Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: diatonix on January 05, 2024, 01:11:53 AM

Title: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: diatonix on January 05, 2024, 01:11:53 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cpi3dm0i8_0&ab_channel=AssiTechnique
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: mselic on January 05, 2024, 04:09:58 AM
That sound! I can’t look…
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Roger Hare on January 05, 2024, 07:59:13 AM
It's not a place where I would ever venture, but it all looks a bit brutal? It also reminds me I have a visit to the dentist booked for Monday...
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 05, 2024, 09:39:16 AM
Nope, nope and NOPE. No one's tuning any of my boxes like that.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Theo on January 05, 2024, 10:35:09 AM
All that effort, what ever you think about power tools, when the block goes back in the instrument the tuning will change. 
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: jarviw on January 05, 2024, 03:06:57 PM
All that effort, what ever you think about power tools, when the block goes back in the instrument the tuning will change.

Just curious, when the block goes back in the box, do the pitches change fairly evenly to the same direction across the different notes, or just all over the place?
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Anahata on January 05, 2024, 03:36:59 PM
Just curious, when the block goes back in the box, do the pitches change fairly evenly to the same direction across the different notes, or just all over the place?

I think "fairly evenly" is about right. Each reed tends to be consistent in itself, so there is a tuning technique where you measure the frequencies of all the reeds while in the box, subtract from what they should be then take them out of the box and change the tuning of each reed by by its calculated offset. When you put them back in the box they should in theory be correct, but even that is not said to be foolproof.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Theo on January 05, 2024, 04:00:41 PM
My experience is that the changes are not consistent and depend on pitch so for example high pitch  reeds can change a different amount from low. It also depends on the position of the reed block.  Reeds that are facing another block, or are close to another surface are affected more, and those facing a larger space are affected less.  The amount of pallet lift also makes a difference which can affect one side of a block more than the other.  The design of your rest bellows outside the box is also an important factor where the thickness of the top plate and the size of the air holes are the most significant variables. 
The techniques to tune in the box don’t take an enormous amount of time to learn, and the tools required are simple.  I’m always happy to share my methods.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Pearse Rossa on January 05, 2024, 04:42:39 PM
The design of your rest bellows outside the box is also an important factor where the thickness of the top plate and the size of the air holes are the most significant variables. 

I was trying to convey this in a previous thread (https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=29927.msg353203#msg353203), but my suggestion was shot down!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: diatonix on January 05, 2024, 08:20:39 PM
It's not only that the frequency may change significantly when the blocks are back in the instrument. To mention just three of several  other invaluable advantages of tuning in situ is a) the fact that it allows you to use the keyboard and quickly check intervals, also across reed blocks (+ make use of registers, if present). And b) an accurate tremolo tuning is only possible with the blocks in situ, when the tuner must be able to quickly cross-reference with neighboring  notes. c) it's so much faster! By the time this guy has finished ruining one reed, I'm already done tuning a whole row...
 
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: boxcall on January 06, 2024, 08:40:59 PM
Oh my valves!!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Pat McInnis on January 08, 2024, 09:56:04 PM
My experience is that the changes are not consistent and depend on pitch so for example high pitch  reeds can change a different amount from low. It also depends on the position of the reed block.  Reeds that are facing another block, or are close to another surface are affected more, and those facing a larger space are affected less.  The amount of pallet lift also makes a difference which can affect one side of a block more than the other.  The design of your rest bellows outside the box is also an important factor where the thickness of the top plate and the size of the air holes are the most significant variables. 
The techniques to tune in the box don’t take an enormous amount of time to learn, and the tools required are simple.  I’m always happy to share my methods.

Would love to hear your in box method. I have my table set up to do a rough tune (off the block), single notes (on the block), both notes together, to tune tremolo and finally in the treble case but not assembled and I find that there is quite a difference when everything is all together.

Please share
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Theo on January 08, 2024, 10:51:12 PM
My method is quite simple.  If there is no change of pitch  I just tune the reeds in situ in the instrument, usually the instruments own bellows hanging in a.simple fixture clamped to the edge of the bench.   If there is a change of pitch, for example tuning up from 435 to 440,  or a conversion from  one key to another then I rough tune singly on a very simple wooden holder on a test bellows.  I aim for very approximately 10 cents sharp of the target pitch.  Once the reeds are valves and waxed  and fitted in the box they usually drop by a few cents.  Then they are ready for final tuning.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Stefan on January 09, 2024, 10:47:59 PM
My method is quite simple.  If there is no change of pitch  I just tune the reeds in situ in the instrument, usually the instruments own bellows hanging in a.simple fixture clamped to the edge of the bench.   If there is a change of pitch, for example tuning up from 435 to 440,  or a conversion from  one key to another then I rough tune singly on a very simple wooden holder on a test bellows.  I aim for very approximately 10 cents sharp of the target pitch.  Once the reeds are valves and waxed  and fitted in the box they usually drop by a few cents.  Then they are ready for final tuning.
with all respect, if your workflow is that way, fine. I today finished an erica, tuned on a table and surprisingly its nearly spot on. And i had used a dremel too ( >:E) In opposite to the video above i removed the reeds and tuned them without valves. I found out that the result is best if i use the original cleaned reedblock, the original cell, and the direction it will be waxed in later. I just push the reedplate agains the block and either push or pull the bellows of my tuning table. I use tape to simulate the valves and my tuning table is small and has nearly similar dimensions as a melodeon. As a rule of thump i tune one row spot on (accurate to the cent) and start with a difference of 22 cent on the lowest reeds and substract 1,5 cent with every higher reed. This is more flat than the original hohner tremolo but i like the medium swing it results in. The last box was a ww2 double ray (laurel leaf) wich i tuned (on the table) as dry as i can get, just to experiment how much the result will differ if the block are installed later, and i found the result surprisingly identical.
There is nou doubt that you are the much more experienced tuner BUT a beginner has to begin somewhere and i think you take the courage out of newbies as you allways repeat your statement that one could not tune another way you do and tuning tables and powertools are inadequate. Maybe my tuning skills are not perfect but my philosophy is to tune as good as possible on the table because tuning in situ is a pita and i think scratching and bending the tongues does unnecessarily stress the material. (and the traces of filing from previous tunings are partially much more worser than what my dremel leaves behind).
btw. I dont think one could get same results with "very simple wooden holder", and taping one side (simulating valves) is important too because the pitch does change if "unvalved" No offense!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Jack Humphreys on January 12, 2024, 08:39:21 AM
I have a relevant story. I took my French-made 3v box to a professional tuner, who, after many hours of struggling, opined that the box was badly made and that the Binci reeds were "unstable".  He said that he was therefore unable to deliver the requested slight swing tuning on MM, and recommended a unison tuning, which I ignorantly accepted.
I was soon bored with unison MM, and took the box to a second tuner, who successfully delivered the slight swing I wanted. He did some work on the reeds outside the box,  but the final tuning was in-box. 
I retrospect, I believe that the first tuner relied entirely on tuning outside the box, using offsets. He said there was "no room"  to tune inside the box, so I assume he was using a rotary grinder/polisher.   The reeds' "instability"  was presumably because the pitch altered unpredictably between the outside-box tuning and the inside-box result.  My second tuner found that all the reeds had been removed and rewaxed, as part of the first tuner's struggles to make his method work.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: -Y- on January 12, 2024, 09:59:34 AM
with all respect, if your workflow is that way, fine. I today finished an erica, tuned on a table and surprisingly its nearly spot on. And i had used a dremel too ( >:E) In opposite to the video above i removed the reeds and tuned them without valves. I found out that the result is best if i use the original cleaned reedblock, the original cell, and the direction it will be waxed in later. I just push the reedplate agains the block and either push or pull the bellows of my tuning table. I use tape to simulate the valves and my tuning table is small and has nearly similar dimensions as a melodeon. As a rule of thump i tune one row spot on (accurate to the cent) and start with a difference of 22 cent on the lowest reeds and substract 1,5 cent with every higher reed. This is more flat than the original hohner tremolo but i like the medium swing it results in. The last box was a ww2 double ray (laurel leaf) wich i tuned (on the table) as dry as i can get, just to experiment how much the result will differ if the block are installed later, and i found the result surprisingly identical.
There is nou doubt that you are the much more experienced tuner BUT a beginner has to begin somewhere and i think you take the courage out of newbies as you allways repeat your statement that one could not tune another way you do and tuning tables and powertools are inadequate. Maybe my tuning skills are not perfect but my philosophy is to tune as good as possible on the table because tuning in situ is a pita and i think scratching and bending the tongues does unnecessarily stress the material. (and the traces of filing from previous tunings are partially much more worser than what my dremel leaves behind).
btw. I dont think one could get same results with "very simple wooden holder", and taping one side (simulating valves) is important too because the pitch does change if "unvalved" No offense!

I *really* don't understand this, erm, approach. Tuning in situ is actually very easy, it's just something, as all manual work of any kind, that needs being used to. I find it easier than designing all the tinkering you're doing to avoid a simpler, more efficient way.
To each person its method, but I don't understand coming here to boast about refusing to use recognised, tested, methods, apart from wanting to upset people.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: diatonix on January 12, 2024, 08:41:37 PM


I *really* don't understand this, erm, approach. Tuning in situ is actually very easy, it's just something, as all manual work of any kind, that needs being used to. I find it easier than designing all the tinkering you're doing to avoid a simpler, more efficient way.
To each person its method, but I don't understand coming here to boast about refusing to use recognised, tested, methods, apart from wanting to upset people.

Thanks, I couldn't have worded this better myself!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Winston Smith on January 12, 2024, 08:53:07 PM
"apart from wanting to upset people."

Why would anyone want to be "upset" by this man's post? He's only stating what his preferred tuning method is.
After all, some strange people put the milk in their cup before the tea, I don't like it! But it certainly wouldn't upset me. And I couldn't imagine that they were doing it to specifically upset other tea drinkers, either.

Surely we can disagree without such harshness?
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: diatonix on January 12, 2024, 09:16:30 PM
Why would anyone want to be "upset" by this man's post?

Unprofessional "tuning" very often goes hand in hand with other examples of malpractice (apart from damaged reeds) such as messy waxing and poor handling/choice of valves and others. Issues, I, being a licensed, professional tuner, have to address before being able to concentrate on what is my real task. Of course it upsets me! And it also upsets my customers, who not only wasted their money dealing with a self-taught unskilled amateur, but are now presented with my bill, where I am forced to charge for more of my time than would have been necessary.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Winston Smith on January 12, 2024, 09:29:48 PM
Is he tuning for other people? I didn't deduce that from his post.

I understand your frustration at having to rectify DIY type work before you can redo it properly, as this used to happen to me, when I was working.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: -Y- on January 12, 2024, 09:43:47 PM
Why would anyone want to be "upset" by this man's post? He's only stating what his preferred tuning method is.
After all, some strange people put the milk in their cup before the tea, I don't like it! But it certainly wouldn't upset me. And I couldn't imagine that they were doing it to specifically upset other tea drinkers, either.

I didn't want to sound harsh, really, sorry if I was. It's just that there's a history of Stefan asking for advice regarding tuning here (which is fine and is what this website is all about), of experienced tuners (eg not me  :D) telling him that one of the best way was to tune in situ with files and scratchers and that it was not such a big deal (that's not what is hard with tuning), and of him keeping to ignore advices. It turns out he was after validation and not advice.
I think that the above message is not an isolated one, but one after some others on the same subject. It also attributes wrong motives: nobody has ever said beginners should have perfect skills from the start. It's just that using power tools and tuning out of the box are not really beginner methods. On the long run, it's much faster to start learning tuning by listening to advices given (especially when we have the chance to have members with very diverse experiences). The main difference between a beginner and a seasoned tuner will be the speed and the regularity of the gestures. But then again, this was said in length in another thread by others.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Rog on January 12, 2024, 10:00:07 PM
Quote
…, I, being a licensed, professional tuner, …
I've been biting my tongue reading this thread…but you really need to get over yourself. You are probably the only 'licensed' person on here, whatever that means. Also, poking fun at YT videos because you think you have all the answers and everyone else knows nothing because they're not licensed, is unprofessional and uncharitable.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: boxcall on January 12, 2024, 11:51:42 PM
Quote
…, I, being a licensed, professional tuner, …
I've been biting my tongue reading this thread…but you really need to get over yourself. You are probably the only 'licensed' person on here, whatever that means. Also, poking fun at YT videos because you think you have all the answers and everyone else knows nothing because they're not licensed, is unprofessional and uncharitable.
I would say  Diatonix is feeling that being “ licensed “ means being trained under one’s professional guidance until you learn the craft throughly and only then you are ready to tackle taking on the work. I would say that there’s a lot of value in that, and I would also say the skills could be learned on the fly but with limitations at first. I fix stuff for myself to learn but wouldn’t take on others repairs for money.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Rog on January 13, 2024, 06:35:28 AM
You've missed my point, but never mind.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: diatonix on January 13, 2024, 05:20:13 PM
Quote
…, I, being a licensed, professional tuner, …
I've been biting my tongue reading this thread…but you really need to get over yourself. You are probably the only 'licensed' person on here, whatever that means. Also, poking fun at YT videos because you think you have all the answers and everyone else knows nothing because they're not licensed, is unprofessional and uncharitable.

In my case "licensed" means that I have the official diploma issued by the German Handwerkskammer ("Handzuginstrumentenmacher"), requiring 4 years of full-time study. In the late nineties  I worked as an instructor tutoring students aspiring for the same diploma. One more thing: I don't "poke fun" at YT videos, but I have no qualms about exposing those who show pathetic craftmanship, while at the same time pretending to be skilled accordion technicians. I'm planning to continue to do so. Don't expect me to sugarcoat  my opinion.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Roger Hare on January 14, 2024, 08:15:39 AM
...I have no qualms about exposing those who show pathetic craftmanship, while at the same time pretending
to be skilled accordion technicians. I'm planning to continue to do so. Don't expect me to sugarcoat  my opinion.
Good for you! Please continue to do just exactly that!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Stefan on January 17, 2024, 11:04:28 AM
My, erm, approach was not to upset people! In this forum there are professional tuners who made it for a living and many amateurs who would like to inform themself about basic maintaining their instruments.
No question, a experienced tuner will do a lot of the work situ. But a beginner will be afraid of bending the smallest inner reeds out (with good reason). So my statement is: you can get far with tuning your reeds on a table (wich results in a playable tuning)  and of course the fine tuning of at least some reeds has to be done in the instrument (if you want perfect tuning). And if you have the time you can install the reedblocks, measure the tuning, deinstall the blocks (or even the single reeds) and made your fine adjustments on the table wich is indeed easier and safer for a beginner.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Stefan on January 17, 2024, 11:17:56 AM
Quote
…, I, being a licensed, professional tuner, …
I've been biting my tongue reading this thread…but you really need to get over yourself. You are probably the only 'licensed' person on here, whatever that means. Also, poking fun at YT videos because you think you have all the answers and everyone else knows nothing because they're not licensed, is unprofessional and uncharitable.
when or why did i ignore advices? All i tried to say is that a beginner should not be put off by statements like "do it like the pros, do it like me (because i am a pro) or keep your hands off!" (and this is true about any comparable forum)
Fact is that even big manufacturers tune on a bench and do very little fine adjustment in situ. I equipped some ericas with brand new reedblocks and had to do very little adjustments. So at least Hohner knows hw to pretune proberly. Again, no offense, i am grateful and i admire Theos skills.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Little Eggy on January 17, 2024, 01:58:53 PM
My old vicar said it was ok to disagree lovingly.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Anahata on January 17, 2024, 02:03:33 PM
So at least Hohner knows how to pretune properly.

Some would say Hohners come out of the factory usable, but with room for improvement.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Theo on January 17, 2024, 02:07:50 PM
I’ve never been so arrogant as to say “do it like me because I’m a pro”, or anything remotely similar.  What I’ve said consistently is that if you are going to learn to tune do the best job you can and learn the best methods you can.   My advice has all been based on experience and practice, so it’s basic and town to earth.   That experience has taken me through many stages of learning, changing and relearning.  Partly that’s because I’m self taught, and I believe that means being self critical and always looking for better ways of doing things.  I have benefited from crucial snippets of advice from a number of more experienced people.  That has helped me to master some of the techniques of doing final tuning in situ.   It’s much harder to pick up these techniques from written instructions.  Perhaps I should run a course?
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Andy Goldfinch on January 17, 2024, 03:24:26 PM
I'm sure lots of people (including myself) would be interested if you ran a tuning course Theo.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: jarviw on January 17, 2024, 06:31:31 PM
Perhaps I should run a course?

Absolutely Professor Theo!
There are people doing the job, and there are people creating and transferring knowledge. The value you can create is beyond monetary means!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: mChavez on January 17, 2024, 09:29:09 PM
How does a perfectly tuned accordion sound anyway?
I've heard about them, but never heard one.


Q: What's a minor second?
A: Two accordionists trying to play in unison.  :||: :|||:
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: diatonix on January 17, 2024, 11:54:18 PM
  Perhaps I should run a course?

Great idea, go ahead, absolutely! As to myself, whether I'm considered arrogant or just outspoken, I don't really care. If my post has raised awareness, both  among ordinary players (=paying customers) and fellow technicians, skilled or not, I'm more than happy.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Pat McInnis on January 19, 2024, 03:04:28 AM
Perhaps I should run a course?

I'm in!!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Rick St. John on January 20, 2024, 11:53:43 AM
Perhaps I should run a course?

Sign me up!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Winston Smith on January 20, 2024, 12:00:46 PM
I suspect that such a course would be oversubscribed in no time at all!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Rick St. John on January 20, 2024, 01:09:17 PM
There you are, Theo: vox populi
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Theo on January 20, 2024, 01:15:23 PM
I seem to have dropped myself right in!
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: tirpous on January 20, 2024, 01:41:19 PM
Maybe include an online option, Zoom or whatever, for us faraways !  :D
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: Peadar on January 20, 2024, 03:09:44 PM
Put me down for the course.....or the waiting list.
Title: Re: Another "tutorial" of how to tune an accordion...
Post by: invadm on January 31, 2024, 10:36:10 AM
I'll be vary happy to join if there was a 'tuning curse' around from pros.. often wonder why there isn't one already ? just like melodeon building courses once a year or every 6 moths tuning courses will be very popular I think.       
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal