Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: nemethmik on December 08, 2010, 02:53:56 PM
-
A number of experienced accordion players and makers, whom I've been contacted recenty, recommended me to stay away from heavy boxes. I asked examples of "heavy diatonic accordion", and Saltarelle Neuilly and Ocean were mentioned regularly.
Yesterday, I was browsing youtube's accordion videos and I found that a couple of good players simply ignored that their Neuilly and Ocean are heavy:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBfEPWzIZ5I
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3A8ujQ33lOs
The facts are that Neuilly is 5.4 kg and Ocean (18-bass) is 6.6 kg
In the meantime I found that a Hohner Corona Extreme IIIN is 5.7 kg and noone regarded this model heavy.
In your opinion what makes a "heavy accordion" really heavy?
I am especially interested in opinions from members who have played diatonic boxes heavier than 4.99 kg regularly.
-
I'm not sure where you got those weight numbers but someone actually weighed their Rivage (which I believe is a flat keyboard version of the Neuilly) and it weighed 7.2kg!!
-
A number of experienced accordion players and makers, whom I've been contacted recently, recommended me to stay away from heavy boxes.
Why???
-
I'm not sure where you got those weight numbers but someone actually weighed their Rivage (which I believe is a flat keyboard version of the Neuilly) and it weighed 7.2kg!!
I've received a list of weights of accordions from Saltarelle and you can find in it that: Rivage and Neuilly both are 5.4 kg.
-
A number of experienced accordion players and makers, whom I've been contacted recently, recommended me to stay away from heavy boxes.
Why???
I was told that they are cumbersome, if not impossible to play. That's why I am looking for cases/examples where heavy boxes are played by established players.
-
I do not find weight to be a problem with multi row boxes...
On single rows I prefer a modest weight ..
On larger boxes I find the weight a comfort if played with a strap or straps and balanced on your lap/leg...
Size however is a problem... such as many of the larger Italian Celluloid 3 row 9 switchers...
But the Saltarelles and Castagnaris at 12-15 lbs and really of compact size are no problem at all.
I think too much is made of weight...
however
size matters
-
I am a fan of largish boxes and like the corona III (5.2Kg) for band work. All things have there limits though. I used to own a Saltarelle Morvan IV (7Kg), 3 row, 4 voice, 9 coupler, which played like a dream, however, after about half an hours playing I would loose the blood circulation in my arm.
-
That's why I am looking for cases/examples where heavy boxes are played by established players.
Saul Rose playing a Handry 18, standing up with only one strap for 2 hours a night. :o
I asked him how he did it once and his reply was, "because I'm made of iron". ;D
-
Hi all ...
Having been one who cautioned Miklos about weighty boxes, I probably ought to say something ...
I think a lot depends on your playing style and also the type of music you want to play...
I play a lot of irish and French stuff on a D/G and I find heavy or bulky instruments more difficult for changing bellows direction. That's one of the reasons I love the smaller Hohners. But I'm conscious that a lot of really good Irish and French players use larger 3 and 4-voice instruments. So maybe I'm just a woos!
But perhaps also the playing patterns and bellows changes required on, for example a B/C, don't require the bellows work of a D/G? I stand to be corrected here ...
I've certainly tried many boxes and, for me, the boxes that 'respond the way I want to play' have been Hohners, Black Pearl 2, salterelle Bouebe etc. But I know others who can rattle out the same tunes on much larger instruments. I once played an entire ceilidh with my Castagnari Dony - deliberately to see if I could 'play myself into it' - but I thought I was going to have a seizure from the effort! After a year I sold the Dony because I always ended up playing slower stuff on it - at which it was majestic, admittedly.
Another point might be relevant - amongst Irish concertina players the Dipper Clare model, modelled on the rare semi-miniature Jeffries (5 and 1/4 inches) is VERY popular - because these smaller instruments play like electricity... for me only a light small instrument is nimble enough - but that is also going to reflect my limitations.
Miklos - why not see if you can borrow/experiment with different models - everyone has their own style and only trying different instruments will you know what is 'too heavy' or 'too bulky' for you. It's your style, requirements and repertoire that is going to determine this... In the end playing music is supposed to be fun - not a fight!
best wishes
Mike
-
I agree about the style and type of music played on any particular box...
-
That's why I am looking for cases/examples where heavy boxes are played by established players.
Saul Rose playing a Handry 18, standing up with only one strap for 2 hours a night. :o
I asked him how he did it once and his reply was, "because I'm made of iron". ;D
I've seen photos of him dancing a jig whilst playing that thing. He apprantly had a hangover too. :o
-
I've seen photos of him dancing a jig whilst playing that thing. He apprantly had a hangover too. :o
Been there, done that, ripped the strap brackets out
-
I don't think of my Loffet Pro 18 as heavy (5.5 kg), in fact it is not much heavier than than the Hohner Club IV I did most of my learning on. But with lots of basses there is more weight in the left hand end and that influences playing style towards more of a cross row approach. Certainly thats what I do, only using push pull for expressive effect where it sounds good, or where it is the only solution (eg, no pushed F on the Loffet).
But I don't play for hours at a stretch, I don't play for Morris and for my age I am a strongish guy because my work is very physical and I work out regularly with kettlebells. For a person of different body type and playing style, the big box might be a real problem. Its a very personal thing.
I actually find a lighter box harder to play, because it bounces around more in response to bellows movement and feels less stable.
Miklos, I don't know where you are based but if you are ever up in Newcastle you are welcome to come and try the Loffet.
-
A number of experienced accordion players and makers, whom I've been contacted recenty, recommended me to stay away from heavy boxes.
I play music that involves a lot of fast bellows reversals and I play a Castagnari Jacky (similar to Handry) three-row. I could not disagree more with the notion that the weight slows the box down. However, cheaper quality reeds or poorly set reeds might affect the responsiveness. However, big boxes are certainly harder to play for players whose bellows technique needs improvement.
There are players in Quebec whose ability to play fast could not possibly be greater, who play on huge four-voice three-row boxes.
-
I once played an entire ceilidh with my Castagnari Dony - deliberately to see if I could 'play myself into it' - but I thought I was going to have a seizure from the effort!
Well, I'm much smaller and wimpier than Mike, but I play my Dony in a ceilidh band most Saturday nights!
However, I always sit down. At one time I used the Dony for playing for morris every week (standing up) and it caused a lot of problems with my fingers because too much weight was falling on my left hand.
I definitely agree that bigger boxes encourage you to play across the rows because it's much easier than trying to move the bellows in and out. Playing across the rows a lot on a small box, however, can leave you running out of air. Bellows control on a large box is easier if you're a big bloke with strong arms, and likewise it's easier to cover a big keyboard, or set of basses, if you have big hands.
At the end of the day it's what suits you and what you play. For a beginner, though, I'd recommend a smallish box any day.
-
I'm surprised to see the Dony being used as an example of a larger box because I've always thought of it as pretty light and compact for a 12 bass 2 1/2 row. The one I had that I bought from Tamba of this parish was easily the best feeling box to me that I've ever owned, I played it with one strap and it fit me like a glove. It's only because circumstances forced me to that I sold it and it's also the only box I've sold that I really do miss.
The heaviest box I've actually owned was a 3 voice 23 button 12 bass Jorgina. I didn't really find the weight a problem as such but I did need to change the way I held it compared to the way I've played all my other boxes. At the same time I had it I played a Handry 18 at the Music Room and the Jorgina, despite having six fewer basses, a whole treble row less and simpler switching, wasn't far off the weight and size. I'd glady change the way I hold the box for a 3 row but the Jorgina, only having 2 rows, didn't offer enough in the way of extra potential to justify fundamentally altering my technique.
I do think personal playing style is the most important factor in deciding if a box is "too heavy", more so than body type or type of music that's being played.
-
Hi Andy, Pauline et al,
I completely agree - it's a personal thing.
I introduced the comparison of a Dony having owned one and sold it because it didn't suit my playing style, which comes from Hohner pokerworks and smaller boxes. In one sense this reflects my limitations as a player - in another sense it reflects "what I want to get out of an instrument" - I like to 'play off' that lovely and lively bounce you get from a Hohner - so its to do with the dynamics of your style, the reed response and the 'feel' as much as weight... I just couldn't play reels and polkas on the Dony and make them really swing - who was it said "Polkas are God's gift to Melodeon players"?
But that's the whole point - what is too 'heavy' or cumbersome for one player is 'no problem' for the next player. I did stick with the Dony for a year, but it never gave me the fun I get from playing Hohners, a Black Pearl or a Bouebe.
I'd advise Miklos to see if he can locate people/friends/shops where he can try various boxes out. The folk world (especially Melnet!) is a pretty supportive network, whilst anyone who seriously wants to sell an instrument oughtn't to mind a potential customer spending a couple of hours getting the feel of an instrument.
cheers
Mike
-
I play two relatively heavy boxes at around 6kg. I deliberately practice on the heavier one because I think it improves one's bellows control, (so that when I switch to the lighter one for gigs, I really notice it flying!) However I think the answer to the question is that it largely depends on what and how you want to play. My tendency has been to go for row swapping to match LH chords, and also in order deliberately to simplifyruns such as in-out-in-out, rather than say in-out-out-in, if I can, because I think it sounds more rhythmic and driving. However others have used the lightness of their boxes to perfect any combination of ins and outs, and achieve the same effect, though that almost always means losing the LH chording to some extent. Also, responsive reeds and valves make a huge difference.
-
Hi,
I agree about the quality of reeds and valves making a big difference,when I do shows with the Manfrini accordions I have boxes with Tipo a mano reeds,on a couple of occasions I have had my daughters box with me,identical model to others on the stand, with A Mano bombatta reeds,customers could not believe the difference,so easy to play,these boxes weigh 10kg,4 voice treble,5 voice 96 bass.
Pete
-
A Mano bombatta reeds
What kind of reed is that? When I place an order for an accordion, can I say I want the accordion with "A Mano bombatta reeds"?
-
Hi,
This is a specially ground a mano reed.You really must try them before you order a box with them,they are very responsive,sometimes too responsive,depends on how you play.
Pete
-
Hi,
I agree about the quality of reeds and valves making a big difference,when I do shows with the Manfrini accordions I have boxes with Tipo a mano reeds,on a couple of occasions I have had my daughters box with me,identical model to others on the stand, with A Mano bombatta reeds,customers could not believe the difference,so easy to play,these boxes weigh 10kg,4 voice treble,5 voice 96 bass.
Pete
I also agree& would add that TWO decent, say 3 or 4inch straps make a huge difference to the feel of a box, although of course not actualy reducing the weight.
The other thing that has a huge effect on the perceived weight of a box is bellows technique or lack of! On a diatonic box there is absolutely no need to open the bellows wide for most of most tunes and whwere a wide opening is requiered e.g. preceeding a long run of push notes, the bellows can be closed up immediately afterwards. Also tugging & shoving on the bellows is unnecesary & removes all chance of sensitive phrasing, dynamics etc - and makes it hard work!
In other words how you attach yourself to the box & how you play it are far more important than the actual weight.
george -( happy with a 2 row 3kg or an 80 bass 3 row - and anything in between)
-
Any boxes sold as being 'cassotto' are going to be heavy due to the nature of the construction. In terms of players who manage great things with heavy boxes - I can't imagine Riccado Tessi's 3 row 18 bass Castagnari is particularly light. I don't see why a heavy box should be any less responsive than a light box if they are both set up properly and the player is used to playing that specific size.
Personally, for playing contential styles with lots of chords, across the rows, I find weight and size no issue. Fast runs are executed to notes in the same direction meaning as long as you have the strength to move the bellows the speed and ease of playing will be determined by the quality of the reeds and the quality of the player.
-
I have boxes with Tipo a mano reeds,... my daughters box with A Mano bombatta reeds
Pete, what you wrote is very interesting. Castagnari, Beltuna and B.Loffet makes professional boxes with "typo a mano" ("hand-made type" as seen on Castagnari webpages) reeds. I asked Castagnari about "a mano" reeds and they replied that for extra mony they are installing "a mano" reeds, if I want to. The same is the case with Beltuna. I asked Saltarelle, if the reeds in their top-grade models are of "typo a mano" or "a mano" and they replied that the Ocean, Neuilly, and many others are made with "a mano", reeds. If this is really true, this may explain why the hefty Neuilly and Ocean is so easy to play ???
-
Apart from just having to hold the thing up, the weight of the treble end doesn't matter very much.
It's the bass end that has to be accelerated rapidly in alternate directions. In fact the inertia of a heavy treble end might even help, as you want that end to stay put.
I'm inclined to agree with those who claim that the quality of reeds and construction makes a difference. It's been pointed out to me more than once, for instance, that a Shand Morino is actually quite easy to play because it's so perfectly balanced and responsive, but it's a very heavy box when you put it on the scales.
On a three row box you may be able to save a lot of left arm effort by cross-fingering to reduce the number of bellows reversals. On a Steirische harmonika you are expected to play it that way.
-
"Voci a mano bombate" is a sub-category of hand made Italian reeds and stands between "voci a mano standard" and the even more exclusive "voci tirate". But, again, there are excellent standard reeds, such as those made by the Binci family and there may also be not so excellent "bombate" or even "tirate" from other sources (the latter being offered by very few makers only: the technique is very time consuming which of course reflects itself in its price tag). As a consequence, knowing who actually makes the reeds one is interested in, is very important, especially to those who aspire to making top notch boxes only.
-
I asked Saltarelle, if the reeds in their top-grade models are of "typo a mano" or "a mano" and they replied that the Ocean, Neuilly, and many others are made with "a mano", reeds. If this is really true, this may explain why the hefty Neuilly and Ocean is so easy to play ???
With these Saltarelles, it is a really good idea, in my opinion, to try the particular box -- i.e., not just the same model, but rather, the exact box that is for sale, ready for you to take home. My experience with them is that they can vary greatly as far as the quality of the reedwork. Another approach is to buy through a dealer who will be willing to address any issues that you identify with the reedwork. Saltarelle has some really great configurations available, but the devil is in the details, and it really is not clear who is handling the manufacture, the reed installation, and the tuning of any given box. If you can either find one that plays at a level that is acceptable to you, or find a dealer who is capable of "making it so," go for it.
-
Next time you ask "Saltarelle" ( I assume George Roux directly) what maker of "a mano" reeds...
Please explain the physical differences/characteristics of the Bombate and tirate... thanks
I will assume the bombate is the reed with the cruved/domed/bombay top of the tongue...
I have had such a reed on older Italian boxes and saw them in a very plain Jane 2 row Italian box
from the thirties.. a very modestly made box with extraordinary tone and playability.
-
Apart from just having to hold the thing up, the weight of the treble end doesn't matter very much.
It's the bass end that has to be accelerated rapidly in alternate directions. In fact the inertia of a heavy treble end might even help, as you want that end to stay put.
I agree entirely, the weight of the bass end was what made my mind up about selling the Jorgina. The bellows were past their prime as well and with them even slightly open it felt like holding a breezeblock on a piece of string. After I sold it I was on the brink of commissioning a box from Olav Bergflodt as a replacement and one of the things I wanted was a stripped down left hand side with no switches and possibly not even any reedplates for the thirds at all to make it as light as possible, sort of a "racing trim" bass end.
-
the weight of the bass end
Very smart point; but, how this concept can be applied to the heavy left sides (80-bass, for example) of BCC# boxes? Most BCC# players I saw on you tube moves these heavy bass ends as if they were feather-stuffed.
When a tune is played in C on a BCC#, I guess the number of bellows-reversals are not less than on a G/C.
-
Most BCC# players I saw on you tube moves these heavy bass ends as if they were feather-stuffed.
Hi Miklos,
This supports the point that I was trying to make. There is some strength-building involved -- simply getting your body used to the heavier box. Thus, people who aren't used to one could pick one up and easily dismiss as "too heavy." But through building a relatively small amount of strength (it really is not heavy weight-lifting!) as well as developing really good bellows technique, the weight on the left side becomes irrelevant -- at least, on a high quality box where the reeds are properly set.
Very little bellows movement is necessary for rapid shifts, but this is a technique that takes some time and effort to learn. Huge bellows movement is necessary for long passages in either direction, big chords, etc -- none of which comes into play when we are talking about rapid bellows shifts i.e. reels and jigs and so on.
I have an acquaintance who plays a huge Petosa piano accordion and is well-known for effectively making it sound like a diatonic accordion -- obviously he is able to shift the direction rapidly despite the huge bass end, which is heavier than any currently manufactured diatonic accordion! In fact, I am certain that the bass end is heavier than both sides combined of a Castangari Handry.
-Andy
-
Model:Handles like
Handry:Rolls Ghost or Shadow
Benny: BMW 3 series
Panther: Mid '70s Chevy pickup
Pokerwork: MG Midget
Lilly: Lotus Elite
Tommy: Honda 2000
Based on my (limited) experience.
-
Model:Handles like
Handry:Rolls Ghost or Shadow
Benny: BMW 3 series
Panther: Mid '70s Chevy pickup
Pokerwork: MG Midget
Lilly: Lotus Elite
Tommy: Honda 2000
Based on my (limited) experience.
Well, the only vehicle on your list that I have first-hand experience of is an MG Midget - and that was a joy on twisty country lanes but a nightmare in wetor icy conditions; sounds ideal for Morris (or maybe that should be Garage Morris?)
Graham
-
the weight of the bass end
Very smart point; but, how this concept can be applied to the heavy left sides (80-bass, for example) of BCC# boxes? Most BCC# players I saw on you tube moves these heavy bass ends as if they were feather-stuffed.
When a tune is played in C on a BCC#, I guess the number of bellows-reversals are not less than on a G/C.
I don't think the weight of the bass end is that important, its much more down to how its handled. The trick is to keep or move the bellows into as near closed position as possible before any rapid ins & outs are indulged in as trying to do these, on any size box, wi;th the bellows extended results in 'bellows waggle' & wasted energy. Try the run down in Harvest Home ON THE ROW with the bellows well extended & then with about 3 inches open & see the difference.
As to C on BCC# the number of bellows reversals can be varied between 6 and 2 depending on the mood the driver is in!
george :D
-
@melodeon: Whereas bombate reeds are supposed to offer better aerodynamic conditions according to Bernoullis Principle (one may, a bit boldly, compare it to the upper rounded side of an aircraft wing), tirate reeds have been filed in a certain way that allows a larger part of the reed to become active in creating sound (it. "tirato" = "stretched"). Filemarks can be seen down and into the foot of the reed, the upper edges are not rounded. These reeds are by many considered the non plus ultra. While the technique itself is not new, it lay dormant for many decades mainly due to the labour intensity involved. One of Castelfidardos top reed makers has now included them in his range: these reeds are truely awesome, as I had the chance of finding out myself.
-
the weight of the bass end
Very smart point; but, how this concept can be applied to the heavy left sides (80-bass, for example) of BCC# boxes? Most BCC# players I saw on you tube moves these heavy bass ends as if they were feather-stuffed.
When a tune is played in C on a BCC#, I guess the number of bellows-reversals are not less than on a G/C.
There are two points to make here. Firstly, and I don't know why, it is different when you are playing BCC#. You use the bass in such a different way that the extra weight and bulk really doesn't matter. If you were playing a G/D with a bass end that size then you might have problems, due to the different ways that the bellows are used.
Secondly, stradella bass systems are actually very weight efficient. They use a lot less reeds than a diatonic equivalent, due to reed sharing, which isn't possible on a bisonoric bass. Thus the reed blocks are smaller and lighter. The weight of the mechanism is I think fairly negligible, although I haven't taken mine out to weigh it! I think that a small and compact stradella bass end in a normal melodeon casing would not weigh significantly more than a diatonic one. Say 32 bass 8*4; counterbass, bass, major, thirdless, F#-F.
I personally think that bass end bulk makes more of a difference to how heavy an instrument is perceived to be than actual weight.
-
Secondly, stradella bass systems are actually very weight efficient. They use a lot less reeds than a diatonic equivalent, due to reed sharing, which isn't possible on a bisonoric bass.
Errr.. I don't think this is entirely true! At least, not for Hohner diatonic boxes, which seem to share bass reeds. The famous 'stop the thirds' issue.
-
Lets consider a couple of examples.
A hohner two row 8 bass box contains 20 reedplates in the bass end, a 4 voice stradella bass contains 48 reeds, so there will be a big weight gain there.
An the other hand a typical 12 bass Italian box will have 36 reed plates, and an 18 bass would have 54.
Conclusion: 8 bass boxes are always going to be lighter in the bass end than stradella, but as the number of bass buttons increases the number of reedplates soon matches or exceeds the stradella. Of course the stradella mechanism is much more complex and is heavier than the simple lever system in a typical melodeon bass.
-
Actually I've done some maths and you are quite right :P But as you get larger, the difference between stradella and diatonic becomes much less. This is for just bass obviously, as stradella is clearly at an advantage if you consider major, minor, dominant and diminished to be 4 separate chords.
EDIT: Theo got there before me.
-
The one important thing that is missing in the standard Stradella bass is an open chord, tonic and fifth only. In much traditional music the ambiguity of having the chord neither major nor minor can be quite important, and is one of the ways that insensitive piano accordion players can make themselves unpopular.
-
Agreed. I think that either s coupler to take out the bass reeds (then you could make open fifths with the tonic reeds from the bass) or an open fifth button in place of the dominant or diatonic would be a very good thing. Or a free bass obviously, if one's thoughts tend that way.
-
A coupler to take out the bass reeds is the norm on instruments which have bass couplers.
-
No excuse for that - you can always play the bass without the chord.
-
I'm not sure where you got those weight numbers but someone actually weighed their Rivage (which I believe is a flat keyboard version of the Neuilly) and it weighed 7.2kg!!
Hey Waltzman, I asked a friend to weigh his Saltarelle Ocean/12 and he replied that it is exactly 6.2 kg, the same value as shown in the "official" document received from Saltarelle. Could you ask the owner of the Rivage to weigh again? a Rivage cannot be heavier than an Ocean.
All the Best and Thank You,
-
My "Parigi Giovanni" is 6.5 kg, but is quite nice to play (for me at least) ...
maybe I'm already 'trained' to lift its heavy bass end.
-
Hi Miklos and all,
Surely this thread reflects the way people play, and how they want to play - ie style... For me, the best illustration of what a lighter instrument can do is illustrated perfectly by Sandra's current TOTM ....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ddhlgemzgfs
That magical rhythmic bounce comes from 'playing off' the instrument - its a dynamic of weight/reed response, air/bellows control - all those things. Each note then becomes shaped and crafted and part of the tempo and life of the tune - not just a sequence of 'the right notes'. For me, there are instruments I can do it on, and those that just don't respond in that way ... for me ...
... but I'll be honest, however suited/good the instrument - I can't do it as well as Sandra -and she's only been playing 10 minutes!
I don't think you can be guided too much by other's experience - you have to give these boxes a good try. That's why I kept the Dony for a year - hoping it would 'play with me' - but it wouldn't! Others have different capabilities and different styles and vive la difference! We don't all want to sound the same ... Melnet is so rich in talent and diverse styles.
cheers
Mike
-
I'm not sure where you got those weight numbers but someone actually weighed their Rivage (which I believe is a flat keyboard version of the Neuilly) and it weighed 7.2kg!!
Hey Waltzman, I asked a friend to weigh his Saltarelle Ocean/12 and he replied that it is exactly 6.2 kg, the same value as shown in the "official" document received from Saltarelle. Could you ask the owner of the Rivage to weigh again? a Rivage cannot be heavier than an Ocean.
All the Best and Thank You,
The owner of the Rivage is a member of this forum and is welcome to 'weigh in' if he would like.
-
The owner of the Rivage is a member of this forum and is welcome to 'weigh in' if he would like.
Off topic: DTN has a beautiful Rivage, AFAIR.
-
I have not seen it mentioned, but it's the case with the tex-mex folks that usually they don't have any bass side blocks at all.
They like to play fast. No time for bass. That is what the band is for. ;D
-
For me, the best illustration of what a lighter instrument can do is illustrated perfectly by Sandra's current TOTM ....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ddhlgemzgfs
You are right, exceptionaly great playing and excellent music. I am terribly missing the video, though, to watch how did she play this great music. This style cannot be done with a 3-reed, 3-row box, can be?
-
Hi Miklos -
I certainly wouldn't want to argue that the sort of playing by Sandra in that clip can't be done on a larger instrument. You would have to ask Sandra how she gets on with larger boxes. I'm not as tidy a player as Sandra, but I can get a nice jaunty rhythm on 3 voice Hohners - pre-corsos and corsos, whilst my Corona II is for some reason harder work, although very similar in size. I'm sure others will argue that they can get a great rhythm from much larger instruments. But we're back with the same point - it's what feels right for you. Once again we get back to the individual player and what 'works' for them. Neither would I want to play 'bouncy Morris' style the whole time - and neither does Sandra if you check out her recordings.
I think there are some quite subtle issues at work - more than weight and size/bulk. It's to do with the balance of an instrument, and how the reeds respond whilst you're playing it. Instruments that I enjoy playing, I can almost 'feel' the reeds and the compression of the air, its almost like they're in my hands, as I'm playing. This was my issue with the Dony - majestic tone - great action - but for me the instrument was a bit remote - it wasn't 'alive'. It was too much like playing a machine... My great friend who I play a lot with, Mike Hawthorn of Pendans (Cornish band in Penzance), has a Dony and 3 Morys - he is a fabulous player on them and he's half my size! (Sorry Mike!).
I think the reeds and air-flow are critical in this - the thin and highly flexible Hohner reeds in a 2-voice box balance beautifully - the flex of the reeds means you can achieve fantastic dynamic range and shape notes quickly and easily - Hohner reeds don't just have volume and a good tone - they are beautifully responsive. In the larger Hohners, I can get the same 'feel' if they are 3-voice (Corso) but the Corona 11 (2 voice) is a bit strangled and lumpy - perhaps more reeds/voices/airflow helps the larger boxes? I'd be interested to hear the views on this of people with more experience and affection for non-Hohners.
cheers
Mike
-
I suspect your Corona II needs the reeds to be set properly. I can't see why it should be more difficult to play than your three reed instruments.
-
I think there are some quite subtle issues at work - more than weight and size/bulk. It's to do with the balance of an instrument, and how the reeds respond whilst you're playing it.
I can appreciate many of the points that you brought up, but I think there are still some factors that you are underestimating. For instance, the area of the fondo/soundboard (whatever you want to call it) that is taken up by the reedblocks seems to have some effects on tone and the overall feeling of liveliness of a given box. I'm not talking about responsiveness, but rather, other factors that give an impression of liveliness -- this includes overtones and even a "live" vibration of the box, especially the keyboard. Perhaps this explains some of the differences you experience between 2-row 2-voice Hohners and Hohners with more reedblocks. You might have included this with "balance of the instrument," but I feel that it makes it sound again like weight.
Another factor is the thinness of the "walls" of the box, which does effect the weight, but contributes to difference between accordions in ways different than weight alone.
I do think that individual experience plays a huge role in expectations. I find that Hohners lack response at low volume, and my playing style (learned in Quebec) depends on modifying pressure from note-to-note to achieve the pulse of a tune. I've heard some great players on Hohners, but it is not the sound that I aim for, nor the feel that I look for when I try out a box. So I do think that personal taste, expectations, and aims are a large part of what distinguishes one box from another for a given player. It certainly does not boil down to the weight of the bass end of the box -- for me.
-
I don't know what the melodeon equivalent of a Morse concertina is, but they have like, no mass, and you would think they would play "fast" but actually don't especially, though they are a pleasure in that they are easy to hold, especially the English, no weight on the thumb and pinky.
So, I would think that some weight is actually helpful, especially to get get some kind of swing and bounce.
-
I don't know what the melodeon equivalent of a Morse concertina is, but they have like, no mass, and you would think they would play "fast" but actually don't especially, though they are a pleasure in that they are easy to hold [...]
Is their "speed" (by which I assume you mean responsiveness) any different than any other accordion-reeded concertina?