Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Jesse Smith on January 11, 2021, 05:58:39 PM

Title: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Jesse Smith on January 11, 2021, 05:58:39 PM
Did Hohner ever limit the button travel of Pokerwork-style boxes, right from the factory? My post-war presswood has a metal bar installed across the pallets, cushioned with plastic tubing, that blocks the pallets from rising farther than the bar. Could this have been original to the box, or was it an "aftermarket" improvement? The reason I wonder if it might be a factory option is because the bar is secured with the same types of washers and roundhead screws that secure the bass panel, etc.

What are the advantages and disadvantages to limiting button travel by blocking the pallet clearance, as opposed to the more typical wood block under the buttons to limit the distance the buttons can descend?

(ETA: Maybe this should have gone in the Instrument Design forum. Mods, please move it if you feel that's appropriate!)
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: george garside on January 11, 2021, 06:23:30 PM
Mally came up with a similar ideasome years ago and i think his version was simply a wooden bar  going the full width of the inside of the box.

I have 2 hohners in which the buttons could go down the holes  but don't for the simple reason I don't waste energy pressing them down
 the holes
george
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: chris hall on January 11, 2021, 06:24:34 PM
neat job. pretty sure its got be an aftermarket fix as not seen on any hohners ive some across. looks like pallets have been fixed up so maybe done at same time. On some (like the HA114) such a method could be a solution where its not possible to limit button travel using other methods. Im currently exploring making a fingerboard for a single row with removable back to address this particular issue.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Kon on January 11, 2021, 06:41:43 PM
I would guess this is after-market, doesn't look "period". But I wouldn't trust me, if you know what I mean.

Some thoughts about the restriction at pallet level rather than button level:

Pros:
- Independent of button height - bending levers to raise or lower buttons will not affect the button travel
- Arguably simpler to install than other methods
- Consistently achieves same height of pallet opening along the row (excluding the possibility of flex in the bar, and not consistent across rows, see below)

Cons:
- Not consistent across rows
- May put more strain on mechanism - the force to open the pallet is applied at one end of the leaver, the stop at the other end, putting the whole mechanism under strain - not sure whether this is powerful enough to e.g. bend the levers over time
- Possible flex in bar could lead to middle pallets opening further than high- / low-end ones

The few times I've seen this method used (most often with a strip of wood) I was always surprised that people didn't install a second bar at the height of the outside row pallets - the penalties in terms of weight, cost and labour would seem to be extremely low, but you would get consistent restriction across the rows.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Tufty on January 11, 2021, 07:16:22 PM
I did the same thing using strips of cork tile fixed inside the grill of an Erica (the black 1980s model). It was still working ok 20 years later. I thought of putting it under the buttons but that was harder and I was too lazy! Certainly improved the playing experience.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Anahata on January 11, 2021, 07:22:29 PM
I'm sure it's an owner mod.
I did something like this with my first Pokerwork. It's the easiest way to do it if you're scared of taking the box further apart.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Jesse Smith on January 11, 2021, 07:46:19 PM
I suppose it is simpler in some sense than removing the keyboard to install a limiting block. I wonder what the piece of metal was originally intended for. It does seem quite purpose built and is the perfect size for this.

Kon, I was having similar thoughts about the potential to bend the button levers since this makes the effective lever arm much longer than when the button levers are blocked only an inch or so from the buttons. But I suppose if it hasn't caused problems yet it should be OK.

At what point does the pallet travel start to affect the sound? My understanding is that the pallets basically have an open/closed binary state, but as the pallet movement shrinks does the sound change? This box is rather sweet and mellow, and I don't know whether that's attributable to the H reeds on zinc plates, this unusual pallet restriction, or the asthmatic bellows with holes in the gussets.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 11, 2021, 11:55:32 PM
...At what point does the pallet travel start to affect the sound? My understanding is that the pallets basically have an open/closed binary state, but as the pallet movement shrinks does the sound change? This box is rather sweet and mellow, and I don't know whether that's attributable to the H reeds on zinc plates, this unusual pallet restriction, or the asthmatic bellows with holes in the gussets.

It is surprising how little the pallets need to open in order to give a good sound and not affect the tuning. For M reeds, anything more than a minimum of around 0.5 cm will probably be OK; 1 cm will be ample. You could test this for yourself on this instrument by just gently depressing the buttons a little way and listening to the sound quality, volume and pitch. There will be a minimum distance below which the sound will be weak and the pitch will be flat.

Vintage H reeds on zinc plates usually have a sweet, mellow sound, which is why they are worth preserving and treating them with respect when tuning/fettling.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Kon on January 12, 2021, 01:19:30 AM
Kon, I was having similar thoughts about the potential to bend the button levers since this makes the effective lever arm much longer than when the button levers are blocked only an inch or so from the buttons. But I suppose if it hasn't caused problems yet it should be OK.

