Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: blafleur on January 05, 2011, 05:22:22 PM
-
I notice some builders use exclusively square holes, some round. Any reason to pick one over the other? Any tonal differences?
-
This is just my guess, but... for a give reed spacing along the block a square hole has a 30% larger area than a round hole of the same width, therefore more room for air and sound to pass. In theory it should make the box capable of playing louder.
-
I think that my Bouebe has square holes for the inside pallets and round for the outside, presumably to try to make sure that the rows sound at the same volume through the same principle that Theo has mentioned.
-
Theo, my only experience is with round holes, are the holes typically the same width? I had experimented a while back with different size holes. I started at 3/8" (9.53mm), where the sound seemed slightly choked and muffled, and increased size 1/64th(.34mm) at a time, the sound gradually became louder and clearer, then started using noticeably more air. But I would imagine that there's all kinds of variable that can come into play here.
Have you ever noticed a tonal difference?
-
Is there an easy way of cutting a square hole without a CNC machine?
-
Is there an easy way of cutting a square hole without a CNC machine?
A mortised bit will cut a square hole using a pillar drill
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortiser (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortiser)
-
Is there an easy way of cutting a square hole without a CNC machine?
A mortised bit will cut a square hole using a pillar drill
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortiser (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortiser)
Thanks Lester! 'suppose Google could have turned that up for me. ;D
-
Theos' guess is correct. There is a significant tonal difference, especially when it comes to larger (Italian) reeds. It doesn't seem to affect the relatively small Hohner reeds in the same degree. The well known German expert in accordion acoustics, Gotthard Richter, touches the subject quite extensively in his book "Akkordeon, Handbuch für Instrumentenbauer".
Is there an easy way etc.: Use a simple frame saw, if it's just for 1 instrument. There are, after all, not that many holes.
-
Or drill circular holes and cut out the corners with a file.
-
Or drill circular holes and cut out the corners with a file.
Files were my first idea. Marking out the edges of the square holes with pencil lines would probably make it easier to determine the centers for the circular bit in the first place?
I've noticed very old German single-row accordions that have square or rectangular holes behind the pallets.. never examined one up close, just seen photos.
-
Diatonix, do you know if the square holes are the same cross section as the diameter of a round one, or is it smaller? A square hole of the same size as the diameter of a round one would be a substantial air flow difference. Based on my hole enlargement experiment, I would have anticipated that would be too much air, but again, lots of variables come into, play, besides my ignorance.
-
Marking out the edges of the square holes with pencil lines would probably make it easier to determine the centers for the circular bit in the first place?
Mark the centres first, much more accurate, and a marking knife would be better than a pencil.
-
Files were my first idea. Marking out the edges of the square holes with pencil lines would probably make it easier to determine the centers for the circular bit in the first place?
I agree with Theo - mark a line for the centres first and then divide it up into the correct centre spacing. Then add additional lines to delineate the edges of the square holes. Ensure the edges of all the holes line up on the same parallel straight lines. Use a centre punch or spike to make a small indentation on the centre point before you start to drill. This will help prevent your drill from wandering. After drilling use a square or flat needle file to remove the remaining wood in the corners of the squares.
-
Steve that method is a lot of unnecessary work, and prone to error.
First off work on a drawing board, or something improvised that can give you the same effect, and some instruments that will give you the functions of a tee square. Draw the centre line of each row of holes first, mark of the positions of the centres of all the holes, scribe* a circle for each hole, where the diameter equals the side of the square you want to end up with. Draw two lines parallel the the centre line, but tangential to the circles, draw vertical lines tangential to the circles to form the other two sides of the square.
* at this point you could make a short cut and drill the holes.
I used to teach tech drawing and I don't like to see people making extra work producing a less accurate drawing!
You could do the drawing on paper, and glue it to the workpiece instead of drawing directly on the wood.
-
Steve that method is a lot of unnecessary work, and prone to error.
Umm.... I thought the two methods were essentially the same. However, I agree that scribing/marking circles as you describe and then marking tangents is the best way to achieve a rapid and accurate set of lines parallel to the centre lines.
(I've done a lot of engineering drawing/cartography in my time too ;) )
-
(I've done a lot of engineering drawing/cartography in my time too ;) )
I thought you would have Steve, so I was surprised at the method your suggested.
-
(I've done a lot of engineering drawing/cartography in my time too ;) )
I thought you would have Steve, so I was surprised at the method your suggested.
I was probably editing my original post at the same time as you were commenting on mine, so you may have been reading an earlier version of mine which I soon abandoned, realising it wasn't the best answer. :|bl
-
Glad we've sorted that out! ;)
-
So are you guys feeling that the improvement in sound is worth all that extra work? I wondered if square versus round was more of tradition thing. I'm not opposed to doing a lot of extra work if the gain is there to warrant it.
-
My guess would be its something to decide when designing the instrument.
-
He he, yep, Theo, but that's where I'm at. And my mind is constantly going "what if". Sometimes I have no choice but to experiment, which is fun in itself. I was just wondering if anyone had experience with both enough to say there are definite differences. There's so many little things with these contraptions that make a difference in the sound, all affected by untold variables, not the least of which is type of music along with personal preference. Off to the drawing board. :-\
-
Off to the drawing board. :-\
By the time you have built 20 of them you might be near to answering part of your own question!
-
Simplicity is a very complex thing...
-
@ blafleur: I make mine 10mmx11mm or 10mmX10mm, maybe a thought smaller when there are register slides to worry about.
Drawing: when using a bench drill one doesn't need to draw the holes or their centers. Before i got computerized i used to make very accurate distance pieces, not more than 10 or 12 of them. One only has to decide where to make the first hole, the remaining will be placed automatically, fast and accurately. No thinking involved.
-
Maybe, Theo, but I'm guessing that after 20 I'll just have more things to wonder about.
Thank you Diatonix. For me, less thinking is usually better. Right now I use a milling machine. Very accurate. I wouldn't recommend getting one for this purpose, just happen to have one and much easier for this purpose than a drill press. I also have a mortising bit, so may try the square holes on a future box. Once my curiosity get up, I'm not happy till I try it.
Good one, Quebecois, and some of us are more efficient at over complicating simple things than others.
-
You could try mocking up a box (or half a box)with a removable soundplate and limited action to test, that way you can control more variables. Not sure how practical that would be though.
-
I've considered that Ukebert, and may be the only way to have actual comparison since everything else would remain the same. It's funny how a number of accordions of same materials could be made, and there would be some variation in sound. One day......
The daunting part of wanting to "experiment" when it comes to something like an accordion is the amount of time it would take to do it right, when just building one is pretty daunting in itself. Making one accordion one way, then making another different one to test an idea changes too many variables to make it a true test.
-
I know little about fluid dynamics (of the non-alcoholic variety), but was pondering this very question (as one does) last night and wondering why a box with a substantially square cutout for the reed and valve followed it up with a round hole and pad.
It seemed to me that a squared hole would allow a more direct and "cleaner" air flow with less turbulence which would probably affect both tone and reed start-up. However, having reached the end of my knowledge of the physics, it did occur to me that round holes (and pads) are much cheaper and easier to come by, and lighter. Well, the pads could be lighter...
Punching rectangular holes in metal is probably as easy as making round ones, but not in wood. As discussed above...
Following from the above, I'm not sure I'd bother to file the holes square into the corners. Round corners might be less inclined to crack.
-
it did occur to me that round holes (and pads) are much cheaper
why a box with a substantially square cutout for the reed and valve followed it up with a round hole and pad.
[/quote]
The hole in the reedblock and the hole in the baseboard are virtually always the same shape, either both round or both square, for this very reason.
-
Let's not forget that the thickness of the faceplate is, from an acoustic point of view, equally influential. Thick plates absorb/block more sound than thin ones. That's why relatively thin faceplates with relatively large (square) openings are preferrable. Better still if the reed block is glued straight on to the faceplate: it will give the box that extra punch (especially with decent reeds). Reed block bottoms and gaskets in diatonic instruments are, in my opinion, quite often unnecessary.
-
I think larger holes are better to a point, but there is a point they are too big and it's using to much air.
Talking about faceplates glued to faceplates, my first big project was I removed the reed blocks, backing plate, and slides out of a Hohner 114, made new reed blocks, and mounted directly to the face plate. Even changed it from a 4 up configuration to a 2 up 2 down. It made it much louder and also changed the tone. I later made a new accordion and also mounted the reed blocks directly to the faceplate, and it had that same tone, kind of a brashness. Sure makes it a pain to tune.
Speaking of faceplates, I'll start a new thread....
-
@blafleur: This is hardly the case. The reeds alone (unless there are other leaks) determine the air flow. The only concern with large openings would be relatively large and heavy pallets.
Providing that all reeds are accessible, tuning shouldn't be an issue. Neither is waxing, depending on the technique.
Now I have to leave and dig out my car from under the snow, if I can find it.
-
I removed the reed blocks, backing plate, and slides out of a Hohner 114, made new reed blocks, and mounted directly to the face plate. Even changed it from a 4 up configuration to a 2 up 2 down. It made it much louder and also changed the tone.
please share, how you removed the original reed blocks.
what is the purpose of your 2 up / 2 down, as to the original LMMH all/or some?
Sure makes it a pain to tune.
also, they're a real bugga to wax
I'm interested in altering a 4 stop into 2 keys of MM, and adding a stop to the bass end for the corresponding bass and cords
2 stops up, 3 stops down = key of G; 3 stops up & 2 down = key of D
these HA114's have an appeal of there own, (and sometimes size does matter :o)
Do you have a favorite melodeon? ???
it has been asked before........
-
Earlier in the discussion, I mentioned seeing square holes in examples of old German one-row accordions. This Beaver carcass currently on Ebay has square holes:
http://cgi.ebay.com/VINTAGE-BEAVER-BRAND-ACCORDION-/160527391925
-
Old Geezer, I just chiseled them out, after knocking the bulk out with a hammer. Removing the backing plate was a little harder. I used the 2 up 2 down to see if there was going to be a difference in tone or volume, there was. Not sure why blocks laying down increase volume, but they seem to. Also makes it easier to tune blocks that are not removable as opposed to trying to get at those reeds facing each other in a double standup configuration. The other issue was using the 2 up 2 down I had to redo 2 of the rows of faceplate holes. So I layed a thin veneer on the backside of the faceplate first, then drilled holes where I needed them. The old holes remained as closed off slots, but were covered by the pallets.
Do I have a favorite? Compared to many folks on this forum I have a very limited experience with accordions. Other than the 114, I've only had access to other Cajun made accordions. I guess I'll have to say my favorite is mine, for fear of offending it's builder. ;D
-
@blafleur: This is hardly the case. The reeds alone (unless there are other leaks) determine the air flow. The only concern with large openings would be relatively large and heavy pallets.
Providing that all reeds are accessible, tuning shouldn't be an issue. Neither is waxing, depending on the technique.
Now I have to leave and dig out my car from under the snow, if I can find it.
Tuning is a pain only because without slides you can't shut off 3 banks to work on one row. I use tape to cover the other 3 rows, not a big deal, but not as easy as slides. I also like to compare one row against another, again much easier with slides.
I don't think I agree that only reeds determine air flow. It seems to me that there is a combination of air flow and pressure build up in the reed block chamber, and there is a sweet spot in the combination. As I said earlier, I experimented to try to find optimum size by starting small and gradually drilling out the faceplate holes. The sound got better and louder, then at a certain point it was using noticeably more air. Not a conclusive or scientific experiment, I know, but it makes sense in my feeble mind. There is lots of head scratching for me on this stuff and a lot of it doesn't make sense.
-
@blafleur: This is hardly the case. The reeds alone (unless there are other leaks) determine the air flow. The only concern with large openings would be relatively large and heavy pallets.
Providing that all reeds are accessible, tuning shouldn't be an issue. Neither is waxing, depending on the technique.
Now I have to leave and dig out my car from under the snow, if I can find it.
Surely there comes a point where the air going into the chamber is too much for the reed and will choke it? Or is that a chamber geometry problem?
-
Surely there comes a point where the air going into the chamber is too much for the reed and will choke it? Or is that a chamber geometry problem?
I think that has more to do with the pressure applied by the bellows.
My experience tells me that the chamber should be as small as possible to get the brightest sound. Just long and deep enough to allow the reed and valve to move freely. I've worked on boxes where the chamber was WAY to big for the reed in place, and the response was not an issue. A strip of wood was applied at the base of the block to accept the smaller reed. The sound was, however, a bit too rounded to my taste. When blocking the chamber from top and thus reducing the chamber volume, the sound appeared brighter.
-
@lars: what you've pointed out is very true when dealing with smaller reeds, say the last 4 to 6 in a row. My experience teaches me that larger reeds benefit from more spacious (i.e. deeper, but not longer than necessary) chambers, probably because they allow their valves to fully open.
-
I've experimented with chamber size some by adding pieces of wood to build up the inside and make the chamber more shallow. Again, I think there is a sweet spot. Too much chamber and you lose volume and some tone, then at a certain point when making it smaller, it began to sound choked and muffled. I also tried building it up unevenly making up for the fact that the push reed is sitting higher than the pull reed. It affected the smaller reeds without valves more positively that the bigger reeds. This time I've tried making the chambers slightly narrower, as narrow as I can get away with, even trimming valves in the chamber a little so they would clear the sides, and making slightly deeper chamber, shooting for a chamber that was roughly the same size in area (guesstimating), but not as shallow, hoping this made air movement more efficient. In case it isn't obvious, I have no scientific or engineering background, this is all just the mindless meandering of a guy with some time and a shop.
Waiting on reeds, I'll know in another month or two....
-
@lars: what you've pointed out is very true when dealing with smaller reeds, say the last 4 to 6 in a row. My experience teaches me that larger reeds benefit from more spacious (i.e. deeper, but not longer than necessary) chambers, probably because they allow their valves to fully open.
My point on the spot - obviosly they have to be deep enough for the valve to open up properly, but I have found that adding a shim to the bottom of the chamber to reduce depth has helped. This was in the case where the reed chamber was deeper than most modern (40s onwards) builders would build.
This is also the case when I replace a low set of reeds with a medium set - I reduce both lenth and depth of the chamber on those chambers where I find the depth to be more than what is just needed for the valve to open properly.
-
This reminds me of a Hohner Corso I tuned many years ago: The accidentals were so penetrant to make my hair stand on end. The "problem" was easily solved be reducing the enormous chamber underneath them. However, when the owner returned he was extremely disappointed with the result: he wanted everyone to hear that he actually used his accidentals! I had no choice but to bring back said chambers to their pristine state...
-
Do you gentlemen use tapered reed blocks?
-
Tapered which direction ?
Across the width, or down the length ?
-
Yes.
-
Trapezoidal?
Nigel
-
it did occur to me that round holes (and pads) are much cheaper
why a box with a substantially square cutout for the reed and valve followed it up with a round hole and pad.
The hole in the reedblock and the hole in the baseboard are virtually always the same shape, either both round or both square, for this very reason.
[/quote]
In my Oakwood -- certainly one of the loudest boxes around -- the holes in the reedblock are square and as large as possible, the holes in the soundboard are rectangular with one big hole for each pallet over two reedblock holes. This gives an even bigger opening for the sound to escape.
Ian
-
This gives an even bigger opening for the sound to escape.
Ian,
Do you think that it is primarily "for the sound to escape" or to promote airflow?
I've noticed that on many French Canadian boxes, the space on the faceplate between the holes for the two "M" reeds has been hollowed out.
-
Do you think that it is primarily "for the sound to escape" or to promote airflow?
Sound.
The airflow is limited mostly by the reed (try taking a reed plate out and playing the box with a gaping hole where the reed plate was!)