Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: jarviw on September 14, 2022, 04:21:52 AM

Title: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: jarviw on September 14, 2022, 04:21:52 AM
So I started tuning the Hohner Club 1 reeds after removing all the rusts.
I started out with the lowest bass reeds, and noticed they are all about 60 cents flat. It was probably originally tuned to 435, so I was expecting everything to be flat.
Then I realized when I blow softer it also go about 20 cents sharper... yes, I am blowing the reeds on the reed block to tune it, instead of using a tuning table.

Uhhh, am I tuning the reeds sharp because I am not supplying the right amount of air? Can I really tune the reeds by blowing it without using a tuning table?


EDIT:  I just tried it on my known properly tuned Panther, blowing it [by mouth] does make the note ~40 cents flatter, vs the normal bellow pressure. oh crap.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Rog on September 14, 2022, 07:21:55 AM
A tuning table is quite useful and v easy to make with old PA bellows..plus normal advice is not to suck because there is a risk you will inhale something ..and you really do not want to do that.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Theo on September 14, 2022, 08:02:24 AM
I don’t think you can get a good result by blowing by mouth.
You can get excellent results, the best in fact, by using the instrument to sound the reeds.  You have to isolate one bank of reeds with masking tape under the reed block.  You also need a way to suspend the bellows while you work.  I have photos somewhere, I’ll try and find them.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Lester on September 14, 2022, 08:11:46 AM

I don’t think you can get a good result by blowing by mouth.
You can get excellent results, the best in fact, by using the instrument to sound the reeds.  You have to isolate one bank of reeds with masking tape under the reed block.  You also need a way to suspend the bellows while you work.  I have photos somewhere, I’ll try and find them.

I use this for tuning 1 rows

https://photos.app.goo.gl/WVytNZTFCpNvs5KE9
https://photos.app.goo.gl/6j7TjLo3gJA6yTR66
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Theo on September 14, 2022, 08:28:16 AM
That’s the boy Lester.
I use the same type of device for all tuning.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Rog on September 14, 2022, 11:13:32 AM
I use this for tuning melodeons (in particular one rows…but Hohners generally fit on there).
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 14, 2022, 12:55:59 PM
I spent quite a bit of time and effort making a set of foot operated tuning bellows, which I'm really happy with. There are pictures of it on melnet somewhere (?).
But, I most often use a set up very similar to Lester's and (presumably) Theo's, but it has adjustment for other lengths of bellows, the butterfly nuts on the screws in the slots can just be seen on the right this picture. (It's almost 3000miles away at the moment, and this is the only picture I could find on my Google stuff, sorry for the other junk on there.)
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: jarviw on September 14, 2022, 02:07:05 PM
Thanks for all the pictures!
I am not following it completely though... how do you use this bellow setup? Do you basically tune the reeds in the instrument, but just mount the box on top as opposed to worrying about the bellow pins?

I think I can make a little board to sit on top of the original bellow easy enough, with an air hole in the middle.


That said, I think I tuned all four low bass plates 40 cents sharp... with a lot of material removed.  :P  :P   Hopefully I have not completely destroyed them...
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 14, 2022, 02:59:14 PM
The "V's" of the last bellows fold slip over the two open ends of the U shape of the rig, with the rest of the bellows (and the opposite end to which you want to work on) hanging down free below. The reedblock can be affixed into the other end and then placed on top of the open bellows and held there by hand. The free hand then can work the bellows up and down to sound the reeds.
May sound a bit problematic, but you soon become adept at it.
Good luck!
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 14, 2022, 09:45:21 PM
Thanks for all the pictures!
I am not following it completely though... how do you use this bellow setup? Do you basically tune the reeds in the instrument, but just mount the box on top as opposed to worrying about the bellow pins?


Here are a few pics to show to show you how this works. The instrument for which this board was made is very heavy, hence the wooden cheeks at the ends to stop the board bending under the weight of a big Club box. I have five boards cut out like this to fit a variety of boxes. The slot is cut out to fit snugly into the valley of the first bellow fold.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 14, 2022, 09:51:42 PM
This shows the bellows fitted into the frame. The treble end is being tuned here so the bass end is still attached to the bottom of the bellows. The treble end is fitted on top to sound the reed you are tuning. I always block the holes where the bellows pins go through with tape or Blutack to minimise leakage.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 14, 2022, 09:56:31 PM
It can be a bit of a faff blocking off ports you don't want to sound or lose air through, especially when you remove some blocks in order to leave yourself enough room to work on the reeds you are tuning.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 14, 2022, 10:10:41 PM
You will need to buy or make a few special tools and learn how to use them in order to do a reasonable job of tuning. I really would recommend that you buy an old junker PA or similar and practice on reeds you can afford to ruin. There is an art to this and however practical you are it will still take some time to acquire the skills, make the inevitable mistakes and tune your eyes and ears to the intricacies of reed work. I've been at it a few years now and I still have a lot to learn!
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Rog on September 14, 2022, 10:18:20 PM
I have to say, I don’t bother with a U frame. You can sit the box on a table and lift the end on and off the bellows and lift it up and down, by gripping the first fold and the side of the casing with one hand, and operate a key with the other.. That’s how I fine tune bigger accordions. The Bugari tuner I saw in Castelfidardo just lifted the end on and off a set of bellows fitted with a big open aperture and wide leather pad as in my photo. I couldn’t get on with the U shaped frame favoured by you guys…it seemed more complicated that it needed to be. But that’s just me…
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 14, 2022, 10:37:17 PM
I have to say, I don’t bother with a U frame. You can sit the box on a table and lift the end on and off the bellows and lift it up and down, by gripping the first fold and the side of the casing with one hand, and operate a key with the other.. That’s how I fine tune bigger accordions. The Bugari tuner I saw in Castelfidardo just lifted the end on and off a set of bellows fitted with a big open aperture and wide leather pad as in my photo. I couldn’t get on with the U shaped frame favoured by you guys…it seemed more complicated that it needed to be. But that’s just me…


I can only speak for myself, I'm an amateur and you're a pro, I find it difficult to hold an accordion end down tightly on a flat surface, press the appropriate key and lift a board attached to a bellows at the same time so I just do what works for me. If I remember correctly, I pinched the idea from Lester who I think was inspired by another fettler/maker. This probably works better on lightweight boxes rather than five voice 120 bass PAs.
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Rog on September 14, 2022, 11:00:04 PM
The U frame Obvs works well…but not for me..
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Theo on September 14, 2022, 11:05:06 PM
It can be a bit of a faff blocking off ports you don't want to sound or lose air through, especially when you remove some blocks in order to leave yourself enough room to work on the reeds you are tuning.

Removing done blocks will alter the pitch of adjacent reeds which defeats the purpose of tuning in the box!
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 14, 2022, 11:28:13 PM
Ouch, another lesson learned then. Ta (I think), the plot thickens!
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: jarviw on September 15, 2022, 02:33:57 AM
Removing done blocks will alter the pitch of adjacent reeds which defeats the purpose of tuning in the box!

So... basically just tune the reeds in place?


I am not quite to that step yet. I was hoping to tune individual reed plates now until I get the new valves placed, and then wax to the block. I guess I am doing it all wrong then :P
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Theo on September 15, 2022, 08:32:10 AM
Fitting valves changes the pitch,  fitting to the reed block changes the pitch.  If you have an old German instrument where the reference pitch was A=435 you can take the pitch up to approximately 440,  but it’s only approximate.  You could call it pre-tuning.  Final tuning has to be done with the Reed’s on the blocks and the blocks in the instrument.  Otherwise it’s only approximate tuning.

Tuning is like any other craft.  It takes many hours of practice to develop your skills.  Tuning reeds off the blocks is a good place to start,  but it’s a lengthy learning process.  I still have the first box I tuned.  Now I know it is pretty terrible, but at the time it represented an achievement along the learning path. At the time I thought it was pretty good.   I keep it as a reminder to myself that I may not be as good as I think I am!
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: John Burks on September 15, 2022, 12:05:10 PM
I am still learning but I hope this helps a bit.  I tuned and declubbed a Hohner Modell 1 fairly early on using this method and it worked well for me.  Great tone. I gasketed rather that waxed to allow ongoing fine tuning.  I still use the same method even when waxing.

Method Phase 1:

I found its best to tune in two phases especially when shifting from A435 to A440. I initially tune “on” the block using a simple tuning table. 

I remove the reeds, fully strip, clean and "set" the reeds. I then fit the valves (I tend to use the thin ones now not leather and this makes things easier).  I also clean and prepare the block.  I then use the block on my table to sound the reed by holding the reed in place with my thumb at the top (see photo below). Most blocks seem to have a ridge at the bottom which helps retain the reed on the block face when you do this. I then tune the pull and push reeds incrementally to hit their targets.  I do this by removing and placing flat on the edge of the table to file. Then replacing and re-sounding. Gradually landing on the target.  This makes it a quick easy process. As mentioned elsewhere I use 400grit diamond files to adjust as I find these better in terms of protecting the reed (You keep the old ones and use them for fine tuning).  I then tack wax the reed onto the block or if I am gasketing I pop in the retaining screws.  I do the tremolo base side of the block first to the pure A440 tone.  I then tune the matching reed on other side to the base tone plus the tremolo offset.  I do this in Hz.  I take the base side pure (actual) Hz figure and say add 2 HZ to give 2 beats per sec.  Once both reeds are set I shift over my table to sound the two reeds together (I remove the mask - see photo) and count the beat rate.  I then fine adjust to hit the target beat rate (usually by ear but I sometimes use the Bill Farmer tuner to let me see the visual). Once this its done and I am happy with the note(s), the attack of the reeds and the beat rate I move on to the next pair.  Once I have finished the block I then test down the block to ensure the beat rate is what I want down its length.  I find at this point if things are basically in balance and sounding good or not.  (At this point I usually have to adjust slightly - its an iterative process.). Once the block is in balance I fully wax or fully screw down the gasket reeds.  I must admit I prefer gaskets as it allows you to fine tune more easily on an ongoing basis as the box shifts.
 
This is repeated for each block and the chords (single notes and then chord balance).  Once all this is done it all goes together.  The box though usually plays reasonably well at this point.

As Theo says though this is really pre-tuning. You need Phase 2.

Phase 2:

I have found that things do shift subtlety when the box goes together and I do have to go back in to get things in balance, but for me pre-tuning really helps as it sets a base line to work from.  Nothing beats (excuse pun) playing, testing and fine tuning the box when fully assembled but pretuning can make things easier.

I use the assembled box itself to fine tune I.e. not mounted in any way. I just play it, map adjustments and open it up a lot and tweak. (After reading this topic though I will now make a support and try using the bellows and placing the box end on it. It will be easier.) In this phase I actually remove the reed plates as I'm not confident with using scratchers/files with the reed plates mounted.  It's more work but it suits me.



The reason for posting is to mention that it might be worth considering it as a two stage approach.  Get it somewhere near using the block method above and then refine.  It might help. It helped me.

I will post some pictures of my table later for this pre-tuning (cost about £5). It makes the above method quite quick/easy.  It's worth making one.

Hope that makes sense.  If not just ask  (:).

John

Edit ... photos attached

Note the single hole in the wooden mask on the table for individual reeds (photo) and the mask removed for tremolo (photo) I have other masks for chord and bass blocks. I tune on the edge of the table. See tools.

Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: jarviw on September 15, 2022, 05:54:36 PM
That's a honest and humble comment I really appreciate Theo!
And thanks John for the detailed description of the process.

I get it now, realistically anything changing the box affects the tuning, probably thru the subtle changes in air flow/pressure, which I have learned l the hard way. At the end I will need to try and tune it as a whole still.

I taped the other valve when I was tuning and only "blow" on the reed while holding it on the block. Not air tight in any sense, and definitely not the normal bellow pressure/air flow.
I will rig up a tuning table with its bellow and try the first phase. I got enough scrap wood around to do one easily (as long as the wife doesn't realize I am working on a hobby project instead of the house).
Title: Re: Do you have to use a tuning table?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 15, 2022, 06:09:41 PM
(as long as the wife doesn't realize I am working on a hobby project instead of the house)

Watch out there, mind! Hearing the same note sounding every 30 seconds or so might just give the game a way.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal