Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: jeverist on November 08, 2010, 03:43:11 PM

Title: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 08, 2010, 03:43:11 PM
Hi, all.  New member here with a few questions.  I have a single-row Hohner (in D) that I got off ebay several years ago.  Having found Charlie Marshall's "paint them on" reed waxing video, I've decided to give it a shot.  The reeds plates are currently being held in by tacks and small nails.  Am I correct in assuming that this was done in lieu of a proper rewaxing, and that these should not be used?  The tuning seems to still be pretty good and I think that it will be OK after the rewax.  The reeds and plates themselves are clean and not rusty.  However, if I want it re-tuned later, will the reeds need to be removed again, or are they retuned in place?  The reed blocks are glued to the air-hole pieces and are not removable.  Thanks very much for any help here.

John
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 08, 2010, 05:09:27 PM
It's even possible that the reeds were not meant to be waxed in on your instrument. Any chance of putting a photo or two up?
AL
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 08, 2010, 06:45:35 PM
Hi, Al

thanks for the response.  I'll try to attach some pics of the reeds to this post.  lots of wax in there with the tacks and nails over that.  There also looks like there is some re-gluing of the block pieces on the bass side that has overlapped the reed plates (even in the inside of the cavity).  The low note block must've come undone at some point and it was just re-glued with the reeds attached.  I do have the missing reeds and plate.  Most of the reed plates look to be zinc stamped with "H", but there are two in the bass chord blocks that appear to be aluminum, also stamped "H"

(http://www.flickr.com/photos/55733323@N08/5158373927/)
(http://www.flickr.com/photos/55733323@N08/5158984760/)
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 08, 2010, 06:46:28 PM
looks like they didn't attach....will keep trying.  sorry      J
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 08, 2010, 07:12:16 PM
how's this?
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: rees on November 08, 2010, 07:18:19 PM
That is quite a rare box - a forerunner to the Hohner 1040, single row, two voice.
The nails and tacks are original and were applied after waxing as a sort of belt and braces approach.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 08, 2010, 07:36:54 PM
I would imagine that if needing to retune at a later date it would be that the reeds would need to be removed?
AL
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2010, 07:41:24 PM
 Having found Charlie Marshall's "paint them on" reed waxing video, I've decided to give it a shot.

When you have the reeds off to clean off the old wax please also replace all the leather flap valves.  The picture shows the valves are curled up, they should lie flat.  They will be causing at least as many horrible noises as the old wax.

No the reeds would not have to be removed to be tuned, unless you were changing the overall pitch, for example from the old German standard of A=435 to modern concert pitch A=440Hz.  Whatever the process the final tuning must be done in situ.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 08, 2010, 07:48:45 PM
Quote
Whatever the process the final tuning must be done in situ.
Given that the reedblock can't be removed would it be a case of using its own bellows as tuning table then?
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2010, 07:49:31 PM
Exactly.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 08, 2010, 09:07:47 PM
thanks, guys

I'll put valve replacement on the to-do list, and will also re-nail and tack.  Even with all the horrible groans, wheezes, and rumbles this is quite a sweet sounding box
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 08, 2010, 09:40:52 PM



  Even with all the horrible groans, wheezes, and rumbles this is quite a sweet sounding box
Sounds just like some eBay descriptions ;D
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 08, 2010, 11:08:39 PM
When I did mine, I found just the wax a satisfactory hold and left the nails off.  :||:
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 09, 2010, 12:28:53 AM
 Having found Charlie Marshall's "paint them on" reed waxing video, I've decided to give it a shot.

When you have the reeds off to clean off the old wax please also replace all the leather flap valves.  The picture shows the valves are curled up, they should lie flat.  They will be causing at least as many horrible noises as the old wax.
Essential advice from Theo, of course.
All I will add is that the four highest (smallest) reed plates which do not have valves in your photo should be left as such; don't be tempted to add valves to these, as they are not required.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: LJC on November 09, 2010, 07:53:28 AM
I'll put valve replacement on the to-do list, and will also re-nail and tack. 

There is no reason to re-tack the reeds once you have waxed them in. The wax its self provides plenty of support to stop them moving, and putting nails back in is a pain.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Theo on November 09, 2010, 07:59:30 AM
The nails are quite unnecessary.  Hohner do not use nails on the boxes they make now.
As far as I can tell the only thing that the nails do is to hold the reeds in place when the wax has perished after several decades.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 09, 2010, 12:12:38 PM
I see a lot more H1140 models with failed wax than any other Hohner model.

Probably because of the flat mounting of the reeds rather than A frame blocks which other Hohner models have.

Seems to be the case with both early and late model H1140s.

So I will have to go against the flow here and recommend that you use the nails in this particular case.

My 10c....
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 09, 2010, 01:31:23 PM
thanks again, for all this good advice.  I can see how putting the nails back in on the perpendicular bass reed plates would be problematic.  Probably have to support the block some how when nailing.  Any chance that these bass plates were waxed on to the blocks prior to gluing in the blocks originally?  would be easier and explain the glue excess found inside the reed cavity (can be seen in the photo - missing reed plate).  Anyway.... I'll decide about the nails when I get to that point.

hope in the end to be able to enjoy the way these reeds sound without being distracted by the "noise".  Thanks for insisting on new leathers
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 09, 2010, 04:22:08 PM
I bought the same exact box although in "C" just a few months ago.  It's in even better condition but the reeds need full overhaul also, it's my winter project. I will be watching this thread with interest.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 10, 2010, 01:18:40 AM
My earlier post and comments about loose reedplates referred more to the treble end than the bass end.

Just a further point regarding the "nails".

A bit of a misnoma perhaps; they are more like mushroom headed thumb tacks.

Jeverist, I would not recommend hammering them in as you would with a nail, but instead just press them in with your thumb, perhaps using an old flat file or similar for a little extra pressure. The wood into which they need to be pressed is fairly soft and the pins are quite sharp. (Ouch!)

Incidentally, I have a 2 row version of your Hohner with the same faux birds-eye maple veneer, though slightly different transfers.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 10, 2010, 04:06:49 AM
I'm not sure which way to go on the rivets/tacks with the waxing.  Wouldn't that have something to do with how vigorously one pushed and pulled the bellows?  Here is a pic of the Single Row that I picked up on Ebay.  The second one is a Paolo gotten the same way...that's the next project.  Now that one appears to have it's reeds not only riveted in but they are caulked? with some sort of material that apparently is for sealing.  The one in the picture is a G/C two voice.  In pretty darn good fettle.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 10, 2010, 07:29:11 AM
I'm not sure which way to go on the rivets/tacks with the waxing.  Wouldn't that have something to do with how vigorously one pushed and pulled the bellows? 
Unless the instrument is seriously abused  >:(, properly applied reed wax on its own is perfectly capable of withstanding the push/pull pressures of the bellows in normal use. Just don't go leaving the instrument in a car on a hot sunny day (the wax will melt) nor in a car boot (trunk?) on a freezing cold night (the wax may crack).
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: LJC on November 10, 2010, 12:31:35 PM
I'm not sure which way to go on the rivets/tacks with the waxing.  Wouldn't that have something to do with how vigorously one pushed and pulled the bellows? 

If you managed to produce enough air pressure to dislodge a good condition, correctly waxed, reed plate I think you would probably be on a course for destroying either your bellows or your shoulder! I don't think that it is even a problem worth contemplating.

I sort of assumed that Hohner pinned the reed plates before waxing as it was a separate factory job, to fit the reeds and pin, and then pour the wax, but it is just my idle speculation.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 10, 2010, 06:20:51 PM
@Malcolm:  nice decals there!  as far as installing the tacks and nails, I agree that "thumbing" in the tacks is the way to go.  Can always get a bigger hammer later.  I am more concerned with the small headed nails which are used to "brace" (took me a while to get Rees's analogy) the low note bass reed plates onto the perpendicular blocks.  These nails are the kind you would ordinarily grip with a needle nose pliers and tap in with your lightest hammer.  These are what caused me to speculate about the possibility that the reed plates might have originally been waxed and pinned into these blocks before the blocks were glued to the soundboard.  Might be able to push the nails in with something, but either way the blocks don't look like they would take the pressure (or impact) without some support.  Thanks for the input

John
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: rees on November 10, 2010, 10:53:05 PM
"Belt and Braces"

Careful - not taking any chances.

Origin

Belts and braces (a.k.a. bracers) are meant to hold one's trousers up. Going 'belt and braces' is a double insurance against having them fall down. The figurative use, as a general term for cautiousness, was coined around the mid-20th century.

In the USA 'belt and suspenders' is used with just the same meaning. That emerged at around the same time too. The first citation in print we have is from the Galveston Daily News, 1935 - in their 'News Behind the News' column:

"A pessimist wears both belt and suspenders."
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 11, 2010, 12:51:57 AM
Belt & braces?  Guilty as charged.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 11, 2010, 01:20:13 AM
Jeverist, I was going to say decals rather than transfers, but generally I've found it  a word that is not recognised by many people (except those of us with a mis-spent childhood building Airfix models...)

Many accordion makers use those tacks you describe. I still wouldn't use a hammer on them, but grip them with a pair of pliers and push them in. As I said, the wood is quite soft and the tacks should be quite sharp.

From my experience however, pins are less essential on those big bass reeds on blocks. But it is the reed plates that are "flat mounted" which really need that extra bit of encouragement to stay put imho; these are the ones that tend to become loose, probably because of the way the air hits the plates face-on when pulling the bellows rather than at an angle as with the plates on blocks.

LJC, I have always assumed that the tacks were fitted after waxing, when the wax is still a bit soft, but not runny. That's what I do anyway....

And incidentally, I do have customers who regularly destroy both bellows and shoulders; one person's abuse is another person's enthusiasm   >:E
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Theo on November 11, 2010, 08:13:16 AM
Jeverist, I was going to say decals rather than transfers, but generally I've found it  a word that is not recognised by many people (except those of us with a mis-spent childhood building Airfix models...)

I believe the graphics on Hohner boxes were screen printed, rather than applied as transfers/decals
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: baz parkes on November 11, 2010, 12:05:22 PM
Jeverist, I was going to say decals rather than transfers, but generally I've found it  a word that is not recognised by many people (except those of us with a mis-spent childhood building Airfix models...

Or the old hippies amongst us with a fondness for Captain Beefheart albums...
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 11, 2010, 12:36:01 PM
Yup!
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: baz parkes on November 11, 2010, 01:24:31 PM
Gimme that harp, boy...but only if fitted with hohner steel reeds... ;)
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 11, 2010, 01:42:47 PM
and my personal favorite:

Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Guy on November 11, 2010, 02:03:56 PM
Complete the well-known phrase or saying...
" A squid eating dough in a polyethelyne bag....."
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Christopher K. on November 12, 2010, 02:04:11 AM
Complete the well-known phrase or saying...
" A squid eating dough in a polyethelyne bag....."

is FAST AND BULBOUS!

Love that record, but the original pre-release (Don's mixes) of Bat Chain Puller is my favorite.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: OwenG on November 12, 2010, 12:08:46 PM
How's about a Beefheart Theme of the Month??  >:E
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: rees on November 12, 2010, 05:49:55 PM
How's about a Beefheart Theme of the Month??  >:E

Yay! I'm gonna grow fins and run off with a mermaid and leave you land-loving women alone.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 17, 2010, 12:11:45 PM
Wow! A classic thread drift/hijack if ever I saw one.

Sorry, John. And good luck with your project.
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 17, 2010, 12:55:05 PM
Thanks, Malcolm, but no need to apologize.  I hadn't thought of Captain Beefheart in decades.  It was fun.  Rehab to start soon, but have a new toy to squeeze  :||:  I bought an old Hohner 3V which had been converted to C#/D by Mike Rowbotham.  What a sound!
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 17, 2010, 05:40:09 PM
Is that c#d sold to you by a fellow in North Carolina? If so then I've played that box!
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: Christopher K. on November 17, 2010, 07:25:28 PM
I was wondering if it was the lovely black 3-v that has been 'on hold' at the Button Box website for the past week or so... I'm dying to get one of those!
Title: Re: Hohner "Steel Reeds" rehab
Post by: jeverist on November 17, 2010, 08:34:08 PM
yes, thats the one.  I do believe it came from NC.  I consider myself very lucky.  a dream to play and listen to.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal