Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: squeezy on June 08, 2011, 11:23:20 PM

Title: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 08, 2011, 11:23:20 PM
i AM going to make a box - a two-row small 3 voice!  I've been saying it for years and years and unless I say I will ... err... I won't!

I have almost no woodworking skills at all, I was a disaster with all woodworking at school although I am now a lot more patient and attentive to detail than I was.  I am, however fairly competent with repair work of the mechanics and reeds on my own instruments.

So ... I know some here have made instruments from scratch either off their own backs or through the building courses run by Emmanuelle Pariselle, and I know there are some pro makers who visit here Rees, Stormy etc..... 

What should I know?  Not instructions from start to finish ... but just advice on the approach to take, the set up needed, tips and tricks or pearls of wisdom would be very gratefully received.

Cheers

Squeezy

PS - I fully intend to ruin large amounts of wood, swear a lot, give up a couple of times and spend lots of money on equipment it turns out I don't need on this project.

Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 08, 2011, 11:26:25 PM
I'd suggest taking it in stages.    Start with reedblocks, and make a new set of blocks for an existing instrument, perhaps in a different key.  I reckon the reedblock is about the most complicated wooden part, if you can manage that the rest should be relatively easy.  

You will need to do a lot of precision sawing of small bits of wood.  I can recommend one of these Proxxon model makers saw benches:
http://www.axminster.co.uk/proxxon-proxxon-fks-e-table-saw-prod20020/ (http://www.axminster.co.uk/proxxon-proxxon-fks-e-table-saw-prod20020/)
http://www.axminster.co.uk/proxxon-proxxon-fet-table-saw-prod791265/ (http://www.axminster.co.uk/proxxon-proxxon-fet-table-saw-prod791265/)
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 08, 2011, 11:33:11 PM
Thanks Theo - that's a very good idea, I hadn't even though about that.  Are there any variables that you know of that change the sound properties of reedblocks that I could experiment with?

Keep 'em coming!
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2011, 11:38:11 PM
That's good advice. Building an instrument from scratch without plans would be tricky. I've been "studying" Engineering for what seems like a lifetime and I still have a very sketchy understanding of how you would go about designing a box. I think though that reedblocks are probably the most critical aspect, because they not only dictate the sound to some extent, they also impose constraints on the size. There would be no point in building a cabinet and then finding that your reeds don't fit!

I would really like to do this project (although I want a small three row three voice, BCC#) and I will one day. I would go about it by first deciding on the orientation of my reeds (currently thinking about M flat mounted, M+ in a inclined pan, L on a conventional block in the middle. Three rows into two rows of pallets as the Shand Morino) and then prototyping reedblocks into an instrument of a known sound and response of a similar sort of size. If you mock up a few reedblocks, attach a few reeds, say one for each octave, splice into a pokerwork, record and see how they respond then you would be able to more easily change your mind about how it should be set up. Once you think that you have a good orientation and chamber size then think about the fondo, how big it should be (because lots of spare space on the fondo has a different sound to very little) and what material (aluminium, ply or solid wood?). Then do the same with the bass end. At the end of that you should have your size constraints and so you can define your bellows dimensions.

Then comes the mechanisms and I haven't got that far in my thinking :P I'm presuming that you don't have a waterjet cutter and I don't know how best to manufacture the mechanism otherwise, other than buying stock, which might not fit.

My feeling is that you should start on the inside and work your way out, making the bellows last. Does that make sense to others? I obviously have no experience in this sort of thing.

You might find www.mimf.com of interest for woodworking stuff. I presume that you know about the boxbuilders yahoo group already.

EDIT: If someone has a conclusive idea of exactly what (quantifiable) effect reedblock chamber size has on the reeds then I would be very interested to hear from you...
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 08, 2011, 11:40:58 PM
Yes, two main ones I can think of, type of timber used being the obvious one.  The way the block is constructed is the other: 1) Built up from smaller pieces glued together, most Hohner and most Italian makes are like this, or 2) Reed chambers carved out of a solid block with separate cap and base, common on Paolo Sopranis and a few other Italian makes.  
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 08, 2011, 11:51:08 PM
Cheers Theo,  so - similar to Ukebert's question here, what qualities of the timber / construction affect which parts of the sound?  I know with soundboards I'm looking for a very stiff material if I want to transmit the maximum volume and higher frequencies to the listener.  Is it the same with reed blocks?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 08, 2011, 11:57:06 PM
I really have no clear answers to that.  But some hunches:  The less sound absorbed in the blocks the better, so rigidity, density, mass, and timbers with good acoustic properties (spruce, maple, cedar etc) are probably good.  I'm sure there are numerous details of construction that are all influential on the final sound.

Sound boards (are not soundboards but we all know what you mean)  the only observation I would add is that Frans van der Aa uses rather thin and flexible high quality ply and his boxes sound great.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 12:09:13 AM
Thanks Theo,  I shan't bother you any more tonight!  It's pretty much what I thought and it will be (as Ukebert suggested) a process of experimentation which is great.  What you have said does verify what I have seen in boxes I have owned/looked inside.

By the way - I plan on a waxless design.  I hate wax and reed-waxing, it's so messy and can be a major source of debris that gets in the reeds eventually.  So my reeds will be screwed/pinned in to a bed of suede or something with similar properties.  Plus the boxes I have owned with this design have all sounded very direct which is the kind of sound I am going for.

Good night,

Squeezy.

PS - anyone else?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 09, 2011, 12:13:56 AM
I have read so many conflicting accounts of the influence of the fondo on the acoustics of the box that I am currently in the confused stage :P I intend to bend my project supervisor's ear about it next year (he's an expert on violin acoustics, I'm hoping that he can give some insight, even though free reeds are different in every conceivable way).

I think that wax has a larger effect on sound than I had bargained for. Certainly from my own limited experience of rewaxing boxes the amount of wax used can have quite an effect on the sound and to preserve the tuning if you need to change the valve, putting on a similar amount of wax than you took off seems to work well. I think that the less wax used the more direct the sound, so it would make sense that pinning would exemplify that. It would be more difficult to get right though, wax is very forgiving. The reedblocks would also probably be bigger and bulkier, which could be critical in a small box.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Lester on June 09, 2011, 08:09:38 AM
Cheers Theo,  so - similar to Ukebert's question here, what qualities of the timber / construction affect which parts of the sound?  I know with soundboards I'm looking for a very stiff material if I want to transmit the maximum volume and higher frequencies to the listener.  Is it the same with reed blocks?

Try this

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7117.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7117.0.html)
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 09, 2011, 08:17:57 AM
The reedblocks would also probably be bigger and bulkier, which could be critical in a small box.

Not necessarily.  Shand Morinos use screwed i plates, and have almost not space between plates.  Instead of having space for screws between plates they either placed at the ends, or the edges are notched to make room for the screw.

By the way - I plan on a waxless design.  I hate wax and reed-waxing, it's so messy and can be a major source of debris that gets in the reeds eventually.  So my reeds will be screwed/pinned in to a bed of suede or something with similar properties. 

If using screws you will need to be careful about the type of timber used for the edges of the reed chambers, softer woods like spruce may not give enough grip for the screws.  Emanuel P uses maple.  He also uses a self adhesive gasket material called "olovice adesivio"  I have some of this if you want to try it.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: LJC on June 09, 2011, 10:24:48 AM
I had a super serious research into building some boxes a year or so ago (had to put it on hold as a table saw in a one bedroom flat isn't really feasible, especially with a neat a tidy missus) and whilst I could conceptualise the wood work in my head, the bass and treble mechanisms from scratch look like a right royal pain the back side.

A basic wooden stepped keyboard like a Max or a Tommy is just precision wood work - I would get a table mountable router or milling machine to do it quickly and accurately. But with a metal setup I wouldn't really consider making one as the assemblies are available from Carini's. It would save lots of time and energy which would be better placed into reed work and beautifying (and stops sharp metal piercing finger tips).

The reason I say this is that if you buy any pre-made parts then you have to tailor the whole box to their sizes. Obviously with building your own wooden mechanism this isn't an issue.

Also, I assume bellows are coming from Galassi - I don't see the point in sticking my own when they can do an amazingly better job for a really reasonable price, in any size/shape/colour etc.

Russells.com is the place to go for any leather - send them samples and they will match it. Waxless design is the way forward, so much less mess, and way easier to maintain, it's just offset by initial fiddlyness.

There are lots of builders websites with photo tours etc - these are amazingly useful for getting your head round certain processes... apart from the Bergflot site, where every time you wonder how on earth he makes a certain amazingly intricate part, you just see it on the plasma cutter... grr.. jealous!
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 11:26:36 AM
Some great advice there too.  BTW - Lester's link is to the recent thread by Peter (Stormy) Hyde about his boxes made from foam where he talks about the fact that his boxes have foam reed blocks.

So to recap:

1: Make the smaller components first as these are a) a bit fiddly and b) can affect the final dimensions and qualities of the box.  Reed blocks and treble/bass mechanisms are suggested.  I'm assuming if coupler mechanisms are to be made they need to be taken into consideration as well.

2: If buying in from outside (Carini), make sure you know the dimensions!

3: Get your bellows from Galassi unless you reeeeeeallllly want to know how to do it.

4. Get a table saw. (expensive - but probably very useful)

That's a great start.  Are there any other pearls of wisdom out there?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 09, 2011, 11:32:10 AM


That's a great start.  Are there any other pearls of wisdom out there?

Don't worry about mistakes, just learn from them.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on June 09, 2011, 12:32:11 PM
By the way - I plan on a waxless design.  I hate wax and reed-waxing, it's so messy and can be a major source of debris that gets in the reeds eventually.  So my reeds will be screwed/pinned in to a bed of suede or something with similar properties.  Plus the boxes I have owned with this design have all sounded very direct which is the kind of sound I am going for.

I 100% with you on this! It's also part of my plans in a similar project.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 01:05:47 PM
If I'm thinking about reed blocks - I suppose I have to think about reeds.  Eventually I will be thinking about high end reeds for the box, but obviously different reed makes have slightly different dimensions, don't they, so should I start off by buying the reeds for the box and designing the reed block around those?

In which case, which reeds, and where would you suggest I get them from? 

I'm aware of this thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3460.0.html) - regarding the Binci Professional reeds, I am incredibly happy with their performance in my new Eric Martin.  But other suggestions would be welcome.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 09, 2011, 01:25:25 PM
.... so should I start off by buying the reeds for the box and designing the reed block around those?
I think that is a good idea, so you will then have the exact dimensions of the reed plates and will therefore be able to design your reed blocks accordingly.

I'm one of those who has made a 1-row 4-stop box with Emmanuel Pariselle on the EATMT melodeon making courses. We used Binci Pro reeds on those, which were ordered in advance of the course, and very fine they are too. Even though Emmanuel has now run this course many times and has developed dimensioned drawings and jigs to make the reed blocks, there were still minor modifications needed when the reeds actually arrived, due to minor variations in the size of the reed plates, I guess.

I also agree with those who say that it is best to buy the bellows ready made. You wouldn't make the reeds yourself (at this stage, if ever) so similarly leave the bellows to those who are set up for it professionally. The Galassi bellows are very high quality and unless you really, really want to make them yourself, it's not worth the extra time and effort.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 09, 2011, 01:31:38 PM
If using screws you will need to be careful about the type of timber used for the edges of the reed chambers, softer woods like spruce may not give enough grip for the screws.  Emanuel P uses maple.  He also uses a self adhesive gasket material called "olovice adesivio"  I have some of this if you want to try it.
Charlie Marshall also has this
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#13
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 09, 2011, 03:34:34 PM
I also agree I wouldn't make reed blocks without the reeds in hand.  Lots of variables between different type reeds.  I also personnally like to have the bellows in hand.  Lot's of different methods to make a dizzying variety of reed blocks. If you can, study a few sets to get an idea how you want to make them, chamber sizes, angles, etc. 

For me and the type I build, by far, the hardest and most trying part was the treble keyboard.  Lots of intricate pieces to deal with and some tedious work in getting the action right.  Axle placement, lever sizes, spring type and placement, and things like that make noticeable differences in action feel.  Again, study some you like. 

If you're like me, you won't know what to look for until you build one.  The first one will make you want to build another one to improve the first, or never go near one again.

Tools I couldn't be without-table saw and drill press. Tools I woulnd't want to be without-routers, band saw, guillotine miter trimmer (like for picture frames).  Tools I won't give up now that I have them-stationary belt sander, drum sander, jointer, milling machine(luxury item).  If you even think you may build a second (refer to previous paragraph), plan on making lots of jigs.  I can't even begin to imagine how much time I've spent on making, adjusting, scrapping, then remaking jigs. You need a system of clamping frames square. Put a LOT of thought into the order of doing things, you really have to plan several steps ahead, somtimes doing a step you think you need to now will mess up a later step.

Be prepared to spend several hours or days making something all undone by a 2 second mistake. The scrap pile gets smaller with each build.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 09, 2011, 03:39:06 PM
I'll also add that I've never built anything as tedious, challenging, or frustrating, and caused me several times to want to sell my tools and just go fishing, but it's also, by a long shot, the most gratifying thing I've ever built.  A hard head is a requirement.

Making the first untuned note on my first build made me giggle like a teenage girl just at the fact that it made a sound, and watching someone play it made me beam as if watching one of my kids perform on stage. 

Good luck.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 05:03:55 PM
I'm working on building my own small 1 voice instrument as a first try at building.

Do start with the reeds and reed blocks. And a table saw is essential for cutting most of the parts needed for the reed blocks. I've developed some simple jigs, easily built for assembling glued up reed blocks. I can now make reed blocks very quickly. Let me know if you want pictures of the jigs.

Also, when building blocks by assembling them, pay close attention to the grain direction. I always make sure that my chamber sides and the plate between the two sides of a double reedblock are quarter sawn. The wood is much less likely to warp over time. Most soundboards for guitars, harpsichords, etc. must be made from quarter sawn wood to prevent warping. A good practice for cutting the strips of wood for the parts is to joint or plane one face of the block you're resawing till you see medullary rays on the surface then saw your strip off.

While we're talking about building reed blocks, there's one step in their manufacture that I'm stumped by. After I glue the reed block chamber side pieces to the backing plate, and put on the top cap, how do I cut the block of chambers at an angle such that the top of the block is narrower than the bottom were the bottom plate will go? Hohner and other manufacturer's blocks have an "A" shape to the reedblock, making it easier to get to the reeds for tuning and keeping the vibrating tongues from interfering with each other. Anyway, I have yet to figure out how to do the cut on a table saw in a way that is safe for the operator. How to the manufacturers do that cut safely and support the block during the cut? Photos would be most helpful. Is a different tool set up better than a table saw for this?

In my own research about building reed blocks I've run into differences in the thickness of the chamber walls. Some manufacturers use 4mm walls, others use 6mm walls. The thinner walls will allow you to make a smaller instrument, true, but what does the thinner wall do for the sound of the instrument as opposed to thicker walls? Thicker walls make it easier to wax on the reeds or fit screws between the reedplates if they're nailed on.

BTW, my current scrap pile is just getting bigger.

Good luck and keep us posted on what you're doing.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 09, 2011, 05:18:58 PM
While we're talking about building reed blocks, there's one step in their manufacture that I'm stumped by. After I glue the reed block chamber side pieces to the backing plate, and put on the top cap, how do I cut the block of chambers at an angle such that the top of the block is narrower than the bottom were the bottom plate will go?

Table saw with blade tilted?
or on a belt sander.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 05:41:31 PM
While we're talking about building reed blocks, there's one step in their manufacture that I'm stumped by. After I glue the reed block chamber side pieces to the backing plate, and put on the top cap, how do I cut the block of chambers at an angle such that the top of the block is narrower than the bottom were the bottom plate will go?

Table saw with blade tilted?
or on a belt sander.

Theo, first off, do you cut the reed block with the top cap down on the the table or with the bottom of the block on the table?

I've been looking at the setup for using the Table saw on a block with the bottom of the block on the table and the blade tilted and it scares me to death. Reedblocks are so small that they would be completely buried between the blade and the fence.

Cutting one side of the block would allow the other side to sit flat against the fence, but cutting the second side is the real problem. Can't see how that's done, yet. Adjust the blade to twice the angle so the first side can sit flat against the fence? That would leave the bottom of the block riding on one corner. Hope this all makes sense. I should draw a picture of what I'm thinking.

Belt sander does make sense though I don't own one. Hmm, that's getting me thinking about a set up for my plunge router that might just work.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: nfldbox on June 09, 2011, 05:50:25 PM
I will NEVER build an accordion but as a novice repairer I am so enjoying this thread. It is making me think about the boxes in a totally different way.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Theo on June 09, 2011, 06:31:07 PM
Theo, first off, do you cut the reed block with the top cap down on the the table or with the bottom of the block on the table?

I've not done this bit yet!  I suppose it depends a bit on the size and quality of your table saw.  Sander would be a slower but safer option.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 06:40:43 PM
So - regarding the reeds:  If I want to get a set of Binci professional reeds, how does one go about the business of getting them?  And do they need to be ordered with special reed numbers to indicate notes (I seem to remember that was the way they could be definitely identified with notes when I worked for The Music Room).

Are there any other suppliers out there who one can deal with personally to get reeds?  I liked the look of the Czech website Harmonikas (http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm) being talked about on the other thread.  But I have no experience of the quality of Czech tipo a mano reeds.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Lester on June 09, 2011, 06:51:49 PM
So - regarding the reeds:  If I want to get a set of Binci professional reeds, how does one go about the business of getting them?  And do they need to be ordered with special reed numbers to indicate notes (I seem to remember that was the way they could be definitely identified with notes when I worked for The Music Room).

Are there any other suppliers out there who one can deal with personally to get reeds?  I liked the look of the Czech website Harmonikas (http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm) being talked about on the other thread.  But I have no experience of the quality of Czech tipo a mano reeds.

Cheers

Squeezy

Attached is the reed order forms for my 2.6 row that I am making at Emanuel's course next month. Should be how to order reeds. They do use reed numbers and Tonic SolFa names. You should be able to work out the numbering system from the forms.

Hope this helps
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 06:55:57 PM
So - regarding the reeds:  If I want to get a set of Binci professional reeds, how does one go about the business of getting them?  And do they need to be ordered with special reed numbers to indicate notes (I seem to remember that was the way they could be definitely identified with notes when I worked for The Music Room).

Are there any other suppliers out there who one can deal with personally to get reeds?  I liked the look of the Czech website Harmonikas (http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm) being talked about on the other thread.  But I have no experience of the quality of Czech tipo a mano reeds.

Cheers

Squeezy

You can also order reeds from Michael at Irish Dance Master (http://www.irishdancemaster.com/reeds.html). He's very helpful.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 09, 2011, 07:40:08 PM
 how do I cut the block of chambers at an angle such that the top of the block is narrower than the bottom were the bottom plate will go?

I tilt my blade 2 or 3 degrees, and I have a jig that holds the block straight up, this tapers toward the top of the block.  The jig also holds the block out at a slight angle so the block is tapered from low reed chamber to high reed chamber.  On my jig I can use shims to adjust the low to high taper.  For standing blocks, I taper before gluing to the divider, which is essentially a wedge to keep the 2 outside lines of the opposing reed blocks parrallel.

Here is a link that shows a pic of my jig.  In the pic I am cutting a lay down block, but I use the same jig to cut standing blocks.  The screws sticking out the top are makeshift handles.  This was a temporary thrown together test jig that I've meant to clean up and add to, just never have.  http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/buildproc/2-2%20cutting%20reed%20block%20angles.JPG 
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 08:15:45 PM
Attached is the reed order forms for my 2.6 row that I am making at Emanuel's course next month. Should be how to order reeds. They do use reed numbers and Tonic SolFa names. You should be able to work out the numbering system from the forms.

Hope this helps

Thanks for that Lester, really helpful indeed and reminded me of the reed numbering system, yes with A440 as number 24.  There is as page on the Harmonikas.cz website that has a great diagram of all the reeds they supply with reed numbers in pale green (http://www.harmonikas.cz/prilohy/Sortiment%20hlas%C5%AF.pdf).  

Good luck with the course!  I'm sure that probably is the right way to learn.

Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 08:18:02 PM
Here is a link that shows a pic of my jig.  In the pic I am cutting a lay down block, but I use the same jig to cut standing blocks.  The screws sticking out the top are makeshift handles.  This was a temporary thrown together test jig that I've meant to clean up and add to, just never have.  http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/buildproc/2-2%20cutting%20reed%20block%20angles.JPG 

Hi bafleur - thank you too.

The pictures on your website are all very illuminating and your boxes look lovely.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 09, 2011, 08:20:26 PM
Of course if you don't fancy the table saw and have huge amounts of money to waste then there is always this: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5643.0.html
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 08:39:44 PM
Thanks Ukebert!  I don't think I'll be getting the Jointmaker Pro first up!  Looks pretty impressive though!
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 09, 2011, 08:49:41 PM
It does, up until the point at which you notice the price! :P
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 08:55:55 PM
Does anyone have any opinions on the best way to go about building the box? (which is, when you look at the complexity of the keyboard and reed blocks, just a box!)

There are many differences I have seen on instruments in this respect.  For example, the Oakwood I sold had walls only 5mm thick but they were significantly braced inside on the corners, whereas the Eric Martin has walls 10mm thick (essential I think for the way it is attached to the bellows with a screw rather than bellows pins) - yet one doesn't feel that significantly heavier than the other.

Also would any of you ever consider approaching the Bellows frame by making them out of the same pieces of wood, i.e build the box and then saw a centimetre of it or so off for a bellows frame of exactly matching dimensions, or is that silly/impractical?

Cheers,

Squeezy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Keithypete. on June 09, 2011, 09:14:14 PM
Of course if you don't fancy the table saw and have huge amounts of money to waste then there is always this: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5643.0.html


  I do a bit of shuttering work now & then so I have a skill saw. A cheap chinese skill saw. By mounting it onto a piece of 9 mm ply I have converted it into a table saw. It is still fully adjustable and along with a cheap chinese router many things are possible.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 10:01:56 PM
Does anyone have any opinions on the best way to go about building the box? (which is, when you look at the complexity of the keyboard and reed blocks, just a box!)

There are many differences I have seen on instruments in this respect.  For example, the Oakwood I sold had walls only 5mm thick but they were significantly braced inside on the corners, whereas the Eric Martin has walls 10mm thick (essential I think for the way it is attached to the bellows with a screw rather than bellows pins) - yet one doesn't feel that significantly heavier than the other.

Squeezy,

My own process has been to do lots of drawings with my very limited CAD program. It's only for 2D drawing but it allows me to create reuseable objects that can be moved around, duplicated for designs I like, and so forth. I start with exact measurements of the reed plates themselves, draw them, then start putting together different designs based on my current ideas of what I want to do with the instrument.

Here are some thoughts to consider:
Do you want the instrument to be extremely small, similar to a Preciosa? You'll want to make the treble side reed blocks in a similar fashion, mounted flat, directly to the sound board. Ukebert has information from another maker about issues to do with volume discrepancies between the upper set of flat mounted reed blocks and the lower reed blocks when the reed plates are not specifically for a Preciosa. Be aware that the Preciosa reed plates are about 14mm, Hohner T reed plates are 16mm and some Italian reed plates are 17mm.

With standing reed blocks you need to figure out whether you want the blocks to stick up into the space between the bellows folds, creating a much wider box, or do you want to fit the top of the blocks entirely within the treble case and under the bellows.

I'm starting with the reed plates, reed blocks and treble side, allowing those measurements to dictate the inside and outside dimensions of the case on the treble side, then duplicating those dimensions for the bass side and seeing what I end up with for space between the bellows folds. The bass reed blocks can sometimes dictate a slightly larger instrument because they do need to stick up inside the bellows.

There are many options for reed block arrangements, each one a compromise on size, weight, complexity, especially in the keyboard complexity.

Given a 21 button box, you could arrange the reeds in the two standard reed blocks, 11 reeds in one, 10 reeds in the other, corresponding to the two keys of the instrument. Or, you can split the reeds amongst three blocks, creating a smaller instrument at the expense of making the keyboard mechanism more complicated. Doable, at least on paper. I've been playing with just such a design myself. It is possible to arrange the reeds and reed blocks into a box so small that the buttons and keyboard size become a limiting factor in overall size.

If you're going for a LMM, then you'll probably want to go with three blocks with the middle block for the L reeds, pretty standard design. And you can add registers. Both treble and/or bass.

Then there's designs with extra buttons, like the Preciosa and others, that have extra accidentals on the third row. Adding more accidentals makes the instrument wider.

Wall thickness is another decision. Do you want plywood with bracing or solid wood. I've been a musical instrument maker in a past life and prefer solid wood so my instrument will have solid wood. That said, I'm making sure to pay strict attention to grain orientation in the wood in order to allow me to use thinner pieces of wood. I'm hoping to keep the final thickness of the case wood to 5 - 6 mm, not unreasonable, I hope.

All of this is probably very obvious to some, but for me, I need to know what each of these options looks like, how big a box will probably result, in order to make decisions about what I want. Only after doing the design work can I make a decision and then start  cutting wood. I'm still ending up with lots of unuseable pieces because the building process then starts to inform the design process, i.e. do this process before that process, etc. I've been through three or four different types of jigs to build the reedblocks alone.

Hope some of this helps with your building process.

Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 09, 2011, 10:08:48 PM
Also would any of you ever consider approaching the Bellows frame by making them out of the same pieces of wood, i.e build the box and then saw a centimetre of it or so off for a bellows frame of exactly matching dimensions, or is that silly/impractical?
No - that's not silly or impractical, but exactly how we made them on Emmanuel's melodeon-making course. Each combined end/bellows frame was made separately, and eventually the bellows frame and end were sawn through to separate them.

Paul Johnson (occasionally posts on here) took a good series of photos during the course to show progress. You can see them here:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/boxplayer/sets/72157608254841685/with/2961563523/

This one shows one of the ends partially cut through to eventually form the bellows frame and the end proper.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/boxplayer/2961566089/in/set-72157608254841685/
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 09, 2011, 10:15:20 PM
Also would any of you ever consider approaching the Bellows frame by making them out of the same pieces of wood, i.e build the box and then saw a centimetre of it or so off for a bellows frame of exactly matching dimensions, or is that silly/impractical?

If I'm understanding you correctly, that's what I've done on my last 3 or 4, one being a pinned frame.  I make the box out of wide enough pieces that I cut the frame in half for my standard accordion, and for the pinned one, a smaller piece to attach to the bellows. I like doing that because with figured wood the grain matches.  Also no worry about misaligning the adjoining frames.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 10:29:40 PM
 how do I cut the block of chambers at an angle such that the top of the block is narrower than the bottom were the bottom plate will go?

I tilt my blade 2 or 3 degrees, and I have a jig that holds the block straight up, this tapers toward the top of the block.  The jig also holds the block out at a slight angle so the block is tapered from low reed chamber to high reed chamber.  On my jig I can use shims to adjust the low to high taper.  For standing blocks, I taper before gluing to the divider, which is essentially a wedge to keep the 2 outside lines of the opposing reed blocks parrallel.

Here is a link that shows a pic of my jig.  In the pic I am cutting a lay down block, but I use the same jig to cut standing blocks.  The screws sticking out the top are makeshift handles.  This was a temporary thrown together test jig that I've meant to clean up and add to, just never have.  http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/buildproc/2-2%20cutting%20reed%20block%20angles.JPG 

Blafleur,

Thanks very much for posting the pic. I'm going to make one for myself soon. Interesting that you taper the divider to offset the outside taper. I like that. How do you make the tapered divider? My guess would be some sort of holding form with a taper that holds the divider while it goes through a thicknesser.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 10:36:27 PM
Does anyone have any opinions on the best way to go about building the box? (which is, when you look at the complexity of the keyboard and reed blocks, just a box!)

There are many differences I have seen on instruments in this respect.  For example, the Oakwood I sold had walls only 5mm thick but they were significantly braced inside on the corners, whereas the Eric Martin has walls 10mm thick (essential I think for the way it is attached to the bellows with a screw rather than bellows pins) - yet one doesn't feel that significantly heavier than the other.

Also would any of you ever consider approaching the Bellows frame by making them out of the same pieces of wood, i.e build the box and then saw a centimetre of it or so off for a bellows frame of exactly matching dimensions, or is that silly/impractical?

Cheers,

Squeezy

My current design is going to use 5-6mm thick solid wood pieces for the case. I'm going to miter the corners to do the initial glue up with a slot for the soundboard in each piece so the soundboard is glued in. Then I'll glue triangular pieces into all the inside corners for strength. After they dry, I'll cut the outside corners of the box and glue in contrasting pieces of wood to strengthen the outside corners. Those pieces will then be rounded over, probably using a router bit.

Your idea for bellows frames makes a great deal of sense to me. Will you glue a wider piece onto the bellows side, a frame of sorts, to provide more surface area for the card stock to glue to?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 10:38:55 PM
Thanks everyone for the last few posts which are very good advice.

I knew I could count on people here!

For the record - I'm not going for a record breaking small box like the Preciosa, but one with a small enough bellows cross section to give a good kick to the reeds / but not so small that it overblows them.  I'm going for a 3 voice instrument with a LMM configuration.  If there is room I will see if I can get 12 basses in - otherwise it's just the standard 8.  I will be trying to keep in mind coupler/stop systems for the low voice on the right hand and the thirds on the chords.

That has little bearing on the advice here though.  I'm not looking for specifics, just general things to consider in the design process.  I'm particularly grateful for the advice on grain direction of the wood used which I just would have never thought about.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 09, 2011, 10:45:37 PM
Thanks everyone for the last few posts which are very good advice.

I knew I could count on people here!

For the record - I'm not going for a record breaking small box like the Preciosa, but one with a small enough bellows cross section to give a good kick to the reeds / but not so small that it overblows them.  I'm going for a 3 voice instrument with a LMM configuration.  If there is room I will see if I can get 12 basses in - otherwise it's just the standard 8.  I will be trying to keep in mind coupler/stop systems for the low voice on the right hand and the thirds on the chords.

That has little bearing on the advice here though.  I'm not looking for specifics, just general things to consider in the design process.  I'm particularly grateful for the advice on grain direction of the wood used which I just would have never thought about.

Cheers

Squeezy

Don't forget that chord blocks can be set up with thirds, or leave them out entirely making for a smaller block that comes to about the same size as the block with the fundamentals. But that's the dilemma, to have thirds or not. Without thirds, you don't need to create a register either making for less complexity in the construction.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 09, 2011, 11:08:08 PM
Don't forget that chord blocks can be set up with thirds, or leave them out entirely making for a smaller block that comes to about the same size as the block with the fundamentals. But that's the dilemma, to have thirds or not. Without thirds, you don't need to create a register either making for less complexity in the construction.

Well - having owned boxes with both configurations I'm firmly of the mind that a real melodeon has got thirds.  For me the thin sound of a thirdless box is a bit feeble for proper dance accompaniment, but sometimes it is essential because of the harmony you are trying to make.  Because of this - I am working on a sprung coupler mechanism which can be worked with the thumb under the air button like a shift key that can take the thirds out while playing - this will also have a lock function that can take the thirds out all the time if wanted.  Only at the development stage at the moment - but it seems eminently doable.

Obviously that's only my opinion - and yes I take on board that an entirely thirdless box is desirable from many construction angles.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 10, 2011, 12:05:47 AM
Your idea for bellows frames makes a great deal of sense to me. Will you glue a wider piece onto the bellows side, a frame of sorts, to provide more surface area for the card stock to glue to?

I do beef up the gluing surface to the bellows on all of them.  Been experimenting on doing it with keeping added weight to a minimum.  This was my first pinned bellows and I didn't have one to go by, so kinda winging it, but here is an in process pic. http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/jamey.jpg  The corners aren't rounded or contrasting, at customer's request.  If you look close you can see the line where the bellows frame is cut.  The lightning bolt base box holes are customer's request also.

I did the contrasting corner thing on the last 3.  I used hide glue because it makes such a tight joint without clamping.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 10, 2011, 12:18:04 AM
Blafleur,

Beautiful! What did you use for a finish? I like the color on the curly maple very much.

How thick are the pieces of wood you're using  for the case, or are you using solid wood?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 10, 2011, 02:54:20 AM
i AM going to make a box - a two-row small 3 voice! 

PS - I fully intend to ruin large amounts of wood, swear a lot, give up a couple of times and spend lots of money on equipment it turns out I don't need on this project.

Ha ha , that's the spirit.

Blafleur,
Beautiful! What did you use for a finish? I like the color on the curly maple very much.
How thick are the pieces of wood you're using  for the case, or are you using solid wood?

Aniline dyes and lacquer. Can't remember the thickness, probably too thick.  I'd be curious if there is a standard accepted thickness for frames on pinned style.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on June 10, 2011, 02:43:18 PM
I fully intend to ruin large amounts of wood, swear a lot, give up a couple of times and spend lots of money on equipment it turns out I don't need on this project.

Squeezy,
This has been a great thread!
I've been planning to build a box and have actually spent years honing my skills for the various parts -- this does not have to take as long as I've spent but in my defense I'm doing everything with hand tools, and it has been a pleasure to build various useful objects and pieces of furniture in the process.
One thing you might consider is to make several boxes -- yes, actual boxes (not accordions) -- that incorporate aspects of the design or process.
This relates to the discussion above concerning using the same wood for the bellows frame etc.  I'm experimenting with making a single box, with a faceplate glued into a groove at each end-- i.e. a completely sealed box.  Before glueing, I cut grooves on the inside of the four sides.  After glue up, grooves are cut on the outside of the sides, offset from the inside grooves by exactly the width of the groove.  When the outside grooves are cut to their full depth (I'm using a plough plane -- a Record 044), the box pops apart, and what is left is a series of interlocking components. 
It all sounds much more complicated than it is, and it would be even easier with machines than with the tools I'm using.  Next time I make one, I'll try to remember to take pictures to document the process.
Cheers,
Andy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Peter_T on June 10, 2011, 03:22:26 PM
Could 3d printing have a part to play?

Print me a Stradivarius (http://www.economist.com/node/18114327)
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Aunty Social on June 10, 2011, 04:02:08 PM
If anyone has ideas for construction and some starting dimensions to go on I may be able to help. I own and use a 3D CAD system that makes visualising ideas so much easier by modeling all the parts and assembling them on the pc. Easy to make changes before committing to sawing! The beauty is that you also create accurate drawings of all the pieces you need to cut. Might be worthwhile PMing a fag packet sketch my way....Be an interesting project to get involved in.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Graham W on June 10, 2011, 04:36:10 PM
If anyone has ideas for construction and some starting dimensions to go on I may be able to help. I own and use a 3D CAD system that makes visualising ideas so much easier by modeling all the parts and assembling them on the pc. Easy to make changes before committing to sawing! The beauty is that you also create accurate drawings of all the pieces you need to cut. Might be worthwhile PMing a fag packet sketch my way....Be an interesting project to get involved in.

Ahh  ;D   I too am making a box (loosely, at the current rate it will be years before it appears in the wood).  I plan to make my own mechanism, which will involve cutting all the levers out of alloy sheet - for which a CAD drawing for water jet cutting (or some other kind of CNC cutting) would be a huge help.  I might be some time though . . . . .
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Aunty Social on June 10, 2011, 05:54:30 PM
That's a straightforward process. There's a fantastic company local to me that specialise in laser cutting. I produce the pattern in a format that plugs straight into the laser machine and Bob's your uncle!
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 10, 2011, 06:02:24 PM
One more thought about using wood. It's very important to pay attention to the humidity level in the room where you're doing your gluing up, especially if you are gluing braces or other pieces that cross the grain of, say, a soundboard. Guitar tops have cross braces that limit the expansion and contraction of the top. If you glue the cross braces on during a spell of high humidity, you run the risk of inducing cracks in the top when the instrument moves to an area of low humidity. Likewise, if you glue the braces on during a period of low humidity and the instrument later moves into a climate of high humidity, the cross braced wood can buckle and warp until the instrument dries out. Finishes don't make much of a difference to this expansion and contraction of wood because the inside of the instrument is never varnished, or only rarely.

You'll want to do your glue up when the humidity is between 50% and 55%. Another way to figure out what humidity you should aim for is to look at the weather data for all the places you're going to play. Find out the highest and the lowest humidity that the instrument will likely encounter and glue up at a percentage half way between the two extremes.

When I studied as a luthier, we constructed a box out of plywood with a heat lamp tied to a light dimmer switch and located in the bottom of the box. We adjusted the humidity either with heat to dry out or by hanging damp rags in the box to increase moisture. The soundboard wood was stored in the box for at least a day before glueing up cross braces to allow the wood to come to equilibrium with the ambient humidity in the box.

That said, I doubt whether you need to pay much attention to humidity when gluing up your reedblocks because there is little cross grain contact. Only the back plate or divider between two rows of chambers would give you any potential problems.

Using hide glue for musical instruments is highly recommended. The stuff just doesn't give up its grip on the wood, no creap, easy clean up even long after the glue has dried, and mistakes are usually very easy to take apart. While I've been using PVA wood glue, I've decided to go back to my hide glue because it's so reliable. And no real need for a special pot for the glue. I use an old slow cooker/"crock pot" with the power run through a light dimmer switch to adjust the temperature. The glue sits in an old coffee or tea mug and the mug sits in a water bath. Easy. You can pick up an old slow cooker for a dollar or two at a garage sale here in the US.

Telemorris
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 10, 2011, 09:07:43 PM
Interesting that you taper the divider to offset the outside taper. I like that. How do you make the tapered divider? My guess would be some sort of holding form with a taper that holds the divider while it goes through a thicknesser.

Several ways you could do it, that's one.  I've used that same jig I showed earlier, but lately I've used my band saw.  I try to use a thick enough piece that after I split it I have at least 2 usable wedges.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: rees on June 10, 2011, 09:19:34 PM
each end-- i.e. a completely sealed box.  Before glueing, I cut grooves on the inside of the four sides.  After glue up, grooves are cut on the outside of the sides, offset from the inside grooves by exactly the width of the groove.  When the outside grooves are cut to their full depth (I'm using a plough plane -- a Record 044), the box pops apart, and what is left is a series of interlocking components. 
It all sounds much more complicated than it is, and it would be even easier with machines than with the tools I'm using.  Next time I make one, I'll try to remember to take pictures to document the process.
Cheers,
Andy

I thought this was the answer until I realised that a saw blade's width would be too weak for a bellows pin. Nice idea, though.  (:)
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 10, 2011, 09:45:09 PM

I thought this was the answer until I realised that a saw blade's width would be too weak for a bellows pin. Nice idea, though.  (:)

A saw blade width would be too small. However, I've done the same type of slot design using an 18mm router bit with success. 18mm for each side of the "tongue" should be enough to hold a pin. The issue for me with this design is how thick the wood in the case should be in the first place since both sides of the interlocking "tongues" are only half the thickness of the original piece of wood.

What is the minimum thickness for the portion of a bellows frame that is pierced by a pin?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: rees on June 10, 2011, 10:51:42 PM
I reckon at least 10mm.
Perhaps glue a strip around the inside of the frame to thicken it up before cutting?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 11, 2011, 09:06:10 PM
Not sure that I can picture exactly what Andy is describing, but if I am, I don't think he was saying it was a sawblade width, but a plow blade width, however thick that is.

Here is what I did on my first and only pinned build.  Haven't put the pins or bellows on yet, but the frame has a good fit.  The triangular corner pieces were put in before I cut the frame, which allowed me to put it back together after cutting exactly as it was minus a narrow kerf saw blade width.  I then installed the inset strips using hide glue rubbed on so I didn't have to clamp, it made a tight and smooth fit.  I beefed up where the pins go, which may be overkill.  Sticks, stones, and other criticisms welcome.  Pics below, with links to see pics better. 

[img width= height=]http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/image1.jpg[/img]

[img width= height=]http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/image2.jpg[/img]

http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/image1.jpg
http://www.lansegriseaccordions.com/image2.jpg
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on June 12, 2011, 05:14:02 AM
Not sure that I can picture exactly what Andy is describing, but if I am, I don't think he was saying it was a sawblade width, but a plow blade width, however thick that is.

Yes, I'm using a plough plane (Record 044) with the widest blade -- I don't recall the mm size but I'll check next time I'm in the shop. If you have only a thinner blade you make a wider grooves by ploughing the (thin) grooves, then adjusting the fences and ploughing a second groove.

People that do the same method with a table saw use a dado stack, I believe.  You can get plenty of overlap for bellows pins!
-Andy
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 13, 2011, 12:25:39 PM
Blimey!

That's quite a lot to digest over the weekend.  But thank you everyone who has written in on this thread.  I really do have a lot to be thinking about - but it doesn't seem as daunting as I thought even with as much detail as has been given here  ;D

I'm going to order a set of reeds and take it from there.

Cheers

Squeezy

PS - if there's something else no-one has thought of ...
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Lester on June 13, 2011, 12:34:17 PM
PS - if there's something else no-one has thought of ...

Almost certainly.  ;D
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: rees on June 13, 2011, 01:41:26 PM
Here's a tip I got from Eric Martin.
Don't build the frame until you have the bellows. Bellows often arrive a few mm bigger or smaller than you ordered, so it's best to build the frame to fit the actual bellows.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: squeezy on June 13, 2011, 01:52:38 PM
That's a good one Rees.  I keep liking Eric more and more!

I've encountered that problem before, when ordering replacement bellows for my instruments.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 13, 2011, 02:39:55 PM
Don't build the frame until you have the bellows. 

I learned this also,  I don't cut frames or reed blocks to size until I have reeds and bellows.  Getting the same type reed each time should be consistent, but I don't trust it.  On bellows, I've also seen at least one out of square.

Squeezy, not only is there a lot left to bring up, you'll have questions you or us havent thought up once you get into it.  I've run into some issue on each of my builds that I didn't on the others, and you probably will too.  I guess there is a point that this will taper off, but I apparently haven't gotten there yet.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: emrock on June 13, 2011, 04:40:48 PM
I've built 2 boxes and am planning on starting number 3 soon. The first one I built is more of a display piece than a playable instrument, as I made lots of mistakes. The second has some flaws but is almost there. I learnt lots from my mistakes, and the best piece of advice I can give is to spend as much time as possible designing and planning your box as possible. There by working out any problems on paper and not wood, this will save you a lot of wasted effort. Another thing that has helped me is to try and work out things for myself and not simply copy an existing box. In doing this I have developed several new ways of making various parts of a box that I am not aware have been done before and are a lot easier for me to make.

Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 13, 2011, 05:01:37 PM
.... Another thing that has helped me is to try and work out things for myself and not simply copy an existing box. In doing this I have developed several new ways of making various parts of a box that I am not aware have been done before and are a lot easier for me to make.

I too have been designing jigs that have helped me speed things up when cutting or gluing up some parts of my instrument. Emrock, I'm very interested in the jigs or techniques you've come up with for building various parts, especially reedblocks and keyboards. Photos would be most helpful too. I'll try to post some of the tricks and jigs I've developed as well.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: TomB-R on June 15, 2011, 01:44:27 PM
Lots of good info already. There really is no need for expensive tools or a workshop. It could be more of a kitchen table, hand tools only, project than most instruments if you start with the right materials.

I found
http://www.modelshop.co.uk/
quite useful for my build.  Always good to get as much as possible from one supplier, otherwise the P&Ps mount up.

Don't be too alarmed by the idea of bellows making, it's doable and needn't take that long. When people see the finished article and you say you made it, they'll be asking about/looking at the bellows, [edit; amongst other things, of course,] !

I agree about the Bergflodt site being very inspiring/daunting! (And scary, those ungauarded table saws!)

Good luck to all,
Tom


Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: blafleur on June 15, 2011, 03:14:44 PM
Bergflodt's site was very inspirational to me also...what a craftsman.  My problem with his site is it made me really, really, want something I cannot have, a laser engraver.
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Telemorris on June 15, 2011, 04:55:03 PM
Blafleur,

Thank you very much for posting the photo of your reed block cutting jig. I made one last night and was able to safely cut the angled face in all of my reed blocks. The jig held onto the reedblock firmly and worked like a charm! The next set of blocks will also have a wedge shaped divider since the setup is so easy with this jig.

Thanks for the information!
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 19, 2011, 03:58:24 AM
So, to see if I've got this right...

1) Order reeds
2) Decide how reeds will be mounted, design blocks, build, test.
3) Based on the dimensions of the blocks, specify bellows size, order bellows (or make if you prefer).
4) Based on actual bellows, construct frames and casing, fit soundboard and blocks.
5) Finishing (I predict that as with so many other projects, "finishing" will take a lot longer than one would think...)

Sound reasonable?
Title: Re: Going to make a box - what should I know?
Post by: juggler on August 21, 2012, 03:57:58 PM
Bergflodt's site was very inspirational to me also...what a craftsman.  My problem with his site is it made me really, really, want something I cannot have, a laser engraver.

If anyone really really wants to have some parts laser cut then get in touch. They are fabulous machines, but do have their limitations.

Squeezy - you have done me favours in the past, time for me to repay!

Ben
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal