Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Ebor_fiddler on February 13, 2008, 10:02:24 PM
-
I have recently acquired an "as new" Scarlatti D/G, on which I am learning, and find the bellows extremely stiff. Friends tell me that plenty of playing will clear the problem, but the stiffness itself limits the time in which I can physically practice. How long do bellows normally take to run in? Is there a quick (and safe!) way to loosen it up?
Chris.
-
Most of the cheap Chinese instruments like these suffer from verystiff bellows. Plenty of use is really the only way to improve things. You might try starting each practice session with a few minutes of air melodeon: hold the air button open and pull the bellows out as far as they will go, then close again. Repeat this until boredom sets in!
-
Is there a quick (and safe!) way to loosen it up?
Chris.
[/quote]
syrup of figs? Seriously though it may help to reduce the effort required if instead of pushing & pulling with gusto you concentrate on keeping the bellows as near closed as possible & devoloping wrist rather than whole arm action. The problem could then be that with a cheaper box the reeds may not respond well to a smaller air flow (the better quality of reeds 'talk' with vry little air flowing over them. But may be worth a try.
Has anybody tried hanging a box with stiff bellows up by the bass strap so the bellows are fully extended by the weight of the treble end, Ive a feeling that this may help loosen them but have never tried it.
george
-
concentrate on keeping the bellows as near closed as possible & devoloping wrist rather than whole arm action
Good advice and definitely something to work towards, but very hard to follow if you are a beginner still playing very slowly.
You can also practice playing as quietly as possible which means less air needed and less pressure on the bellows, therefore less strain on the arms and wrists. I found that the beginners that I've worked with tend to start out playing full volume all the time. Everything becomes much more relaxed if you play more gently.
-
"Has anybody tried hanging a box with stiff bellows up by the bass strap so the bellows are fully extended by the weight of the treble end, Ive a feeling that this may help loosen them but have never tried it."
I tried it with my small £15 Chinese I row but it made very little difference over a month or so
-
I tried hanging up one of my black pearls (with treble stretching the bellows) it did seem to slightly ease them but not much. I think not securing the bellows fully closed - i.e. leave the straps undone - helps too.
Try lots of small practices (up to five minutes) each day rather than one long one. It's easier on the arms and allows you to build up your strength without strain.
-
A very extreme solution, not recommended unless you know what you are doing:
Take the bellows off, spray the inside with water to dampen all the cardboard, then work the bellows in and out. Once the card is all nice and damp then clamp it very firmly with pressure applied to the bellows frame, and to the interior of the folds so they are clamped tightly. Then leave to dry for several days at room temperature.
I have used this method successfully on new concertina bellows, but I've not tried it on big box bellows.
Disclaimer: I take no responsibility for the consequences if this goes wrong
-
Thanks Theo - I DONT KNOW WHAT I'M DOING, so I'll leave your latest solution until I do! Thanks for all you other helpful ideas as well. Thanks to everybody else too, especially those who suggested ways of playing that would do the job and not k*****r my underused muscles.
-
A very extreme solution, :
....Take the bellows off, spray the inside with water to dampen all the cardboard, .
It may also not be the cardboard but the surface cloth or paper. There can be an enenermous increase in bellows stiffness after the surface cloth is glued compared to what it was without it. If the cloth is glued carelessly, or the material is too thick, or you use wrong type of glue or too much of it, you get very stiff bellows. With same disclaimers as Theo the water trick might work applied on the outside as well...
-
If we realy let our imaginations run wild we could well come up with some heath robinson devices for bellows loosening that at best may not wrk and at worst may buggr the bellows completely !
I think some sort of mechanical device , preferably an existing one, should be coupled by some means or other to the ends of the bellows (separatd from the box ends) in such a way that the devices natural movement would repeatedly stretch the bellows without any effort on the part of the owner,
Various methods come to mind! Plan1 - connect one end of bellows to lounge door & other to adjacent wall so stretching takes place everytime door opened & shut, particularly suitable for those withchildren who are always going in & out of room. Plan 2! connect one end to grannies rocking chair & other end to fixed object end then get grannie rocking!, Plan 3 - those fortunate to have a good old fashioned thunderbox with high mounted systern opperated by lavatory chain could substitute bellows for chain so that thunderbox could be flushed by pulling bellows - the legth of time taken to loosten the bellows could be greatly reduced by putting laxative in everybodys (exept owner of bellows) to increase freqency of pulling!
george, thankfully with neither bellows nor bowels that need loosening
-
Plan 4
Attach left hand to one end, right hand to the other and play it for an hour a day minimum! ;D ;D
-
There IS a simple and good tried method, used many times with 100% success.
Take the accordion, open the air valve or depress all the buttons, and stretch it to the limit, then some more.
You'll hear slight crackling from the bellows - it's the excess of glue, it's OK. Keep it there for a few seconds (10-20 if you can keep it up), then relax. Try playing - already wa-ay better, isn't it? Do it a few times It took 3 days of such excersize (once a day!!!) for my Parrott to loosen. It served me for 3/5 years, then I sold it. When I pick up Chinese made Ariette of the cheaper version (the better version has very good bellows indeed) - this strertching gets it to the point of playability. Otherwise it's just some funky box with semi-flexible middle part.
Hanging it with air valve taped over and weights attached also works, but marginally. You never know how much is enough. When you stretch it, you feel the pressure and do a better job.
I guess the key here is the quality of the cardboard. In cheaper boxes it's ... cheaper and softer and can be stretched this way.
On more expencive boxes it may not work this way. My Castagnari Lilly didn't stretch much. It was new and with very stiff bellows. I sent it back, didn't feel the need to pay for inferior bellows work.
-
I was revisiting this thread which started a year ago. I just found a new Ariette for very cheap, the owner bought it 2 years ago and never played it... The bellows is the older model with the brown tape, very stiff indeed! It stayed closed for 2 years.
I found that stretching it (lots of cracking noises!) often and to its maximum, and playing the thing as much as I could significantly loosened it, to the point that it is now very playable and not so stiff.
I understand it's a cheap chinese box but it sorts of grows on you, I spent time fixing little details, adjusting the stop mechanism so stops now move freely, etc. Not bad after all.
-
"Has anybody tried hanging a box with stiff bellows up by the bass strap so the bellows are fully extended by the weight of the treble end, Ive a feeling that this may help loosen them but have never tried it."
I tried it with my small £15 Chinese I row but it made very little difference over a month or so
It the one row one of the so called childrens boxes, how does it play apart from tight? £15 seem a silly cheap price if it actually plays and reasonably in tune, Just the job to leave in my motorhome or carry in a rucksack.
-
Hasn't materials technology produced anything better than cardboard, cloth and paper yet?
-
Hasn't materials technology produced anything better than cardboard, cloth and paper yet?
I've been wondering about this myself. Seems to me that a supple vinyl material would be more flexible, maybe even weigh less. Plastics work harden at different rates, some experimenting would have to be done to find one that could withstand repeated play without stretching or ripping. If it's longevity and exposure to the elements that is a concern with vinyl or other polymers, just look at paper and card stock. Old boxes require bellows work anyway from failing glue and torn paper.
Would kevlar work, if it was woven sufficiently tight?
Players would have the extra advantage of being protected by bullets and other high-velocity projectiles fired at the band in protest of shoddy skill, excess volume, or repertoire. ;D
-
québécois, btw, good to see you're having a nice time with the Ariette. My first impression was that it wasn't consistent witht he current Hohner Chinese line of boxes. I'll have to take a second look next time I'm at the shop where I played one, if getting one secondhand for a project is wirth a few hours. Have you changed it more since the initial tweaks?
-
I did not have to do much more after the initial fixes.
For the box, I think they had a few versions, the earlier had very stiff bellows with the brown tape, now the later ones came with a different bellows with black tape, which I think is a bit better. They also have larger stop knobs.
The issues that I found with this box all have to do with a "quick and dirty" approach to build it, like parts that dont fit well together, rough edges, flimsy keyboard with cheap pallets, cheap shoulder straps, bass buttons that are not straight, stop registers that don't close well, etc
Many of the reeds need adjustment to become responsive, otherwise they need lots of air.
However the treble reed blocks are very nicely made, the bass block is also properly fit. At least it's easy to dismantle and fix, we can replace and/or tune the reeds very easily.
BTW we do not see the word Hohner anywhere on the box!!! The little plate only says Ariette. The warranty card and book are from Hohner.
So if you can find one for cheap (they sell new on eBay for about USD 300) and are ready to spend 5 or 6 hours on repairs then it's not so bad. I only paid CAD 200 for mine.
There are other brands that look absolutely identical, one of them is Milan. I bet they come from the same factory.
-
Hasn't materials technology produced anything better than cardboard, cloth and paper yet?
Cardboard is cheap and price is always an issue. Could some other modern material be cheaper? Cardboard can be is manufactured from used materials and in large quantities. It has also been used for 200 years which proves it works, so why change.
The surface material in Morgane does not feel like paper or cloth, rather something synthetic. Also the leather doesn't feel like genuine leather, again feels like synthetic material. In my digi Roland the leather feels just like the one in Morgane.
-
It the one row one of the so called childrens boxes, how does it play apart from tight? £15 seem a silly cheap price if it actually plays and reasonably in tune, Just the job to leave in my motorhome or carry in a rucksack.
Just a bit of fun really, I have one which I call my 'pocket melodeon' as it does fit in my overcoat pocket. But 'serious' playing will give you sore fingers as well as a frustrating lack of notes. On the good side the kids love to have a go. My nipper learnt a tune and then there was no stopping him. £7 pounds when I got mine 6 years ago, but it is still going strong.
-
If it's longevity and exposure to the elements that is a concern with vinyl or other polymers, just look at paper and card stock.
My concern would be my own exposure to vinyls - and longevity! My other half is currently researching the effects of "endocrine-disturbing" chemicals. Trust me, you don't want to be breathing in some of the stuff that PVC releases into the atmosphere. (Don't buy PVC shower curtains...) Paper, cloth and cardboard seem just fine to me, thank you.
-
Has anybody tried hanging a box with stiff bellows up by the bass strap so the bellows are fully extended by the weight of the treble end, Ive a feeling that this may help loosen them but have never tried it.
Yes...............on some stiff Castagnari bellows. I hung them in a closet for 3 months and also did the stretching exercise too. It helped substantially. They were, of course , good quality bellows. Whether it would work on cheaper one, I don't know.
Robin
-
It worked on my Scarlatti finally, when I had the courage to leave it hung for a couple of days.. Thanks all! :D
-
I put a similar post up a few weeks ago concerning my chinese made melodeon. Lots of advice to hang it etc came back.
I tried hanging it with weights for a few days - not very effective.
So last week I went on holiday in Scotland and took a remote cottage in the shadow of Ben Lawers -played the damn thing for at least two hours every day. I now have muscles like Charles Atlas, and the bellows are still too stiff.
Corollary to the tale however: As soon as I got home yesterday I went straight back to my lovely old Hohner Erica - now I find that I can hardly play the thing 'cos I'm heaving a very soft set of perfectly played in bellows around. It's going to take time to re-adjust. So be careful - cheap chinese bellows can seriously mess you up. I've now also gone up a shirt size!
AL
-
I think one of the issues with cheap Chinese boxes is that the reeds are usually unresponsive and need a lot of air to produce a sound, which adds to the difficulty of handling a stiff bellows. I ordered a set of italian reeds that I will fit to the Ariette and these should turn it into a half-decent box.
I too find it a big switch when going back to play on "good" bellows, but not on a negative way. The Chinese box is good for the warm-up part!
-
I ordered a set of italian reeds that I will fit to the Ariette and these should turn it into a half-decent box.
Now strangely enough that's what I've been thinking about. Not that I actually KNOW how to fit a set of reeds (which probably puts me roughly in the same league as the factory that made this thing in the first place) - but how would I go about working out what to do - what reeds to order etc? And would it be worth it?
AL
-
It will be the second reed transplant I'll do. I replaced reeds from a 1-row 2-voice box with a set I bought from CGM. I'm a pretty handy guy (I used to repair old cameras, and I am good at woodworking, etc) so it was a bit experimental but I managed, as I also had to do some adjustments to the bass reed block to accomodate narrower reedplates, etc. They were helpful in proposing a solution.
The 4-voice reed set I just ordered (Cagnoni macchina) cost me GBP 90 shipping included. I paid CAD 200 for the Ariette, so for roughly CAD 400 I will have a usable cajun-style box!
-
The 4-voice reed set I just ordered (Cagnoni macchina) cost me GBP 90 shipping included. I paid CAD 200 for the Ariette, so for roughly CAD 400 I will have a usable cajun-style box!
That's really great - CGM is that Charlie Marshall?
AL
-
That's really great - CGM is that Charlie Marshall?
AL
Yes. The sets they sold me are really nice. They offer excellent service.
The MM reeds were factory-tuned dry, I only had to do a little tuning to the L and H sets. The biggest challenge was to modify the reedblocks to accomodate the new reeds, which have longer reedplates than the originals. I had to cut and extend the MM reedblock, and adjust some of the cavities for other reeds. The original basses had 6 plates, the new set had 5... I had to disable one of the ports.
The box sounds terrific now! And uses a lot less air than with the original reeds.
-
Sounds great - I shall be contacing Charlie in the near future!
AL
-
Just remember that replacing reeds may not be a straightforward remove/clean the old wax/place the new/wax operation!
Reed plates come in various shapes, lenghts and thicknesses and the reedblock may not accept the new reed plates without some modification. May not accept them at all! I was surprised to see how different two reeds producing the same note might be so different from one maker to another. The chinese reeds I removed were short and wide, the italians are comparatively narrow and long.