Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on June 22, 2010, 08:22:38 PM

Title: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andrew Culwell on June 22, 2010, 08:22:38 PM
http://www.cajuncraftedaccordions.com/Ordering.php

I might not be the first to post about this gentleman and his accordions.  Anyone have experience with him.  Seems to be rather well priced for a box with Binci reeds.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 07, 2010, 02:28:17 PM
Butted corners.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Christopher K. on July 09, 2010, 12:24:40 AM
Butted corners.

I'm not familiar with Tim Reed's boxes, but this joint is suitable for an accordion case and I don't think it's a fair assessment of an accordion's quality given how many other factors contribute to a make a high quality instrument.

It's not much different than a mitred corner, when you're talking wood panels that are only half an inch thick. Moreover, a butt joint in this case has the advantage of at least one half of the joint using long grain, whereas a mitre is all end grain, i.e. not a glue surface. I've never seen any accordion suffer from racking due to poor construction as by butt joints as we generally don't use them for step stools and there is no sheer force involved in playing.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Christopher K. on July 09, 2010, 12:31:53 AM
http://www.cajuncraftedaccordions.com/Ordering.php

I might not be the first to post about this gentleman and his accordions.  Anyone have experience with him.  Seems to be rather well priced for a box with Binci reeds.

Ajay,

There is a fellow on YouTube by the name of Jim who plays mostly Marc Savoy boxes, but he has experience with a wide variety of single row Cajun instruments as well as with instrument modification, maintenance, tuning, etc. I had a conversation with him once about a few other Louisiana-style box makers when I was considering one I saw on Ebay and if you shoot him a PM then he might have the information you're looking for. He's in pretty regular contact with some of those makers. There's also a Cajun box forum that's just as active as mel.net I just can't remember the name at the moment.

Here's his profile page on TY:
http://www.youtube.com/user/BmoreBusker

Chris
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 09, 2010, 02:55:56 AM
Butt joints....
Are by many, not considered a joint at all

The issue is one of taking extra time and skill to make a joint that does not show end grain and requires more than junior high school woodworking abilities.

Many Cajun accordeon makers take the time and trouble to make mitre joints, among them Jude Moreau and  Poullard.

Butts are expedient, take no skill and are unsightly.

Just an opinion.

There is NO good reason to use a butt joint other than a time saver and lack of skill.

The following accordeon makers use mitres
Kincora
Gaillard
Bergflodt
Castagnari
Melodie
Messervier
Clement Breton
Sagne
Van der AA
Van der Leuuw

There are always apologists for  butt joints.
Why not just make em ?

Problem solved.

No one ever says... oh  too bad   mitre joints

I spoke with Jr Martin and wanted to order and accordeon... he would not do a butt joint
I asked him why...
Answer.. I sell all I can make without them.

Buy em if you like em.

Butt  where else is the builder cutting corners. ?
Saltarelle ie Dino Baffetti
etc
etc
etc
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andrew Culwell on July 09, 2010, 05:05:31 AM
I've seen this argument many times on the site here!  I see your point about craftsmanship and I think it's fair to address that point, seems like we pay a premium for these boxes and they should be built in a premium way.  I hear also this is a huge talking point and area of discussion between these very same makers.  It seems to be a reoccurring theme here on Mel.net.  My Globe Special has mitred corners and I think they look nicer than the butted joints. As to whether they affect acoustic quality, that I doubt!  It is a sign however of a maker who cuts corners (no pun intended) the fact is that craftsmanship is important if your going to spend 2400.00 on a box!  That said Tim Reeds boxes start at 1200.00 which to me allow for butted joints as long at they are made well and sound great.  That I don't know yet. Still thinking and talking about this investment.  However Tim says he uses Binci A Mano reeds and high end woods etc.  Since I have not heard his boxes as of yet I cannot judge, butted joints aside I'd say that 1200 dollars is quite reasonable for a box w/ Binci A Mano.  IMHO!
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on July 09, 2010, 09:57:54 AM
Yo Jeff. I use mitres so add me to your list.  ;)
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Graham W on July 09, 2010, 10:31:05 AM
Surely,

If strength, elegance and the acme of wood working caftsmanship are important then the darn things should  have secret mitred dovetail corners .  .  ? ;D

Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on July 09, 2010, 11:26:58 AM
Surely,

If strength, elegance and the acme of wood working caftsmanship are important then the darn things should  have secret mitred dovetail corners .  .  ? ;D



Fancy pants.  ;)
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: C age ing on July 09, 2010, 12:38:12 PM
I suppose it depends on whether you want to play the box or just put it on the shelf and admire it.

Ho hum. Each to their own.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 09, 2010, 01:29:44 PM
If strength, elegance and the acme of wood working caftsmanship are important then the darn things should  have secret mitred dovetail corners .  .  ? ;D

I'd rather go for something like the third and fourth boxes in the first row:
http://www.eurus.dti.ne.jp/~k-yazawa/jointwork.html
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Theo on July 09, 2010, 01:59:10 PM
I've often thought it would be nice to build a box that looked as rough as a bandgers wotsits, but played like a dream!  Unfinished exterior wood surfaces with sawmarks, maybe a quick paint job with a few dribbles, and the corners rubbed away to show contrasting wood, but carefully built action and reedwork. :o
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 09, 2010, 02:26:35 PM
Agreed, but with proper mitres.

Theo you are describing some of my furniture and my  (folk)art .

Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Theo on July 09, 2010, 02:29:42 PM
Agreed, but with proper mitres.
Of course, but disguised.


Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 09, 2010, 03:17:08 PM
Theo,
You are describing my furniture and  my folkart.

Added to the list of Mitre Makers

Rees Wesson
Hohner
Beltuna
Gagne
Beltuna
serafini


Butt  Boxes

Savoy
Jr Martin
All the wannabe copyists..who are slapping boards together , belt sanding the butt joints and covering them with bits of tin ( aluminum ) to cover
and then engrave/imprint billboard sized scrolls etc (clumsy quasi arte nouveau ) on the end plates to distract from the clumsy corners.
Why is no one doing something original.  Oh I see, it's tradititon... what tradition.. German , Bohemian Saxon or bogarted (er adopted.)
I appreciate all the elements and the idea, but how about just a spark of imagination or perhaps a slightly higher degree of workmanship.
Unless that too is part of the ( new) tradition.


To butt or not to butt, that is the question.

And now I'll butt out.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on July 09, 2010, 03:33:57 PM
but, but, but..............................!
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: emrock on July 09, 2010, 04:29:59 PM
Must admit that my home made mini melodeon prototype has butt joints. Though the box is tiny, and the joints are all secured with a 2mm brass pin as well. This may change with the next one I build but for the time being I'm a butt jointer  >:E

runs for cover
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Mike Averill on July 09, 2010, 05:39:00 PM
An accurate 90 degree cut takes just as much skill and machine setting as an accurate 45 degree cut. Its just a different angle and is of little relevance to the working or playing of the finished melodeon.Even if it did take more skill, so what? wasted effort and expense.
 
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 09, 2010, 07:40:48 PM
I've often thought it would be nice to build a box that looked as rough as a bandgers wotsits, but played like a dream!  Unfinished exterior wood surfaces with sawmarks, maybe a quick paint job with a few dribbles, and the corners rubbed away to show contrasting wood, but carefully built action and reedwork. :o

The "Imaginaire" that Rees had (has?) was a bit like that.
What you described sounds like 'shabby chic' -- in which case, nails might be the appropriate "joinery"!
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 09, 2010, 08:18:43 PM
So if it does not take any more skill, why not do it.... because it does take more skill and more time

Jr Martin flat said it took too much time... he tried it and decided against it... expedient.

Mitres do not show exposed end grain.. look at Japanese  and most oriental furniture.. never an exposed end..

Wasted effort and expense... always an apologist for substandard... no skill effort

So I will take it that all the accordeon makers listed are wasting their time and adding needless expense

Imagine a Gaillard with butt joints.....

Ypu buy and play what you like .. I'll stick with quality

And If Martin an dSavoy are cutiing corners making butt joints and their quality ( IMNSHO) is matched by many who sell for less, is not the saved time ergo money going into their pockets and not going back to the customer.  Computed to not such a great value.. I don;t pay for fame but I'll pay more for excellence..

Might er Might not   I'll Mitre

PS:

Perhaps I did not mention I am a full time furniture maker... no ifs and or "butts"

I still maintain that a box maker who makes expeditious butts, is cutting corners elsewhere.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Mike Averill on July 09, 2010, 09:38:35 PM
If your buying a melodeon as a piece of furniture then fair enough, if your buying it as a musician don't worry about it. If the maker has saved a bit of money on the corners good luck to him. He might stand a better chance of staying in business to make your next box. Even if end grain does offend you It really doesnt make any difference one a 1 row as the metal corners cover it.



Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andrew Culwell on July 10, 2010, 04:17:48 AM
  I think your somewhat correct in your assumptions when you say if one cuts corners on construction they might pay less attention to detail in other areas such as reed work etc.  I think though that if your a person of relatively modest means and you have the choice between a Messervier that runs a couple thousand or more and a cajun box that sounds good seems adequately constructed and is durably if not beautifully made, and costs a fraction of the name box then that's a logical choice.  If Savoy started mitering his corners and then subsequently raised the cost 2-300 bucks I'd tell him to go pound sand.  As it is I can't afford one of his boxes butt jointed or not. 

I have a Stickley Bed that I treasure and it's construction is probably up to your standards, I inherited that bed but if I had to go out and buy one now it would break the bank, I'd sooner go to Ikea and not have to pawn my soul for a bed.  The fact is that it's all well and good to talk about mitering joints but if I can't afford it then I don't give a hoot as to whether it's mitered or not!  I think that mitering is probably the sign of a superior craftsman, attention to detail is always a good prognosticator of the rest of the construction of an accordion.   I think Savoy is overpriced and 75% of the people who buy his boxes do so so they can have a "real Savoy"   Or is that Mcoy? 
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Christopher K. on July 10, 2010, 08:53:39 AM
I don't agree that a using butt joint, where a mechanically stronger joint is not required given the expected use (holding on the lap or dangling from straps), is cutting any corners at all. It takes about the same amount of time to prepare four properly squared butt joints for glueup as it does to set up the shooting board with a donkey in order to dress the edges of two freshly mitred boards. If we were talking about tables, or furniture that is commonly leaned upon or carries things, then it would be different.

I ask myself: What is it about an accordion that requires a mitre joint to be used for its casework over a reinforced butt joint? Aesthetics. So why not half blind dovetails? Why not mitred rabbet joints? A reinforced butt joint is just as strong for this purpose, otherwise we would be seeing $1200+ accordions at sessions everywhere which suffer from racking after heavy play (and we don't). Has anyone ever seen a designer accordion that has been broken due to poorly designed corners?

Moreover, using a butt joint doesn't indicate poor quality in other areas of a fine accordion. Where could other corners be cut? It's not like a car where there are thousands of parts which can be hidden from view. If the builder "cuts corners" in tuning the reeds then his boxes would be out of tune. If he used a poor finish then the wood would be blotchy. If he used poorly seasoned, unstable lumber then the joints would tear themselves apart. If he used strips of newspaper for ventili then he would do fine as a roadie for a conjunto band, but fail as an accordion builder. No one claims that a manufacturer is cutting corners when they use veneered plywood instead of solid wood for the casework. Why is a butt jointed case that is quite strong and not known to fall apart in this particular application considered cutting a corner? Most mitred corners in accordions that I have seen are reinforced from the inside, much as a butt joint is.

I bought our bed at Ikea. It was inexpensive, it is quite comfortable, and it fit in the car on the way home. But while the bed exceeded my expectations, I have to warn you that the 50 cent coffee is genuinely terrible.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 10, 2010, 02:57:18 PM
Hey Ajay, FYI several years ago -- very recently in fact -- a new Savoy box cost about $1200 and the cheaper Cajun boxes were about $900.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 10, 2010, 03:13:12 PM
It is good that some accept mediocrity.

Some folks will buy a name brand of modest quality , for a higher price, rather than buy a better item
by an unknown maker for less. . This perpetuates the myth.

What is really silly is that the copiests simply don't get it, and reproduce the
mediocrity as if that mythical maker's product is the standard; and the standard is low.

It has been  said that it what you do when no one is watching that is a real determinate of character

I also believe that unseen areas of extra effort determine quality. That which you do not see.
 A  box  maker ( or any other craftsman) can demonstrate his respect for the materials ,  the craft , and the customer by
that unseen extra measure.   And that is ... character.  It often translates to an undefineable quality, beyond simple excellence.
And I suspect that the maker did not really expect compensation for the extra effort.


This has always been a point of curiousity to me..
An accordeon maker offers three levels of quality
1.  Plain
2, Slightly figured
3 Highly figured

The retail price goes up for each level...

1.  $1995
2.  $2295
3.  $2495

Why , when the increase in the cost of the materials is about $25

There is nothing that justifies the use of a butt joint. In my opinion it demonstrates a contempt for the customer, laziness, greed , or lack of skill.   No excuses.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 10, 2010, 03:22:14 PM
I don't agree that a using butt joint, where a mechanically stronger joint is not required given the expected use (holding on the lap or dangling from straps), is cutting any corners at all. It takes about the same amount of time to prepare four properly squared butt joints for glueup as it does to set up the shooting board with a donkey in order to dress the edges of two freshly mitred boards.

I do a lot of joinery by hand using traditional methods and I believe that your statement above leads to a conclusion that the mitering is an 'extra' process, not 'about the same amount of time.'  The butt jointed Cajun boxes require simple, repeatable table saw cuts that can even be done with a cheap contractor's saw or chop saw.  The long miters require more precision -- which could be done with a finer table saw, with a quality framemaker's trimmer, or with a shooting board as you mentioned.  I don't think that very many Cajun builders have even heard of a shooting board or have the skill to sharpen and hone a handplane to use with the shooting board.
Moreover, one can't just consider a single joint, but rather, the precision and time required to make all four boards and joints fit properly.  

Quote
I ask myself: What is it about an accordion that requires a mitre joint to be used for its casework over a reinforced butt joint? Aesthetics. So why not half blind dovetails? Why not mitred rabbet joints?

There is actually a good reason not to use the half blind dovetails -- the wall thickness of the accordion's box is really too thin for this wonderful joint.  And mitred rabbet joints ARE in fact used on some boxes, and I bet Jeff would approve of this!  There are also some other possible joints that would be practical as well as attractive for accordion frames.

Quote
A reinforced butt joint is just as strong for this purpose, otherwise we would be seeing $1200+ accordions at sessions everywhere which suffer from racking after heavy play (and we don't).

Correct, but what we do see are a lot of boxes that require metal hardware to hold together their butt joints.  And this makes for uncomfortable play for those of us who angle a one row box on the left thigh -- a common playing position for Quebecois box players.  The Mélodie has mitered joints, rounded at the corners, and is the most comfortable one-row box I've ever played.  So it is not necessary a purely aesthetic concern.
A friend of mine who repairs and tunes accordions shared a point of view about Cajun accordions that I find rings true.  They can be viewed as a form of naive folk art.  For some buyers, this has a special value (that is ALSO aesthetic) --- this explains the relatively high price for a box coming from Marc Savoy's workshop.  The builders are largely self-taught and have made accordions that serve the purposes of the kind of music played by Cajuns and some Zydeco and Creole musicians.  I can understand why some people admire them in the same way that I might admire a simple homemade banjo.
Maybe 6 or 7 years ago there was a Cajun builder who was offering boxes at a low price -- around $800.  One of the places were he was saving time was in applying the finish.  They were fairly ugly but there were individuals who felt that it was "purely aesthetic" and that the instruments would play just fine.  In fact there were positive reviews being posted on another forum.  It turned out that the people who liked the boxes and posted glowing comments had very little experience with quality boxes -- they had been playing Hohner Ariettes and such.  I recall that one fellow who had a stable of Castagnaris ended up ordering one and was fairly disappointed.  At any rate, I don't think that the builder is in business any more!
As far as the boxes in question on this thread, who knows how they sound and how they feel to play?
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: oggiesnr on July 10, 2010, 11:31:34 PM
A mitre joint is but a butt joint made on an angle, with modern glues it should be no stronger.  Aesthetics are in the eye of the beholder but I've seen more bad mitres than butts.

If you're talking about woodworking then consider joints such as mitred mortice and tenons, hidden dovetails etc which give structural integrity to the joint (strictly speaking neither mitres or butts are joints to the purist).

BTW a biscuited jointed butt joint will be more stable than a pinned and glued mitre.

Steve
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 11, 2010, 04:51:41 AM
A mitre joint is but a butt joint made on an angle, with modern glues it should be no stronger.  Aesthetics are in the eye of the beholder but I've seen more bad mitres than butts.
If you're talking about woodworking then consider joints such as mitred mortice and tenons, hidden dovetails etc which give structural integrity to the joint (strictly speaking neither mitres or butts are joints to the purist).
BTW a biscuited jointed butt joint will be more stable than a pinned and glued mitre.

These comments about hidden dovetails, and now biscuits, lead me to believe that some don't realize how thin the material is.  Also the mitered mortise and tenon makes no sense on the joint on an accordion.

Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on July 11, 2010, 05:21:40 AM
Eenie  weeniee teenie little  biscuits...  butt biscuits no less...
End grain to long grain.. worst combination
End to end  ie  mitre... better and cleaner and no exposed end grain  for the ingress and egress of moisture
The "Cajun" made boxes usually have a wall thickness of 3/8ths of an inch
Most Euro and Quebec boxes are thinner

Butt or mitre... simple choice between the two...
there are other options  ( other than  eenie weenie teenie  butt biscuits)

Bad mitres are usually the result of bad equipment, poor skill level  but mostly the humidity of the wood at construction and or wide swings in ambient humidity

Why oh  why are most picture frames mitred when it is not necessary given the excuses   er  reasons. offered by the apologists
for butts ?    


"A mitre joint is a butt joint made on an angle"    (right)

A butt joint by definition is end grain to long grain which requires a single 90 degree cut.

An end grain glued to long grain ,then  stressed, will rip the long  grain right off.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: acctech on August 25, 2010, 06:44:12 AM
I almost weighed in, but then I figured why get all out of joint about joints. So Cheers instead.  :|glug
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: nfldbox on August 25, 2010, 12:55:57 PM
As an "expert" in another field I am always so aware of how flummoxed anyone can be by experts.
The end result of the above is I know some new words--"shooting board"--but still have no idea whether butt joints on a cajun box are such a bad idea.
I must admit I prefer mitre to butt.
But I prefer parsnips to turnips, with much the same justification.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on August 25, 2010, 03:41:53 PM
Butt  joints are a bad idea on any accordeon, "Cajun" or not.
As to butt joints on a "Cajun" box...    there are other better options , and many "Cajun" builders use mitres.
It is simply a standout that the two most famous and prolific makers, namely Savoy and Martin ,use butt joints. and they are
among the most expensive. So, now along come the copiests who emulate their "hero" box makers and continue the mediocrity rather than take that extra little step and make a mitre joint.
Ever see a mitre joint on a Castagnari Melodeon... nope,  and it is the same price as some "Cajun" accordeons.

There will always be apologists, with other than logical reasons, to justify butts.

IMNSHO  there is no justification for a butt joint   (see previous posts)
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Quebecois on August 25, 2010, 03:45:23 PM
No one mentioned the 'historical' aspect of butt joints in accordion making!

Perhaps some early accordion makers who had a limited number of tools had to simplify the construction of their boxes, the most important was the sound and playability rather than sophistication of the joints! Hence some makers might still be using that technique for authenticity... Just an idea!

 
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on August 25, 2010, 05:41:18 PM
A simple shop made mitre box....
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on August 25, 2010, 07:03:00 PM

Ever see a mitre joint on a Castagnari Melodeon... nope,  and it is the same price as some "Cajun" accordeons.


Yo Jeff, I think you meant "butt joint"
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on August 26, 2010, 02:24:14 PM
Yup..   thanks... 

let's try that again

ever see a butt joint on a Castagnari ?
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Theo on August 27, 2010, 06:40:48 PM
Even cheap Saxony built boxes with cheap timber and cheap brass reeds always have mitred corners.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Mike Averill on August 27, 2010, 06:58:06 PM
Even cheap Saxony built boxes with cheap timber and cheap brass reeds always have mitred corners.
That proves it then - mitres are cheap joints - nothing to fuss over.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Broadland Boy on August 27, 2010, 07:41:44 PM
Disregarding structural strength factors, a mitre joint leaves no exposed end grain so unless covering in sheet material, there need be no special finishing time taken to prepare and match the end grain when using a shellac or varnish finish.

The early 1900's Hohner I'm working on at present has mitred corners as does the relatively modern looking and 'bargain basement' end mini melodeon with one plate reeds which I have just denuded of the remnants of perloid covering, I'm not so certain of the Hohner's wood but I suspect birch and the mini is beech.

in the early to mid 1900's for most machine made / mass produced, non furniture domestic goods if you wanted looks you mitred, if looks were unimportant or to be veneered or otherwise covered then butt or half lapped seemed to predominate, if you wanted ultimate strength like battery boxes then the comb joint was favoured, ultimate strength and looks brought in the dovetail. Both butt and mitred joins were often strengthened by using an internal fillet or block (or by default another part glued across them)  and in the days of hot animal glues, assembly and hold while drying were also an important consideration.

Yes, I can also think of lots of exceptions  :D

Take the older box makers who survived and they must have got the balance of fitness for purpose versus cost right, as the price of labour rose and mechanisation became (perhaps) more affordable compromises have had to be made and we eventually end up with Chinese Hohners, I've hear lots about their perceived tonal deficiencies, some about their finish but nothing about their wholesale disintegration - something must be still working or we'd see the ends being injection moulded in some rigid plastic or foam.

So to modern makers, whichever joint they choose to use, if the box sounds and looks right it should sell, if you don't like the sound or it looks badly made, well you'll not pay top whack for it and the maker either compromises on price or improves quality or goes hungry.

Given their greater size were PA box ends made in the same way or not ?

Richard - who has just installed the latest version of Bills tuner and may attack the old Hohners bronze reeds tonight and try to teach them some manners - watch this space for Olympic class swearing or tears before bedtime :P
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 04, 2010, 05:28:51 PM
Added to the list of Mitre Makers

... Zero Sette (one row 4 stop) and the bellows frame on my Dino Baffetti Black Pearl.

There's too much black paint and stuff to tell on the main body of the Baffetti and I don't want to start poking it and make it leaky.

I can confirm the wood is thin, but I think we've all seen that before.

From "bored of Coventry", not having got down to to Stowmarket today  :-\
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: kenneads on October 18, 2010, 12:10:15 PM
I purchased a Tim Reed Cajun Accordion. Butt joints aside, I am not really happy with it. The stops are stiff - one is almost unworkable. I am going to pull it apart and see if I can remedy the problem. Also I am not really happy with the tuning. As I live in Australia sending it back for repair is not really an option.
Caveat Emptor - let the buyer beware. You get what you pay for.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy in Vermont on October 18, 2010, 06:16:07 PM
Caveat Emptor - let the buyer beware. You get what you pay for.

I'm sure there are several reasons for your dissatisfaction, but the stiff stop shouldn't be a problem.  That box has just moved from one climate to another that is drastically different.  Give the wood a chance to acclimate.  I'm more concerned about the stops that are NOT too stiff right now -- they might open up later and result in some air leakage.
In past threads regarding mitres vs. butt joints, Jeff and others (present author included) have taken flak for being picky about something not relevant to the sound or playability of the box.  Yet we have asserted time and time again that the joinery can be indicative of other, perhaps less visible, ways of taking less time and care and applying less skill to building an accordion.  While it is entirely possible for a satisfactory box to be made with butt joints, there is also a good chance that the builder also takes little pride in the keyboard's construction, the reedblocks or the tuning and setting of reeds. 
On another forum a butt-joint defender claimed that he had built several houses with butt joints, and it they were good enough for houses they were good enough for accordions.  By this same logic, it would make sense to build accordions out of wet "whitewood" sold in Home Depot.  Perhaps tar shingles for roofing should be used for the bellows?
Sorry for the rant, it's just that it is clear to me that the above poster was exposed to the "Tim Reed Cajun Accordions" via the internet, and that the same internet could have easily warned him away from what appeared to be a sub-par product.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on October 18, 2010, 09:31:10 PM
Reed  and I had some private e-mail exchanges..
seems like a nice guy but hopelessly deluded.
His idol,  Savoy.
His boxes, Savoy copies.

Butt brothers.


Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 18, 2010, 10:08:29 PM
Butt brothers.


......errrrrr.....sounds like you're implying more than just a common approach to joinery.... :o
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on October 18, 2010, 11:22:47 PM
Definitely wait for the wood to acclimatise.
I've brought accordions back from hot, humid Louisiana to cold, wet Wales and had to wait months for them to dry out.
Australia is another kettle of crawfish altogether.
Let it breathe.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: kenneads on October 19, 2010, 10:43:29 AM
Definitely wait for the wood to acclimatise.
I've brought accordions back from hot, humid Louisiana to cold, wet Wales and had to wait months for them to dry out.
Australia is another kettle of crawfish altogether.
Let it breathe.

How long does acclimatisation take? Contrary to popular belief; the climate of Australia differs immensley. Tim Reed accordions are not manufactured in hot, humid Louisiana but in cold, wet Chicago. Where I happen to live in Australia it is cold wet and windy. Very much down south, just across from Tasmania. Next stop Antarctica.

Not trying to start an argument about Tim's accordions, just making some observations.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on October 19, 2010, 11:35:19 AM
Sorry, I didn't realise he's in Chicago.
Definitely less humid than the swamps.  ;D
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Matthew B on October 19, 2010, 04:19:37 PM
I have a Cajun-built one-row that is pretty climate sensitive.  In a humid Maine summer it's quite happy and mellow.  In the heating season, once I fire up the wood-stove, it behaves very differently.  If I keep it in the living room for a few weeks the buttons start to snag a little on the holes, the stops stiffen up, and the whole thing creaks a bit when I start to play it.  I've found that storing it in the closet on the outside wall of the house, where we keep damp boots and coats, eases this problem significantly.  It took me quite a while to figure this out, and I had several false starts (eg unheated mud-room: bad plan).  Other boxes seem far more stable.  I suspect this is because many more of the Cajun's components are wooden, whereas the various and sundry other boxes I play have a lot more metal and plastic bits.  Another factor may be that some critical tolerances and clearances are a bit finer on "hand-crafted" instruments, so they don't take to change so well.  I had a chance to play a Wesson Clipper the other day (#10: thanks Liam!), and amongst other things, I was most impressed by how precise it all felt.  Perhaps a locally-built instrument tends to be better acclimatized?
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 19, 2010, 05:47:07 PM
I think it's more likey that the instrument was built without attempting to control the humidity of the enviroment in which it was made and/or with inadequately seasoned wood. If an instrument is made somewhere that's too dry or too wet or worse still, with different parts assembled at different humidity levels in an uncontrolled enviroment then it will react adversely to climactic changes. This problem is compounded if the timber isn't well-seasoned and is still drying out.

I have to take great care to maintain a level of 40-45%RH in my workshop, not only to ensure that the different parts all stay the shape and dimensions they're supposed to whilst I'm working on them but also that the finished instruments will react evenly to seasonal changes and were made in the middle of the range of humidity they'll typically encounter and can handle being a bit drier or wetter without too much trouble.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: ceemonster on October 19, 2010, 09:11:14 PM
well, since it's come up.....i have a good-quality C box purchased a couple years ago new as-new from an ebay seller, and one stop will not pull.  i have pulled as hard as i dare but don't wish to risk breaking it---any suggestions/thoughts?
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 19, 2010, 10:18:29 PM
This might sound incredibly daft but are you sure that there are actually as many voices as there are stops and that one isn't a non-functioning dummy put on for looks like some early Messerviers?.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on October 20, 2010, 12:22:53 AM
Chicago is humid in spring through summer

less so late fall and winter.


And  my my  yes those reeds swell and shrink in the humidity...

there are always going to be apologists.


Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Matthew B on October 20, 2010, 03:36:49 PM
Chicago is humid in spring through summer

less so late fall and winter.

And  my my  yes those reeds swell and shrink in the humidity...
there are always going to be apologists.

Wow.  I didn't know that.  I'll have to be more careful in the future. 

Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: waltzman on October 20, 2010, 05:57:59 PM
Steel reeds swelling and shrinking in the humidity??? 
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: Andrew Culwell on October 20, 2010, 06:13:29 PM
I think that Jeff's post was sarcasm...
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: rees on October 20, 2010, 10:35:44 PM
I think that Jeff's post was sarcasm...

No, really, not Jeff, surely? (chortle)  ;D
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: ceemonster on October 21, 2010, 10:07:01 PM
[This might sound incredibly daft but are you sure that there are actually as many voices as there are stops and that one isn't a non-functioning dummy put on for looks like some early Messerviers?]

well....this is a junior martin "C" box. i can check, but never heard of "dummy stops" on those. i will say, though, that this stop is so resistant i can't believe there is in fact a stop there. it doesn't feel like there's anything to pull, it feels nailed shut.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: melodeon on September 23, 2013, 04:08:02 AM
insist that the stops are for the maker or repair person to tune ONLY  and not to be used by the player.Keep in mind that many Cajun box makers
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: ButtonBox21 on September 23, 2013, 12:25:27 PM
Here is the link to the Cajun Accordion Discussion Group. http://pub21.bravenet.com/forum/static/show.php?usernum=1722942123&frmid=16&msgid=0 Or you can go to Big Nick Box Lessons and click on the link for the forum.  They are the group to go to if you want qualified feedback on Tim Reed accordions. There are players and builders on that site and you can get plenty of good info from them. Personally, I have never heard anything bad about Tim Reed accordions. I almost bought one a few years ago but couldn't get the money for it. Good luck. :||:
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: kenakordeon on September 23, 2013, 12:26:13 PM
My experience with Tim and his melodeons...He was an easy person to do business with and was always responsive to my emails.  The melodeon arrived by his estimated delivery date.  The stops were very stiff and acclimating for two weeks in another climate did not make them any easier to move.  Air was escaping at the flappers, the reeds themselves were breathy, I'm guessing due to bad leather adjustment.  I returned it to Tim for adjustment.  He returned it to me a few weeks later and then there were other problems including a reed plate that had fallen out of the block.  I was angry, called him and he agreed to refund my money including some extra to cover shipping costs.

This all happened almost three years ago.  I'm hoping that his skills have improved and that his boxes are now quality instruments.  I know at the time he was juggling full-time work, family and the building of his instruments.  For anyone who has been in that position its not easy and usually something suffers.

All that said, he was a pleasant person with, I believe, the right intentions.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: kenakordeon on September 23, 2013, 12:28:45 PM
If you are looking for a well-built Cajun melodeon, and don't want to pay the price for a Martin or Acadian, I suggest contacting Bryan LaFleur who builds L'Anse Grise accordions.  I've only played one, his 11th, and it was a wonderful instrument.  He's now into numbers 21 - 24, I think.
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: TommyD on November 23, 2025, 07:24:23 PM
I have seen pictures on eBay of Tim Reed ten button accordians! The Conor button joints are reinforced with metal!
Title: Re: Tim Reed Cajun accordions
Post by: TommyD on November 23, 2025, 07:27:18 PM
I have seen pictures on eBay of Tim Reed ten button accordians! The Conor butt joints are reinforced with metal!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal