Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: WestOz on January 17, 2012, 09:09:45 AM
-
My D/G Hohner Pressed Wood is fine when practising at home (not too loud), but when used outside for Morris (as loud as possible) a couple of the basses don't fire up as soon as I hit the buttons, but do if I leave buttons depressed. It is especially noticable on faster tunes, as I my fingers only stay on buttons momentarily, and the reed might not sound at all. How to adjust the reeds?
-
Could be possible your playing to hard ? air preasure can be to great causing a sort of pause, you may also have disturbed the set of the reeds or valves need replacing but from your description I suspect it's the first suggestion. Take a peek inside if the valves are curled back from the bass reeds it would suggest they are at fault All the Best mory get back to us
-
My D/G Hohner Pressed Wood is fine when practising at home (not too loud), but when used outside for Morris (as loud as possible) a couple of the basses don't fire up as soon as I hit the buttons, but do if I leave buttons depressed. It is especially noticable on faster tunes, as I my fingers only stay on buttons momentarily, and the reed might not sound at all. How to adjust the reeds?
It sounds very much to me like the reed tongues are set too low in the frames, causing them to choke under pressure.
The remedy is to set the reed tongues higher. An easy job on the outside reeds (the push reeds), just lift them up a bit to increase the gap between the tongue and the frame but a bit more tricky on the inner (pull reeds). You can try to ease them down with a small screwdriver or something similar but to be more accurate you will need to remove them from the blocks to adjust them.
Martyn
-
playing as loud as possible never does anything for a tune anyway and is not necesary even for morris - if it was they wouln't be able to dance to a single whistle which has been known!
george ;)
-
playing as loud as possible never does anything for a tune anyway and is not necesary even for morris - if it was they wouln't be able to dance to a single whistle which has been known!
If you mean the traditional three hole pipe, that's far from a quiet instrument, played entirely on the overblow, and accompanied by a drum to make sure nobody misses a beat. And didn't some of the morris men that spoke to Cecil Sharp complain that they couldn't hear the fiddle that replaced the old whittle'n'dub?
Also, purchase of my Oakwood was triggered by a complaint that Smiffs couldn't hear my Pokerwork over the traffic when dancing in Richmond-on-Thames...
-
As Martyn says, its is the reed set, but with bass reeds it is always difficult to get them to start properly. You also need to bear in mind:
The high bass reed also needs to be gapped correctly, because there is some coupling between the reeds, and the low bass reed will start better if the high bass reed is also adjusted optimally.
Some Hohner bass reeds just don't start as well as others.
Bass reeds that are set up to respond best when playing very loud will not respond so well when played gently.
So it really is not always just a simple matter of adjusting one reed. Good Luck!
-
I can assure you that a NW morris side greatly appreciates the loudest music you can offer - all them clogs drown out any wusses! Strangely my Pokerwork doesn't seem to suffer from choking, but the DB BPII does. It helps if you can tap a few extra treble buttons along with the bass as it takes some of the pressure off whilst contributing more volume.
Rob.
-
Does it happen in both directions WestOz
-
Thanks to all for your input/advice. It does seem to happen on push and pull. I will try opening up the gaps, bearing in mind Theo's remark about relationship with other reeds. i will report any progress (or failure!).
-
Hi WestOz, it might just pay, if you have the opportunity, to make a comparison with someone else's box both by playing and as a visual reference before you get stuck in AtB mory
-
This if very helpful for me too. The pull C and pull D fundamentals on my Erica choke when I'm playing at morris practice. I'll try resetting the gap tomorrow.
-
It's a good idea when setting the reed higher to hold the bottom third of the reed tongue down with your thumb while lifting the top two thirds. This will avoid any strain on the rivet and also ensure the 'bend' is put in the right place.
Martyn
-
Excellent advice! Keeping the root of the reed from bending up will help with preventing the whole reed tongue from bending up and creating a problem with the sound of air passing past the reed without the reed sounding. I've noticed that with some of the reeds I've tuned that getting the reed to sound properly sometimes requires bending the root of the reed down a bit (into the chamber) then bending the tip back up to get the proper amount of gap. Helps the reed to speak quickly.
-
Strangely my Pokerwork doesn't seem to suffer from choking, but the DB BPII does.
Rob.
I had this problem with my BPII as well, but have not experienced it with the Binci where the basses seem more blanced against the treble.
-
I've done the gap setting on all the low fundamentals on my Erica. There's been a marked improvement in most of the reeds response under normal playing conditions though not on the low C fundamental, especially the pull C.
I've tried opening up the gap more and more on the low C fundamental. The push reed seems to work fairly well at this point but the pull reed (the one outside the chamber) keeps choking no matter how big a gap I put into the tip. I'm only able to get sound out of the reed at very low pressure but not at standard Morris dance volume. Can anyone help with this? Is this just a standard problem with a Hohner Erica or Pokerwork?
I ended up replacing the original low C fundamental with a brand new reed thinking that I'd created a problem by reworking an old reed from a set of GC Hohner reeds. Can't remember what the original pitches were for the reed I used but I did add a blob of solder to lower the pitch. The brand new reed doesn't seem to behave much better than the old one with the solder though. The new reed still takes a second or two to come up to pitch and stabilize at that pitch. Not sure what to do about that.
-
I've tried opening up the gap more and more on the low C fundamental. The push reed seems to work fairly well at this point but the pull reed (the one outside the chamber) keeps choking no matter how big a gap I put into the tip.
Umm.. The pull reed is the one inside the reed chamber....
-
You're right. I keep getting pull and push mixed up when I'm looking at the reed blocks outside of the instrument.
I'm still wondering if the low C fundamental is more prone to choking for the pull stroke?
-
The more solder a reed has , the slower it will be.
If you can find a Italian bass reed out of a old piano accordion, you will have to add solder to one reed to bring it to pitch (of course). This may help if the hohner reeds don't cut it.
The hohner bass reeds are pretty big so you may have to fill in the block for a smaller reed.
-
My expertise is more in concertinas and if this was a concertina I would say; while a low set will mean a reed will choke more easily, raising the set will not always help if the reed is too thin, and I suspect this is compounded if the clearances are not good. It will also not help if the shape of the set is such that the reed passes through the tightest part of the slot in a progressive fashion rather than all at the same moment.
Chris
-
My expertise is more in concertinas and if this was a concertina I would say; while a low set will mean a reed will choke more easily, raising the set will not always help if the reed is too thin, and I suspect this is compounded if the clearances are not good. It will also not help if the shape of the set is such that the reed passes through the tightest part of the slot in a progressive fashion rather than all at the same moment.
Chris
I've been wondering how the shape of the tongue itself affects how the reed works. What you're saying is that a reed tongue that forms a straight line from root to tip will be less prone to choking and speak more quickly?
-
Sorry about the delay in replying...
Again let me repeat my expertise is in concertinas, the parallels to accordions are nothing like complete. And nor is my knowledge, ie. opinion alert!
Let me try an analogy; if you imagine the reed as a piston in a combustion engine, and imagine it is a sloppy fit. Some of the explosive force will leak around the piston and the engine will not be as efficient. Revheads say 'compression is acceleration', and this has to be true here too. The tighter the reed is at the most closed point the more force will be imparted to the reed by the airflow. The more force taken from the airflow the more open the reed will get, and more quickly also. So speed and volume are aided by tight clearances.
Tight clearances have other effects, ie. more higher partials, and its a lot more complex than this because as you can imagine there is more resistance on the return stroke also. Other factors are hardness of metal, thickness of reed, etc.
The role of the shape of the underside of the reed as it passes through the tightest point lies in creating that good seal. If the reed passes through the slot progressively with the tightest point travelling from root to tip then you are missing a percentage of potential thrust.
Predicting what shape will have a chance of travelling through the tight point all at the same time is difficult, its not going to be a straight line. The only reed for which this would be true would be one with a hinge at the root.
My experience is, long low reeds work well with a straight underside from the thinnest point. The longer the thinnest point is the more spread out that initial upwards curve needs to be. A reed which is wedge shaped ie. high reeds, will have progressively more lift along the reed proportional with the shape of the wedge.
I find when I am missing that last 1% in performance from a reed, attention to the exact shape of the lift will sometimes give it to me.
It is also the reason, while staring at the high reeds of my Castagnari, the ones inside the chamber, thinking how to lower their lift to get them starting a little easier, I can't see how to do it without removing them because though I could adjust them in situe it would be hard to assess their shape.
Hope this all makes sense, happy to hear contrary opinions...