Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Fungusface on August 09, 2010, 07:54:03 AM
-
How do you stop that Tinny sound you hear on Hohner Pokerworks or the Hohner "Slap" on the bass.
-
Not sure what you mean by the 'tinny' sound. Perhaps the instrument needs a re-tune?
The 'Hohner slap' is the noise made by the impact of the pallets on the table (the wood panel with the holes in it). The slap is particularly noticeable on the bass end, where the springs are quite strong, returning the pallets with quite a force. The treble end is also prone to the slap noise.
The facing material on the pallets may be thin, and/or old and hard. This will contribute to the noise. On my Erica, the original facing material was very thin leather, less than 1 mm thick. I replaced this with a 2 mm leather/felt combination, obtainable from Charlie Marshall. The pallet noise has been very much reduced. Definitely worth doing.
-
A lot of the bass end rattle seems to be from clearance in the pinned joints, a little plier work can reduce it a lot but how long it will last I don't know, pallet slap - wondered if some chamois instead of the felt would be a little kinder, yet to experiment.
All the moaning and squealing - try running reed wax along all those little springy metal bits in the ali plates, I think the basic problem is that they are too short and only rivetted on at one end..................
Richard
-
I love the sound that pokerworks make if you sound the bass loud and then close the pallett and the reed carries on for a short while and all you can hear is the mechanical sound of the reed vibrating :)
-
pallet slap - wondered if some chamois instead of the felt would be a little kinder
The stuff I got from Charlie Marshall was a two-ply facing consisting of 1 mm felt and 1 mm soft chamois-type leather. Seems to have done the trick quite nicely.
-
Chamois is actually a poor material for this, it's surface is not smoothe enough and the thickness is not even enough.
-
Thanks for that Theo, probably saved me a fix and strip job :)
Something like shammy (calf ??) was used on a harmonium I stripped a while ago and it appeared to have lasted the test of time compared to an earlier one which was felted (and both had survived the woodwork, more wormhole than remaining timber hence the 'recycling'
Richard
-
The stuff I got from Charlie Marshall was a two-ply facing consisting of 1 mm felt and 1 mm soft chamois-type leather. Seems to have done the trick quite nicely.
Chamois is actually a poor material for this, it's surface is not smoothe enough and the thickness is not even enough.
I don't know very much about the way leather is described, so perhaps I am using the wrong terminology. The leather part of the felt/leather facing material I got from Charlie Marshall is soft (like Chamois) but is quite fine-grained and even in thickness and texture.
What should I be calling it?
-
I have relined the treble pallets of a few of my boxes with the material sold by CGM (soft leather on felt) and it was a big improvement. Just make sure the pallets rest flat on the table after the thicker material is applied.
-
Probably on thinnish ice but has anyone experimented with the black closed cell (I think Neoprene) foam sheet - usually with a self adhesive backing as used for watertight gaskets or as cushioning in things like cases for calipers etc ? Not certain if I'd trust the adhesive other than on a sealed surface but at about 2mm and quite soft it conforms nicely so ought to seal without clacking.
Steve F - when last I visited Barkers Tannery at Otley (to see their steam engine before they shut down) they had a variety of Victorian machinery which split hides from various animals to differing thicknesses and then either buffed, burnished or brushed the flesh / skin / split sides from a near mirror smoothness through to a very downy suede, they had so many trade names for each finish and degree of tan that I lost track. IIRC Chamois is the name of the goat from which the leather comes but these days seems to be used to describe a variety of skins of the wash leather sort, I have seen this as Theo describes where the thickness varies considerably, I suspect this is the less accurate split and the better, constant thickness part is used for higher class goods like Gloves so it probably depends on how good a bit you end up with :D
Richard
-
The stuff I got from Charlie Marshall was a two-ply facing consisting of 1 mm felt and 1 mm soft chamois-type leather. Seems to have done the trick quite nicely.
Chamois is actually a poor material for this, it's surface is not smoothe enough and the thickness is not even enough.
I don't know very much about the way leather is described, so perhaps I am using the wrong terminology. The leather part of the felt/leather facing material I got from Charlie Marshall is soft (like Chamois) but is quite fine-grained and even in thickness and texture.
What should I be calling it?
It's called pallet leather - doh! Available from Russels and other organ building suppliers.
Beware of ordinary chamois as it can be porous.
-
It's called pallet leather - doh! Available from Russels and other organ building suppliers.
Beware of ordinary chamois as it can be porous.
I completely fail to understand why people want to experiment with different materials for a job.
Especially when the traditional material:
(a) does a good job
(b) is inexpensive and easily available
(c) the proposer of the new "problem solution" has not yet tried the traditional material and found it wanting
The kind of repair jobs I find most frustrating are those where some previous repairs have to be undone first, making the job longer and therefore more expensive for the client.
-
I completely fail to understand why people want to experiment with different materials for a job.
Well, I can understand your point, but also consider that when the "traditional" way was found, the only materials available were leather and felt. Now we have new, different materials that may (or may not) do the same job, possibly better, possibly worse. Only time and usage will tell. But it's sometimes tempting to get into experimenting. Nevertheless we know that leather over time will dry and lose its properties and we know what to do about it.
Steinway learned their lesson the hard way when they decided to use Teflon bushings instead of felt in their keyboards in the 1960's. They thought this new material would be better and more durable than good old felt, but usage proved otherwise when bushings were slipping out of their holes due to wood contraction and expansion. They had to recall the pianos and put good old felt bushings!
Many years ago I used to collect and repair classic cameras, one problem we had with many Canon SLR models is that the foam that they used in various places as a light-blocking material and mirror damper was turning into goo after about 10 years... The material was going back to its original liquid form! At the time they decided to replace felt with high-tech foam it probably seemed like a good idea.
Conclusion: stick to the traditional ways!
-
I completely fail to understand why people want to experiment with different materials for a job.
They could be just as good or better and if nobody tries then we won't know.
-
I've nothing against experimenting with new materials, but I think you have to get some experience use the tradional materials so you have something tocompare with. Eg felt and leather that detriorates and has to be replaced after a few decades seems to me to be a pretty good material already but if there are obvious defeciencies I'm the first to look for something better. Hohner pallets faced with just leather is a good example. They are fine for airtightness, but notoriously noisy, so even in fairly new instruments it may be worth replacing with leather on felt.
-
I have found that the "trimmings" from leather used to upholster fine furniture makes excellent pallet material. It's typically thin and of very high quality and usually inexpensive or free for the asking.
-
Just called in a long standing 'favour' and have now got a nice piece of pallet leather (as used by organ builders) sitting here, hopefully it will be enough for both Hohners if used carefully and is the right type !
Will have to clean out the old glue kettle prior to a brew up - one of the few workshop smells I hate :-\
Richard
-
Just called in a long standing 'favour' and have now got a nice piece of pallet leather (as used by organ builders) sitting here, hopefully it will be enough for both Hohners if used carefully and is the right type !
Will have to clean out the old glue kettle prior to a brew up - one of the few workshop smells I hate :-\
Richard
Ordinary Bostik 'all purpose' glue is fine for fixing pallet leather to wooden pallets. Recommended by Charlie Marshal, who supplies the stuff.
I've just refaced the pallets on a Hohner Erica. I used the Bostik and it worked just fine and was easy to use. Nowhere near as smelly or inconvenient as using hide glue in a kettle.
-
Ordinary Bostik 'all purpose' glue is fine for fixing pallet leather to wooden pallets. Recommended by Charlie Marshal, who supplies the stuff.
I've just refaced the pallets on a Hohner Erica. I used the Bostik and it worked just fine and was easy to use. Nowhere near as smelly or inconvenient as using hide glue in a kettle.
And, for a change, the Solvent Free version is better. Easier to handle than the flammable type especially if you are sticking all the pallets onto a sheet at one go.
-
Thanks Steve,
I may well try Bostic (or a similar leather glue I use for splicing belts for the watch lathe) on the DG when I get round to it, however the first to be done is the early Hohner 1 row which, while having no value, in view of its age I am trying to 'conserve' where possible and the old glue on the pallets is hoof glue - I'm so glad that the experts of the parish warned against using chamois, although a century on the old leathers look more like it than the proper stuff - no wonder they clatter and leak.
It has also developed an interesting new noise, not apparent before but several of the lower press note leather valves are fluttering and making dare one say here, a farting sound, as are some of the bass - first off I thought that it was the valves I had removed when flattening their reeds and had perhaps not repositioned them properly but it is as bad on some of those still intact from factory - I'm guessing that perhaps its something related to the damp weather we've just got, can't see any sign of them fluttering against the reedplate internal walls or underside of pallet table and given their age they were (surprisingly) not dry and crispy (no oiling or other treatment) any ideas ?
Richard
-
Doesn't the simple PVA glue work too? Water-based, solvent free, cheap!
-
Doesn't the simple PVA glue work too? Water-based, solvent free, cheap!
I think there would be a high risk of the glue soaking into the felt too much and making a hard matted mass when set, and thus reducing the resilience of the felt. I was happy to go with Charlie Marshall's recommendation of Bostik, trusting his experience and wisdom. It certainly did the job quickly, cleanly and most importantly, effectively.
-
It has also developed an interesting new noise, not apparent before but several of the lower press note leather valves are fluttering and making dare one say here, a farting sound, as are some of the bass - first off I thought that it was the valves I had removed when flattening their reeds and had perhaps not repositioned them properly but it is as bad on some of those still intact from factory - I'm guessing that perhaps its something related to the damp weather we've just got, can't see any sign of them fluttering against the reedplate internal walls or underside of pallet table and given their age they were (surprisingly) not dry and crispy (no oiling or other treatment) any ideas ?
I don't think it is worth trying to conserve old leather valves. Even though they may look OK, they may not be lifting properly and therefore could be fouling the reed tongue. The larger reeds have a surprising swing amplitude! I would replace them with new leather valves and hopefully the fluttering noise will disappear.
Also, it is not a good idea to remove valves in order to tune the reeds. The presence or absence of the valve can have a significant (several cents) effect on the pitch. So always tune reeds with the valves in place.
-
All understood Steve, you may not have seen the pics on the thread when I first got this box as it was under makes and models
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4424.0.html
At some point in its history, mischevious fingers had bent several push reeds (bronze) up vertical so the damaged reed plates came off to burnish these back down, (and fit a replacement for one broken off) I made an 'anvil' with recess to take the rivets allowing the plates to lay flat - didn't think distorting these would help matters and the valves came off as part of this - waxed as opposed to glued on originally.....
Its just as well it has started making this noise now as I was on the verge of starting on the tuning (so far have been carefully excavating the plate slots to get free travel on the reeds, checking on Bills tuner as the lower reeds appeared to be drifting in tone, presumably working out the stresses induced while ironing them flat. As far as I can see through the pallet 'oles there is no interference between valves and reed tongues and they are pretty floppy, sound similar to hoovering up a strip of paper which gets trapped in the airstream and flutters.
Is there a proper name for this stuff ? I have bought plenty of valve leather over the years but this has been 1/4" - 3/8" thick and steeped in tallow (for water or air pumps)
I agree with not using PVA or similar, the old simmer and stink glue is reversable at need and Bostick would scrape off - I still need to have a brew up as one long joint between backboard and box has come adrift and until I discover what sort of pallet cover I have to produce (tis missing and nothing like the Pokerwork size) the flexing will probably run the crack further.
Oh the joys of MAD, still, detuned, clattering and f**ting it sounds nice enough to be worth the time and trouble :|||:
Richard
-
All understood Steve, you may not have seen the pics on the thread when I first got this box as it was under makes and models
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4424.0.html
Ah yes, that one. Now I understand.... ;)
As far as I can see through the pallet 'oles there is no interference between valves and reed tongues and they are pretty floppy, sound similar to hoovering up a strip of paper which gets trapped in the airstream and flutters.
Sometimes the valves develop a tendency to vibrate in resonance with the reed tongue, which can also produce the fluttering noise. As a temporary fix I have been known to weight the tip of the valve with a tiny blob of Blue-tac, which alters its resonant frequency, but the best solution is to replace the valve. It also may be that you need a valve with a wire spring and fixing dot (see link below).
It's very odd, this fluttering business. Sometimes it just suddenly develops for no apparent reason. Most annoying. It can also disappear suddenly too. A few months ago I took delivery of a new concertina, and one of the valves was fluttering. I was a bit dis-chuffed, and was contemplating sending the instrument back to the maker, but decided not to do anything in haste. Sure enough, after a few hours playing, the problem mysteriously went way.
Is there a proper name for this stuff ?
Er... Reed valve leather?
Charlie Marshall sells all different sorts and sizes. Not just leather but vileda and vinyl too.
See here (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Valves.html).
-
Yes that one indeed Steve (:)
I guess this is one reason for using plastic valves instead of leather now - the only difference I could put my finger on was it was a damp cool day rather than a dry stinky hot day when I had experience no problems and it had been sitting with the keyboard / pallets off so open to the air.
On the basis that they will need replacing I'll dose a couple with some neatsfoot oil without removing the plates and see if it has any beneficial effect - it will certainly alter the weight and maybe the flexibility.
The more I read and hear about tuning, or more specifically consistent toning, the easier it is to put off starting on it ;)