Chris
I am open to correction on this but my impression is that the BC system has been largely superseded by the C#D. I'm sure that someone who plays chromatic systems could clarify.
-
I am open to correction on this but my impression is that the BC system has been largely superseded by the C#D. I'm sure that someone who plays chromatic systems could clarify.
No, that's not correct Greg. You might get that impression, but it's only because we C#/D players are a vociferous minority.
-
In my opinion the melodeon should be enjoyed for what it is, lightweight, easily portable, but eventually best used to play diatonic melodies. If you want to play jazz and complicated tunes which modulate through several keys then stick with your CBA. Horses for courses.
Yes, this. Spot on Chris! (:)
-
I am open to correction on this but my impression is that the BC system has been largely superseded by the C#D. I'm sure that someone who plays chromatic systems could clarify.
My understanding is that B/C is still the dominant system, in Ireland and at large, but that there is currently a relative resurgence of interest in the older C#/D system (self included). The question is mostly one of playing across the rows with fewer bellows changes, at least in the most common keys (B/C), versus playing mostly along the row (C#/D).
Keys on the row on a C#/D: D, G, Em, Amix, Bm, and on the outer row, C#, F#, Ebm, Bbmix, Bbm.
Keys on the row on a B/C: C, F, Dm, Gmix, Am, and on the outer row, B, E, C#m, F#mix, Abm. (Less common, at least in my repertoire.)
At least, mostly on the row. Some of these require dipping into the other row for a note or two.
Keys across the row: the others! Some more intuitively than others.
-
Chris, you already have options.
If you need to play a tune more chromatically, you can fall back on your Anglo surely?
I realise we are all throwing ideas around, but have no idea of the type of tunes you play?
I play mainly English tunes and though some of the unusual ones we seem to be finding digging into manuscripts, the accidentals I have are fine for ~ 95% if not more of the tunes I find.
You might be worrying unnecessarily!
-
Agreed that it absolutely isn't a concern until you decide there's a tune you want to play, and you don't have the notes. Might as well cross that bridge when it comes.
That said, for what it's worth, a couple of other thoughts: a quint system gives you many more options for chords, harmonies, and basses, so your playing style (either your current style, or the style you intend to learn) matters as much as your repertoire.
And finally, nothing wrong with having two* boxes!
* subject to interpretation
-
And finally, nothing wrong with having two* boxes!
"Two" meaning "an arbitrary integer greater than one", presumably? 🤫
-
You might be worrying unnecessarily!
I'm sure you're right about that!
What sort of tunes do I like? Well, I'm a classically-trained pianist, but on my squeezeboxes I love playing traditional music of all kinds. I have a particular fondness for tunes like sea shanties. I'm sure I'll have no difficulty in finding enough tunes to play on my Pokerwork!
Thanks to everyone for the great advice,
Chris
-
These instruments became so popular because they suited the music people wanted to play. Most British folk tunes are diatonic and can easily be played on a melodeon, although you might have to transpose them into a suitable key. Yes, the melodeon is limited, but it's only a problem if you want to play music it was never designed for.
-
Everything as per above. The great things about a DG are its lightness, and … natural percussiveness in play, great for rumbustuous English dance tunes. Not so easy for Irish tradition which seems to flow easier on BC or C#D systems.
Here in Britain the DG also “finds†the right chords very easily, or many plan the tune from left side chords … and then rt end notes magically work! Surprisingly few folk tunes need long complex thought wrt fingering once you have the feel of the instrument.
If you are into chromaticism, stick with CBA. so much more logical and just a few generic fingerings. But around twice the weight to lug round at festivals.
-
Everything as per above. The great things about a DG are its lightness, and … natural percussiveness in play, great for rumbustuous English dance tunes. Not so easy for Irish tradition which seems to flow easier on BC or C#D systems.
Here in Britain the DG also “finds†the right chords very easily, or many plan the tune from left side chords … and then rt end notes magically work! Surprisingly few folk tunes need long complex thought wrt fingering once you have the feel of the instrument.
If you are into chromaticism, stick with CBA. so much more logical and just a few generic fingerings. But around twice the weight to lug round at festivals.
. Correct. Except if you want a 120 bass four voice with *casotto* then you’re talking hernia inducing, needing a trolley to lug around. And only playable while seated unless you’re Arnold Schwarzenegger in his prime.
-
Everything as per above. The great things about a DG are its lightness, and … natural percussiveness in play, great for rumbustuous English dance tunes. Not so easy for Irish tradition which seems to flow easier on BC or C#D systems.
A big difference between semitone and fourth apart systems is in the choice of fingerings available. On a BC or C#D, only a few notes are available in both bellows directions. So there's usually no choice. This is good in some ways as it means you don't get stuck choosing between the alternatives and you have to master the fingerings and bellows control required. On a DG, most notes can be found on both push and pull so you can choose how much legato playing you want to do in one bellows direction by crossing rows and how much press and draw along the row you want to do. This can be as much of a curse as a blessing but IMHO it allows you to play Irish or any other music with as much flow as you want.
-
I am open to correction on this but my impression is that the BC system has been largely superseded by the C#D. I'm sure that someone who plays chromatic systems could clarify.
No, that's not correct Greg. You might get that impression, but it's only because we C#/D players are a vociferous minority.
And then there’s the even smaller minority of us who like to do things backwards and play D/C#. Of course, we secretly know it’s everyone else that has it backwards ;D. Kidding, kidding...
-
I am open to correction on this but my impression is that the BC system has been largely superseded by the C#D. I'm sure that someone who plays chromatic systems could clarify.
No, that's not correct Greg. You might get that impression, but it's only because we C#/D players are a vociferous minority.
;D
I'm glad I was cautious in my assumptions.
So, is BC still a common choice?
-
If you are into chromaticism, stick with CBA. so much more logical and just a few generic fingerings. But around twice the weight to lug round at festivals.
The Pokerwork weighs 2.6kg. My Hohner Nova III 96-bass CBA is at the "small and light" end of the CBA range and it weighs 7.6kg. Some weigh as much as 16kg! So weight is very definitely a factor; that's one reason I want to learn to play the melodeon. The concertina is even smaller and lighter, of course, but with its single reed it can sound a bit "thin" and it's not nearly as good from the accompaniment point of view, either. The melodeon seems like an ideal middle ground between weight and capabilities for when I really don't want to haul the CBA around.
-
So, is BC still a common choice?
Very much so. Between 1955 and about 1975 probably, in Ireland more or less everybody played "B 'n' C". And while, as Gonk wrote, the popularity of the C#/D has grown steadily since 1975, B/C still dominates and I don't think there is much danger of its being swept aside or superseded.
D/C# has been undergoing a bit of a revival in Québec in the past 15 years or so, infecting Matt and other good one-row players. It will be interesting to see how that tiny minority within a slightly larger minority develops. ;)
-
If you start looking at two and a half and three row instruments with umpteen basses then the weight approaches a small CBA, so you’re back where you started.
Not necessarily, actually. There are plenty of models, starting from 2.5r and going to full 3r with a weight that starts at barely more than 3 kg and that have all the notes from the chromatic scale (although, being melodeons, arranged according to two diatonic scales) on two octaves.
That being said, the DG standard accordions are perfectly fine, as other people said earlier !
-
Hi Chris (belated) welcome to the MAD house.
Not chromatic- does it matter ?
No. The melodeon is a diatonic instrument. The accordion was invented in 1829 to play a range of chords, enabling a singer to accompany themselves and was intended as a lightweight instrument a traveller could take with them for self accompaiement. The melodeon is a development in which a row of bi-sonoric single note buttons was provided giving a diatonic scale enabling the user to play a melody. The bass was reduced to two buttons.
Arguably the melodeon is the ancestor of the ghetto blaster. Totally portable and made lots of noise, to the joy of the owner and the costernation of the classically trained.
It's a melodeon 'cos it can play a melody.
In Scotland a melodeon can be a two row semitone box with limited basses. Or a 1 row. In Ireland if it's got 2 rows it's an accordion.
BC is the common semitone box in Gaelic Scotland. which is bizarre because apart from the odd tune in A minor, the only key less common than C in instrumental music is B
-
BC is the common semitone box in Gaelic Scotland. which is bizarre because apart from the odd tune in A minor, the only key less common than C in instrumental music is B
Not bizarre at all, because playing in keys on like G,D or A on a BC box using the notes on both rows is what gives the BC box it's unique character. No-one ever set out to play them in B and C
-
BC is the common semitone box in Gaelic Scotland. which is bizarre because apart from the odd tune in A minor, the only key less common than C in instrumental music is B
Not bizarre at all, because playing in keys on like G,D or A on a BC box using the notes on both rows is what gives the BC box it's unique character. No-one ever set out to play them in B and C
You are of course right. It only seems strange to me because my initial interest was in "little black box" one rows .
P
-
This has been a really interesting thread to follow. I went from playing the fiddle for years to the box (the move was partly caused by an injury that literally forced my hand). I went for a diatonic system as that is what most of my friends played. I did have a go on a CBA but it was just too big for my liking. With a two row DG diatonic system I kept on finding tunes that I knew on the fiddle were unobtainable (lack of an F etc). So I eventually moved to a three row. With a row of accidentals this open up keys like D minor, G minor etc that I was after. As time has gone by I’m more and more comfortable that I’ve got everything that I think I would need. Sometimes I lack basses to do what I really want to do (my DG’s are 12 bass), but I work around that. So to the issue of chromatics. When the violin was my main instrument and I was playing trad, I was working round a number of keys and modes. I now have these available on the box (the system is not always logical and it sometimes involves a bit of muscle memory, but it’s there). In the trad world some keys never came up. I don’t know any tunes in the key of C# major for example. So the fact that would be hard work on my layout does not bother me. I’m not going to play in that key anyway. I’ve got all the keys I would like to a greater or lesser extent so no need to worry about the esoteric others. Some fit better on the box (and I’ll be honest that I also have a G/C as I find a lot of the European stuff I like to play just sounds better on that box). The issue, if there is one, comes with playing with others. Fine if it’s trad tunes, but I do miss the free form way I was able to ‘jam’ on the fiddle. There are a lot of keys and modes that are there, but there are others where I have to sit and physically work out where the notes are (that’ll be C# major then). The more esoteric keys just don’t flow. You can find the notes, but it’s hard work. But here is the thing, over my time playing a diatonic box (and I stand as a relative newcomer compared to some of the esteemed members at Melnet), I’ve come to accept that the limitations are what makes the system fun. Accidentals, a half row or full third row, can give you more options. But alternatively, if a two row system gives you all the keys for the music you want to play then that is fine. To quote my father in law, who when I asked if I could borrow his pokerwork to see if I got on with the box ‘it’s not chromatic you know’. I laughed at the time thinking a third row would give me that goal. But now I am really not that bothered that it doesn’t (or at least not in any real practical sense), it’s limitations are also its greatest strengths. Apologies for the rambling post (:)
-
Not bizarre at all, because playing in keys on like G,D or A on a BC box using the notes on both rows is what gives the BC box it's unique character. No-one ever set out to play them in B and C
In East Anglia, and in Lincolnshire too, going by the old manuscript collections, many of the traditional tunes played in the 19th and into the 20th century were in the key of C. When the melodoen started to become popular, there were no D/G boxes. The only instruments available were in C/C#, B/C, C/F Club system boxes, or one rows in C or G. Musicians like Oscar Woods played a one-row in C, Cecil Pearl played on the C-row of a C/C# box, as did Percy Brown. Dolly Curtis played in C on a B/C box.
East Anglian playing style was (and still is) almost exclusively up-and-down the row. On two-row instruments, there was little or no attempt to do any cross-row playing and minor key dance tunes were unheard of. Playing in C# or B major wasn't much use to anyone, so perhaps in some ways the choice of the available boxes rather determined the keys in which tunes were played in.
When the D/G melodeon started to become available in the mid-1950s and 1960s, players such as Percy Brown and George Craske used them in addition to their C/C# or Club instruments, and tunes in D started to be played, and tunes originally in C gradually became played in D instead. Sadly, the key of C is falling into disuse, even in East Anglia; such a pity as it is a lovely key to hear and play.
-
I've just bought a DG melodeon and I find myself curiously and probably entirely needlessly "stressed" about the fact that it isn't a chromatic instrument :).
If it is causing you to feel stressed; then I would say it definitely is a problem.
I'm surprised you didn't realize the fact before you made your purchase.
The solution to your dilemma should be fairly obvious.
-
Chris said he's wanted to 'thicken up' his sound as he finds his Anglo a bit thin sounding.
I totally relate to that, having a similar journey from English Concertina to melodeon to thicken up the sound. In fact exactly the same reason for gravitating to melodeon.
I too remember being a bit underwhelmed initially at the instrument's limitation.
I also remember a comment from Roger Watson, when he switched from EC to melodeon. He told me he didn't need the full chromaticity of the EC as the melodeon gave him all he needed to play the tunes he wanted to play.
It comes back to the tunes you want to play, and within the English repertoire it has the toolbox for most tunes you will encounter with the advantage of it being a light instrument.
When encountering a new instrument, it takes time to work out exactly what it can do and what it can't.
Take your time Chris, it's characteristics won't always become obvious until you've played around with it for a while.
A final thought: I don't own a 4 wheel drive off road vehicle because where I live the roads don't require such a vehicle. Owning one would be way more vehicle than I need.
I only go off road on a mountainbike!
Cheers
Q
-
I've just bought a DG melodeon and I find myself curiously and probably entirely needlessly "stressed" about the fact that it isn't a chromatic instrument :).
No need to be stressed! The D/G melodeon is a fantastic 'band in a box' as John Kirkpatrick once described it. Just enjoy playing the diatonic music it can do gloriously, rather than worrying about its chromatic limitations.
-
What sort of tunes do I like? Well, I'm a classically-trained pianist, but on my squeezeboxes I love playing traditional music of all kinds. I have a particular fondness for tunes like sea shanties. I'm sure I'll have no difficulty in finding enough tunes to play on my Pokerwork!
As people have been hinting at, the D/G melodeon (especially the Hohner Pokerwork/Erica) is superbly well suited to playing traditional English dance music. The inbuilt push-pull action and the layout of the LH basses and chords allow it to be played with a tremendous rhythmic drive.
When I first started playing in the 1980s, I remember listening and talking to a chap busking in Llanelli market square, who said words to the effect of 'It's tunes innit? You've got to learn some tunes'. And he lent me a cassette tape of him playing a few traditonal tunes such as Speed the Plough, Winster Gallop, Sheep Shearing, Jimmy Allen, etc. I went away and learned them, partly by ear, partly by transcribing them into written notation.
If you don't know quite what a D/G melodeon can do well, you perhaps need to get hold of some traditional English repertoire. Thee days there are some good tune books around, and since you have previously mentioned that you are a good music reader, they ought to be able to help you pick out some well known and popular English tunes. Here are a couple of recommendations to really get you started:
Dave Townsend's English Dance Music (vols 1 and 2)
https://www.davetownsendmusic.com/product/dave-townsends-english-dance-music-vol-1-2/
https://www.davetownsendmusic.com/product/dave-townsends-english-dance-music-vol-2/
My other recommendation is to 'get' the tunes in your head first of all. The melodeon is a strange beast, and even for good music readers, it is not easy to sight-read from written music at first (it comes after a while). But if you can whistle, sing, hum the tune, then you will have it in your head and then try picking it out on the box.
