So if the sound of boxes is independent of soundboard and is independent of reedblock, what makes good reeds sound good and bad reeds sound bad?
A good example of how sounds change,get hold of a cassotto box,especially one with a cedar cassotto chamber,the resonance makes the bassoon reed in a PA sound richer very like a Bassoon and if the clarinet reed is in the cassotto chamber this then produces a sound more akin to a wooden clarinet,obviously the resonance of the chamber has a great influence on the sound of the instrument.
I think the tapered block (bottom to top) is an exercise in getting the air flow behind the tongue as in the flat mounted reed and is a real necessity in an upright block to get a quick response to the reed even if it lacks a little in volume by comparison AtB mory
As a builder I do not worry too much about what to make my reed blocks from. My personal choice is alder: it works easily, it is stable, resistent and not too heavy, glues well. It is also relatively inexpensive. I also used abachi in two or three batches, but continuous exposure to its dust may lead to health issues...
My priorities: Sound improves noticeably when the blocks are glued straight on the board (no bottom, no gasket, no screws). Large sound holes. Following this simple recipe you should get more or less the same result as with flat mounted reeds.
This statement does not follow from your previous discussions, its false logic. Your arguments clearly describe why some possible effects on sound production are not going to happen, but there may be others. One could test the statement of yours that I have quoted with some fairly straightforward experiments in a test rig that simulates a real instrument but where reedblocks and/or soundboards of different designs and materials can be substituted.
My own personal hunch is that the materials and construction of reedblocks is critical, but I'm afraid I don't understand the factors involved well enough to design the ideal reedblock. One small clue is in the design of the Castagnari Mory. I'm not alone in believing that the models made prior to the late 1990s are superior players to the ones made around 2000 and onwards (though recent examples are better). The early Mory (identifiable by the semicircle design on the grill) have reedblocks carved out of a single piece of timber with the grain running lengthwise, with a cap and base glued on. Later ones are built up from a mid rib with chamber walls glued on. The most highly regarded Paolo Sopranis also have their blocks made in the same manner as the early Mory. I don't know what this means, but there could be something there. What I suspect is important is the ability of the reedblock to hold the reed rigidly and to resist any vibration of the reed plate, thus ensuring that as much energy as possible is retained in the vibrating reed.
I have one other hunch, nothing stronger than that, about the difference in sound from a flat mounted reed as opposed to one on a block is, at lease in part, simply a result of the site where the sound is produced is closer to the outside world, therefore the emerging sound has a shorter path with less opportunity for being modified by interaction with the surfaces it passes.
I fully agree that the cassotto chamber makes a difference to the sound, but I don't think it is correct to describe it as being produced by "resonance of the chamber". Ukebert has given a good summary of why resonance is almost certainly not a beneficial thing in reed block acoustics. What does happen in the longer and larger chamber such as a cassotto is that there is a more complex pattern of reflection of sound waves within the chamber which can cause a variety of interactions between partials, and a much greater opportunity for absorption of sound by the chamber walls. I strongly suspect that it is this increased internal reflection of sound that is responsible for the different sound character.
When I place a reed flat on my tuning bellows either on a flat/half block or straight on the surface they are always much louder than any on upright blocks, I always thought of it as the angle of attack if you like with the air coming from behind the tongue on the flat mounted and end on on the upright racks, maybe to do with turbulence I suspect, same loud volume in a Connie for same reason regardless of other contributary factors AtB mory
I think the tapered block (bottom to top) is an exercise in getting the air flow behind the tongue as in the flat mounted reed and is a real necessity in an upright block to get a quick response to the reed even if it lacks a little in volume by comparison AtB mory
As a builder I do not worry too much about what to make my reed blocks from. My personal choice is alder: it works easily, it is stable, resistent and not too heavy, glues well. It is also relatively inexpensive. I also used abachi in two or three batches, but continuous exposure to its dust may lead to health issues...
My priorities: Sound improves noticeably when the blocks are glued straight on the board (no bottom, no gasket, no screws). Large sound holes. Following this simple recipe you should get more or less the same result as with flat mounted reeds.
IBack to blocks. Also as an experiment, I made my blocks on another accordion (with my conventional maple blocks) with dual level chambers. The thought was since the push/pull reeds are set the space of the plate apart, I would try to take up that space under the push reed. First impression was inconsistent. Some reeds seemed louder, and some choked. So I tried shaving down the top of the raised portion under the tip of the push reed, problem solved. My next 3 will also have these stepped chambers, so hopefully I'll be able to see if it is consistently better than what I had been doing.
You are in good company there. Castagnari have made their reed blocks like that for many years.
I do not strongly doubt the argument that it doesn't too much matter the material of the block, and my recent balsa block project helps confirm that, but if so, why does it make such a drastic difference if the reed is on an aluminum or brass base? Why shouldn't the material that the plate is attached to also make a difference? I also think there is a distinction between what make no difference and what can make a little difference. A little difference can be the difference between preferring this accordion or that one.
With my last 2 projects, I also helped confirm Digitonix's report that a bigger sound hole is better, which also kills what I had previously thought. I assumed that a hole needed to be big enough, but too big would use too much air. So I made square holes, which added quite a bit more surface area than my round holes. I can tell no difference in air consumption, but a noticeable difference in volume and richness of sound. Still can't help but think there is a point of diminishing returns.
Back to blocks. Also as an experiment, I made my blocks on another accordion (with my conventional maple blocks) with dual level chambers. The thought was since the push/pull reeds are set the space of the plate apart, I would try to take up that space under the push reed. First impression was inconsistent. Some reeds seemed louder, and some choked. So I tried shaving down the top of the raised portion under the tip of the push reed, problem solved. My next 3 will also have these stepped chambers, so hopefully I'll be able to see if it is consistently better than what I had been doing.
My experiments have very little scientific thought, but a whole lot of "what if..",but is definitely the fun part for me.
You may be on to something with the mention of starting transients. It's well known that much of the recognisable character of the sound of a musical instrument is in the way the notes start. Snip those off recordings of a flute and a trumpet playing the same note, for example, and they sound surprisingly similar. The speed of starting also affects the feel of the instrument for the player, and is a major difference between good reeds and bad reeds.
I do not strongly doubt the argument that it doesn't too much matter the material of the block, and my recent balsa block project helps confirm that, but if so, why does it make such a drastic difference if the reed is on an aluminum or brass base? Why shouldn't the material that the plate is attached to also make a difference? I also think there is a distinction between what make no difference and what can make a little difference. A little difference can be the difference between preferring this accordion or that one.
With my last 2 projects, I also helped confirm Digitonix's report that a bigger sound hole is better, which also kills what I had previously thought. I assumed that a hole needed to be big enough, but too big would use too much air. So I made square holes, which added quite a bit more surface area than my round holes. I can tell no difference in air consumption, but a noticeable difference in volume and richness of sound. Still can't help but think there is a point of diminishing returns.
Back to blocks. Also as an experiment, I made my blocks on another accordion (with my conventional maple blocks) with dual level chambers. The thought was since the push/pull reeds are set the space of the plate apart, I would try to take up that space under the push reed. First impression was inconsistent. Some reeds seemed louder, and some choked. So I tried shaving down the top of the raised portion under the tip of the push reed, problem solved. My next 3 will also have these stepped chambers, so hopefully I'll be able to see if it is consistently better than what I had been doing.
My experiments have very little scientific thought, but a whole lot of "what if..",but is definitely the fun part for me.
You may be on to something with the mention of starting transients. It's well known that much of the recognisable character of the sound of a musical instrument is in the way the notes start. Snip those off recordings of a flute and a trumpet playing the same note, for example, and they sound surprisingly similar. The speed of starting also affects the feel of the instrument for the player, and is a major difference between good reeds and bad reeds.
So it'll be interesting to see what flat-mounted reeds (short air path) Allen-bolted down to a milled aluminium "reed pan" with no gaskets sound like, the reed should think it's mounted directly on a big rigid metal block and you can't much get more massive and rigid than that... ;)
Ian
Anahata, this observation (and ukebert's) is crucial -- thank you! It might deserve another topic. But in my opinion, this factor also is highly influential in the differences among playing styles developed by good musicians who play dance music. Some musicians seem to have developed a style using very high bellows pressure to get quick response and good articulation of rhythms at a micro time scale, and this can work with reeds that are less than optimally efficient and/or somewhat leaky instruments. You can achieve the accuracy without harshly overblowing the reeds on the attack. Other musicians have a lower-pressure style that depends on extremely efficient reeds and very tight instruments to achieve those great dance rhythms. Each approach can sound accurate and tonally beautiful, on the appropriate instruments for each style.
I have played a highly customized Hohner Amatona (a 4 voice D/D#) years ago, owned by a very creative and handy guy. The reedblocks had been modified to have metal bases (aluminum or stainless, I can't remember which), machined to exactly mate surface-to-surface on a metal soundboard, and locked in place to yield an airtight metal-to-metal fit with no gasket. This box had a really unique, rich, bright and present sound, but it had many other modifications also (for example the original grille was off and an open, curved metal "collar shape" installed) and I don't know what it sounded like before the reedblocks were modified.
but that the construction of the block makes far more of an affect.Quote
But I don't think we should concentrate on just the things that have the biggest affect, the little nuances can make the difference in a good sounding accordion, or an exceptional one, and vice versa.
Do you mean that you shaped the inside of the chamber such that there was less wood under the push reed?Quote
There is more wood under the push reed. The push reed is the thickness of the reed plate higher than the pull reed, so I added a strip of wood to take that amount of space up.Also big area pallet holes in a thin pallet board are better (my Oakwood used big rectangular holes), as is a clear open path for air flow to the reed. Bigger holes don't use more air, by far the smallest cross-section in the air flow path is the reed in its frame.
Ian
Additionally, my assumptions, also maybe wrong, were that there should be some degree of pressure build up in the chamber, not for volume but tone.
But I don't think we should concentrate on just the things that have the biggest affect, the little nuances can make the difference in a good sounding accordion, or an exceptional one, and vice versa.
There is more wood under the push reed. The push reed is the thickness of the reed plate higher than the pull reed, so I added a strip of wood to take that amount of space up.
Additionally, my assumptions, also maybe wrong, were that there should be some degree of pressure build up in the chamber, not for volume but tone.
This thread is most interesting to me as I have started an Open University Technology of Music Course and this discussion seems in point. I shall bookmark it and return to it when (if) I learn something from the course.
But I don't think we should concentrate on just the things that have the biggest affect, the little nuances can make the difference in a good sounding accordion, or an exceptional one, and vice versa.
This is perfectly true. What I meant was that it is conceivable that the material of a reedblock might make a noticeable affect on the sound and it is conceivable that it doesn't. The difference between them may be that one has a different construction than the other. i.e. that the construction can make the affect of the material so tiny that you wouldn't notice it. But of course, the only way to know is to test it, which you have done (:)QuoteThere is more wood under the push reed. The push reed is the thickness of the reed plate higher than the pull reed, so I added a strip of wood to take that amount of space up.
Sorry, typed the wrong thing. Yes, that's what is described in Sounding Out. You found that it improved the response of the push reed?QuoteAdditionally, my assumptions, also maybe wrong, were that there should be some degree of pressure build up in the chamber, not for volume but tone.
You may be right, but I think that Ian's point was that the resistance of the reed is so huge compared to the hole that increasing or decreasing the resistance of the opening by changing the hole diameter isn't going to change the pressure in the chamber hugely. Correct me if I'm wrong Ian. With a larger hole, however, the air flow will be cleaner and more direct into the chamber, which is important for the sound.
I think I'm using affect and effect wrong. This is what 4 years of studying a numerate subject does to you :P
This thread is most interesting to me as I have started an Open University Technology of Music Course and this discussion seems in point. I shall bookmark it and return to it when (if) I learn something from the course.
Oh good - you're going to come back and tell us all the answers ;)
I think the problem is that *nobody* knows all the answers for free-reed instruments, there's been far too little serious investigative work (as opposed to anecdotes or opinions) done on them to see what really affects the sound -- or at least, that has been published so people know about it...
I think the problem is that *nobody* knows all the answers for free-reed instruments, there's been far too little serious investigative work (as opposed to anecdotes or opinions) done on them to see what really affects the sound -- or at least, that has been published so people know about it...
That's true, we all just guess based on our ideas and our own experiences, and it's so hard to experiment because of the huge amount of time it takes to build the components. What has always amazed me is how efficient and well thought out turn of the century accordions were considering how new the concept was. Taking into account technology and improved materials, we have not really improved accordions nearly as much as we should have. Maybe technology is our problem. ::)
... and to throw another spanner in the works, we're dealing with human perceptions.
We all blithley go along thinking that we "hear sound" when in fact this is a creation of the human brain interpreting reactions from parts of the body. The interpretation is also acclimitised to particular experiences and the environment. People brought up using different languages will even hear human speech differently with one group completely unable to differentiate certain sounds that are plainly separate for another group.
This is not to say that things are unknowable, and I'm not throwing in a bit of "woo" to say that science is meaningless, far from it. But if anyone thinks that you can simply wave a sound pressure meter and an osciloscope at a melodeon and come up with a definitve answer then I think they are misguided.
Psycho-acoustics I think it's called.
... and to throw another spanner in the works, we're dealing with human perceptions.
We all blithley go along thinking that we "hear sound" when in fact this is a creation of the human brain interpreting reactions from parts of the body. The interpretation is also acclimitised to particular experiences and the environment. People brought up using different languages will even hear human speech differently with one group completely unable to differentiate certain sounds that are plainly separate for another group.
This is not to say that things are unknowable, and I'm not throwing in a bit of "woo" to say that science is meaningless, far from it. But if anyone thinks that you can simply wave a sound pressure meter and an osciloscope at a melodeon and come up with a definitve answer then I think they are misguided.
Psycho-acoustics I think it's called.
Nobody said you should only use measurements, though these help if you know what you're looking for. For example it's easy to tell louder from quieter, or brighter from softer tone. But what you want to know is what people prefer.
So you try out different things and compare them using a panel of listeners and see which they like best. So long as this is done in an unbiased way, you then *are* finding out what people want to listen to -- it's science, but based on perception.
As was pointed out, the problem is the amount of time and effort to do all this. Just trying few different things for a melodeon would take an entire thesis i.e. several years of work, and for no money. This kind of investigation has been done with various aspects of violins on several occasions, but there's no university department specialising in the acoustics of melodeons :-(
Exactly what I meant -- almost all the pressure drop will be across the reed, what seems to matter most for sound is clean air flow -- especially to the tip of the reed where most of the air flows -- and least obstruction in the air path.
As was pointed out, the problem is the amount of time and effort to do all this. Just trying few different things for a melodeon would take an entire thesis i.e. several years of work, and for no money. This kind of investigation has been done with various aspects of violins on several occasions, but there's no university department specialising in the acoustics of melodeons :-(
It would be interesting to see the airflow in various settings of reeds/blocks/hole size/shape etc can't you set some thing up ukebert, you know Slow mo camera, glass sided chambers, smoke machine, etc, a wind tunnel for free reeds or maybe this is taking the science to far and we could just enjoy the results we already have!
While I don't have the equipment to do it, I don't think that we're talking about that complicated an experiment.
We're measuring sound right? Not whether we like it or not, but whether it changes? So we need measuring equipment, no problem in an acoustic lab, a bellows system (motorised so as to be consistent), one reed and a variety of reed blocks/fixing systems compatible with that reed. One set of measurements for each of the different reed blocks, one set of measurements for each fixing method with each reed block. There will either be a difference than can be measured or not.
Second or maybe third year degree project stuff.
This thread is most interesting to me as I have started an Open University Technology of Music Course and this discussion seems in point. I shall bookmark it and return to it when (if) I learn something from the course.
Oh good - you're going to come back and tell us all the answers ;)
But opinions is all any of us really have, actually it's more theories with a few opinions thrown in. ;D
Simulating the air flow sounds easy, but whether it can be done in a sensible amount of computing time is the issue. According to the simulation software manufacturers their software is perfectly capable of simulating the chips we're designing, but to do this in enough detail would take years of real time (on a 128-CPU cluster) to get useful results; if you simplify the simulation to the point where it runs in useful time, you discard exactly the details that you're looking for. It's the kind of scale of problem that jet engine manufacturers have to deal with, and they have rather large budgets (both time, effort, money and supercomputers). Maybe if I could get access to the Fujitsu K supercomputer ('cos I know the engineers who designed it, in fact I met them last week at an award ceremony in Japan) this could be overcome, but I somehow think the Japanese government has first call on it...
So you're down to building stuff and measuring/listening to it. You don't need an anechoic chamber for free-reed measurements, a cardioid mic placed a few inches away will reject room reflections almost completely. But you do need someone to spend a lot of time building stuff with different materials/construction and this is where the time/effort would go; compared to this doing the measurements is easy.
Also doing anything significantly different in reed/frame construction in particular is a lot of work, the machinery is built to make standard reeds in standard frames so anything else has to be either done by hand (the old way) or using CAD/CAM machining (the new way). If I remember correctly there was one paper only about a new way of making high-frequency reeds with better volume and tone by shaping the reed and/or frame, and just this was a 3-year PhD.
I'd love all this to happen and be taken seriously but it would need a university engineering department to drive it, and multiple postgraduate students to work on it over several years. Anyone know any suitable heads of department who play melodeon?
Thinking further, do you need to use bellows at all? What we are after is a constant airflow so would a fan (suitably ducted) be sufficient?
This thread is most interesting to me as I have started an Open University Technology of Music Course and this discussion seems in point. I shall bookmark it and return to it when (if) I learn something from the course.
Maybe if I could get access to the Fujitsu K supercomputer ('cos I know the engineers who designed it, in fact I met them last week at an award ceremony in Japan) this could be overcome, but I somehow think the Japanese government has first call on it...said it would be interesting if the Japanese got involved, moryThinking further, do you need to use bellows at all? What we are after is a constant airflow so would a fan (suitably ducted) be sufficient?
This is what I was suggesting, a compressed air supply, a proportional valve (or similar) and a duct to the reed. Controllable and repeatable.
This thread is most interesting to me as I have started an Open University Technology of Music Course and this discussion seems in point. I shall bookmark it and return to it when (if) I learn something from the course.
Thats a fun course; I did it last year. Its very weighted to the music side though,lacks the serious physics/engineering rigour. The tutors are free reed friendly. I took my concertina to a day school at Milton Keynes and there were other free reeders there. Used it for the final examined assignment too.
Maybe a good place to start might be to get some measurement for air pressures likely to be created from your average player with average reeds, average bellows, playing in an average manner at the point of exit into an average reed chamber etc etc I think you would encounter a huge range of variables in this area alone and you'd have to use a tanked air source as any one who has played near a ceiling fan or a cooling fan will tell you and I'm sure your aware, it plays havoc with the air pressure, it fluctuates and the reed responds accordingly, you would also encounter the moisture aspect of compressers so you'd have to filter as well or not AtB mory
you'd have to use a tanked air source as any one who has played near a ceiling fan or a cooling fan will tell you and I'm sure your aware, it plays havoc with the air pressure, it fluctuates and the reed responds accordingly
Not so sure about reflection, I can understand why you might think so with a large blade ceiling fan but, you get the same effect with a six inch blade cooling fan at a variety of speeds but, generally seems more so when facing at the box, I'm thinking of the release pressure from the reeds not the imput pressure, maybe about turbulence? still the proof is in the science so I'll leave it to those that wish to prove or disprove it. All the Best moryyou'd have to use a tanked air source as any one who has played near a ceiling fan or a cooling fan will tell you and I'm sure your aware, it plays havoc with the air pressure, it fluctuates and the reed responds accordingly
Aside: I'm pretty certain that the objectionable fluttering effect you get when playing near a fan is caused by reflections of the sound off the blades interfering with the direct sound, not by modulating the air pressure supplied to the reeds.
Nevertheless I agree that you need a controlled source of air pressure for useful measurements, and it would be useful to know what pressures are generated inside a typical instrument.
As a builder I do not worry too much about what to make my reed blocks from. My personal choice is alder: it works easily, it is stable, resistent and not too heavy, glues well. It is also relatively inexpensive. I also used abachi in two or three batches, but continuous exposure to its dust may lead to health issues...
My priorities: Sound improves noticeably when the blocks are glued straight on the board (no bottom, no gasket, no screws). Large sound holes. Following this simple recipe you should get more or less the same result as with flat mounted reeds.
@Telemorris:
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.1314690187123.2040831.1226742509&type=3#
(Album #1 picture 66)
I just came across this thread and found it interesting, and I also enjoyed the open mindedness and curiosity from the posters. It's not a very old thread, so I can perhaps chime in, though I don't mean to re-hash a lot of worn topics.
you'd have to use a tanked air source as any one who has played near a ceiling fan or a cooling fan will tell you and I'm sure your aware, it plays havoc with the air pressure, it fluctuates and the reed responds accordingly
Aside: I'm pretty certain that the objectionable fluttering effect you get when playing near a fan is caused by reflections of the sound off the blades interfering with the direct sound, not by modulating the air pressure supplied to the reeds.edit Anyone remember Dick Nudds playing his "ol tremelodeon" in the 80's - had a tiny bellow pressure fan inset AFAIR. Wacky and definately 'modulated'
Kept out of this as I don't 'make' .. but it seems obvious to me that ... ;)
- Tapered block = tapered resonance chamber behind the plate. In most instruments this has massive consequences, for examples organ pipes are segregated into straight and tapered sets, and the lovely (or otherwise) tone of a clarinette has (I'm told by makers) all to do with geting the taper just right on their reamer
.- It's common to treat the block as an 'infinite mass' in accoustic terms (ie forget it), but that ain't the case? There is massive coupling from the action/reaction at the base of reed, and we've dicussed how without a coupling strap between blocks, the tone can go t1ts up on some notes. That coupling into block/box is so strong on my Gaillard that I feel the keyboard vibrate when playing low notes .. makes it a second "sounding" board (as opposed to fondo)! I think BG has made it super thin for that effect. Makes such a lovely hollow sound as you tap, that I considerered Carty style 'percussive' play for a while, though (as on guitar), I'm no Carty
That'll be 2p please :|glugyou'd have to use a tanked air source as any one who has played near a ceiling fan or a cooling fan will tell you and I'm sure your aware, it plays havoc with the air pressure, it fluctuates and the reed responds accordinglyAside: I'm pretty certain that the objectionable fluttering effect you get when playing near a fan is caused by reflections of the sound off the blades interfering with the direct sound, not by modulating the air pressure supplied to the reeds.edit Anyone remember Dick Nudds playing his "ol tremelodeon" in the 80's - had a tiny bellow pressure fan inset AFAIR. Wacky and definately 'modulated'
Ah, so the melodeon fourier is a pure sine wave? No harmonics. That explains why the chamber makes no difference ;) And that vibration of the fingered is reflected off the fan?
Hi Ukebert, In your paragraph, I think you captured many of the key ideas I tried to get across in my paper, and I'm glad they were communicated. Although I may be overlooking something, I see no reasonable physical basis for the claim that airflow considerations explain the reason for the taper in vertically mounted reed blocks.
I am curious, are you reasonably convinced that flat mounted reed blocks sound differently than vertically mounted ones? If so, do you prefer the sound of one over the other?
If we imagine two reeds mounted at 45 degrees and minus 45 degrees from the vertical, meaning that the chambers are a triangle and a trapezium, the airflow is going to be very different in each of them. Does this make a difference?
If we imagine two reeds mounted at 45 degrees and minus 45 degrees from the vertical, meaning that the chambers are a triangle and a trapezium, the airflow is going to be very different in each of them. Does this make a difference?
In the operation of reeds, there's a great distinction between the steady, or time averaged, or mean flow of air and the oscillatory (unsteady, or time dependent) vibrations produced in the air. It seems to me you are visualizing and focusing only on the mean flow of the air. It is the air vibrations that give rise to the sound we here, and thus, it's this motion that we need to focus on if we are to understand how different reed blocks influence sound. This oscillatory motion is governed by concepts that are absent from a purely steady state treatment.
Trying to understand the sound of a reed by focusing only on the mean, steady flow is like trying to understand the operation of Alternating Current circuits through application of only Direct Current concepts. In the analogy, we understand clearly that capacitors and inductors, for instance, behave very differently to AC current than they do to DC current. DC current cannot pass across a capacitor, whereas AC current can. An ideal inductor behaves as a short circuit to a DC current, whereas it supplies an electrical inertial resistance to an AC current.
Acoustics is an inherently unsteady (time dependent) phenomenon, and if you leave out this feature, you lose everything that explains how the reed is able to generate sound.
Best regards,
Tom
In the operation of reeds, there's a great distinction between the steady, or time averaged, or mean flow of air and the oscillatory (unsteady, or time dependent) vibrations produced in the air. It seems to me you are visualizing and focusing only on the mean flow of the air. It is the air vibrations that give rise to the sound we here, and thus, it's this motion that we need to focus on if we are to understand how different reed blocks influence sound. This oscillatory motion is governed by concepts that are absent from a purely steady state treatment.
Trying to understand the sound of a reed by focusing only on the mean, steady flow is like trying to understand the operation of Alternating Current circuits through application of only Direct Current concepts. In the analogy, we understand clearly that capacitors and inductors, for instance, behave very differently to AC current than they do to DC current. DC current cannot pass across a capacitor, whereas AC current can. An ideal inductor behaves as a short circuit to a DC current, whereas it supplies an electrical inertial resistance to an AC current.
Acoustics is an inherently unsteady (time dependent) phenomenon, and if you leave out this feature, you lose everything that explains how the reed is able to generate sound.
This could be one reason why flat-mounted reeds sound different; when the vibrating reed travels above the frame a pulse of air travels down through the frame, with flat-mounted reeds this is already travelling towards the air hole under the pallet but with reed blocks it has to make a 90 degree turn (or get reflected, which amounts to the same thing).
It's also possible that inside a reed block the pulse gets reflected off the back of the chamber back towards the reed, which doesn't happen with flat-mounted reeds (at least, if the free end of the reed is over the pallet hole).
Theory is all very good and I can waffle on as well as any. We need experiment, or we'll twitter about this forever. I guess a constant pressure of air input (to keep simple) and I haven't cracked the problem of switching it on and off. Fast Fourier Transform programs can be downloaded for free, but you'd need a decent microphone into your sound board.
The shape of the chamber and where the reed is placed compared to the pallet hole are much more important since these affect the air flow past the reed; if the chamber is "too small" it's the effect on air flow (constricting it) that matters, not the volume of the chamber as such -- this might sound like I'm being picky, but I'll bet that a small chamber with good airflow from reed to pallet hole will sound far better than a large chamber with poor airflow.
This is all very interesting but still does not explain why an old grey Paolo sounds like it does, or a Pokerwork has that Hohner sound! I wonder if the designers of the boxes that became so popular since the 1940's ever went that far in studying all of the acoustics phenomena. One can get obsessed with technology, others will simply enjoy playing their box and enjoying the sound! People get more impressed with your playing than the scientifiic precision of the reedblocks... ::)
But it seems to me that it should be possible to make a melodeon which would be better to play and sound better (which leads to a happier musician), because to be honest the design has essentially been stagnant for almost a century in design, construction methods and materials.Perhaps things are fine as they are! The "sounding better" thing is a very subjective topic, as no two humans have the same hearing... What sounds "good" on an oscilloscope may not be perceived as such by humans.
But it seems to me that it should be possible to make a melodeon which would be better to play and sound better (which leads to a happier musician), because to be honest the design has essentially been stagnant for almost a century in design, construction methods and materials.
One day the Buddha met an old man sitting by a river, and asked him what he has done with his life. The man replied: "I spent the last 50 years learning how to walk on the water, and I think I am just about to succeed". The Buddha replied: "Wouldn't it be easier just to use a boat?"
or that something has already been raised to the peak of perfection by many years of artisanal endeavour.
???????? the mind boggles !!!!!!!
george >:E ;D
or that something has already been raised to the peak of perfection by many years of artisanal endeavour.
???????? the mind boggles !!!!!!!
george >:E ;D
Artisanal, not courtesanal :-)
If the boat was called the Titanic, perhaps some improvements would be a good thing... P.S. Quebecois, if you're so against proposals for improvements, you don't have to read this thread and waste your valuable time replying to it ;-)
P.S. Quebecois, if you're so against proposals for improvements, you don't have to read this thread and waste your valuable time replying to it ;-)True! I much prefer to spend time playing and learning new tunes on one of my "stagnant designed" boxes!
OK, in my defence please note that I was not the one who used the word "stagnant" in relation to melodeon design and I also pointed out that I thought I disagreed with that statement anyway.
There are however times when the a product is a particular form because the basic configuration works and has been proven to work reliably.
Steve
I agree with the basic premise that many aspects of the modern melodeon can still be improved, but I also think that the developments of Castagnari and others have been massively underestimated in statements like Ian's last 50 years" of stagnation. I would be very interested in hearing the perspectives of engineers and physicists who can actually identify the specific 'tweaks' that make modern Castagnaris so wonderfully playable, and a more detailed accounting of the reasons why a Pokerwork with TAM reeds still doesn't match a Castagnari, and why a Castagnari with Hohner reeds doesn't perform the same as a Hohner -- as observed by Rich Morse years ago on the Squeezebox list. There is more than just cosmetic difference.
| I was reminded of this thread today when EJay spotted this video (http://youtu.be/JWToUATLGzs) and posted it to FB. However this rather more nerdy version (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADGmBtLJ6y4) is probably better for our purposes. They simulate (no more than that) a fondo in having multiple resonators on a solid board. The metronomes are all close tuned - some spot on, out of phase - some a few 'cents' out, moving in and out of phase. Basically they all magically synchronise within minutes! These tickers are at about 1.5Hz, so scaling to a more melodeonic ±250 Hz, I'd expect effects to evolve over say a second. Note that anything remotely harmonic on our box (eg tonic+5th played together) will also be affected, basically all harmonics will interact with similar harmonics in any active reed. The model is crude but I think this demo may scotches theoretical arguements that fondo mass/wood/stiffness etc "has no affect on tone"? :|glug | (http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/ADGmBtLJ6y4/mqdefault.jpg) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADGmBtLJ6y4) click photo |
I think (Theo might correct me here) that straps are to do with reed block resonance.
I think (Theo might correct me here) that straps are to do with reed block resonance.
The practical mans answer is that without the strap you can find the the tremolo on one particular reed pair will not sound the same when mounted in the instrument as is does when sounded outside the instrument. Fit a strap and the note sounds as it should. That much will have been observed by anyone who has done tuning work at all extensively.
The explanation is I believe more or less as ukebert states, though I would prefer to change "reed block resonance" to "resonance of the reedblocks and the system that reedblocks are part of"
I've tried both and am unable to hear any difference. Perhaps I don't know what to listen out for?
Won't a link with spring put in a phase shift?
I think (Theo might correct me here) that straps are to do with reed block resonance.
The practical mans answer is that without the strap you can find the the tremolo on one particular reed pair will not sound the same when mounted in the instrument as is does when sounded outside the instrument. Fit a strap and the note sounds as it should. That much will have been observed by anyone who has done tuning work at all extensively.
The explanation is I believe more or less as ukebert states, though I would prefer to change "reed block resonance" to "resonance of the reedblocks and the system that reedblocks are part of"
Ian - so do you think that with say an MM box with both M reeds on the same block, that coupling through the block will pull the reeds in phase with one another?Yes, if there's a resonance in the block which increses the coupling between the reeds. They don't always lock completely together (no beats), they often pull in and out of lock so you get slowed down or irregular beating, which sounds particularly horrible -- my Tommy did this with the link strap removed. It's usually only one note that's affected, unless you're unlucky enough to have more than one resonance coinciding with reed fundamental frequencies.