It seems to me that throughout this thread there has been a confusion between having an instrument which uses chromatic tones to play diatonically in a variety of keys and an instrument which can use all twelve tones to play chromatically in one or more different keys.
To illustrate this I have recorded two different versions of a C major scale. To keep things simple I am playing mainly on the C row of a Hohner B/C, with only eight basses. The chords are the same as those found on a standard eight bass G/C instrument.
In this first recording I play only notes from the scale, using only chords G, C and F:
01_diatonic_scale.mp3In this next example I play the same scale, with extended harmony and subtle passing tones. In this chromatic realisation I am still playing in the key of C, but I use all twelve chromatic notes:
02_chromatic_scale.mp3In this final recording I play
Over The Waves (Sobre las Olas) as an example of a chromatic melody. To keep keep things simple I have continued to play only in the key of C, left hand harmony is limited to three chords - G, C and F. The interest comes from the frequent insertion of chromatic tones.
03_over_the_waves.mp3To return to the questions posed in this thread I will say that I enjoy chromaticism, but I do not regard it as essential. For many years I made a good living playing only single row melodeons. I found that sufficient for solo shows and band work. It is worth noting that the standard D/G with accidentals offers many chromatic possibilities.