Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Gary on April 10, 2011, 10:36:50 AM

Title: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary on April 10, 2011, 10:36:50 AM
We all started somewhere by being inspired, a yearning to get the style , timing and everything else right. I know that by tradition it is said we must push ourselves to make progress but as a self taught player I am getting frustrated.  From being patient I am now keen as mustard and I am starting to wonder if I am aiming to high. I did not start out as a youngster so seem to feel I am catching up all the time.

Maybe it is time to get a bit more organised and get my core  tunes listed and then practice what I know in sets. Part of this will be tackling learning to read music, even at a basic level so I can get the first notes as reminders.

Is it just me feeling like this ? And how did you all get this urge under control!!!
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary on April 10, 2011, 10:39:11 AM
oops, of course we all started out as youngsters !!!  I meant I took up playing the box later  rather than as a school age person in a musical family.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Theo on April 10, 2011, 10:41:30 AM
No it's not just you Gary, most adult learners feel like this for some time.  I found the most helpful thing was to always be on the lookout for very small signs of progress in my own playing.  Just feel good about each tiny improvement and they will all gradually build up.  Don't rush, but do work at it,  it takes time.  Having ambitious goals is great.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 10, 2011, 11:53:48 AM
Hi, Gary. You are not alone. I started playing at the age of 50. I tend to be a perfectionist in most things I do and get frustrated when I fail to reach the high standards I set myself, so making slow progress as a melodeon player was particularly frustrating. However, I found (and continue to find) that certain things helped speed up the progress and replace the frustration with the pleasure and satisfaction of discernible progress and achievement.

One thing that helped enormously was teaching myself to read music. It is not difficult and it opened up a much wider range of tunes to me. Secondly, I try to be very organised and disciplined in my practising whilst making sure that it remains fun. I do this by practising at least an hour every day (there are days when this is impossible, so I make up the time by putting in extra practice on other days). Part of each practice involves revisiting techniques and tunes that I can already play and part of it is spent on learning new techniques and tunes. If I find myself getting frustrated because something is not going well, I abandon it and play some tunes I enjoy until the frustration dissipates, then I return to whatever it was that was causing the problem.

I also try to use yardsticks to measure my progress. For instance, there is a feeling of satisfaction to be gained from playing successfully at one session a tune that I did not feel confident enough to play at an earlier one or a tune that I tried to play at an earlier session and did not play very well.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary P Chapin on April 10, 2011, 02:30:26 PM
I also found it helpful to journal practices and write down goals. At the end of the day, when I practice, I'm tired. It's easy to wander through the tunes and not be productive.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Owen Woods on April 10, 2011, 04:53:31 PM
I've never been very good at practicing, probably why my box playing has improved so much over the past few years. I tend to just play tunes, which is nice and I enjoy it, but it isn't the same as actually practicing. The advice that others have given you is good, but I find that the biggest push to my playing has come from playing with others, whether in ceilidhs, sessions or for dance.

Learning to read music, writing down the tunes that you know, putting them into sets and so on is a very valuable thing to do. As is recording yourself and putting it on YouTube. My perception of what is good changes completely when a camera is in front of me and if you do it fairly regularly it drives your playing up no end.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary on April 10, 2011, 04:53:48 PM
Some useful ideas there thanks, certainly need a bit more self discipline !

What sparked this off was my current battle to learn Flatworld by ear.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary P Chapin on April 10, 2011, 05:39:01 PM
What sparked this off was my current battle to learn Flatworld by ear.

Have you heard this recording of it?

http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2011/04/my-giordy-has-gone-to-better-place.html
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Tufty on April 10, 2011, 06:50:35 PM
Some useful ideas there thanks, certainly need a bit more self discipline !

What sparked this off was my current battle to learn Flatworld by ear.
Are you playing a D/G? I am learning the same tune at the moment, OK on a G/C but when I try on a D/G only dogs can hear it! Also a good 75% of general session tunes are a fair bit easier than Flatworld, so if you can play that I think you are doing well.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary P Chapin on April 10, 2011, 07:12:03 PM

That's not me. It's the person I sold me GC Giordy to.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: HarpDave on April 10, 2011, 08:37:10 PM
I'm new to melodeon, but one thing that has helped me to learn other instruments is to alternate between blocks of disciplined practice and free form playing. The practice helps me to hone my skills and the free playing lets me blow off some of the frustration of not progressing quickly enough, have some fun and bring some creativity to my playing even if I'm not very good yet. Give yourself permission to be sloppy and just have some fun half the time.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 10, 2011, 09:04:27 PM
Gary - I can recognise completely where you're coming from, as I've only taken up melodeon since last summer, and feel  time is marching on for me. Though my mental age is in the teens, I fear my birth certificate might indicate otherwise  ::)
 
Theo had some wise words for me early on - ' it takes time to learn to play...' and I now realise it's true.
We've now embarked on a past time that will continue for as long as we want it to, and we'll always learn during this time. Sometimes it's leaps and bounds, sometimes it's minute improvements possibly unrecognisable.
I sometimes have a little panic, but I remember those words. Sometimes if it's been a hard period of work and I'm really too tired to play, I don't beat myself up, I'm starting to realise it will do more harm that good if I try and practise under such conditions.
I too need to organise my practising, to concentrate on some tunes and techniques. I think it's a sensible approach to concentrate on specific things.
.....and of course, sometimes, hell to it just  :|||:

I think whatever stage we're at, we all sometimes have little wobbles of faith!
Keep at it
Q
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: **DTN** on April 10, 2011, 09:30:07 PM
i started melodeon (first instrument) @ age 36  .... first challenge i set myself was to play flatworld too... achieved that (took a while) and now 14 years on i still play it .. but hopefully better!
The wobbles come and go .... can be very frustrating @ times but then you get it! ... or another bit of technique! ... then you're good for a while more!.

I continually set myself nearly impossible challenges ... the work you put in on them .. makes all your other tunes work better!

DTN
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Anahata on April 11, 2011, 08:50:59 AM
I've been playing for 30 years and I stall can't play Flatworld  :|bl

Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary P Chapin on April 11, 2011, 01:34:52 PM
Current challenge: tightening up rhythm (playing with metronome).
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: GbH on April 11, 2011, 09:31:48 PM
Is it just me feeling like this ?

Well, it's certainly the case that I frequently feel frustrated with it (or, more accurately, with myself).  It's not that I'm not able to learn, or find new things to play.  More, that I just don't really know what it is I'm really expecting to achieve from it.  It almost feels like I've missed something fundamental, somewhere along the line, in terms of understanding what makes for a good performance.  Maybe that's a result of trying to do too much, too soon and that I should really be listening to others more than I actually do?  Or maybe, as Theo says, it's something that will sort itself out naturally once I've been playing for a bit longer.

And how did you all get this urge under control!!!

I haven't managed to do that.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Dunny on April 11, 2011, 10:38:48 PM
I thought I could play Flatworld a bit - until I saw Andy Cutting play it last night! I know it's his tune, but he played it soooo well  (:)
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Sandy on April 12, 2011, 12:57:01 AM
I've been playing for 30 years and I stall can't play Flatworld  :|bl


That made me smile. I've been playing for about six years. Can play Flatworld but know so few tunes at a session.  :|bl
I think goals or difficult challenges are great.......but they have to be achievable in your mind.

Sandy
 (:)

Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: branwell5 on April 12, 2011, 01:02:56 AM
I started 3 weeks ago after years of on/off dabbling(read struggling !) with piano accordion.All I can say is that there is a wonderful amount of resources available now via the internet giving help/encouragement(Melnet/forums/computer software/abc's, and goals to aim for (I wanna play that like him/her on Youtube....oh,that's what it sounds like....etc.,etc.).I think it's brilliant and it has opened up a whole new world for me and I needn't struggle on alone anymore.I'm in the fortunate position of being able to pick up my box almost anytime at work without disturbing anyone and spend a lot of time away from home,so it gives me something worthwhile to fill my time away,and plenty of practice.(Not forgetting my tutor,who I need to keep pushing me,which stops me churning out the tunes I think I know and getting in a rut - thanks Bob !)
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 12, 2011, 09:41:40 AM
Gbh: Sometimes time is your best friend.
Very many moons ago I got it a right state with my English concertina, unsure of where to go with it, frustrated etc etc. and after years of hard work and a lot of regular practising, it went into a slow decline. My life changed, moved into an old house, then kids, so all my free time was put into renovating and children. Plus all the local sessions just dried up. About 18months ago, I realised a new embryonic session had started in a pub a mile away. I woke up again! .....and now am taking on the challenge of a new instrument as well.
On reflection, I can't remember what it was I got all knotted up about. More to the point, I now no longer care, I just want the sheer unadultereated enjoyment of playing again.
I know it's difficult, but try not to worry so much and let time take it's course. You'll come out the other end.
Just.....keep playing!

Sandy: Blimey! I've often wondered how long you've been playing.  I hope I'm half as good 6 years on!
A good point made though, make sure your goals are achievable.
cheers all
Q

Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Alan Morley on April 27, 2011, 10:28:34 AM
Flatworld

While we are talking about playing Flatworld - there is a lovely version by Squeezyjoan on YouTube that shouldn't be overlooked.

It's played well at a steady pace and with feeling, have a look http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1w4L_inc5EQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1w4L_inc5EQ)

Played in Em on a D/G box too

It's got me looking at it now...

Almo
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Owen Woods on April 27, 2011, 12:42:19 PM
...who is a member of thi forum... ;)
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Gary on April 27, 2011, 05:48:37 PM
After listening to around 10 versions of Flatworld on U tube I settled on this one by busketeer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yn0VEbRH8Zk&feature=related

Last night I finally managed the tune without stopping and it was at last great fun to play. It has opened up another avenue to explore.

And I did not play my pokerwork upside down !
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: mikeed on May 02, 2011, 02:20:37 PM
Hi all.  While on the subject of 'too much too soon?' - I only started playing just before last Xmas.  I picked up a Chinese Pokerwork of e-bay and bought a couple of excellent tutor books (George Garside and Maggie's Melodeon) to get me going. It is often commented on this forum that you become 'hooked' on the melodeon and, yes, I'm there.  One of the best decisions I ever made was to give it a go.   However, my desire to progress is much stronger than my talent will probably ever be.  Having taken that into consideration, I would welcome some advice. If I wish to explore the option of purchasing a further box (yes, see, hooked!) should I go for a more expensive DG or a box in a different key?
I know it's all down to practice, practice, practice and please forgive my ignorance, but are more expensive boxes more satisfying (dare I say easier) to play?  Am I being a little bit adventurous in considering a different key when I am still very green with the DG?  Help for a hooked man would be welcome as I am 62 this year and want to pack in the enjoyment as much as I can!
 :||: ???
Cheers
Mike
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 02, 2011, 03:01:42 PM
Hi mikeed. The bad/good news (depending on your point of view) is that there is no known cure for this affliction that we share.  ::)

However, to address your question, it would help us to advise you if you could provide a bit more information. For instance, what kind of music are you playing on your Chinese Pokerwork and what sort of music do you want to play in the future? When considering a new box, what budget do you have in mind?
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Theo on May 02, 2011, 03:10:29 PM
but are more expensive boxes more satisfying (dare I say easier) to play? 

My experience was I started with a Hohner, and thought I would be able to play better with a more expensive box.  Wrong!  I had a Baffeti, a Saltarelle, and a Castagnari.   None of them made me a better player, and I now play a Hohner!   There are many people here with similar experience.

Whether the more expensive boxes are more satisfying is an entirely personal thing, it all depends on what you like.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 02, 2011, 03:17:36 PM
but are more expensive boxes more satisfying (dare I say easier) to play? 

My experience was I started with a Hohner, and thought I would be able to play better with a more expensive box.  Wrong!  I had a Baffeti, a Saltarelle, and a Castagnari.   None of them made me a better player, and I now play a Hohner!   There are many people here with similar experience.

Whether the more expensive boxes are more satisfying is an entirely personal thing, it all depends on what you like.

While there are many people, I am sure, Theo, who share your experience, some of us do not. I started with a Hohner Erica and quickly reached a plateau that I struggled to get beyond. The breakthrough came when I bought a Castaganri, which I found quicker, more responsive and more satisfying to play. I also find it much easier to play an instrument with mushroom buttons than one with peg-in-hole buttons.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: nemethmik on May 02, 2011, 03:21:04 PM
Maggie's Melodeon
You definitely do not need a better box, at least not now. Maggie's Melodeon book with the playalong CD is excellent learning method book with exercises to follow and simple tunes to learn first. The only thing I found missing are the fingering hints. What I did, I invented (figured out) my fingering and wrote the i,m,r,p letters below the notes. I would have prefered the fingering hints included with the book.

Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Theo on May 02, 2011, 03:24:01 PM
While there are many people, I am sure, Theo, who share your experience, some of us do not.

Absolutely,  the point I was really trying to make is that there is no simple answer to the question of what box any individual will be happy with. Part of the fun is discovering the box that feels and sounds right for oneself.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: waltzman on May 02, 2011, 03:47:47 PM
I think it is also worth pointing out that there is a world of difference between playing a Hohner that has been tuned and 'fixed up' and playing one off the shelf.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Theo on May 02, 2011, 05:19:52 PM
That is very true,  but it can be true of more expensive instruments too
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Tufty on May 02, 2011, 06:25:16 PM
If I wish to explore the option of purchasing a further box (yes, see, hooked!) should I go for a more expensive DG or a box in a different key?
Choice of keys very much depends on what you want to play. The general pattern is DG=English, GC=French and BC=Irish but I use both DG and GC for French and lots of people play Irish on a DG. The BC has a very different system of playing and is rarely heard other than in Irish music. Which players/styles do you enjoy? That will probably guide you towards the best system for you.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Peter_T on May 02, 2011, 06:35:20 PM
... Chinese Pokerwork of e-bay and bought a couple of excellent tutor books ... 'hooked' ...  However, my desire to progress is much stronger than my talent will probably ever be.  Having taken that into consideration, I would welcome some advice. If I wish to explore the option of purchasing a further box (yes, see, hooked!) should I go for a more expensive DG or a box in a different key?

I know it's all down to practice, practice, practice ....are more expensive boxes more satisfying (dare I say easier) to play?  Am I being a little bit adventurous in considering a different key when I am still very green with the DG?  Help for a hooked man would be welcome as I am 62 this year and want to pack in the enjoyment as much as I can!

...
I think it is also worth pointing out that there is a world of difference between playing a Hohner that has been tuned and 'fixed up' and playing one off the shelf.

That is very true,  but it can be true of more expensive instruments too

Hmmm. I've yet - after a couple of years and edging into my mid-60s - to reach the stage of finding the D/G Pokerwork inadequate. After the initial - and long-lasting - unhandiness, it seems to become much less of a difficult beast as I give it more time.

That said, could sometimes use different low notes and accidentals, of course, but not to the extent of feeling it has to be modified yet. I think it was Lester Bailey who posted an ABC for The Dark Island which fudged the missing low C natural, and Ashokan Farwell can probably be played in G rather than D. I forget who first mentioned 'fudging' notes - perhaps Brian Peters at Witney - but it is something I clearly need to know more about. Wouldn't mind a one-row in C of course, but still...

The Hohner's tuning is probably less than perfect  - I scared myself by testing it against a tuner - but tolerable for my purposes. The treble button travel hasn't been limited, which I cope with so far. The main problem continues to be the brain of the bod playing trying to play it.

Getting it tweaked would mean spending cash I'd rather save. The other thing, of course, would be not having a box to play while it was away. I'm very much inclined to leave spending money until I feel I have to rather than would simply like to. All the same, apart from the long journey Up North, who fettles boxes within reach of Surrey?

In answer to Mikeed, I'd probably say that it also depends on how much you can spare the cash and the time. At worst you might end up re-selling a box you don't get on with, and will have learnt a bit. I rather wonder whether you may have already decided to get another box anyway, in which case good luck to you and have fun.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Ollie on May 02, 2011, 06:46:19 PM
I would suggest sticking with the Pokerwork for the time being until you settle on what style of music you want to play. This will dictate whether or not to go for another key, or a more expensive box, or both! At this stage of the game, you don't really need anything more than a Pokerwork; a more expensive box is unlikely to make your playing any better.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: mikeed on May 04, 2011, 11:27:56 PM
Thanks all for your good advice.  I suppose I knew really that it is much too early for me to be expanding my horizons with another box.  With hindsight I didn't really think that a more expensive box would make me a better player - just that a more expensive box might sound sweeter than a cheaper box?  Therefore, ipso facto, I can fool my brain into believing that it is my exquisite 'pumping away' that is creating this lovely sound!  And of course, it is the lure of 'the pretty things' (to quote the League of Gentlemen).
Of course, that's another question.  Does expensive, good quality, equipment naturally sound tonally better than cheaper, good quality equipment?  Why did you settle on the box/es you are currently playing if they are all of a muchness. 
Forgive me if I am asking banal questions, but there is no opportunity to try out different boxes where I live, Swansea, South Wales.  And with only an imperfect, yet full-on rendering of 'Buttered Peas' and 'Egans Polka' to my repetoire so far, it is quite difficult to sit somewhere like Hobgoblin trying out various instruments.

Cheers all  :|glug
Mike
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Peter_T on May 04, 2011, 11:35:14 PM
....  And with only an imperfect, yet full-on rendering of 'Buttered Peas' and 'Egans Polka' to my repetoire so far, it is quite difficult to sit somewhere like Hobgoblin trying out various instruments.

.... :|glug
Mike


My experience is that a minimal repertoire is no bar to playing instruments in music shops. The arrangement is that we, eventually, pay them, which confers a certain moral advantage. And they're nice people anyway, of course.

I shan't name the shop in Fitzrovia, London where I was the only person present who could play the melodeons on display at all, and found myself answering a customer's questions on something totally unrelated....

Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Guy on May 05, 2011, 12:06:14 AM
Thanks all for your good advice.  I suppose I knew really that it is much too early for me to be expanding my horizons with another box.  With hindsight I didn't really think that a more expensive box would make me a better player - just that a more expensive box might sound sweeter than a cheaper box?  Therefore, ipso facto, I can fool my brain into believing that it is my exquisite 'pumping away' that is creating this lovely sound!  And of course, it is the lure of 'the pretty things' (to quote the League of Gentlemen).
Of course, that's another question.  Does expensive, good quality, equipment naturally sound tonally better than cheaper, good quality equipment?  Why did you settle on the box/es you are currently playing if they are all of a muchness. 
Forgive me if I am asking banal questions, but there is no opportunity to try out different boxes where I live, Swansea, South Wales.  And with only an imperfect, yet full-on rendering of 'Buttered Peas' and 'Egans Polka' to my repetoire so far, it is quite difficult to sit somewhere like Hobgoblin trying out various instruments.

Cheers all  :|glug

Mike

Hi Mike,

I live just outside Caerphilly, so not too far away. I'm lucky enough to have acquired several nice boxes (Castagnari, Saltarelle, Loffet-none of which I'm selling, by the way!), so if you'd like to come over and have a try on them some time to give you some ideas you'd be welcome.

PM me if you're interested....
Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 05, 2011, 04:59:03 PM
Mike - that's 2 more tunes than I could play when I bought my box!
I could barely get a single one note melody out, and felt a bit conspicuous in the midst several large stands at Sidmouth wih a lot of people browsing. The stall staff were excellent, respecting the fact I was a total beginner and pointing out salient features and kindly acknowledged my absolute begginnership rather than making fun of it. Everybody knows you have to start somewhere!

The choice of box can come down to things like me having small hands and need to reach the basses properly. For me it self selected my choice down to 2 melodeons, one was good, the other felt even better.
Somewhat stunned after purchase, my mate simply said two things:-
1. It's no good buying something you can't physically play ( i.e. too heavy, large, can't handle properly etc ).
2. After walking around every stall in site and trying most things, he commented that I'd now discovered a meloeon's not just a melodeon, they all feel different.
I think both were very thoughtful comments, and I'd now just learnt what he meant.

I'm not sure how far, ( not that far? ) but a trip up to Chippenham at the end of the month 's bank holiday would let you take a look at several stall's worth of melodeons from large retailers, even if you simply went for a window shop and a squeeze.
Just a thought.....
Q
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Alan Morley on May 05, 2011, 05:11:42 PM
When I'm on the lookout for a new box - I often don't attempt to play a tune right away..

Usually start with the 'feel' of the box, the action of the keys, the ease of the bellows, position of the bass and air button - after all that play some chords and scales.

If everything feels right - then bash out 'Twinkle Twinkle Little Star'......   :||:

So don't worry about not being up to speed when you try out a box....


Almo
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 05, 2011, 05:15:14 PM
Almo - Yes absolutely!
Unfortunately at the time I couldn't carry out your second bit  :|bl
Q
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 05, 2011, 08:28:49 PM
There are the obvious things to consider when buying a box such as the tone, the feel of the keyboard and the responsiveness or otherwise of the bellows, but a factor that is less obvious is, for me, one of the most important. That is the air button or lever. If it is in the right place and easy to operate, bellows control is so much easier than if you are searching for it or if you find it stiff or uncomfortable.

Personally, I prefer an air lever to an air button. I never felt comfortable with the button on the Hohner Erica that was my first box, whereas the levers on all four of the Castagnaris I have owned at one time or another have been comfortable and easy to play. That cannot be said of all air levers, however. Recently, I borrowed a Dino Baffetti from a friend and the air lever was very uncomfortable, so much so that I developed a blister on the side of my thumb that has only just healed. Of course, this is probably due to a combination of the size of my hand and my playing style: my friend has no such problem with his Dino. But it does emphasise the need to consider the air button/lever when trying out different boxes to determine which one suits you best.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: ladydetemps on May 05, 2011, 08:40:02 PM
Having a tame melodeon player on hand to take the box through its paces and give you a 2nd opinion is also useful. ;)
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on May 05, 2011, 10:59:21 PM
There are the obvious things to consider when buying a box such as the tone, the feel of the keyboard and the responsiveness or otherwise of the bellows, but a factor that is less obvious is, for me, one of the most important. That is the air button or lever. If it is in the right place and easy to operate, bellows control is so much easier than if you are searching for it or if you find it stiff or uncomfortable.

Personally, I prefer an air lever to an air button. I never felt comfortable with the button on the Hohner Erica that was my first box, whereas the levers on all four of the Castagnaris I have owned at one time or another have been comfortable and easy to play. That cannot be said of all air levers, however. Recently, I borrowed a Dino Baffetti from a friend and the air lever was very uncomfortable, so much so that I developed a blister on the side of my thumb that has only just healed. Of course, this is probably due to a combination of the size of my hand and my playing style: my friend has no such problem with his Dino. But it does emphasise the need to consider the air button/lever when trying out different boxes to determine which one suits you best.


I think you're dead right about the air button. The Excelsior 3v that I bought recently had a truly awful air button setup, stiff and with a "spongy" response. It made the whole instrument feel wrong, along with giving me a pain in my thumb and cramp in my hand.

Looking inside the instrument I found that they had topped the air button lever with leather and felt (between it and the button), removing this made a massive difference. I then slackened off the air button spring. Now the instrument feels completely different, much more responsive, easier to play and no cramp or pains in my hand.
Title: Re: Too much Too soon??
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on May 05, 2011, 11:05:13 PM
Having a tame melodeon player on hand to take the box through its paces and give you a 2nd opinion is also useful. ;)

I think that's excellent advice if you can do it. It's all very well looking for that box that will "feel right" in an instance (like eyes meeting across a smoky room?), but some experienced help might let you avoid many possible pitfalls.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal