Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: forrest on August 29, 2011, 10:17:42 PM
-
Just wondering if someone can clarify for me the intended use of the small metal strap that is sometimes seen nowadays between adjacent reedblocks in the newer melodeons.....are they there to prevent the reedblocks from physically jarring loose from impacts or handling, or are they installed to mitigate some sort of acoustic overtone or harmonic, etc..... ???
-
If it's the same sort of thing I have in my Scarlatina, it seems to be to ensure that the reed blocks remain at the right distance apart and opposite the correct holes. Over to the experts - Mr Ellis? Theo?
-
If it's the same sort of thing I have in my Scarlatina, it seems to be to ensure that the reed blocks remain at the right distance apart and opposite the correct holes. Over to the experts - Mr Ellis? Theo?
Not quite, there should be locating blocks on all sides of the reedblocks that ensure they sit in the correct position with the holes lined up.
The purpose of the metal strap is to prevent a resonance effect that can result in the tremolo not working properly. This does not affect every box, and it usually only affects one note, but when it does happen it can be quite horrible. If you are tuning, then the usual symptoms are that the reeds play perfectly on the tuning bench, but once inside the instrument the affected note just sounds bleurgghh, I can't think of a better description. Fit a strap and hey presto, the problem vanishes.
-
If you are tuning, then the usual symptoms are that the reeds play perfectly on the tuning bench, but once inside the instrument the affected note just sounds bleurgghh, I can't think of a better description. Fit a strap and hey presto, the problem vanishes.
As I've always understood it, the vibrations at the base of one reed are transmitted via the block to the other reed and are trying to pull it into sync, making an irregular warble instead of the smooth beat between the two reeds. I suppose the block is usually too stiff to transmit much vibration, but has a resonant frequency where it can do so.
Strapping the blocks together changes the resonant frequency and adds some damping, at minimum extra cost and weight.
-
There we go, theory and practice in unison!
-
I can testify to the effectiveness of the reed-block strap. A few weeks ago, on the advice of Theo, I made and fitted a narrow brass strip connecting the top of the three reed blocks of a three-voice instrument which I was putting into 'Dedic' tuning with a very light tremolo.
Although I was tuning with the reed-blocks in situ and the tremolo seemed OK on the bench, as soon as the instrument was completely reassembled, on certain notes the light tremolo disappeared, as the adjacent reeds concerned 'pulled' each other into a unison. Fitting the brass strap not only instantly cured this problem but even better, it evened out the whole tone quality of the instrument, making a brighter and more consistent sound over the whole range. I was amazed by just how much improvement such a simple modification made. Definitely to be recommended!
Thanks again for the advice, Theo!
Edit:
I guess the science behind this is that the sound generation of the free-reed set-up is caused by the reed tongue 'chopping' the airstream into packets. The more rigid the reed-block structure, then the more energy will be transfered to the moving airstream. In a poorly supported, 'sloppy' reed-block structure, some of the energy from the reed tongue will be wasted as it goes into making the reed block vibrate, leaving less energy available to be transfered to the airstream. So ideally the reed-block assembly needs to be as rigid as possible. I wonder how it would perform if the whole set of reed-blocks were to be cast/machined/3D-printed out of a single starting piece with supporting struts at each end and in the middle?
-
The old Hohners I've worked on had, for want of a better description, headless panel pins wedged between the blocks. I presume they do the same job as a strip screwed down across the top of the blocks?
Placement and number of these pins seems to vary quite a bit, I've seen up to three between a pair of blocks (and as few as none!) and the spacing between them is uneven. Would they have be placed next to the affected reed plates? Whenever I've removed any of these I've always put pencil marks on the blocks to ensure they go back in the same place.
-
The old Hohners I've worked on had, for want of a better description, headless panel pins wedged between the blocks. I presume they do the same job as a strip screwed down across the top of the blocks?
Placement and number of these pins seems to vary quite a bit, I've seen up to three between a pair of blocks (and as few as none!) and the spacing between them is uneven. Would they have be placed next to the affected reed plates? Whenever I've removed any of these I've always put pencil marks on the blocks to ensure they go back in the same place.
I'm sure these do the same job. The ones I've seen are just short lenths of thin steel rod. I believe that only one of these is needed in each gap between blocks, and I don't think the exact position is important, except that its is usually low reeds that are affected by the warble so it seems sensible to place the rods or straps nearer to the low notes than the high notes.
-
Edit:
I guess the science behind this is that the sound generation of the free-reed set-up is caused by the reed tongue 'chopping' the airstream into packets. The more rigid the reed-block structure, then the more energy will be transfered to the moving airstream. In a poorly supported, 'sloppy' reed-block structure, some of the energy from the reed tongue will be wasted as it goes into making the reed block vibrate, leaving less energy available to be transfered to the airstream. So ideally the reed-block assembly needs to be as rigid as possible. I wonder how it would perform if the whole set of reed-blocks were to be cast/machined/3D-printed out of a single starting piece with supporting struts at each end and in the middle?
True, although remember that the sound of a pure siren tone is not necessarily pleasant... a lot of the timbre does come from the body. Whether that is absorption or resonance of course I have no idea, but I think that it's a mistake to assume that an utterly rigid, utterly reflective casing is the perfect solution.
Interesting theory about the reedblocks Anahata, makes a lot of sense (:)
-
These posts are what I have been seeking (:) Reminds me very much of a device marketed for guitar called the JLD Bridge Doctor (http://www.jldguitar.net/warped_tops/fixtop.html), which has a two-fold purpose. One is to help correct the 'belly' that happens on a flat top guitar, and secondly, it profoundly improves the sound of the guitar as well by transmitting audio vibrations to the outer periphery (sides and back). Having installed these in a couple of guitars, I must say that I was astonished at the clarity and brilliance that this device brought forth. It seems to operate in a similar fashion to the soundpost of a violin.
I'm going to try some strap experiments in a couple of my boxes to see what may come of it. I'm hoping that this might be a way to add clarity to the reeds.
-
Edit:
I guess the science behind this is that the sound generation of the free-reed set-up is caused by the reed tongue 'chopping' the airstream into packets. The more rigid the reed-block structure, then the more energy will be transfered to the moving airstream. In a poorly supported, 'sloppy' reed-block structure, some of the energy from the reed tongue will be wasted as it goes into making the reed block vibrate, leaving less energy available to be transfered to the airstream. So ideally the reed-block assembly needs to be as rigid as possible. I wonder how it would perform if the whole set of reed-blocks were to be cast/machined/3D-printed out of a single starting piece with supporting struts at each end and in the middle?
True, although remember that the sound of a pure siren tone is not necessarily pleasant... a lot of the timbre does come from the body. Whether that is absorption or resonance of course I have no idea, but I think that it's a mistake to assume that an utterly rigid, utterly reflective casing is the perfect solution.
Interesting theory about the reedblocks Anahata, makes a lot of sense (:)
All the real quantitative work that has been done suggests that more rigidity and reflectivity is best for free-reed instruments, the last thing you want is resonances absorbing energy from or coupling with the reed (which is exactly the problem that the strap solves).
Normally the reed blocks are only clamped to the case at the ends, and the reed which have the "warble" problem usually seem to be towards the middle of the block where it's least rigid, so my suspicion is that the problem is a torsional resonance along the reed block (which one of the notes is almost bound to hit) excited by the beating between the two reeds on opposite sides of the block. This will also be made worse because the reeds are mounted "tips-up", so the forces are generated at the top of the block where the main reed movement is -- if so, "tip-down" mounting would help but may cause other problems.
So anything that braces or damps the middle of the block against twisting will probably fix the problem -- the "best" solution would probably be a strap that not only linked the blocks but continues downwards to the strong point in the corner where the soundboard meets the case.
-
Normally the reed blocks are only clamped to the case at the ends, and the reed which have the "warble" problem usually seem to be towards the middle of the block where it's least rigid, so my suspicion is that the problem is a torsional resonance along the reed block (which one of the notes is almost bound to hit) excited by the beating between the two reeds on opposite sides of the block.
.
.
So anything that braces or damps the middle of the block against twisting will probably fix the problem -- the "best" solution would probably be a strap that not only linked the blocks but continues downwards to the strong point in the corner where the soundboard meets the case.
Ian - I'm sure you are right. I think this is confirmed by the traditional one-row Cajun-type construction, which do not seem to suffer from the resonance problem, at least not to anywhere near the same degree, to my knowledge. Here, the vertically standing reed block (which carries two of the banks of reeds) is glued along its entirely length directly to the soundboard, so there is much less scope for torsional movement. The other two reed blocks are mounted horizontally and similarly glued directly to the soundboard. Cajun boxes are also generally renowned for their powerful sound, again probably testament to this method of construction as much as anything else.
-
Well, I did it. After reading the comments posted, I was compelled to try out some straps and find the results.
My problem child: old Hohner 3-row.....basses overpowering the treble, lots of trebl-y overtones from the basses, almost 'raspy' sounding. On the treble side, notes a bit timid, chords 'mushy', indistinct. I had attributed this to the fact that the reedplates were secured by screws on leather gaskets, rather that waxed directly to the block.
After installation: basses and left hand chords much more compact and distinct. Treble notes and chords much more distinct. Improved balance between treble and bass. I am able to achieve similar volume with less effort, allowing me to play with a lighter touch. The best word to describe the change is that now the box is focused, where before it was blurred.
Used some stuff on hand for the job. The bass side was made from a piece of heavy gauge perforated steel tape about .035" thick. It was bent precisely to fit the blocks so that there was no strain imposed when screwing it down. The screws are about 1/4" long, and only partially penetrate the upper timber of the block. The treble strap is similar material, but only about .015" thick. Some pic's below. Excuse me now, because I have to go back and play some more. It's like having a new box (:)
Edit: Also a pronounced brightness in the treble reeds! Eureka!
-
It's also worth checking that the projection at the end of the block opposite the fixing screw is a good fit under the wooden bar that locates it. Take up any slack with paper or card shims. If the reedblocks are loose they will be able to move and vibrate, and will be liable to leak air from below.
-
Got me bit of metal bent to shape, put some holes on it (need to file off the burs). I need to discover/go out and hunt for some little screws though. None of the ones in my toolboxes are quite small enough. I'll have to wait a day or two to see what it does for my three voice box.
-
Good thread.
@JW Forrest: "It was bent precisely to fit the blocks so that there was no strain imposed when screwing it down."
You have it right there. This is crucial.
@you other guys: We seem to be in accord. I am fascinated by this phenomeneoemenem and have been experimenting with reed-blocks made from Rachel's Organic Yogurt.
-
I need to discover/go out and hunt for some little screws though. None of the ones in my toolboxes are quite small enough.
Yes....they are quite difficult to find these days. Slightly less scarce than hand-forged nails! Although CGM offers an assortment. If you find other sources, please post!
@you other guys: We seem to be in accord. I am fascinated by this phenomeneoemenem and have been experimenting with reed-blocks made from Rachel's Organic Yogurt.
How's that working out, Rees?
-
messy but very tasty
-
It's also worth checking that the projection at the end of the block opposite the fixing screw is a good fit under the wooden bar that locates it. Take up any slack with paper or card shims. If the reedblocks are loose they will be able to move and vibrate, and will be liable to leak air from below.
Good call, Theo....I have an old Supertone I am re-doing, and it has this condition. I was thinking of adding a bit of veneer to the top of the projection, and sanding down to a snug fit.
-
messy but very tasty
Does it wobble?
-
I am fascinated by this phenomeneoemenem
This is Welsh thing isn't it? Why use six letters when you can squeeze twenty seven in ...
and have been experimenting with reed-blocks made from Rachel's Organic Yogurt.
:o Oh, the stench!
-
Now that idea could be extended - the edible melodeon. So Rees is building the fermented milk based reedblocks, I'll offer turned hazlenut buttons and rice paper bellows. Any offers for the case?
-
Now I'd have thought that if you really must go down the dairy route then something like Parmesan would probably be more suitable for the reedblocks and probably holds screws better if you want to go with a wax-free design.
...I think I've got some Kendal mint cake that'd do nicely for the case....
-
Amendment - it was a good thread. :P
-
Peter Hyde uses foam, do you think a Victoria sponge would work?
-
I need to discover/go out and hunt for some little screws though. None of the ones in my toolboxes are quite small enough. I'll have to wait a day or two to see what it does for my three voice box.
Last time I needed tiny screws (for a bass lever on my 1-row) I found something just about small enough at a wind instrument repair shop in Cambridge. Mind you I hadn't heard of CGM then...
-
do you think a Victoria sponge would work?
The texture would be too open I think, screws would tend to pull out fairly quickly. Thinly sliced it might work as a grille cloth though.
-
Edit:
I guess the science behind this is that the sound generation of the free-reed set-up is caused by the reed tongue 'chopping' the airstream into packets. The more rigid the reed-block structure, then the more energy will be transfered to the moving airstream. In a poorly supported, 'sloppy' reed-block structure, some of the energy from the reed tongue will be wasted as it goes into making the reed block vibrate, leaving less energy available to be transfered to the airstream. So ideally the reed-block assembly needs to be as rigid as possible. I wonder how it would perform if the whole set of reed-blocks were to be cast/machined/3D-printed out of a single starting piece with supporting struts at each end and in the middle?
True, although remember that the sound of a pure siren tone is not necessarily pleasant... a lot of the timbre does come from the body. Whether that is absorption or resonance of course I have no idea, but I think that it's a mistake to assume that an utterly rigid, utterly reflective casing is the perfect solution.
Interesting theory about the reedblocks Anahata, makes a lot of sense (:)
All the real quantitative work that has been done suggests that more rigidity and reflectivity is best for free-reed instruments, the last thing you want is resonances absorbing energy from or coupling with the reed (which is exactly the problem that the strap solves).
Normally the reed blocks are only clamped to the case at the ends, and the reed which have the "warble" problem usually seem to be towards the middle of the block where it's least rigid, so my suspicion is that the problem is a torsional resonance along the reed block (which one of the notes is almost bound to hit) excited by the beating between the two reeds on opposite sides of the block. This will also be made worse because the reeds are mounted "tips-up", so the forces are generated at the top of the block where the main reed movement is -- if so, "tip-down" mounting would help but may cause other problems.
So anything that braces or damps the middle of the block against twisting will probably fix the problem -- the "best" solution would probably be a strap that not only linked the blocks but continues downwards to the strong point in the corner where the soundboard meets the case.
I appreciate that coupling modes would indeed be a problem and understand why this solves them. From this it is simple to deduce that a casing which can be treated as a single body, rather than many coupled bodies is an ideal. I am not sure about the reflective bit. By having a casing which has a particular absorption spectrum you are changing the timbre of the sound that is being produced, no? If you say that reflective is the best then that implies that the sound given by a reed on its own, or in a chamber is the ideal. I find the sound of reeds in blocks being excited rather harsh and find that the absorption of the casing makes a beneficial effect. I know that others have said things about grille cloths and absorption properties. Always ready to be proved wrong though.
-
I find the sound of reeds in blocks being excited rather harsh and find that the absorption of the casing makes a beneficial effect. I know that others have said things about grille cloths and absorption properties. Always ready to be proved wrong though.
I agree....naked reeds do sound pretty harsh. The sound of a particular box is merely the sum of all attributes; Shape, volume, cabinet materials, reed quality, block and chamber design,etc. I guess we're on a quest to find what conditions make them sound in an 'undesireable' manner. In this case, it is apparent to me that reeds need to 'hook up' with one another to produce a strong, unified, "in tune" sound. We know it when we hear it. We know what it sounds like if this is missing.
-
Quote from: Andrew Wigglesworth on Yesterday at 09:46:19 PM
I need to discover/go out and hunt for some little screws though. None of the ones in my toolboxes are quite small enough.
Yes....they are quite difficult to find these days. Slightly less scarce than hand-forged nails! Although CGM offers an assortment. If you find other sources, please post!
House of Musical Traditions in Maryland has a selection of various screws that are useful for accordion repair, sold in a batch. (edit: Here is a link, it's toward the bottom of the page. http://www.hmtrad.com/catalog/winds/sbx/sbx-part.html )
Otherwise, Ace Hardware is the best place around here for weird screws. My local Home Depot and Lowe's stores are useless for anything not featured in a Bob Vila program.
No tremolo problems, but I had a similar problem with mushy tones and overpowering basses from an old Hohner two-row box. I took out the reed blocks from both ends and found someone had glued what looked like pallet felt/leather to the base plates of each, maybe to prevent against leaks? But both base plates were perfectly flush with the mating surface so I removed the felt and tightened the screws holding down the blocks. No leaks and presto, the sound was "in focus" as you described.
-
I find the sound of reeds in blocks being excited rather harsh and find that the absorption of the casing makes a beneficial effect. I know that others have said things about grille cloths and absorption properties. Always ready to be proved wrong though.
I agree....naked reeds do sound pretty harsh. The sound of a particular box is merely the sum of all attributes; Shape, volume, cabinet materials, reed quality, block and chamber design,etc. I guess we're on a quest to find what conditions make them sound in an 'undesireable' manner. In this case, it is apparent to me that reeds need to 'hook up' with one another to produce a strong, unified, "in tune" sound. We know it when we hear it. We know what it sounds like if this is missing.
If you want a "softer" sound then a heavier grille cloth can usually provide this, or even something heavier -- some concertinas used to have a leather sheet underneth the fretwork, on standoffs so at least some sound escaped.
OTOH if the sound has already been absorbed inside the instrument you can't get it back, and there's also the risk that if more sound is absorbed inside it's more likely to excite undesirable resonances in the reed blocks/body. It's been mentioned that some accordion makers use a hard varnish on the reed blocks and inside the case which will decrease absorption (same reason as you need to varnish wooden treble horns for speakers, should you ever make one).
Surely the point is that you don't want reeds "hooking up" with each other, this is the resonant coupling that reed block straps are trying to remove?
Ian
-
If you want a "softer" sound then a heavier grille cloth can usually provide this, or even something heavier -- some concertinas used to have a leather sheet underneth the fretwork, on standoffs so at least some sound escaped.
OTOH if the sound has already been absorbed inside the instrument you can't get it back, and there's also the risk that if more sound is absorbed inside it's more likely to excite undesirable resonances in the reed blocks/body. It's been mentioned that some accordion makers use a hard varnish on the reed blocks and inside the case which will decrease absorption (same reason as you need to varnish wooden treble horns for speakers, should you ever make one).
Surely the point is that you don't want reeds "hooking up" with each other, this is the resonant coupling that reed block straps are trying to remove?
Ian
Perhaps my choice of words is inappropriate. I think the term 'focus' is closer. I have already tried the damping route using felts, cardboard baffles, and even experimented with changing the air-flow to the left side reeds. None of these were the solution. Rather than regulating volume, I needed to eliminate distortion that was present. Apparently, this is one of the benefits of the straps...they seem to mitigate unwanted overtones produced by unstable or resonant parts (the reedblocks in this case) that are adding an undesirable element to the sound. For me, it cured the problem ;D
-
Synchronicity...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klw7L0OZbFQ
-
Synchronicity...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klw7L0OZbFQ
That I like ;D
-
It's hard enough to play without having to stand on a teeter-board as well........ ;D
-
Synchronicity...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klw7L0OZbFQ
You can even see the middle one trying to move out of synchronisation and being pulled back -- just like the horrible pulling-in-and-out-of phase warbling sound you get with reed blocks with the problem under discussion...
-
You can even see the middle one trying to move out of synchronisation and being pulled back -- just like the horrible pulling-in-and-out-of phase warbling sound you get with reed blocks with the problem under discussion...
In this particular experience it seems to be more about a "majority wins" effect, but we can definitely see how waves can interact and interfere with each other.
-
You can even see the middle one trying to move out of synchronisation and being pulled back -- just like the horrible pulling-in-and-out-of phase warbling sound you get with reed blocks with the problem under discussion...
In this particular experience it seems to be more about a "majority wins" effect, but we can definitely see how waves can interact and interfere with each other.
yes, and as more become sync-ed, perhaps the quicker it all happens. Seems like a good reason for dry tuning...the reeds tend to be somewhat bound to staying in step.
-
You can even see the middle one trying to move out of synchronisation and being pulled back -- just like the horrible pulling-in-and-out-of phase warbling sound you get with reed blocks with the problem under discussion...
In this particular experience it seems to be more about a "majority wins" effect, but we can definitely see how waves can interact and interfere with each other.
yes, and as more become sync-ed, perhaps the quicker it all happens. Seems like a good reason for dry tuning...the reeds tend to be somewhat bound to staying in step.
The problem is that the closer the reeds are tuned the more prone they are to jumping in and out of synchronisation if there's any coupling between them instead of the phase gradually and smoothly drifting past each other -- in weakly coupled oscillators this is called "mode locking" and is usually avoided at all costs, because the slipping in and out of lock is partly random leading to uneven beat rates.
-
Synchronicity...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klw7L0OZbFQ
That I like ;D
I prefer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGfqW8LylBs&feature=related
OK so we have a violist in the family ::)
-
(...) Seems like a good reason for dry tuning. (...)
Or very wet! Maybe that's why Hohner uses dripping-wet tuning...
-
Synchronicity...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klw7L0OZbFQ
I think this makes one very important point very clear and that is for this to happen the system needs some compliance, some movement.
With my production engineers hat on just attaching the reed blocks at the ends i.e. one end wedged and the other screwed down is, in almost all cases, good enough but with just my engineers balding head it has always seemed to me that I would like to see the reed blocks screwed or clamped down in the centre as well.
-
with just my engineers balding head it has always seemed to me that I would like to see the reed blocks screwed or clamped down in the centre as well.
Some accordions do have fixings in the centre too.
-
with just my engineers balding head it has always seemed to me that I would like to see the reed blocks screwed or clamped down in the centre as well.
Some accordions do have fixings in the centre too.
Last time we talked about this my conclusion was that a torsional resonance along the length of the block was the most likely mechanism. Just screwing the middle of the block down to the pallet board might have some effect depending on whether the board is flexing with the block or not; in any case the block is probably a lot stiffer than the board so it wouldn't help much, since stiffness depends on the square of thickness -- even allowing for chambers and narrower width, a 50mm tall reedblock is probably at least 10x stiffer than a 5mm thick pallet board.
What is needed is to brace the middle of the top of the block so it can't move sideways; a strap to another block helps (assuming the other block resonates differently which is very likely), extending this strap down diagonally to the corner strongpoints where the pallet board meets the case would be better still.
-
"Last time we talked about this my conclusion was that a torsional resonance along the length of the block was the most likely mechanism"
To my mind the two likely ways that the reed block can move are:
a) due to the compliance of the gasket material between the block and the soundboard.
b) torsional bending of the base of the reed block (the thin part) where it is attached at the ends
The sound board may only be 5mm thick (4mm on my pokerwork) but where the reed blocks are attached it is close to the side walls of the box and has thick blocks of wood glued to it to clamp the reed blocks to and so is very stiff.
Finally, by experimentation, pushing the top of the reed block sideways in the centre shows some lateral movement with no discernable flexing of the sound board. Further pushing on the sound board with much greater force resulted in no discernable flexing.
So by adding three small screws to clamp the edges of the two reed blocks, at their mid points, to the sound board would result in a much stiffer assembly.
-
"Last time we talked about this my conclusion was that a torsional resonance along the length of the block was the most likely mechanism"
To my mind the two likely ways that the reed block can move are:
a) due to the compliance of the gasket material between the block and the soundboard.
b) torsional bending of the base of the reed block (the thin part) where it is attached at the ends
The sound board may only be 5mm thick (4mm on my pokerwork) but where the reed blocks are attached it is close to the side walls of the box and has thick blocks of wood glued to it to clamp the reed blocks to and so is very stiff.
Finally, by experimentation, pushing the top of the reed block sideways in the centre shows some lateral movement with no discernable flexing of the sound board. Further pushing on the sound board with much greater force resulted in no discernable flexing.
So by adding three small screws to clamp the edges of the two reed blocks, at their mid points, to the sound board would result in a much stiffer assembly.
Agreed, if the gasket has compliance and the pallet board (yes I refuse to use the s-b word...) is sufficiently stiffened by blocks braced to the case, screwing down the middle of the blocks will help.
But if you're just screwing it down onto the pallet board via the gasket this will still not help much, you'd need to screw the reed block directly to the stiffening blocks to "short-circuit" the gasket compliance.
And in the end, a metal strap across the blocks and screwed down into the corner strongpoints will still provide a lot more torsional stiffness if you analyse the forces involved and how they get fed into the case. Even things that look rigid or feel it to the touch aren't when you analyse resonances in the hundreds of Hz to kHz range.
Ian
P.S. Yes I did structural and mechanical engineering as well as properties of materials :-)
-
I should have made it clear Ian that I agree with both the strap across the blocks and screwed down to the Pallet board and any thing which gets away from the idea of a sound board but I just find the strap inelegant.
My logic for screwing the reed blocks in the center is that the pallet board will be very stiff, being rigidly fixed into a section of tube that forms the case of the treble side so the screws will increase the stiffness of the assembly and so shift its resonant frequency up and out of the range of this effect. Putting my old production engineers hat back on this saves you a strap and one screw.
It would be interesting to know if this is more of a problem with longer reed blocks and less of a problem with blocks glued to the pallet board.
-
I just find the strap inelegant.
Inelegant?
It is simple,
It works.
From an engineering point of view I call that elegant.
-
From my experience, screwing the reed blocks in the center, apart from certain constructional issues that may present themselves, will not make the resonance straps obsolete. I've encountered a wobbly tremolo and related phenomena in cases where the blocks were solidly glued on to the sound board (no bottom, no gasket, no screws). Again, the problem is rapidly solved by attaching a strap. I use the small parts (no idea what they could be called in English) that usually make part of the register in chromatic instruments. There is a small hole in either end and they can be had in different convenient lengths from Carini. They may even look a bit more elegant than some straps.
-
Even the much disparaged Chinese Pokerworks come with them fitted ;)
-
but I just find the strap inelegant.
You could always paint miniature flowers on it.
-
From my experience, screwing the reed blocks in the center, apart from certain constructional issues that may present themselves, will not make the resonance straps obsolete. I've encountered a wobbly tremolo and related phenomena in cases where the blocks were solidly glued on to the sound board (no bottom, no gasket, no screws). Again, the problem is rapidly solved by attaching a strap. I use the small parts (no idea what they could be called in English) that usually make part of the register in chromatic instruments. There is a small hole in either end and they can be had in different convenient lengths from Carini. They may even look a bit more elegant than some straps.
Do you think this suggests then that there may be movement in the soundboard after all (the much disparaged idea and name discussed vigorously on here previously) as its seems evident that the metronome example happens only when the board they are on is allowed to move All the Best mory
-
It's fairly evident that the fondo does move, as it isn't infinitely stiff. The point is that it isn't desirable for it to move, unlike in a stringed instrument.
-
...and that's further evidence, as if it were needed, that movement in the soundbasefonpalletableboardo is a Bad Thing...
-
...and that's further evidence, as if it were needed, that movement in the soundbasefonpalletableboardo is a Bad Thing...
Evidence? What was the evidence please, unless I've missed something the only evidence we have from instruments is that fitting a brace across the reedblocks can improve the tremolo sound. Everything else is just been throwing around ideas, good ideas mind, but not actual evidence m'lud.
Re the flexibility of the fondo, Van der Aaa boxes have a very thin and flexible one and the generally sound great. Not sure what that means, but I'll throw it into the discussion.
-
Inelegant?
It is simple,
It works.
From an engineering point of view I call that elegant.
[/quote]
Theo, don't get me wrong as a fix for an obvious problem I think it is neat, simple and probably difficult to better but I was referring to it fitted as standard.
To me it is like seeing a buttress added to a building, no matter how well it has been executed in engineering terms it just tells you that the building has a problem.
-
Evidence? What was the evidence please, unless I've missed something the only evidence we have from instruments is that fitting a brace across the reedblocks can improve the tremolo sound. Everything else is just been throwing around ideas, good ideas mind, but not actual evidence m'lud.
Is it not generally accepted that the problem remedied by the strap is a result of resonance?.
-
To me it is like seeing a buttress added to a building, no matter how well it has been executed in engineering terms it just tells you that the building has a problem.
Yes, but in the case of the metal link, it is inside the accordion, and it is not there because of a "problem"! It's there to alleviate the effects of a law of physics...
-
It's fairly evident that the fondo does move, as it isn't infinitely stiff. The point is that it isn't desirable for it to move, unlike in a stringed instrument.
...and that's further evidence, as if it were needed, that movement in the soundbasefonpalletableboardo is a Bad Thing...
mmmmmmm wasn't sure if this was passive aggressive at first still not sure :-\ but the vibrations are certainly evident maybe a brace is called for
-
Mory, don't worry, I wasn't being passive-aggressive (:)
Theo, don't get me wrong as a fix for an obvious problem I think it is neat, simple and probably difficult to better but I was referring to it fitted as standard.
To me it is like seeing a buttress added to a building, no matter how well it has been executed in engineering terms it just tells you that the building has a problem.
A buttress is not a sign that the building has a problem! The flying buttresses of gothic cathedrals are fantastic and elegant pieces of design. They allow the outer wall of a cathedral to be enormously tall, support a heavy stone vaulted roof and still be mostly made of glass. Without them the walls would need to be very thick and would likely collapse under their own weight.
-
It is simple,
It works.
exactly; the 'kiss' principle :D
-
Mory, don't worry, I wasn't being passive-aggressive (:)
Theo, don't get me wrong as a fix for an obvious problem I think it is neat, simple and probably difficult to better but I was referring to it fitted as standard.
To me it is like seeing a buttress added to a building, no matter how well it has been executed in engineering terms it just tells you that the building has a problem.
A buttress is not a sign that the building has a problem! The flying buttresses of gothic cathedrals are fantastic and elegant pieces of design. They allow the outer wall of a cathedral to be enormously tall, support a heavy stone vaulted roof and still be mostly made of glass. Without them the walls would need to be very thick and would likely collapse under their own weight.
And the big heavy statues that you often see on the top of the outer pillars that the flying buttresses connect to aren't just for ornament, they add weight to keep the thrust line (ooh err missus) in the right place so the buttresses don't fall down.
Of course the mediaeval masons didn't know about thrust lines, they just knew that if they didn't placate God by putting the statues up His displeasure would make the building collapse...
-
"a buttress added to a building"
I was actually referring to a buttress added at a later date to building to stop it falling down, I am familiar with the elegance of cathedral design.
Moving this on, would someone like to suggest a method by which one reed can influence another sufficient to pull them in to synchronization?
-
Quote Ian D [Of course the mediaeval masons didn't know about thrust lines, they just knew that if they didn't placate God by putting the statues up His displeasure would make the building collapse]
Can you show your evidence please (:)
Is the balancing strap/link on a BCC# Chromatic where the term Jock strap comes from? ;D AtB mory
"a buttress added to a building"
I was actually referring to a buttress added at a later date to building to stop it falling down, I am familiar with the elegance of cathedral design.
Moving this on, would someone like to suggest a method by which one reed can influence another sufficient to pull them in to synchronization?
I don't know the terminology but I guess at some form of sympathetic vibration as with strings if we play anywhere near a stringed instrument it suddenly jumps to life (I bet that was spooky way back when). We must be heading towards string theory in this topic everythings about vibration AtB mory
-
I'm a bit late in here - the strap in the accordeon/melodeon makes loads more sense to me now
but can anyone confide why Hurdy-Gurdy luthiers carve gargoyles on the ends of their creations ???
TIA Chris
-
but can anyone confide why Hurdy-Gurdy luthiers carve gargoyles on the ends of their creations ???
To scare away evil spirits, which is bizarre... I would have thought the sound of the thing would've been enough...
-
Moving this on, would someone like to suggest a method by which one reed can influence another sufficient to pull them in to synchronization?
It's called 'acoustic coupling' and is a well-known phenomenon which is responsible for the synchronisation of the metronomes referred to in this post:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7706.msg112610.html#msg112610
Quite why it happens, I'm sure others will explain better, but I guess it is to do with two or more periodic, cyclic forces aligning themselves so that they are in phase with each other as much as possible.
Perhaps one analogy is if you get a line of people standing side-by-side and nearly shoulder-to-shoulder, then tell them to sway sideways left and right at whatever speed they choose, but to remain comfortable. At first there will be a lot of shoulder-bumping but soon they will all tend to adopt a uniform synchronised swaying together at the same speed and direction.
-
It's called 'acoustic coupling' and is a well-known phenomenon which is responsible for the synchronisation of the metronomes referred to in this post:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7706.msg112610.html#msg112610
Not convinced it is 'acoustic coupling' in this case more mechanical coupling as the effect is not seen until the metronomes are placed on a moving platform. Asd somebody far cleverer than me stated on you tupe
You are witnessing is a normal mode of a system of coupled oscillators.
After he puts it on the cans, the entire platform will oscillate according to the net movement of the center of mass of all the pendula.
A system like this is destined to fall into a normal mode because normsal modes are low energy states. This particular mode is: 5 pendula left, platform right. (could have 4 left, 1 right and platform right - but is less likely)
-
Quote Ian D [Of course the mediaeval masons didn't know about thrust lines, they just knew that if they didn't placate God by putting the statues up His displeasure would make the building collapse]
Can you show your evidence please (:)
Is the balancing strap/link on a BCC# Chromatic where the term Jock strap comes from? ;D AtB mory
"a buttress added to a building"
I was actually referring to a buttress added at a later date to building to stop it falling down, I am familiar with the elegance of cathedral design.
Moving this on, would someone like to suggest a method by which one reed can influence another sufficient to pull them in to synchronization?
I don't know the terminology but I guess at some form of sympathetic vibration as with strings if we play anywhere near a stringed instrument it suddenly jumps to life (I bet that was spooky way back when). We must be heading towards string theory in this topic everythings about vibration AtB mory
Buttresses : see "Structures -- or why things don't fall down" by J.E.Gordon, one of the best popular science books ever written.
-- his "The New Science of Strong Materials -- or why we don't fall through the floor" is even better on materials but -- obviously -- less good on structures :-)
Coupling between reeds is mechanical through energy transmitted through the reed block; especially with "tip-up" reeds (most are) the mass of the reed vibrating back and forth tends to make the top of the reed block move from side to side in opposition. If you imagine two detuned reeds next to or opposite each other, if they move out of phase (in opposite directions) there's no force on the block and it doesn't move, if they move together the block moves which reduces the mounting stiffness seen by the reeds and will slightly lower their frequency.
If you analyse a system of coupled resonators like this you'll find that any coupling means that the phases tend to "stick" as they move past each other. If the coupling is strong enough (e.g. due to a reed block resonance) they can lock together completely, if it's weaker they can slip in and out of lock at varying intervals (it's a chaotic system if you want to be precise) giving a "phasing" sound, weaker still and you just get uneven tremolo rate and a rough sound.
In electronics, if you have two oscillators very close in frequency any coupling between them leads to the same locking problem and can be very difficult to fix completely because you need very high isolation between them, in this case coupling is often via things like common power supplies rather than reed blocks :-)
With multiple reeds there are two options; either isolate them from each other using soft mounting under each reed (difficult for many reasons, the "suspension" would have to be very soft to work because an aluminium reed frame is very light and the resonant frequency has to be well below the note), or clamp them to a stiff and preferably braced structure (reed block with straps) which is much heavier than the reed frames and doesn't move.
Ian
-
I'm a bit late in here - the strap in the accordeon/melodeon makes loads more sense to me now
but can anyone confide why Hurdy-Gurdy luthiers carve gargoyles on the ends of their creations ???
TIA Chris
Never played a gurdy but with a guitar adding mass to the peg head increases the sustain. This can be easily demonstrated by clamping a heavy capo on the end of the peg head.
Michael
-
Thanks. A use for the 'capo' at last then? (I don't include castrating pigs in this) :|glug
-
I'm a bit late in here - the strap in the accordeon/melodeon makes loads more sense to me now
but can anyone confide why Hurdy-Gurdy luthiers carve gargoyles on the ends of their creations ???
TIA Chris
Never played a gurdy but with a guitar adding mass to the peg head increases the sustain. This can be easily demonstrated by clamping a heavy capo on the end of the peg head.
Michael
Sustain isn't much of a problem on an instrument with a continuously rotating wheel.
That's not quite true about just adding mass to the peghead either. Clamping something like a capo or one of those "tone enhancer" thingies, (ie, something heavy and rigid), helps stop string energy being lost as, (theoretically useless), vibration of the neck so that more is unloaded at the bridge. I believe the technical term is something like an active mass damper.
-
I doubt they new nothing about thrust lines even if the terminology didn't exist, from Beaker structures to Round house and beyond they must have had experience of it surely Ian (Unfortunately I don't have time to read the books you've pointed to but thanks, can't you just quote the paragraph where it says what you said. AtB mory
from Waltzman [Never played a gurdy but with a guitar adding mass to the peg head increases the sustain. This can be easily demonstrated by clamping a heavy capo on the end of the peg head.]
bedding a big chunk of solid brass in the body worked a treat for the Yamaha SG2000 . I can't think off hand of the maker but there's the Irish guy who leaves a big chunk on the heads of his bouzouki's etc was on TG4 Ceolchuairt a little while back AtB mory
I've always found on Saltarelle's in C#D anyway the third D always seems to sound really dry but when I've looked at the tuning it has around 4-5 cent in it might try a pin between the blocks at that point.
-
[...] I believe the technical term is something like an active mass damper.
Lots has been tried and believed in, with all sorts of instruments, including trumpets with heavy valve caps or rings to put on the leadpipe, etc. Some people say it's nothing more than "voodoo", some other swear it's scientifically proven...
-
but can anyone confide why Hurdy-Gurdy luthiers carve gargoyles on the ends of their creations ???
To scare away evil spirits, which is bizarre... I would have thought the sound of the thing would've been enough...
I hope they're grotesques -- gargoyles spout water out of their mouths...
Ian
-
I doubt they new nothing about thrust lines even if the terminology didn't exist, from Beaker structures to Round house and beyond they must have had experience of it surely Ian (Unfortunately I don't have time to read the books you've pointed to but thanks, can't you just quote the paragraph where it says what you said. AtB mory
from Waltzman [Never played a gurdy but with a guitar adding mass to the peg head increases the sustain. This can be easily demonstrated by clamping a heavy capo on the end of the peg head.]
bedding a big chunk of solid brass in the body worked a treat for the Yamaha SG2000 . I can't think off hand of the maker but there's the Irish guy who leaves a big chunk on the heads of his bouzouki's etc was on TG4 Ceolchuairt a little while back AtB mory
I've always found on Saltarelle's in C#D anyway the third D always seems to sound really dry but when I've looked at the tuning it has around 4-5 cent in it might try a pin between the blocks at that point.
from "Structures" p.214:
"The decorative possibilities of flying buttresses in conjunction with large windows are very great, and, as we have said, they are still further enhanced by the judicious introduction of statues and pinnacles, whose weight, as the masons must somehow have realised, helps the buttresses in the tricky task of guiding the thrust lines safely down through the lace-like forest of masonry."
Probably the only author who in one book has used both helicopter fuselages and Mlle Vionnet's bias-cut dresses as examples of the same structural phenomenon, compared the stress-strain curves of steel and spit, and explained why you can put a crease in paper but not in a worm :-)
Ian
-
Thanks Ian. I am aware of this. It was the bit about them knowing nothing about thrust lines actually and the bit about appeasing God etc, not to worry though no big deal just thought you had it on some authority, not that, that, always proves anything anyway eh! I'll get used to your humour (:) . I often think we withhold the appropriate credit to man's earlier awareness of different aspects through our arrogance of the modern age, that some how we have advanced when in reality it's often true that we have regressed or are merely stationary, I think there is a by word for it that signifies the age were in "Arrogant Ignorance" sad really. All the Best mory. :||: still intend to pin the Saltarelle
-
I've always found on Saltarelle's in C#D anyway the third D always seems to sound really dry but when I've looked at the tuning it has around 4-5 cent in it might try a pin between the blocks at that point.
Next to the offending reed plate may not necessarily be the optimum position for a brace. Generally the exact position seems not to be critical.
-
Thanks Ian. I am aware of this. It was the bit about them knowing nothing about thrust lines actually and the bit about appeasing God etc, not to worry though no big deal just thought you had it on some authority, not that, that, always proves anything anyway eh! I'll get used to your humour (:) . I often think we withhold the appropriate credit to man's earlier awareness of different aspects through our arrogance of the modern age, that some how we have advanced when in reality it's often true that we have regressed or are merely stationary, I think there is a by word for it that signifies the age were in "Arrogant Ignorance" sad really. All the Best mory. :||: still intend to pin the Saltarelle
The mediaeval masons managed to build some astounding structures from experience but but without any real understanding of structures, as can be seen by the number of said structures which fell down without warning -- sometimes more than once. One reason for the ones which stood up even though they looked like they should fall down was said to be "the grace of God".
Trial end error isn't really a good way to build cathedrals... ;-)
(but experience of what didn't fall down before is, even if it was smaller -- large masonry buildings are one of the few structures which can be scaled up safely)
-
I've just restored an old Hohner Club Modell 1 C/F. Same problem, low notes just not behaving. Fitted a strap between the blocks this morning.
Hey presto, all is sweet and dandy. (:)
-
This is an amazing trick. I installed a strap between the treble blocks on my Erica and the tuning has suddenly improved! Thanks for the tip.
-
Yes, it seems to work!
-
Hello.
I have followed this tread whit great interests. And yesterday I tried it on my 4 voice Borsini button accordion. And I was amazed. I sounded noticeably better. Specially when playing accords. Next to try on is an old Hagström. Thanks for this good advice .
Anders
-
This is a very interesting thread, and I thank the OP for starting it and for Theo to zoom into a seducing and fundamental explanation.
It seems to me there are two cases to consider: 1) when only one reed is speaking and its vibration causes an oscillatory movement in its own reed plate, because the block on which it is placed is induced to vibrate, and 2) when the reed plate of a first speaking reed is being vibrated by a resonance between the block and a second speaking reed.
In case (1), the frequency of the induced motion in the reed plate is likely to be the same as the fundamental of the musical tone, with probably a phase difference. It's difficult to know for sure how this affects the sound of the reed, but my guess is that it can cause a lowered volume and a frequency spectrum with reduced overtones, perhaps causing a "less bright" sound. Some listeners might prefer such a timbre.
In Case (2), the situation is more complex. If the reed plate is vibrating at a frequency that is an integer multiple of the fundamental of the speaking reed, the effect on sound might be similar to that of Case (1). When the frequencies are different, aperiodic pressure pulses will contribute to the sound produced, simply because such pulses contribute to the chopping of the air produced by the relative motion between the vibrating tongue and the vibrating reed plate. In other words, there will be some measure of noise, and it's magnitude can, in general, range from imperceptible, to the annoying "warbling" described by others.
The video showing synchronization of the metronomes is very interesting, though note that these metronomes are tuned to have very nearly the same individual frequencies. Thus, their oscillations are pulled in phase, with all having vibration amplitudes close to their individual responses. When two linear oscillators of different frequencies are coupled, their oscillations can be in unison, at some intermediate frequency, albeit with possibly a greatly reduced amplitude. If the separate natural frequencies are far apart, I believe complicated, seemingly chaotic, motion is possible. Thus, I can see that, in some cases, very unpleasant warbling can occur when more than one reed is vibrating in a reed block that is susceptible to it's own harmonic behavior.
Those familiar with the Asian free reed instruments can observe that the natural vibrational frequencies of the reed tongue and the coupled tube resonator often differ, and the resulting musical tone of the coupled vibration operates at a pitch somewhat intermediate between the two. This sound, however, is entirely enjoyable, though I'm not suggesting that all the important physical mechanisms are the same.
Contrary to some here, I don't see that the effect of reed block motion occurs via influence on the reed tongue vibration itself. I see it happening through its effect on the air chopping that is so fundamental to free reed operation. For instance, since the tongues are mounted tip up, their attachment to the plate/block is near the bottom of the block, where the block's motion is likely at some minimum. In my view, I see the tongue vibrating pretty much like it wants to vibrate, with the block doing the same, and their nexus is at the top, where their relative motion is most pronounced. This is where the musical tone is affected.
For those energetic enough, the entire phenomenon should be relatively easy to set up for experimentation, in an apparatus that allows vibration of the reed plate at user-selected frequency and amplitude.
Best regards,
Tom