-
If you want a selection of tunes played mostly up and down the rows and mostly on a D/G I might recommend this guy
https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/p/tune-index.html
-
If you want a selection of tunes played mostly up and down the rows and mostly on a D/G I might recommend this guy
https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/p/tune-index.html
Yep - he's a good guy! ;)
-
Another tick for Lester's website, a wealth of tunes there.
Nick Barber's tune books are another great source, along with accompanying cd's if required.
I've just tried to open his 'Tuneworks' website but can't for the minute, but Google is your friend!
-
I've just bought a DG melodeon and I find myself curiously and probably entirely needlessly "stressed" about the fact that it isn't a chromatic instrument :).
No need to be stressed! The D/G melodeon is a fantastic 'band in a box' as John Kirkpatrick once described it.
He may well have said that, but he has an obvious preference for BCC# (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dPHk5uIu3k).
Just enjoy playing the diatonic music it can do gloriously, rather than worrying about its chromatic limitations.
I would agree up to a point, but the OP has already intimated that there may be a problem.
-
Basically, Chris, there are a number of session tunings in the British Isles. The "Irish chromatic" and the diatonic (mostly) DG are two of the common ones. They are both equally valid ways of making great music. The trouble is that hinting at them tends to touch some people's buttons and provoke a ya boo repsonse. The merits of each are discussed to death. A search should bring some relevant threads should show up if you do a search.
So far as your original query goes, I wouldn't be stressed about the chromatic limitations on DG etc. If you want to play English music, it will not be a drawback, although it might offer the occasional challenge.
-
The "Irish chromatic" and the diatonic (mostly) DG are two of the common ones. They are both equally valid ways of making great music. The trouble is that hinting at them tends to touch some people's buttons and provoke a ya boo repsonse.
If that is directed at me, then you have misconstrued what I have been saying.
I don't care what people choose to play, and that's being honest about it.
I was merely trying to help the OP figure things out.
-
It seems to me that throughout this thread there has been a confusion between having an instrument which uses chromatic tones to play diatonically in a variety of keys and an instrument which can use all twelve tones to play chromatically in one or more different keys.
To illustrate this I have recorded two different versions of a C major scale. To keep things simple I am playing mainly on the C row of a Hohner B/C, with only eight basses. The chords are the same as those found on a standard eight bass G/C instrument.
In this first recording I play only notes from the scale, using only chords G, C and F:
01_diatonic_scale.mp3 (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/music/01_diatonic_scale.mp3)
In this next example I play the same scale, with extended harmony and subtle passing tones. In this chromatic realisation I am still playing in the key of C, but I use all twelve chromatic notes:
02_chromatic_scale.mp3 (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/music/02_chromatic_scale.mp3?a=b)
In this final recording I play Over The Waves (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sobre_las_Olas) (Sobre las Olas) as an example of a chromatic melody. To keep keep things simple I have continued to play only in the key of C, left hand harmony is limited to three chords - G, C and F. The interest comes from the frequent insertion of chromatic tones.
03_over_the_waves.mp3 (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/music/03_over_the_waves.mp3)
To return to the questions posed in this thread I will say that I enjoy chromaticism, but I do not regard it as essential. For many years I made a good living playing only single row melodeons. I found that sufficient for solo shows and band work. It is worth noting that the standard D/G with accidentals offers many chromatic possibilities.
-
Mike, thanks for that eye-opening demonstration of Over The Waves played on a B/C box using the basses to such good effect.
That was a popular tune played on single-row boxes, judging from some old tapes I've heard. Due to the limitations of the one-row, these old players needed to take some liberties with the chromatic melodies but it was all in the nature of the 'rough and ready' approach they had to playing their music for a bit of fun.
To return to the subject raised by the original poster (who mentioned earlier being interested in playing sea shanties), it probably doesn't matter much whether your accordion is chromatic or diatonic if you're looking to accompany some boisterous singing sessions!
-
Thanks for all the helpful information. This has been a very useful discussion.
Chris