Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: upmine3 on November 25, 2009, 10:58:09 PM
-
Bought on E-bay all i know is it's in G/C with accidentals.
Just wondering if anyone could shed any light on where it was made and what year my knowledge on Hohners is basic i'm afraid.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/23306008@N05/?saved=1 (http://www.flickr.com/photos/23306008@N05/?saved=1)
-
Germany, mid-1930s.
But though it's the same style, there's no pokerwork on it.
-
Oh cheers triskel.
What exactly do you mean by no Pokerwork on it?
It just needs a good clean up it's got a lovely sound to it.
I'm going to convert it to B/C
-
What exactly do you mean by no Pokerwork on it?
"Pokerwork" is a design pressed into the wood using heat, hence the name - which is originally for wood that has a design burnt into it with a heated poker. There is none of that on the box you've bought, which is covered in smooth birdseye-figured wood, so it's not a pokerwork as such.
-
I have a question. Is the finish on that box actually pecky birdseye veneer, I've seen them before and always thought it was a celluloid finish made to look more like wood. No pun intended, of course.
-
cpsmart,
On all the similar Hohners I have seen, it's neither a real birdseye figure in the wood itself nor a celluloid coating. It's a sort of "faux" painted finish that is very thin and fairly fragile, probably screened or rolled on the wood; the wood itself doesn't have a birdseye figured grain. I'm sure triskel knows this but his wording may have misled you. You can see that the birdseye is only "skin deep" when bits of the finish flake off or are otherwise damaged. A lot of cheaper German button accordions and concertinas have a faux grain similarly applied as a finish layer.
Having said that, when it's in good condition, the "faux birdseye" finish of these Hohners looks great IMO.
PG
-
On all the similar Hohners I have seen, it's neither a real birdseye figure in the wood itself nor a celluloid coating. It's a sort of "faux" painted finish that is very thin and fairly fragile, probably screened or rolled on the wood; the wood itself doesn't have a birdseye figured grain. I'm sure triskel knows this but his wording may have misled you.
That's the meaning my wording was meant to suggest, though maybe it wasn't successful in that... I've a couple of them here, with the finish starting to wear off beneath one of them.
-
That's pretty much what I thought when I saw it. I couldn't imagine they would have used real figured veneer on the more inexpensive boxes in the 30s. It looked more like paint or plastic.
-
Germany, mid-1930s.
But though it's the same style, there's no pokerwork on it.
Just out of curiosity, is there any actual pokerwork on 'Pokerwork' Hohners?
-
Germany, mid-1930s.
But though it's the same style, there's no pokerwork on it.
Just out of curiosity, is there any actual pokerwork on 'Pokerwork' Hohners?
If you mean "Has anybody actually burnt a design into the wood with a red-hot poker?" then the answer is no. But the wood has undergone a "pokerwork" process, that has pressed a design into it using pressure and heat.
-
But not on the current models, which just have a pattern (screen?) printed in black and gold.
-
Well, it's only us players that call them Pokerworks. Hohner call them Goldbrand.
Rob.
-
"Goldbrand" means that a pattern is burnt into the wood and then colored with gold.
-
Well, it's only us players that call them Pokerworks. Hohner call them Goldbrand.
Rob.
Rob,
I have a 72 pp. English language Hohner catalog, presumably dated a little later than 1926 (catalog # 700), that lists several models of "Hohner poker work Accordeons" (quoting pp. 25 -32).
PG
-
Well, it's only us players that call them Pokerworks. Hohner call them Goldbrand.
Over here in the Netherlands the common name for the instrument is 'Goudbrand', which is exactly the same (gold is goud in Dutch). More popular the are called 'Goudbrandje' (diminutive). Diminutives are quite common in Dutch. A bit off topic but speaking about dimnutives: there are players over here (those who play the posh Costalotti's, or whatever0) who arrogantly say, when you come along with your 'Goudbrand': "Ah, a Hohnertje" (diminutive). I always reply when the show their instrument: "Ah, a Castagnaritje". (little Castagnari). Great fun to see their reaction >:E
Robert
-
Cheers for all the info folks i've got a fair idea now as to what i've bought.
Looks like a B/C conversion project coming Theo's way.
-
Well, it's only us players that call them Pokerworks. Hohner call them Goldbrand.
Rob.
Rob,
I have a 72 pp. English language Hohner catalog, presumably dated a little later than 1926 (catalog # 700), that lists several models of "Hohner poker work Accordeons" (quoting pp. 25 -32).
PG
Most of the time Hohner seem to just call them No 2915.
-
Hi Theo,
In recent years, in the US, the 2 row model commonly called the "pokerwork" model (not the one referenced in the OP) is usually listed as 2815.
In my late 1920s catalog, the models designated as "poker work" include many different models such as 7015/21/8, 7017/21/12.... on up to 7767/21/12, as well as others including 3872/31/12.
PG
-
There's an old thread that goes into many of these issues: Pokerwork History (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,823.0.html)
-
Thanks for the link, Stephen, lots of great history there.
PG
-
Just on a different tangent here but i've just been looking at my own photo of the treble reeds photo number 5 to be precise and something has startled me.
How come there is metal round headed pins in between each reed plate and yet it doesn't cause inteference? I mean you are bridging the gap here between two vibrating plates with a metal pin and yet it still works. Obviously Hohner know what they are doing but it seems on scientific terms that the resonance would be carried over.
Just take a look at my Kriss III reeds (photo 3) to see they are all independant.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/14636356@N08/2073916845/ (http://www.flickr.com/photos/14636356@N08/2073916845/)
Strange but true.
-
I think the answer may be that although the pins bridge the plate gap, their main aim is to hold them tightly against the wooden frame, which will tend to deaden any plate vibes. (?) I had this arrangement on my one-row, but forgot to put the pins back when I rebuilt, with no appreciable sound difference.
-
I thought the purpose of such pins was so that the plates could be tacked into position before being waxed?
-
I thought the purpose of such pins was so that the plates could be tacked into position before being waxed?
I think they are put in afterwards. On the Liliput that I have just refurbished, the wax was so dried out that several reed plates were buzzing despite the pins, and two fell out when disturbed. Most of the pins were loose enough to be pulled out easily, even the big dome headed ones like drawing pins. I didn't put them back, but the holes were a useful visual guide for getting the reed plates back in exactly the same position.
-
I thought the purpose of such pins was so that the plates could be tacked into position before being waxed?
That makes sense to me. I suspect it speeded the assembly process to have someone tack the reeds in place and then pass the block off to someone else to wax.
-
I thought the purpose of such pins was so that the plates could be tacked into position before being waxed?
That makes sense to me. I suspect it speeded the assembly process to have someone tack the reeds in place and then pass the block off to someone else to wax.
You would have great difficulty running wax between the plates with the pins in place.
I suspect it would be equally hard to knock the pins in without the plates being waxed down first!