Yes, if it hasn't done any harm so far then presumably it's not a problem! I suppose you'd have to give the buttons a fair walloping to bend the levers.

At what point does the pallet travel start to affect the sound? My understanding is that the pallets basically have an open/closed binary state, but as the pallet movement shrinks does the sound change? This box is rather sweet and mellow, and I don't know whether that's attributable to the H reeds on zinc plates, this unusual pallet restriction, or the asthmatic bellows with holes in the gussets.

I experimented with this the other day, as I was fixing the travel on my Erica, and came to a very similar conclusion to Steve. 5mm seemed to be sufficient for the reeds to sound fully and reliably. Below that there is some modulation of the sound - I can't remember exactly how, but I wouldn't say in a desirable way.

Surprisingly, though, I do think my Erica sounds sweeter now the button travel is restricted, but I couldn't possibly say why. It might just be that I'm enjoying the more responsive feel and finding it easier to play more expressively - that seems the most likely explanation to me.

I suspect the sound characteristics of your box are far more likely to be determined (at least mostly) by the reeds, and maybe reedblock construction.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 12, 2021, 08:50:43 AM
"Surprisingly, though, I do think my Erica sounds sweeter now the button travel is restricted, but I couldn't possibly say why. It might just be that I'm enjoying the more responsive feel and finding it easier to play more expressively - that seems the most likely explanation to me."

It seems rather incongruous that you would think that having buttons which are bordering on being an on/off switch can be played more expressively; I just cannot see it. But I have to admit that I'm with George Garside on the "just don't press the buttons so far" frame of mind. Anyway, can pallet opening gap really add to playing expressively? I would have imagined that that would be more a function of controlling bellows movement and/or note/silence timings. (Not that I have a clue about it!)
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: -Y- on January 12, 2021, 09:03:41 AM
I did a similar operation on an Erica, it changed the feeling dramatically (in a good way). It's also a single bar and I'm not really satisfied that the travel is not limited equally on both rows, but as it's a C#/D I'm not using the C# row that often so that it's not a big deal in the end. But I may have a streak of motivation one day and see if I can't have a "battlement-shaped" bar to replace it and have equal travel.

It seems rather incongruous that you would think that having buttons which are bordering on being an on/off switch can be played more expressively

Well, if the sound doesn't change beyond a certain amount of button travel, as Steve rightly said earlier, then it makes no difference in terms of sound if you push the button a little or if you make them touch the bottom of the keyboard, so it's not really incongruous I think.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: playandteach on January 12, 2021, 01:56:22 PM
I agree that resolving a mechanical issue can cause musical playing to be more likely. Obviously if button travel doesn't bother you, then there's no need to change it. If on the other hand you rather like a definite stop to the button, then you may gain from losing that extra layer of irritation. Giving you more head space to focus on the important bits.
Naturally people have different styles, but also different finger shapes, sizes and approaches.
I suspect it may also depend on where you've come from to the melodeon. Every instrument I play has a definite closed finger position, clarinet, recorder, piano (even though the finger is never in contact with anything that is in contact with the string.
Perhaps if you are a singer, trombonist or theramin player, you are happier with finding your own arrival points.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: george garside on January 12, 2021, 04:35:32 PM
'expression'  comes from fine movement of the bellows  . once a pallet is clear of its hole the reed will sound  and how far the lift of the pallet is doesnt make any real difference.   some boxes have clattery pallets (free percussion!)  but that has nothing to do with distance off the hole but is inflenced by the construction of the pallets and the  brake lining material

george
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Dick Rees on January 12, 2021, 04:46:51 PM
'expression'  comes from fine movement of the bellows  . once a pallet is clear of its hole the reed will sound  and how far the lift of the pallet is doesnt make any real difference.   some boxes have clattery pallets (free percussion!)  but that has nothing to do with distance off the hole but is inflenced by the construction of the pallets and the  brake lining material

george

George...

You and I both chime in regarding silence and the spaces BETWEEN the notes.  While it may be true that pallet clearance has little effect on tone, when considering articulation and phrasing, the closing of the pallets does indeed come into play.  If you add to that the percussion inherent in closing, I feel the overall statement of the music benefits from having the ability to regulate pallet-slap, a feature which is to a great degree eliminated by limiting the action.

So I don't...
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: -Y- on January 12, 2021, 05:10:51 PM
If I agree that instrument noises are part of the music, I don't think it extends to the usual giganormous clatter you have on old (Hohner or not) boxes. I don't feel that limiting the racket makes for a less expressive instrument.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Andy Cleveland on January 12, 2021, 05:23:55 PM
In my post about The Meinel and Herold box I was worried about lateral movement and I had considered doing something like this as a guide for the wires to the pallets. Cool.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 12, 2021, 05:29:09 PM
'expression'  comes from fine movement of the bellows  . once a pallet is clear of its hole the reed will sound  and how far the lift of the pallet is doesnt make any real difference.   some boxes have clattery pallets (free percussion!)  but that has nothing to do with distance off the hole but is inflenced by the construction of the pallets and the  brake lining material

george

George...

You and I both chime in regarding silence and the spaces BETWEEN the notes.  While it may be true that pallet clearance has little effect on tone, when considering articulation and phrasing, the closing of the pallets does indeed come into play.  If you add to that the percussion inherent in closing, I feel the overall statement of the music benefits from having the ability to regulate pallet-slap, a feature which is to a great degree eliminated by limiting the action.

So I don't...

<gentle rant alert>

I hope I have understood the previous remarks correctly...
Respectfully, I can't help feeling that there is something akin to inverse snobbery going on here. Perhaps that's too strong a term but it will have to do for now.

Reducing the typical Hohner noise and clatter by refacing the pallets and limiting the action travel does not render the instrument incapable of musical playing. It is entirely up to the player to bring music to life by phrasing, silences and gaps between notes, etc. To suggest that this is only possible on a rattly Hohner is, frankly, ridiculous. By extension, it also suggests that players of instruments e.g. Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Baffetti, etc. with more (shall we say) finely finished mechanics and action can never play musically, with sensitive phrasing, gaps and silences, etc., which of course is not the case (cue Andy Cutting, Saul Rose, Brian Peters, Simon Care... )

I play both Castagnaris and Hohners depending on the music and sound I want to achieve. But I also don't want extraneous rattles and clunks to get in the way of the music. That is why my Hohners have been de-rattled and do not have the buttons disappearing down mine shafts. It actually helps me play better and I am more satisfied with the music I am producing.

I want and expect my instruments to be in optimum mechanical condition. A pianist would not stand for noisy, rattly action or uneven key travel; a clarinettist would not tolerate sluggish keywork or sticky pads; a fiddle player would be hampered by a poorly set up bridge and fingerboard height - and so on. Why should a melodeon player's needs be any different?

</gentle rant alert>
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Dick Rees on January 12, 2021, 06:32:03 PM
Steve...

I wasn't talking about rattly actions or noise.  Rather, the shape and definition of the space between the notes and any associated acceptable percussive articulation...whether more or less audible. 
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 12, 2021, 06:57:30 PM
Steve...

I wasn't talking about rattly actions or noise.  Rather, the shape and definition of the space between the notes and any associated acceptable percussive articulation...whether more or less audible.

OK Dick, thanks. It was the "So I don't ..." bit that puzzled me.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Dick Rees on January 12, 2021, 07:39:00 PM
Steve...

No problem.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 12, 2021, 08:06:38 PM
So far as disappearing buttons goes, I was getting absolutely nowhere with my pokerwork and nearly gave up completely, then I tried having the mod applied as a last resort. The difference in playability was the difference between an instrument that gave me no pleasure to one that led to one of my life's great enthusiasms. Indifference to a love of playing it.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Kon on January 12, 2021, 08:43:43 PM
I suppose this is all drifting a bit from Jesse's original question...

I'm not really interested in wading into the oft-repeated discussion of whether button travel should or should not be limited - a lot of the same points seem to come up, and surely the only reasonable answer can be that it's up to the player. Some very skilled players prefer one, some the other. It's not compulsory and it's easily reversible.

But I would like to respond to Winston, with whom I once shared a very enjoyable afternoon in Whittonstall:

"Surprisingly, though, I do think my Erica sounds sweeter now the button travel is restricted, but I couldn't possibly say why. It might just be that I'm enjoying the more responsive feel and finding it easier to play more expressively - that seems the most likely explanation to me."

It seems rather incongruous that you would think that having buttons which are bordering on being an on/off switch can be played more expressively; I just cannot see it. But I have to admit that I'm with George Garside on the "just don't press the buttons so far" frame of mind. Anyway, can pallet opening gap really add to playing expressively? I would have imagined that that would be more a function of controlling bellows movement and/or note/silence timings. (Not that I have a clue about it!)

I can see why what I said might not sound like it makes a huge amount of sense, but I promise it does (to me, at least). I will try to explain my experience - all of this is of course to be taken as personal opinion only.

It's not that I feel I am playing the buttons themselves more or less expressively (though see Dick's post for somebody who says they do just that!), but that the altered feel of the keyboard allows me to play the whole instrument more expressively. Having a crisp point of "arrival" for the button (as well as having slightly lightened the action) makes the keyboard action feel cleaner and more responsive to me. This has two positive knock-on effects on my playing:
1) the obvious one, it simply makes it easier to play more quickly - quick runs, grace notes and trills all seem to fall much more easily under my fingers;
2) slightly less obviously, I feel that it aids my bellows control, because I have to spend less time thinking about what my fingers are doing - because with the crisper feel to the keyboard the notes seem to be easier to find.

Now it might just be that changing the keyboard action has made me pay more attention to what my fingers are doing, and maybe I "should" have just learned not to press the buttons all the way down. But that doesn't ring true to me - it feels like the change is actually giving me mechanical cues that make it easier to play the treble more delicately. George Garside's "just don't press the buttons so far" always reminds me of my uncle who said his car insurance policy was to "just not have an accident". Leaving aside the legality of that, surely the point of modifying the action isn't actually how far the pallet opens specifically, but how the keyboard feels to play, which is simply not addressed by George's comment (in the same way that my uncle's "policy" didn't address the issue of insurance).

Why not try it out Winston? Surely that's the only way to know for sure whether you like it one way or the other. It's not a tricky job and you seem like a hands-on kind of person. Or maybe in a brighter future you can have a go on someone else's box who's decided to do it.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 12, 2021, 09:43:10 PM
Kon, you're certainly right about it being a personal thing; like most things melodeonwise, there are no rules!
My first "proper" box was a 1040 in C, and after reading on here about members needing to have the button travel limited (in a vain attempt to find some way of improving my playing) I decided to try it. As you may remember from that great weekend at Wittonstall, it didn't work. In fact, your playing after only one day was still better than mine is today! I find that when my finger end touches the flat of the keyboard, I just stop pressing, automatically.
If someone feels that it does improve their playing, or enjoyment of, in some way; then that's fine and dandy and good luck to them.
p.s. I'm really pleased that you stuck with it, and that Vicky's efforts (and Nigel's Erica) didn't go to waste.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Peadar on January 12, 2021, 10:50:57 PM
I do wonder if some of the enthusiasm for limited travel is driven by the change from movement based controls to pressure based controls in the electronic era....
Those of us who were introduced to keyboards via upright pianos and manual typewriters learnt control of strength and depth of finger strike putting momentum into the operating mechanism whether of piano hammer or typewriter arms - whereas electronic key boards have only a light spring and keys usually pressed to the limit of travel in operation.

So I feel comfortable with the fairly long travel and firm springing of my old boxes.
I feel control in actually moving the button a  perceptible distance when I play. Whether that is good for my playing is another matter.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: CAB on January 12, 2021, 11:27:53 PM
I do wonder if some of the enthusiasm for limited travel is driven by the change from movement based controls to pressure based controls in the electronic era....
Those of us who were introduced to keyboards via upright pianos and manual typewriters learnt control of strength and depth of finger strike putting momentum into the operating mechanism whether of piano hammer or typewriter arms - whereas electronic key boards have only a light spring and keys usually pressed to the limit of travel in operation.

So I feel comfortable with the fairly long travel and firm springing of my old boxes.
I feel control in actually moving the button a  perceptible distance when I play. Whether that is good for my playing is another matter.
That may be a factor for younger folk but I remember disliking the feeling of my finger disappearing down a hole in the keyboard as long ago as the 1970s. And I'd spent hours using typewriters, not to mention telex machines.
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: Kon on January 13, 2021, 12:45:30 AM
Winston, you're selling yourself short! I enjoyed your playing with or without restricted button travel.

Peadar, I see your point, but as a youngish person myself I am not keen at all on my instrument feeling anything like an eletronic device. I (tried to) play the piano for a bit before I discovered the delights of the melodeon, and that's still my frame of reference for thinking about the keyboard action. I find my new and improved keyboard more piano-like than before, for reasons I would struggle to put into words. But of course my experience won't be universal!
Title: Re: Hohner built-in button travel limit?
Post by: JNM SY on February 05, 2021, 01:39:23 PM
"What are the advantages and disadvantages to limiting button travel by blocking the pallet clearance, as opposed to the more typical wood block under the buttons to limit the distance the buttons can descend?"

One possible disadvantage  (see picture in OPost) is that unless you are carefull with the length of the screws  -  some fondos are surprisingly thin - the next time you do a bit of spot tuning etc. you'll find the reedblock surprisingly difficult, if not impossible to remove.
 Its easy to forget about the reedblock when working on the pallet side.
 I found this out when adding a mount for a cantilever/pallet at the top of the fondo on my club 3bs. Everything was tikkety boo untill the next time I tried to take out the top reed block.  It was firmly screwed in place with the two brass screws I had used - which were the same size as the other screws on the adjacent mount!  The metal I had used was slightly thinner, - the one and a half turns that entered the block was enough to keep it firmly in place.  Could be worse though, - a joiner I know was asked to put up shelves in the back of a van, which he duly did - nice and firm. He got out to find ... two rows of screws sticking out of the outside of the van. ;D
    Good luck - John
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal