Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: docEdock on December 24, 2010, 11:58:13 AM
-
My Hohner A/D is going into do-it-yourself surgery in the hope that it gets better -- rather than worse. See photos 7 & 8 at http://picasaweb.google.com/docedoc123/Hohner?authkey=Gv1sRgCKCG2LWAu7rE2wE# (http://picasaweb.google.com/docedoc123/Hohner?authkey=Gv1sRgCKCG2LWAu7rE2wE#) for details about a keyboard crack that has me concerned.
I thought an bosca ceoil's advice excellent,
You should have asked some of these questions before you started the job (:) . . .
so, in that spirit, I have questions before I start hacking away.
Is the crack better left alone perhaps because it isn't life threatening whereas surgery may be?
What else is involved in freeing the keyboard other than removing the two screws shown in Photo 12 and perhaps depressing the treble buttons?
Once the keyboard is removed, is this a straight forward glue and clamp job? I imagine flexing the crack just a bit to open it and using a syringe to introduce a bead of Elmer's Carpenter's Wood Glue from the inside while shop-vacuuming a suction on the outer surface to encourage penetration. Any need to reinforce from the inside with a millimeter layer of fiberglass and epoxy?
-
Humm, perhaps the quote should have been, "You should have searched more thoroughly before you posted."
Here are the photos (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38) on my facebook page. This is a public link please let me know if you can't see them.
Shows how to remove the keyboard. Thanks Theo.
-
You are best placed to judge whether it needs doing!
It should be easy enough to stabilise the split in the back of the keyboard from inside and a piece of scrim embedded in epoxy might make less mess than fibreglass.
The crack at the end is almost certainly caused by the retaining screw, which is going to wedge open any repair when replacing it.
I think your best bet is to drill the screw hole out and glue in a dowel. This should also enable you to get more glue into the existing crack.
-
I think your best bet is to drill the screw hole out and glue in a dowel. This should also enable you to get more glue into the existing crack.
Thanks for the tip. I do believe I'll remove the keyboard and peer at the inside. Perhaps that will help decide the next steps.
-
Remove the keyboard and mask off around the seam of the crack with blue 3m painters tape. Use Medium CA glue to repair the crack. Make sure to have your clamp prepared ahead of time as you have little time to work with CA before it bonds. Apply as much of the glue as possible to the inside of the keyboard where it will not affect the finish. This should be sufficiant.
-
Use Medium CA glue to repair the crack.
Medium CA glue? Does it go by another name?
-
Cyanoacrylate = superglue
-
medium=medium viscosity
-
I would use a good wood glue personally over superglue, as it gives a little more room for error and timing. Superglue is fine if the crack is fresh and clean, but on something like this it can just end up bonding to the dust inside the crack. A wood glue has better gap filling properties.
Put the glue in the crack, clamp, and wipe any excess which squeezes out off with a damp cloth. If it's cracked all the way through you can do it from the inside at the same time. A blunt knife can be used to help open the crack from the inside to massage the glue all of the way in.
-
Cyanoacrylate = superglue
medium=medium viscosity
Oh, THAT STUFF. Thanks for the clue. I had CA as construction adhesive and was headed out to buy a tube of the glop.
-
I would use a good wood glue personally over superglue, as it gives a little more room for error and timing.
Agreed, but the one situation where I prefer superglue is when repairing a crack that only extend part way through a piece and I can't to open up the crack to get the glue in. Superglue will capillary itself deep into a fine crack. This is typically the situation with wooden Hohner fingerboards that crack along the grain through the screw holes.
-
Thanks for all the advice. My G/C's arrived so I'm finally ready to put this A/D under the knife.
My own experience with CA is that I end up permanently bonded to the piece and end up leaving my fingerprints behind -- literally. I'll post pictures if I can still type.